Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
[Oshi No Ko]
Available on Manga Store
New
Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »
Sep 26, 6:47 AM
Offline
Mar 2024
13
Aqua and neither Gorou doesn't hav any romantic interest in Ruby or Sarina
It's one sided
So no
Sep 26, 7:15 AM

Offline
Jan 2023
256
how many fucking times are we going to have this conversation
死人に口なし
Sep 26, 7:22 AM

Offline
Jan 2020
284
Reply to Zarutaku
     
WaterMage said:
He never saw Sarina that way
5Reinheit said:
It's clear that Gorou always saw Sarina as a little sister, like some kind of family he never truly felt he had before, and never took her romantic feelings seriously because she was a kid and he was an adult.


Sorry but Gorou wasn't a p*do, he didn't even had that kind of feelings for Ai, and Aqua is not into incest.
Sep 26, 8:13 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
     
5Reinheit said:
Sorry but Gorou wasn't a p*do, he didn't even had that kind of feelings for Ai, and Aqua is not into incest.
Piromysl said:
It's pretty obvious he didn't meant it because denying a dying girl would be a dick move.
Imouto making her onii-chan make such promise is quite common cliché, where everyone plays along because it's obvious they will grow out of it.
And it's not like Sarina would even have a chance to grow out of it, so...

Zarutaku said:
Perhaps, but regardless of that, the topic is about what you think should happen. Should Aqua accept her love and love her back?
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 8:25 AM

Offline
Jul 2015
12300
Zarutaku said:
     
5Reinheit said:
Sorry but Gorou wasn't a p*do, he didn't even had that kind of feelings for Ai, and Aqua is not into incest.
Piromysl said:
It's pretty obvious he didn't meant it because denying a dying girl would be a dick move.
Imouto making her onii-chan make such promise is quite common cliché, where everyone plays along because it's obvious they will grow out of it.
And it's not like Sarina would even have a chance to grow out of it, so...

Zarutaku said:
Perhaps, but regardless of that, the topic is about what you think should happen. Should Aqua accept her love and love her back?

I think people thoroughly explained it to you, that it will never happen.
At no point Gorou has ever held any feelings for Sarina and will never reciprocate them. In previous life because she was underage and in current beside she is his sister.

Sep 26, 8:31 AM

Offline
Aug 2017
11427
Yes, as an Incest lover, absolutely 💖
NurguburuSep 26, 8:49 AM
BANZAI NIPPON. Nippon is the Land of freedom. Nippon is the Land of Peace. Nippon is the Land of Justice and Prosperity.

In Nippon, we trust.

We love Nippon, we love Anime. Anime love us, Nippon love us. 日本
Sep 26, 8:31 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Reply to Piromysl
Zarutaku said:
     
5Reinheit said:
Sorry but Gorou wasn't a p*do, he didn't even had that kind of feelings for Ai, and Aqua is not into incest.
Piromysl said:
It's pretty obvious he didn't meant it because denying a dying girl would be a dick move.
Imouto making her onii-chan make such promise is quite common cliché, where everyone plays along because it's obvious they will grow out of it.
And it's not like Sarina would even have a chance to grow out of it, so...

Zarutaku said:
Perhaps, but regardless of that, the topic is about what you think should happen. Should Aqua accept her love and love her back?

I think people thoroughly explained it to you, that it will never happen.
At no point Gorou has ever held any feelings for Sarina and will never reciprocate them. In previous life because she was underage and in current beside she is his sister.
Piromysl said:
it will never happen

The topic isn't about what will happen, but what you think should happen. (x2)
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 9:25 AM

Offline
Jan 2021
1643
AustinJamB said:
Cielord said:

So you just conveniently forget that Ruby also has a past life?

Even if we include their past life age, they are both well into their adult life; if we don't, they are both the same age. So no problem.

You can’t just add their past life age and current age together. Ruby may have experienced 28 years of life across two childhoods, but that doesn’t mean she has the mind of a 28 year old. She’s never experienced adulthood. Aqua has.

If you add their past life age for Aqua, you also do it for Ruby; if you don't for Ruby, then you don't also for Aqua. Not a tough concept to understand.
Sep 26, 9:35 AM

Offline
Jul 2015
12300
Reply to Zarutaku
Piromysl said:
it will never happen

The topic isn't about what will happen, but what you think should happen. (x2)
Zarutaku said:
The topic isn't about what will happen, but what you think should happen. (x2)


It won't nor it should happen.

