| Don't take my point in wrong meaning. I mean no harm. I really loved this ending. But what If she had survived how do you see this idea?? From my point of view. I really love to see her alive because I like Happy ending than sad Ending. |
 |
| Well, her surviving operation would give her just little bit more time (im not sure did they say exact time). Lets be honest, do you really think this show would be this popular if they made her beat the illness, have concert and live happily ever after, i honestly doubt. Emotional ending and tearjerker tag is what made this anime so popular same as it did to Anohana. But despite what i just said, i would still like happy ending more than this. Idk, Kaori reminded me to Yuzuki from "Kimi no iru machi" so that is the extra reason why would i like happy ending. |
 |
| I appreciate your point of view. But compare it with clannad (Biggest Tearjerker) with happy ending. |
|
| Well, Clannad had supernatural elements which led to that ending. Collecting balls of happiness or what its name is ( i forgot). Also Shigatsu had only ending sad while Clannad was full of those events. So, if they took out that ending show wouldnt be tearjerker anymore but just a really nice drama. |
| |
| If it didn't end like that it would fade away after the season finished like something like WIXOSS or daybreak. You should change the tittle though. |
| added the fourth most popular anime onto this site |
| So, Nice of you replying of my comment. I have finally accepted ending of Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso At that moment My heart was really broken and now it has been healed. |
wasif_khanMay 8, 2015 6:06 AM
|
| Well, I should say that I really wished she stayed alive and played with Kousei one more time for real... I also wanted to hear more of her crazy ( but fuckin awesome) violin interpretations. The thing I enjoyed the most about Shigatsu was the music, and I would love to hear that duo playing once more ( jk, I actually would love to see them playing their way to worldwide fame). Anyway, I don't know how a happy ending would affect the show overall, but thats just how I wanted it to be x/ |
| "The world is just another word for the things you value around you, right? That's something I've had since I was born. If you tell me to rule such a world, I already rule it." It means no worries For the rest of your days It's our problem-free philosophy Hakuna Matata! s2 A man tells his stories so many times that he becomes the stories. They live on after him, and in that way he becomes immortal. |
Narco said: Lets be honest, do you really think this show would be this popular if they made her beat the illness, have concert and live happily ever after, i honestly doubt. Emotional ending and tearjerker tag is what made this anime so popular then what do you say about Clannad AS? It was happy ending yet it is one of the most amaizng anime ever |
|
wasif_khan said: Narco said: Lets be honest, do you really think this show would be this popular if they made her beat the illness, have concert and live happily ever after, i honestly doubt. Emotional ending and tearjerker tag is what made this anime so popular then what do you say about Clannad AS? It was happy ending yet it is one of the most amaizng anime ever It is, but we cried the river before those last few minutes, we were still highly emotionally damaged. Also, if they didnt survive then all those scenes in afterlife and with lighting balls were useless. |
| |
Narco said: wasif_khan said: then what do you say about Clannad AS? It was happy ending yet it is one of the most amaizng anime ever It is, but we cried the river before those last few minutes, we were still highly emotionally damaged. Also, if they didnt survive then all those scenes in afterlife and with lighting balls were useless. Any ways Clannad AS and Shigatsu wa kimi no Uso both are fucking genius and in my all time favorite list |
|
| Yeah. Just because there were things left unsaid. |
| I think she should have at least played with Kousei one more time, for real. Just one last time... OH NO, THE FEELS ARE COMING BACK AHHH. |
crystowl said: I think she should have at least played with Kousei one more time, for real. Just one last time... OH NO, THE FEELS ARE COMING BACK AHHH. Ya feeling are very real :) Love this series alot. cant rewatch it due to those heavy feelings :) |
|
| Although I really loved Kaori and wanted her operation to be successful, you have to face the facts. The operation was going to be extremely dangerous with a low chance of surviving. Now that I thought about it, the ending would not have been as emotional if she were to survive. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Who's better?kmmentino - Jan 4, 2017 |
3 |
by JLeo20
»»
Feb 28, 2018 8:50 PM |