| If you saw something good... great writing.... but with lazy, sloppy, pathetic animation, could you stomach it? (this time I used the search feature, so I don't think this has been asked before) |
silversongwriterFeb 4, 2015 6:36 PM
 |
| Yes |
 |
| Ping pong was awesome so yes |
| Yes, almost always |
| The fate of destruction is also the joy of rebirth |
| Eh, kind of. I was able to sit through and enjoy Digimon Tamers, but god it's shit animation just got to me and ruined many moments. I can usually stomach the bad animation, but I've got a breaking point. |
Chelizzle said: No it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at allWilliwod said: Ping pong was awesome so yes Ping Pong had great animation |
| The fate of destruction is also the joy of rebirth |
AllenVonStein said: Yes |
| Kemonozume... It was alright |
 |
| well yes i can, i'm not that picky when it comes to art/animation, if the plot/characters are decent i don't really care about anything else ... |
 |
Link_of_Hyrule said: yuasa was not responsible for the art styleChelizzle said: No it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at allPing Pong had great animation |
 |
Link_of_Hyrule said: No it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at all No. That goes to: VitaminCaim said: Kemonozume... |
Link_of_Hyrule said: Chelizzle said: No it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at allPing Pong had great animation The art style I found was pretty unique and expressive. The animation was where it fell short. |
| Yeah, I got through Kingdoms shit tier Cg animation |
 |
| Yea. |
Williwod said: Link_of_Hyrule said: No it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at all The art style I found was pretty unique and expressive. The animation was where it fell short. ^ same |
|
Cupquake said: Well, Yuasa had the option to change it and opted not to.Link_of_Hyrule said: yuasa was not responsible for the art styleNo it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at all |
| The fate of destruction is also the joy of rebirth |
| Usually, yes. Some people have different definitions of "Bad Animation" though, but so far, everything I have given high ratings to had good enough animation to me. |
 |
| I gave Ping Pong an 8 so yes. |
 |
Link_of_Hyrule said: Fair enough. Though I'd be really fucking pissed if he changed it. The manga's artsytle really grew on me.Cupquake said: Well, Yuasa had the option to change it and opted not to.yuasa was not responsible for the art style |
|
| Yes, Ping Pong is a good example. I really liked the art style, but i found the animation to be mediocre at certain points. That doesn't take away from the captivating story it tells. |
FragOutFire said: Why am I a Berserk fan? All I ever experience is pain. We are in the eclipse and Miura has sacrificed us |
| I could stomach it, but I probably couldn't forgive it. |
Chelizzle said: Example? ginga nagaraboshi gin... loved it despite it's flaws, but honesty, even for 80s anime, I've seen much better as far as animaton goes... if you want good 80s animation... galaxy express 999 |
|
| It would depend I guess. I find I'm fairly easy to please when it comes to artstyle/animation in general, unless it's something I immediately find repulsive like Aku no Hana or Reign. |
| another good example is BONES's captain earth, it had exquisite animation, but the story/plot and overall story were REALLY bad .... so in the end animation/art is not the decisive factor about the quality of an anime. |
|
Chelizzle said: Technically not, but it directly contributes to the visual appeal of the show, AKA the point of animationLink_of_Hyrule said: No it didn't. The art style was the worst thing Yuasa's ever done and the animation was not fluent at all Art style has nothing to do with animation. |
| The fate of destruction is also the joy of rebirth |
WAD1992 said: another good example is BONES's captain earth, it had exquisite animation, but the story/plot and overall story were REALLY bad .... so in the end animation/art is not the decisive factor about the quality of an anime. well, at least it gave me a reason for finishing it :) the OST and voice acting too. A+ |
silversongwriter said: If you saw something good... great writing.... but with lazy, sloppy, pathetic animation, could you stomach it? With most anime I usually have to, but I'm less forgiving of bad art style. Something about it has to look good, otherwise I'm better off reading the manga. |
Cupquake said: Link_of_Hyrule said: Fair enough. Though I'd be really fucking pissed if he changed it. The manga's artsytle really grew on me.Well, Yuasa had the option to change it and opted not to. The manga's art is so similar to Yuusa's usual choice of art. It's like he was the only person meant to direct it. |
|
tsudecimo said: Interesting... I think ping pong was my first yuasa anime so i wouldn't knowCupquake said: Fair enough. Though I'd be really fucking pissed if he changed it. The manga's artsytle really grew on me. The manga's art is so similar to Yuusa's usual choice of art. It's like he was the only person meant to direct it. |
|
| Yes, honestly I haven't dropped any anime because "bad animation". |
 |
| yeah |
| This leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi |
| I still can't believe I made it almost halfway into Captain Earth. The animation wasn't even that good. |
tsudecimo said: Eh, his art styles are very unique, but they vary tremendously. Ping Pong looked NOTHING like the Tatami Galaxy or KaibaCupquake said: Fair enough. Though I'd be really fucking pissed if he changed it. The manga's artsytle really grew on me. The manga's art is so similar to Yuusa's usual choice of art. It's like he was the only person meant to direct it. |
| The fate of destruction is also the joy of rebirth |
mayukachan said: This leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi I definitely enjoyed Nobunaga Concerto enough to wish for another season we'll probably never get as far as that goes... |