Sep 26, 9:37 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Reply to Cielord
AustinJamB said:
Cielord said:

So you just conveniently forget that Ruby also has a past life?

Even if we include their past life age, they are both well into their adult life; if we don't, they are both the same age. So no problem.

You can’t just add their past life age and current age together. Ruby may have experienced 28 years of life across two childhoods, but that doesn’t mean she has the mind of a 28 year old. She’s never experienced adulthood. Aqua has.

If you add their past life age for Aqua, you also do it for Ruby; if you don't for Ruby, then you don't also for Aqua. Not a tough concept to understand.
@Cielord I think he's trying to argue that only the max. age they have reached in each life matters.
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 9:54 AM

Offline
Jan 2021
1643
Zarutaku said:
@Cielord I think he's trying to argue that only the max. age they have reached in each life matters.

That's even dumber than the alternative.
Sep 26, 10:38 AM

Offline
Jul 2020
1649
aw as much as I love anime incest, Akane is still superior
I wouldn't mind if they had a threesome though
Sep 26, 10:52 AM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Inexplicable said:
aw as much as I love anime incest, Akane is still superior
I wouldn't mind if they had a threesome though

Poor Kana being left out, Akane is superior indeed, but Kana is still great, she deserves to be part of the harem as well.
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 10:52 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20055
Reply to Cielord
Zarutaku said:
@Cielord I think he's trying to argue that only the max. age they have reached in each life matters.

That's even dumber than the alternative.
@Cielord Nah it makes sense , honestly.

Sarina was "forced" to live inside a hospital room for most of her life. She has no experiences in life and never matured. The only things that she could think about were her mother, Ai and Gorou. Ruby might as well had started her new life from 0.

Aqua on the other hand was in his 30s. He understood himself and the world around him, had connections with people, got good education etc.

In gaming terms, Ruby started a new game while Aqua was in NG+.

That aside, it is irrelevant since what Sarina/Ruby's feeling for Gorou/Aqua are onesided from the start.Whether they are same age or a 28yo woman and a guy in his 50s is irrelevant.
Sep 26, 10:53 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20055
Reply to weeb00_00
Fukoku said:
No, they are siblings. And I don’t care what anyone says, incest is incest.

The mangaka says otherwise tho
@weeb00_00 I didnt know Aka stopped writing this because clearly you are following a different mangaka.
Sep 26, 11:02 AM

Offline
Jan 2021
1643
ssjokg said:
@Cielord Nah it makes sense , honestly.

Sarina was "forced" to live inside a hospital room for most of her life. She has no experiences in life and never matured. The only things that she could think about were her mother, Ai and Gorou. Ruby might as well had started her new life from 0.

Aqua on the other hand was in his 30s. He understood himself and the world around him, had connections with people, got good education etc.

In gaming terms, Ruby started a new game while Aqua was in NG+.

That aside, it is irrelevant since what Sarina/Ruby's feeling for Gorou/Aqua are onesided from the start.Whether they are same age or a 28yo woman and a guy in his 50s is irrelevant.

Regardless of how she spent her life as Sarina, that life has importance for her; it affects hers. The same goes for Aqua in his life as Aqua Hoshino.

By judging only the maximum age they both reached, you're removing an experience that severely impacted them.
Sep 26, 11:15 AM

Offline
Oct 2021
13
Commit_Crime said:
soulless mimics pretending to have an ounce of humanity be like:
"grrrr look at them being happy and having genetically superior children, this is evil, we need to stop this😠😠😠😠"

Bro what the actual fuck 😭
*Train Noises*
Sep 26, 11:18 AM

Offline
Oct 2021
13
God I really fucking hate anime fans. This is why y'all get bullied man 💀
*Train Noises*
Sep 26, 11:20 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20055
Reply to Cielord
ssjokg said:
@Cielord Nah it makes sense , honestly.

Sarina was "forced" to live inside a hospital room for most of her life. She has no experiences in life and never matured. The only things that she could think about were her mother, Ai and Gorou. Ruby might as well had started her new life from 0.

Aqua on the other hand was in his 30s. He understood himself and the world around him, had connections with people, got good education etc.

In gaming terms, Ruby started a new game while Aqua was in NG+.

