Forum Settings
Forums

Anime Project for 'Mukuwarenakatta Murabito A, Kizoku ni Hirowarete Dekiai sareru Ue ni, Jitsu wa Motteita Densetsu-kyuu no Kami Skill mo Kakusei shita' Light Novel in Progress

New
Oct 25, 2023 9:44 PM
#1
Content Admin
Overkilled Red

Offline
Aug 2013
7115
The wraparound band on the sixth volume of Nazuna Miki's Mukuwarenakatta Murabito A, Kizoku ni Hirowarete Dekiai sareru Ue ni, Jitsu wa Motteita Densetsu-kyuu no Kami Skill mo Kakusei shita light novel announced an anime adaptation on Wednesday.

The anime was originally announced on the 48th and final episode of the "Kappei Yamaguchi's Dramatic Radio" program on the HiBiKi Radio Station on September 20. The radio drama, which began in June 2021, was part of the mixed media project for the series. The Dash X Bunko imprint's official X (Twitter) account also posted the anime announcement earlier this month.

Miki began penning the isekai fantasy novel on the Shousetsuka ni Narou website in May 2020. Shueisha began publishing the series under its Dash X Bunko label in February 2021, featuring illustrations by Kaito Shibano (Ben-To).

Suzume Kumo began serializing a manga adaptation on the Suiyoubi wa Mattari Dash X Comic web magazine in December 2022. Shueisha released the first volume on May 19.

Synopsis
Matteo, who was supposed to be just a common villager, is reborn as the grandson of an imperial aristocrat, Lawrence. He spends his days being doted on by his powerful grandfather. With his immense magical powers, Matteo rapidly hatches a dragon egg and tames the dragon, naming it Eva. When his magical abilities are measured, it's revealed that he possesses the strongest magic power ever recorded!

He quickly learns how to use magic, reviving ancient spells and effortlessly drawing the most powerful sword that absorbs magic, making it the strongest. Matteo is also favored by the emperor he meets, but the emperor holds a secret—?

Clever, illustrious, strong, as expected! The life of the most beloved noble, where everything is affirmed, boldly begins!

Source: Dash X Bunko on X (Twitter)

Mukuwarenakatta Murabito A, Kizoku ni Hirowarete Dekiai sareru Ue ni, Jitsu wa Motteita Densetsu-kyuu no Kami Skill mo Kakusei shita on MAL
VindstotOct 26, 2023 4:39 AM

Oct 25, 2023 10:36 PM
#2

Offline
Feb 2021
6817
I like how this light novel is not even on the database...
Oct 25, 2023 10:36 PM
#3

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
So, the industry needs so many new anime that studios have literally moved on to adapting school teen fanfiction about unlimited strength and power? Although, if you think about it, this was an expected step after adapting increasingly male and female fantasies in romance...
Oct 25, 2023 10:37 PM
#4

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
Reply to MadanielFL
I like how this light novel is not even on the database...
@MadanielFL It seems that its name is too long even to simply add it to the database.
Oct 26, 2023 12:03 AM
#5

Offline
Jan 2018
558
Reply to MadanielFL
I like how this light novel is not even on the database...
@MadanielFL Does anybody even know what its named as in the database? lmao
Oct 26, 2023 6:05 AM
#6

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to RobertBobert
So, the industry needs so many new anime that studios have literally moved on to adapting school teen fanfiction about unlimited strength and power? Although, if you think about it, this was an expected step after adapting increasingly male and female fantasies in romance...
@RobertBobert

It'll only be matter of time before fanfiction.net becomes a potential haven for LN adaptations

Oct 26, 2023 7:07 AM
#7
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
HOLY SHIT

another LN adaptation about a reincarnated short black haired underdog character in a medieval fantasy world who's going to end up being OP/unbeatable?????




EcchiGodMamsterOct 26, 2023 7:18 AM
Oct 26, 2023 8:08 AM
#8

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
HOLY SHIT

another LN adaptation about a reincarnated short black haired underdog character in a medieval fantasy world who's going to end up being OP/unbeatable?????