mayukachan said: WAD1992 said: another good example is BONES's captain earth, it had exquisite animation, but the story/plot and overall story were REALLY bad .... so in the end animation/art is not the decisive factor about the quality of an anime. well, at least it gave me a reason for finishing it :) the OST and voice acting too. A+ i found it laking some "stuff" tbh ... The relationship between the main cast was never fully explored , and there was kinda of a "what if" .... but i can see why some would like it, the emphasis on the 3 main characters relationship was good, even though it seamed forced some times, but it was kinda cute ..... 3 kids just forgetting all about it and becoming "really good" friends ................... however that was NOT the main plot of the show, which kinda ruined the overall mood. |
|
mayukachan said: Yes, I'm not Solvite.This leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi |
 |
Link_of_Hyrule said: Eh, his art styles are very unique, but they vary tremendously. Ping Pong looked NOTHING like the Tatami Galaxy or Kaiba Unique sure, I personally don't like it, and think it's ugly. That's because Tatami Galaxy has someone in charge of the character design (His art is amazing, he might be one of the main reasons why I loved Tatami) don't know about Kaiba, but I assume it was because of the story, they need to look like that or something. I'm more referring to Kemonzume and his general choice to have non-detailed mushy art. |
|
badwolf45f said: I haven't either. Bad animation is kind of like AIDS, it's not what actually does the killing, but it exacerbates everything elseYes, honestly I haven't dropped any anime because "bad animation". |
|
WAD1992 said: i found it laking some "stuff" tbh ... The relationship between the main cast was never fully explored , and there was kinda of a "what if" .... but i can see why some would like it, the emphasis on the 3 main characters relationship was good, even though it seamed forced some times, but it was kinda cute ..... 3 kids just forgetting all about it and becoming "really good" friends ................... however that was NOT the main plot of the show, which kinda ruined the overall mood. I know and I agree. It really could have been a lot better. I actually really enjoyed the romance scenes but every character was so "meh" |
mayukachan said: Yes, definitely.This leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi |
FragOutFire said: Why am I a Berserk fan? All I ever experience is pain. We are in the eclipse and Miura has sacrificed us |
ReaperCreeper said: mayukachan said: Yes, I'm not Solvite.This leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi sometimes it's hard, especially in some mech shows, where they switch instantaneously from normal animation to CGI, it kinda kills the mood and seriously stops being anime at that point!!! |
|
| I asked the question because a lot of the times I've seen people who start a CGI show and drop it after the 1st episode because it's hard to get used to. |
WAD1992 said: You should probably get used to it, CGI mecha is the norm now.ReaperCreeper said: Yes, I'm not Solvite. sometimes it's hard, especially in some mech shows, where they switch instantaneously from normal animation to CGI, it kinda kills the mood and seriously stops being anime at that point!!! |
|
silversongwriter said: Chelizzle said: Example? ginga nagareboshi gin... loved it despite it's flaws, but honesty, even for 80s anime, I've seen much better as far as animaton goes... If you use that as an example then yes. |
 |
| yes. example: boys be mayukachan said: implying sidonia is good story 'hurr durr teh gauna are people' m3 did that better than sidoniaThis leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi |
 |
romagia said: mayukachan said: implying sidonia is good story 'hurr durr teh gauna are people' m3 did that better than sidoniaThis leads to the question: Can you forgive CGI if the story is really good? Examples: Nobunaga Concerto and Sidonia no Kishi m3? You mean "trash: the anime"? |
mayukachan said: WAD1992 said: i found it laking some "stuff" tbh ... The relationship between the main cast was never fully explored , and there was kinda of a "what if" .... but i can see why some would like it, the emphasis on the 3 main characters relationship was good, even though it seamed forced some times, but it was kinda cute ..... 3 kids just forgetting all about it and becoming "really good" friends ................... however that was NOT the main plot of the show, which kinda ruined the overall mood. I know and I agree. It really could have been a lot better. I actually really enjoyed the romance scenes but every character was so "meh" ahhhh, yes, the innocent yet controversial (because they were kids, duhhh) romance scenes were kinda cute, it really helped the relationships blossom!!! also it helped that these scenes were brief and more implicit so they would not cross the line to become just blatant sexual fan-service , it gave the relationships meaning and depth ... also the mech fights were kinda awesome!!! |
|
mayukachan said: sidonia? you mean 13 volume manga in 12 episodes: the anime?romagia said: implying sidonia is good story 'hurr durr teh gauna are people' m3 did that better than sidonia m3? You mean "trash: the anime"? |
|
romagia said: mayukachan said: sidonia? you mean 13 volume manga in 12 episodes: the anime?m3? You mean "trash: the anime"? Really? That was 13 volumes? I read it and the pacing was pretty much like the anime. (I thought the anime was better, by far) |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Does your first ever favourite anime(s) still holds a place in your favs?NubFix - 8 hours ago |
31 |
by TheDarkLordOtaku
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» Anime that low-testosterone males can't comprehend ( 1 2 )Ejrodiew - Apr 14 |
76 |
by velvetnyan
»»
13 minutes ago |
|
» What anime do a lot of people consider to be one of the greatest that you think is just good? ( 1 2 )arinthach - Yesterday |
55 |
by Pokitaru
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Spring 2024 my fav anime lineup yet! What is your fav series that is going under the radar?rohan121 - 6 hours ago |
10 |
by Zettaiken
»»
43 minutes ago |
|
» Please recommend anime that has plot/tone sci-fi + fantasy?Donkunsan - 11 hours ago |
10 |
by Zettaiken
»»
54 minutes ago |