That aside, it is irrelevant since what Sarina/Ruby's feeling for Gorou/Aqua are onesided from the start.Whether they are same age or a 28yo woman and a guy in his 50s is irrelevant.

Regardless of how she spent her life as Sarina, that life has importance for her; it affects hers. The same goes for Aqua in his life as Aqua Hoshino.

By judging only the maximum age they both reached, you're removing an experience that severely impacted them.
@Cielord It is important yes but she hardly has experiences with the world AND people. Just because someone is 18+ doesnt mean they are mature.

And we can definitely see how mature Aqua and Ruby are for their age. Ruby is hardly different from those her age, hell sometimes she actually shows how much more mature her peers are.
Sep 26, 11:21 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20055
Reply to Yougoddamnnerd
Commit_Crime said:
soulless mimics pretending to have an ounce of humanity be like:
"grrrr look at them being happy and having genetically superior children, this is evil, we need to stop this😠😠😠😠"

Bro what the actual fuck 😭
@Yougoddamnnerd On one hand, it is disgusting yes. On the other hand Ai gets the love she always wanted and deserved.
Sep 26, 11:25 AM

Offline
Jan 2021
1643
Reply to ssjokg
@Cielord It is important yes but she hardly has experiences with the world AND people. Just because someone is 18+ doesnt mean they are mature.

And we can definitely see how mature Aqua and Ruby are for their age. Ruby is hardly different from those her age, hell sometimes she actually shows how much more mature her peers are.
@ssjokg
ssjokg said:
It is important yes but she hardly has experiences with the world AND people. Just because someone is 18+ doesnt mean they are mature.

Yes, I understand that, but as said before, "By judging only the maximum age they both reached, you're removing an experience that severely impacted them."

And if that's how you're going, then what would say the 'actual' age of both of them is?
Sep 26, 11:28 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20055
Reply to Cielord
@ssjokg
ssjokg said:
It is important yes but she hardly has experiences with the world AND people. Just because someone is 18+ doesnt mean they are mature.

Yes, I understand that, but as said before, "By judging only the maximum age they both reached, you're removing an experience that severely impacted them."

And if that's how you're going, then what would say the 'actual' age of both of them is?
@Cielord Their current biological age.

Aqua may have a head start because of experiences but by his own admission he isnt Gorou. Aqua is a mature for his age 16yo and Ruby is a less mature than her peers 16yo.
Sep 26, 11:35 AM

Offline
Jan 2021
1643
Reply to ssjokg
@Cielord Their current biological age.

Aqua may have a head start because of experiences but by his own admission he isnt Gorou. Aqua is a mature for his age 16yo and Ruby is a less mature than her peers 16yo.
@ssjokg In that case, I agree.
Sep 26, 12:59 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Trimethylglycine said:
how many fucking times are we going to have this conversation

Until the majority will be red pilled.
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 12:59 PM

Offline
Oct 2021
13
ssjokg said:
@Yougoddamnnerd On one hand, it is disgusting yes. On the other hand Ai gets the love she always wanted and deserved.

?????? You realise just how dumb that sounds right? Ngl if I was the child of my own kids who literally incested themselves I would be the opposite of happy. Don't normalise this complete insanity.
*Train Noises*
Sep 26, 1:05 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Reply to Yougoddamnnerd
ssjokg said:
@Yougoddamnnerd On one hand, it is disgusting yes. On the other hand Ai gets the love she always wanted and deserved.

?????? You realise just how dumb that sounds right? Ngl if I was the child of my own kids who literally incested themselves I would be the opposite of happy. Don't normalise this complete insanity.
@Yougoddamnnerd

No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 1:06 PM

Offline
Oct 2021
13

Hmm yes... It's a shame that people with brilliant artistic talents draw complete garbage isn't it?
*Train Noises*
Sep 26, 1:15 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Yougoddamnnerd said:
It's a shame that people with brilliant artistic talents draw complete garbage isn't it?

Happy families aren't garbage 😐
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 1:41 PM

Offline
Apr 2013
37000
Man, I don't know... on the one hand Sarina really loved the dude and deserves to be happy in her 2nd life. On the other hand Aqua x Akane fits so nicely... >_<
Sep 26, 1:43 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Gator said:
Man, I don't know... on the one hand Sarina really loved the dude and deserves to be happy in her 2nd life. On the other hand Aqua x Akane fits so nicely... >_<

As always harem route is best solution.
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 2:11 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
rohan121 said:
The bond of siblings is not rooted in sex

You make that sound like a general truth, but there are many exceptions.