@EcchiGodMamster
We did it was just in different form called "The Battle Harem"

Oct 26, 2023 10:31 AM
#9

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster
We did it was just in different form called "The Battle Harem"
@GalacticMagna I think that as an ecchi fan he is well aware of this. For some reason he just can’t get past shows that irritate him. I never understood such people. No one is forcing us to watch or discuss this.
Oct 26, 2023 10:34 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to RobertBobert
@GalacticMagna I think that as an ecchi fan he is well aware of this. For some reason he just can’t get past shows that irritate him. I never understood such people. No one is forcing us to watch or discuss this.
@RobertBobert

That's the thing. I don't watch most of Isekai series as of recent cause they all are the same.. Hell I don't even give it passing glance. (Well that and I read their manga adaptation). And don't complain about it. It's a trend at the end of the day... It'll die down at some point.

Oct 26, 2023 10:36 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
Reply to GalacticMagna
@RobertBobert

That's the thing. I don't watch most of Isekai series as of recent cause they all are the same.. Hell I don't even give it passing glance. (Well that and I read their manga adaptation). And don't complain about it. It's a trend at the end of the day... It'll die down at some point.
@GalacticMagna I just try not to spend too much time on it. Some isekai I will watch, some I will ignore. There are so many of them that it’s simply a shame to spend so much time on each one. Although judging by the discussion of the episodes, each isekai still finds some kind of audience.
Oct 26, 2023 12:23 PM
Offline
Nov 2021
24
Reply to MadanielFL
I like how this light novel is not even on the database...
Well probably no one bothered to add them until now lol, likely because it don't have an official or unofficial translation no one knew it existed in the west, and same goes for the manga lol, but they shortly got added after the news

-

Given the LN have 6 Volumes by now, it really flew under, and going with the other works from this author i don't really expect much of this, same author as My Unique Skill Makes Me OP Even at Level 1 btw
Oct 26, 2023 12:58 PM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster
We did it was just in different form called "The Battle Harem"
@GalacticMagna

Uh...NO...

I've seen every battle harem and almost all of these isekai/reincarnation anime

battle harems didn't all have the what is basically same looking guy in the same looking world fighting the same looking enemies, nor was the main character ever untouchable or the girls

They were far easier to tell apart nor were there this fucking many a season
Oct 26, 2023 1:09 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

Uh...NO...

I've seen every battle harem and almost all of these isekai/reincarnation anime

battle harems didn't all have the what is basically same looking guy in the same looking world fighting the same looking enemies, nor was the main character ever untouchable or the girls

They were far easier to tell apart nor were there this fucking many a season
@EcchiGodMamster
Right... Let's forget those Ichika/Issei clones we had every season. And untouchable girls? Yeah outside of what Shinmai Maou and Masou Gauken... Can't find anything else... Oh yeah, the same school setting that has only girls in them. Let's be real they aren't any better, you just came to like them.

Oct 26, 2023 1:45 PM
Offline
Apr 2023
10
literally nobody cares about this light novel, why is it getting an anime adaptation? Lol
like we don't have a sh#t ton of uninspired/boring isekai's already
I'm waiting for studios to start making adaptations of some random wattpad/ao3 fanfictions made by edgy 14 year olds
Oct 26, 2023 3:15 PM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster
Right... Let's forget those Ichika/Issei clones we had every season. And untouchable girls? Yeah outside of what Shinmai Maou and Masou Gauken... Can't find anything else... Oh yeah, the same school setting that has only girls in them. Let's be real they aren't any better, you just came to like them.
@GalacticMagna

oh?

lemme challenge you then


I'm thinking of an isekai/reincarnation anime

theres a boy with short black hair who is in a medieval fantasy world, and in this medieval fantasy world he gets special powers that make him overpowered to the point where no one can defeat him

along the way he meets some girls who end up following him around, these girls are also OP at least in comparison to most others in the world

there is also a king who seems to be pretty dumb and he also has a horde of knights that are also pretty dumb

along the way, he meets other adventurers, none of which seem to be as strong as his group

there are also demi-humans, ie elves, monsters girls, the like

he spends much of his time in villages, forests, dungeons

most of his enemies consist of goblins, dragons, slimes,  and mostly bald bandits who are causing trouble

he finds out that there is a demon lord as well



which isekai/reincarnation anime am i thinking of?



NOW

do the same thing with ONE battle harem and see if i can't figure out which show you're talking about

then tell me I'm wrong
EcchiGodMamsterOct 26, 2023 3:52 PM
Oct 26, 2023 8:23 PM

Offline
Jan 2016
523
I always lose a bit of my sanity when I see these projects announced, I love when the anime industry fails to innovate a genre. I get that kids watch this stuff but like, I doubt most of them have a budget to even buy blurays for this stuff.