ZarutakuSep 27, 3:22 AM
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 26, 4:39 PM
Offline
Feb 2019
8
Zarutaku said:
     
WaterMage said:
He never saw Sarina that way
5Reinheit said:
It's clear that Gorou always saw Sarina as a little sister, like some kind of family he never truly felt he had before, and never took her romantic feelings seriously because she was a kid and he was an adult.


He said this because both knew that she never will turn 16.
Sep 26, 6:21 PM

Offline
Nov 2015
686
if they do imma be mad. This show is always on the brink on being bad.
Sep 27, 2:10 AM

Offline
May 2021
4237
Zarutaku said:
Since Ruby is Sarina and she still loves Goro who is Aqua now, do you think Ruby & Aqua should become lovers?

Abso-fucking-lutely NOT!!

Aqua and Ruby are related by blood, doesn't matter who they were in their past lives
Sep 27, 2:19 AM

Offline
May 2021
4237
Reply to WaterMage
Aqua's standpoint is not clear. He never saw Sarina that way and the fact it's her sister will make situation even worse.
Even if siblings taboo is ignored there's also a 20 year age gap.

But if both of them are into it maybe...
Who cares anyway.
WaterMage said:
Even if siblings taboo is ignored there's also a 20 year age gap

That would've been a problem in their past lives

But say if they got reincarnated as different people, so not blood related, 16 years have past since Goro's death and 20 years since Sarina's

Sarina was 12 when she died, Goro was in his late 20s/early 30s, so if you want to go by the logic that because they remember their past lives their mental age retains their age of the past lives, that's make Sarina in her early 30s and Goro in his mid 40s in current time, now the age gap isn't so jarring

But they are now siblings and it was very one sided anyway, so i don't think there'll be anything romantic between them, some confusion maybe, but not romance
Sep 27, 2:23 AM

Offline
May 2021
4237
Reply to Commit_Crime
soulless mimics pretending to have an ounce of humanity be like:
"grrrr look at them being happy and having genetically superior children, this is evil, we need to stop this😠😠😠😠"
@Commit_Crime If by genetically superior you mean lowered immune system and possible genetic mutations yeah sure, they're superior...
Sep 27, 2:36 AM

Offline
Jan 2024
1050
Reply to DigiCat
WaterMage said:
Even if siblings taboo is ignored there's also a 20 year age gap

That would've been a problem in their past lives

But say if they got reincarnated as different people, so not blood related, 16 years have past since Goro's death and 20 years since Sarina's

Sarina was 12 when she died, Goro was in his late 20s/early 30s, so if you want to go by the logic that because they remember their past lives their mental age retains their age of the past lives, that's make Sarina in her early 30s and Goro in his mid 40s in current time, now the age gap isn't so jarring

But they are now siblings and it was very one sided anyway, so i don't think there'll be anything romantic between them, some confusion maybe, but not romance
@DigiCat there past relationship was also immoral this is also same.
That's my point.

But I do feel for Ruby/Sarina though..
Sep 27, 2:45 AM

Offline
May 2021
4237
Reply to WaterMage
@DigiCat there past relationship was also immoral this is also same.
That's my point.

But I do feel for Ruby/Sarina though..
@WaterMage Exept there wasn't a past relationship

Like i said, it was one sided, on Sarina's part

Goro did not have any romantic feelings for her at the time, and considering he also seemed to see her as a lil sister he likely never would even if they'd both survived and met in the future when they're both adults

But say if they did survive and meet up as adults and Goro did start to have feelings for adult Sarina, at that point they are both adults, there is nothing immoral there
Sep 27, 2:52 AM

Offline
Jan 2024
1050
Reply to DigiCat
@WaterMage Exept there wasn't a past relationship

Like i said, it was one sided, on Sarina's part

Goro did not have any romantic feelings for her at the time, and considering he also seemed to see her as a lil sister he likely never would even if they'd both survived and met in the future when they're both adults

But say if they did survive and meet up as adults and Goro did start to have feelings for adult Sarina, at that point they are both adults, there is nothing immoral there
@DigiCat I said hypothetically..
And I am already aware of what you said.