"Get your tentacles off me or ill make calamari out of your manhood" -Mirai Nikki Dub
Oct 26, 2023 9:40 PM

Offline
Jun 2019
6661
Commence the countdown.

Anyone else ultra-excited for this? Apparently the word on the street from the slowly growing overseas fanbase of the light novel who've carved out a reputation for it as a cult classic say that if they play their cards right with the adaptation, this anime has the potential to be the next Made in Abyss of the 2020s.
Oct 27, 2023 4:06 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
Reply to WatchTillTandava
Commence the countdown.

Anyone else ultra-excited for this? Apparently the word on the street from the slowly growing overseas fanbase of the light novel who've carved out a reputation for it as a cult classic say that if they play their cards right with the adaptation, this anime has the potential to be the next Made in Abyss of the 2020s.
@WatchTillTandava Are we sure we're talking about the same show?
Oct 27, 2023 4:54 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

oh?

lemme challenge you then


I'm thinking of an isekai/reincarnation anime

theres a boy with short black hair who is in a medieval fantasy world, and in this medieval fantasy world he gets special powers that make him overpowered to the point where no one can defeat him

along the way he meets some girls who end up following him around, these girls are also OP at least in comparison to most others in the world

there is also a king who seems to be pretty dumb and he also has a horde of knights that are also pretty dumb

along the way, he meets other adventurers, none of which seem to be as strong as his group

there are also demi-humans, ie elves, monsters girls, the like

he spends much of his time in villages, forests, dungeons

most of his enemies consist of goblins, dragons, slimes,  and mostly bald bandits who are causing trouble

he finds out that there is a demon lord as well



which isekai/reincarnation anime am i thinking of?



NOW

do the same thing with ONE battle harem and see if i can't figure out which show you're talking about

then tell me I'm wrong
@EcchiGodMamster

We're really doing this huh? (Sigh)

Battle Harem template
- Boy is transfered to a boarding school where students (mostly girls) are able to do magic/wield Mecha

- Meets main love interest but gets pissed for reasons unknown

- Main love interest challenges boy and loses badly

-On his life he finds varies love interest

- Boy have some vague pack story that will never be revealed.

If you can reduce Isekai to it's most reductive format, it can be done just as easily for Battle Harem. I said before and I might as well say it again, how is it any different from Isekai/Harems. Battle Harems and Isekai/Harem have very similar content the difference is setting.

Now ask me this what makes Battle Harems better. Like what makes it better than something like Reincarnated as a Sword or Skeleton Knight (not even gonna mention the popular ones). Don't get this twisted I'm not all that interested in Isekai either but honestly 10 years ago we had this same exact format but in different setting (Battle Harems)

Oct 27, 2023 5:43 AM

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

We're really doing this huh? (Sigh)

Battle Harem template
- Boy is transfered to a boarding school where students (mostly girls) are able to do magic/wield Mecha

- Meets main love interest but gets pissed for reasons unknown

- Main love interest challenges boy and loses badly

-On his life he finds varies love interest

- Boy have some vague pack story that will never be revealed.

If you can reduce Isekai to it's most reductive format, it can be done just as easily for Battle Harem. I said before and I might as well say it again, how is it any different from Isekai/Harems. Battle Harems and Isekai/Harem have very similar content the difference is setting.

Now ask me this what makes Battle Harems better. Like what makes it better than something like Reincarnated as a Sword or Skeleton Knight (not even gonna mention the popular ones). Don't get this twisted I'm not all that interested in Isekai either but honestly 10 years ago we had this same exact format but in different setting (Battle Harems)
@GalacticMagna As I've said before in similar debates, the reality is that almost any popular genre can be simplified into a popular formula. Starting from CGDCT with a harem cast without a protagonist and moe SoL elements, to all-male sports shows with their BL character designs and the “get stronger to defeat a stronger opponent” system. It's like with musical genres. When you are immersed in a genre, you are able to separate the slightest nuances from each other and recognize any group by sound, while if you don’t like a genre, all the groups in it will seem the same to you.
Oct 27, 2023 6:34 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

We're really doing this huh? (Sigh)

Battle Harem template
- Boy is transfered to a boarding school where students (mostly girls) are able to do magic/wield Mecha

- Meets main love interest but gets pissed for reasons unknown

- Main love interest challenges boy and loses badly

-On his life he finds varies love interest

- Boy have some vague pack story that will never be revealed.

If you can reduce Isekai to it's most reductive format, it can be done just as easily for Battle Harem. I said before and I might as well say it again, how is it any different from Isekai/Harems. Battle Harems and Isekai/Harem have very similar content the difference is setting.

Now ask me this what makes Battle Harems better. Like what makes it better than something like Reincarnated as a Sword or Skeleton Knight (not even gonna mention the popular ones). Don't get this twisted I'm not all that interested in Isekai either but honestly 10 years ago we had this same exact format but in different setting (Battle Harems)
@GalacticMagna

You didn't even do what I asked...

I gave you way more detail than you did including some of the characters

and most battle harems don't start like that

by some of the details you gave you just eliminated the majority of them
Oct 27, 2023 6:46 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

You didn't even do what I asked...

I gave you way more detail than you did including some of the characters

and most battle harems don't start like that

by some of the details you gave you just eliminated the majority of them
@EcchiGodMamster


Yeah, this is going nowhere... You didn't give any details about Isekai either. It's all boiled down to... Main guy goes to fantasy world and forms harem. Most Isekai I watch hardly have a harem anyway or start out like that.

Oct 27, 2023 6:55 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster


Yeah, this is going nowhere... You didn't give any details about Isekai either. It's all boiled down to... Main guy goes to fantasy world and forms harem. Most Isekai I watch hardly have a harem anyway or start out like that.
@GalacticMagna

i dont' think you understand what i was trying to do

THAT WAS THE POINT

the entire point of what i was doing was trying to prove that i can lay out most of the isekai/reincarnation format by mentioning:

what the MC looks like

his power level

the world he lives in and where he goes

describe some of the other characters including who he fights against


without you being able to tell which show im talking about





so i was challenging you to do the same with battle harems


what im saying is, IF you tell me the same details about a battle harem, i will be able to tell which battle harem you're talking about

get it?

Oct 27, 2023 7:05 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

i dont' think you understand what i was trying to do

THAT WAS THE POINT

the entire point of what i was doing was trying to prove that i can lay out most of the isekai/reincarnation format by mentioning:

what the MC looks like

his power level

the world he lives in and where he goes

describe some of the other characters including who he fights against


without you being able to tell which show im talking about





so i was challenging you to do the same with battle harems


what im saying is, IF you tell me the same details about a battle harem, i will be able to tell which battle harem you're talking about

get it?

@EcchiGodMamster

But here's the thing they are NO different.

The MC in most battle Harems are just as OP as the Isekai MC. We don't know who he is apart from vague back stories. We don't know where's he's from cause most the setting is at school. As for the fights it's the same tournament arcs that the MC inevitably wins. If they aren't doing that it's random missions to defeat gimmicky monsters.

If this doesn't explain most battle Harems then I don't know what does.

Oct 27, 2023 7:10 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

But here's the thing they are NO different.

The MC in most battle Harems are just as OP as the Isekai MC. We don't know who he is apart from vague back stories. We don't know where's he's from cause most the setting is at school. As for the fights it's the same tournament arcs that the MC inevitably wins. If they aren't doing that it's random missions to defeat gimmicky monsters.

If this doesn't explain most battle Harems then I don't know what does.
@GalacticMagna

i don't think you remember most battle harems or even watched them all, cause you're not describing the majority of them

no, the MC were not all just as OP as isekai protagonists... people used to whine about the fact that in many cases the guy was useless or a pussy

did some of what you're describing happen in SOME of them? yes... but your'e clearly forgetting some of the key differences that most of these short black haired mc isekai dont have

i've seen EVERY battle harem... the format had more variation and the varation you're not mentioning is what matters




and EVEN IF for sake of argument they were just as generic, there were no where near as many as there are isekai
EcchiGodMamsterOct 27, 2023 7:14 AM
Oct 27, 2023 7:18 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

i don't think you remember most battle harems or even watched them all, cause you're not describing the majority of them

no, the MC were not all just as OP as isekai protagonists... people used to whine about the fact that in many cases the guy was useless or a pussy

did some of what you're describing happen in SOME of them? yes... but your'e clearly forgetting some of the key differences that most of these short black haired mc isekai dont have

i've seen EVERY battle harem... the format had more variation and the varation you're not mentioning is what matters




and EVEN IF for sake of argument they were just as generic, there were no where near as many as there are isekai
@EcchiGodMamster

At this point, I don't care... Isekai and battle Harems follow certain formulas. Isekai has just as much variation, you're too ignorant to see them and focus on the worst ones. Battle Harems hardly has any far as I'm concerned. Both of these genres are just trends.