Except..
DigiCat said:
But say if they did survive and meet up as adults and Goro did start to have feelings for adult Sarina, at that point they are both adults, there is nothing immoral there

Sarina was 12 when he died Gorou at minimum will have 16-17 year age gap.
Idk how a 16 year old Sarina would get him to accept. That WAS HER GOAL. Not as a 30 year old girl rizzing up a 50 year old.
Sep 27, 3:36 AM

Offline
May 2021
4237
Reply to WaterMage
@DigiCat I said hypothetically..
And I am already aware of what you said.

Except..
DigiCat said:
But say if they did survive and meet up as adults and Goro did start to have feelings for adult Sarina, at that point they are both adults, there is nothing immoral there

Sarina was 12 when he died Gorou at minimum will have 16-17 year age gap.
Idk how a 16 year old Sarina would get him to accept. That WAS HER GOAL. Not as a 30 year old girl rizzing up a 50 year old.
@WaterMage That was her goal because she didn't have long to live
Sep 27, 5:17 AM

Offline
Aug 2009
20055
Reply to Yougoddamnnerd
ssjokg said:
@Yougoddamnnerd On one hand, it is disgusting yes. On the other hand Ai gets the love she always wanted and deserved.

?????? You realise just how dumb that sounds right? Ngl if I was the child of my own kids who literally incested themselves I would be the opposite of happy. Don't normalise this complete insanity.
@Yougoddamnnerd FFS get a joke. Not everything has to be serious. If you cant, that's on you. Get riled up on your own over anime incest meme where the cycle of reincarnation between parent and kids in the joke.
Sep 27, 5:52 AM

Offline
Jul 2021
1448
Reply to DigiCat
@Commit_Crime If by genetically superior you mean lowered immune system and possible genetic mutations yeah sure, they're superior...
@DigiCat
A little retardation never hurt anyone
(also being born with extra limbs = better work flow)
Sep 27, 6:37 AM

Offline
May 2021
4237
Reply to Commit_Crime
@DigiCat
A little retardation never hurt anyone
(also being born with extra limbs = better work flow)
@Commit_Crime Assuming those limbs will be functional and not obstructing the function of vital organs...
Sep 27, 6:48 AM

Offline
Feb 2011
3611
Even though I find Akane a good choice too, it's hard to compete against the shared destiny of Ruby and Aqua.

@Commit_Crime You have a very fitting avatar.
Sep 27, 6:51 AM

Offline
Jul 2021
1448
Reply to DigiCat
@Commit_Crime Assuming those limbs will be functional and not obstructing the function of vital organs...
@DigiCat
no biggie, siblings can share anything including organs
Sep 27, 6:53 AM

Offline
Jul 2021
1448
Reply to Shizuna
Even though I find Akane a good choice too, it's hard to compete against the shared destiny of Ruby and Aqua.

@Commit_Crime You have a very fitting avatar.
@Shizuna
Even though I find Akane a good choice too, it's hard to compete against the shared destiny of Ruby and Aqua.

congrats, you have a soul!!!!!!
@Commit_Crime You have a very fitting avatar.

Sep 27, 12:23 PM

Offline
Sep 2016
10165
Reply to Mykasan
if they do imma be mad. This show is always on the brink on being bad.
unbased gab 💀
No, this isn't my signature~desu.
Sep 27, 12:46 PM
Offline
Nov 2023
78
bro, they are literally biological twins, how fucked up must you be to think that there is a chance between them.
Sep 27, 3:05 PM

Offline
Jan 2014
3761
71%? god damn what a bunch of fucking normies

Sep 27, 4:22 PM
scientia exitus

Offline
Mar 2020
6006
Yes, but actually..... yes

However, Kana is a better match for him, so it should actually be Ruby

Ok but seriously now, there is no one for him other than Akane. They were meant to be together. So he should be with Ruby



NYANPASU
whiskey tango foxtrot

Pages (3) « 1 [2] 3 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Ricky16 - Oct 6

317 by reizero-0 »»
3 hours ago

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Ricky16 - Sep 18

250 by Shikkakku »»
Nov 25, 2:46 AM

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

nirererin - Aug 21

245 by unmemorablehero »»
Nov 22, 10:23 PM

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Softhenic03 - Jul 10

191 by TheAquilaSamurai »»
Nov 21, 12:28 AM

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

IzanaSolos - Sep 25

221 by Threepybot »»
Nov 19, 11:39 AM

Preview MangaManga Store

It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login