Oct 27, 2023 7:29 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

At this point, I don't care... Isekai and battle Harems follow certain formulas. Isekai has just as much variation, you're too ignorant to see them and focus on the worst ones. Battle Harems hardly has any far as I'm concerned. Both of these genres are just trends.
@GalacticMagna

no they don't

most of the MCs are a guy with short black hair and theyre pretty much always OP/unbeatable

they ALL take place in a medieval fantasy world

they all have the same monsters

they all have demi-humans

they all have the same looking bandits

they all have the same looking villages, forests, locations, including the fortress town

they almost all have some dumb king whos knights are also dumb



thats not the same amount of variation as battle harems had


the mc of battle harems looked different and their power levels varied

the schools didnt all look the same neither did the locations

some were mostly girls school, but most were mixed

the villains were different depending on the show

SOME had demi-humans, some didnt

some had mech suits, some didnt

some had monsters, some didnt


that is variation
EcchiGodMamsterOct 27, 2023 7:33 AM
Oct 27, 2023 7:33 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

no they don't

most of the MCs are a guy with short black hair and theyre pretty much always OP/unbeatable

they ALL take place in a medieval fantasy world

they all have the same monsters

they all have demi-humans

they all have the same looking bandits

they all have the same looking villages, forests, locations, including the fortress town

they almost all have some dumb king whos knights are also dumb



thats not the same amount of variation as battle harems had


the mc of battle harems looked different and their power levels varied

the schools didnt all look the same neither did the locations

some were mostly girls school, but most were mixed

the villains were different depending on the show

SOME had demi-humans, some didnt

some had mech suits, some didnt

some had monsters, some didnt


that is variation
@EcchiGodMamster


Yeah... No

Battle Harem had the same short hair

The same "evil for the sake of being evil" villains

The schools looked the same

I'll give points for demi humans

But everything else is pretty much the same

I can be ignorant as you, you know... Alright I'm done

Oct 27, 2023 7:39 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster


Yeah... No

Battle Harem had the same short hair

The same "evil for the sake of being evil" villains

The schools looked the same

I'll give points for demi humans

But everything else is pretty much the same

I can be ignorant as you, you know... Alright I'm done
@GalacticMagna

you're purposefully ignoring the details in what im saying to claim theyre just as similar, because you dont want to acknowledge that even small details are variation


i guess people dont care about that as long as something is fundemantally similar they'll just ignore the nuance and say "well its still the same thing"

i've noticed hell people do that and i guess you're one of them


well that applies to pretty much ANY genre

EcchiGodMamsterOct 27, 2023 7:43 AM
Oct 27, 2023 7:42 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

you're purposefully ignoring the details in what im saying to claim theyre just as similar, because you dont want to acknowledge that even small details are variation


i guess people dont care about that as long as something is fundemantally similar they'll just ignore the nuance and say "well its still the same thing"

i've noticed hell people do that and i guess you're one of them


well that applies to pretty much ANY genre

@EcchiGodMamster

I mean you're doing that with Isekai. But at the end of the day that's okay. I watch Super Sentai and Kamen Rider and it's mostly about heroes in armor fighting rubber suited monsters planning to take over the world.

Oct 27, 2023 7:48 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

I mean you're doing that with Isekai. But at the end of the day that's okay. I watch Super Sentai and Kamen Rider and it's mostly about heroes in armor fighting rubber suited monsters planning to take over the world.
@GalacticMagna

what im saying is there are far less details in what makes these isekai vary than there were in battle harems..

but you're either ignoring that or that just doesnt matter to you because on a fundemental level theyre the same, but fundementally most anime genres are the same

most shounen are forumulaic/generic, but the details and nuances are varied enough that you can tell which show is which even with a small description, and im saying its the same with battle harems and not most isekai

all it takes are small details to make something less generic than something else
EcchiGodMamsterOct 27, 2023 7:51 AM
Oct 27, 2023 8:03 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Reply to EcchiGodMamster
@GalacticMagna

what im saying is there are far less details in what makes these isekai vary than there were in battle harems..

but you're either ignoring that or that just doesnt matter to you because on a fundemental level theyre the same, but fundementally most anime genres are the same

most shounen are forumulaic/generic, but the details and nuances are varied enough that you can tell which show is which even with a small description, and im saying its the same with battle harems and not most isekai

all it takes are small details to make something less generic than something else
@EcchiGodMamster

But that's because I'm inclined to say Isekai is the same.. but it's okay as long the execution of the series is good.

I mean look at Farming into another world. It has the same "OP" abilities, same medieval video game town. But it turned out to be the more wholesome Isekai that I've seen.

It's easy to say that the genre and ideas are the same but that don't matter to me. As long as they work it in a coherent matter. With Battle Harems though... I don't see how they look any different you can't just tweak different gimmicks and settings and call it different. To matters worse, it also has poor writing and execution.

That's I'm more easy on Isekai because I like how it's done better there than Battle Harems. Unlike you I don't care if they are the same, as long as the execution is good and has likable characters that's fine.

Oct 27, 2023 8:08 AM
fanservice<3

Offline
Mar 2012
12600
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

But that's because I'm inclined to say Isekai is the same.. but it's okay as long the execution of the series is good.

I mean look at Farming into another world. It has the same "OP" abilities, same medieval video game town. But it turned out to be the more wholesome Isekai that I've seen.

It's easy to say that the genre and ideas are the same but that don't matter to me. As long as they work it in a coherent matter. With Battle Harems though... I don't see how they look any different you can't just tweak different gimmicks and settings and call it different. To matters worse, it also has poor writing and execution.

That's I'm more easy on Isekai because I like how it's done better there than Battle Harems. Unlike you I don't care if they are the same, as long as the execution is good and has likable characters that's fine.
@GalacticMagna

if im seeing the same looking short black haired character in the same looking world fighting the same looking villains/monsters, especially when he can never lose or in many cases not even be touched... im going to get bored

all it takes are small variations for me to remain interested in something, im always saying that just changing the setting from medieval to something like ancient egypt would make isekai more interesting to me or shit... changing the dudes freaking hair color to like red would be a noticable
difference... make up monsters and villains, like The Legendary hero is dead did instead of just using the same goblins, wolves, dragons and bandits

not to mention everything needs more tits and ass

well clearly this doesnt apply to you, as i expected, you just dont consider those differences... cause its all it takes for me to see something as less generic


i didnt say anything about writing
EcchiGodMamsterOct 27, 2023 8:17 AM
Oct 29, 2023 8:35 AM
Offline
Oct 2023
8
Reply to GalacticMagna
@EcchiGodMamster

But that's because I'm inclined to say Isekai is the same.. but it's okay as long the execution of the series is good.

I mean look at Farming into another world. It has the same "OP" abilities, same medieval video game town. But it turned out to be the more wholesome Isekai that I've seen.

It's easy to say that the genre and ideas are the same but that don't matter to me. As long as they work it in a coherent matter. With Battle Harems though... I don't see how they look any different you can't just tweak different gimmicks and settings and call it different. To matters worse, it also has poor writing and execution.

That's I'm more easy on Isekai because I like how it's done better there than Battle Harems. Unlike you I don't care if they are the same, as long as the execution is good and has likable characters that's fine.
@GalacticMagna

Are you sure is the farm is no different ..? Let say the Isekai smartphone.

Most Isekai look the same and carbon copy rpg cause there's "NO" background for MC-kun
They Mostly flat or pathetic Human being to begin with

- They get tools or power the time they go to another world.

The farm Isekai have super tool that even can change shape and defeat the dragon.

- No sex appeal for mc-kun or ur just average boy with the same face and persona,( Flat, kind that's the only option u have )

-Both of them didn't have real human male friend to begin with, didn't you have real buddy irl..? Even in Isekai..?
( Let alone have buddy the same age or gender or race )

- again same flat kind personallty mc-kun u found in thousand Tittle of Isekai genre

- How they approaching or interact with the opposite sex is the same BS over an ober again
It's like the author never have experience with how to build or maintain relationship

- in few eps
Surroundiing by girl with no good reason nor explanation
even my friend can't found or pint points what make him so interesting let alone casual audience like myself.

Despite the "Tool" he have
So What..? you vampire no place to go.just live here..Huh..?

So basically just throw away the tool MC have
And boom..!!! MC Kun just look the same shit Isekai u found There and there every season.

so any different Isekai smartphone compared to farm Isekai and many Isekai outhere release after 2010

Thats answer is big NO..

- same background
- same persona for MC kun
- same rpg game power up
- same looking face
- same situation
- same power tools
- same persona for other character

This basically what the other dude point off to you to understand
but can't accepted the fact of the reality of isekai genre nowadays.
YesmanghhOct 29, 2023 9:05 AM
Oct 29, 2023 8:45 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1602
Yesmanghh said:
@GalacticMagna

Are you sure is the farm is different ..?

This basically what the other dude point off to you to understand

Most Isekai look the same and carbon copy rpg cause "NO" background for MC-kun
They Mostly flat or pathetic Human being to begin with

- They get tools or power the time they go to another world

The farm Isekai have super tool that even can change shape and defeat the dragon

- No sex appeal for mc-kun or ur just average boy with the same face and persona,( Flat, kind that's the only option u have )

-Both of them don't even have real human male friend to begin with, don't you have real buddy irl..? I don't get it
( Let alone have buddy the same age or gender )

- again same flat kind personallty mc-kun u found in thousand Tittle of Isekai genre

- How they approaching an interact with the opposite sex is the same BS over an ober again
It's like the author never experience with how bulid relationship

- in few eps
Surroundiing by girl with no good reason
even I can't found what make him so interesting
Despite the "Tool" he have
So What you vampire no place to go. So live here..Huh..?

So basically just throw away the tool MC have
And boom.. MC Kun just look the same shit Isekai u found There and there every season.

so any different with Isekai smartphone ,farm Isekai and many Isekai outhere release after 2010

Thats answer is big NO..

- same background
- same persona for MC kun
- same rpg game power up
- same looking face
- same situation
- same power tools
- same persona for other character


and like I said... I don't care about that, I didn't say it was any different. Despite all the generic tropes I still liked it

Oct 29, 2023 4:22 PM

Offline
Apr 2012
21612
Reply to GalacticMagna
Yesmanghh said:
@GalacticMagna

Are you sure is the farm is different ..?

This basically what the other dude point off to you to understand

Most Isekai look the same and carbon copy rpg cause "NO" background for MC-kun
They Mostly flat or pathetic Human being to begin with

- They get tools or power the time they go to another world

The farm Isekai have super tool that even can change shape and defeat the dragon

- No sex appeal for mc-kun or ur just average boy with the same face and persona,( Flat, kind that's the only option u have )

-Both of them don't even have real human male friend to begin with, don't you have real buddy irl..? I don't get it
( Let alone have buddy the same age or gender )

- again same flat kind personallty mc-kun u found in thousand Tittle of Isekai genre

- How they approaching an interact with the opposite sex is the same BS over an ober again
It's like the author never experience with how bulid relationship

- in few eps
Surroundiing by girl with no good reason
even I can't found what make him so interesting
Despite the "Tool" he have
So What you vampire no place to go. So live here..Huh..?

So basically just throw away the tool MC have
And boom.. MC Kun just look the same shit Isekai u found There and there every season.

so any different with Isekai smartphone ,farm Isekai and many Isekai outhere release after 2010

Thats answer is big NO..

- same background
- same persona for MC kun
- same rpg game power up
- same looking face
- same situation
- same power tools
- same persona for other character


and like I said... I don't care about that, I didn't say it was any different. Despite all the generic tropes I still liked it
@GalacticMagna People continue to think that it is enough to find some common tropes and point a finger at them, ignoring some nuance and you will find that the shows are exactly the same, etc. This is why we get threads where people claim that Frieren and To your Eternity are clones, because both shows are about immortal characters who have lost friends. And even after I've repeatedly argued the absurdity of this, literally reducing any genre to a generic formula for example, people continue to say things like "hey, both shows are medieval, so they're the same!" This is either lazy manipulation or a critical lack of understanding of how tropes work.
Nov 14, 2023 11:43 AM

Offline
Oct 2017
27308
Who's that girl? The emperor?
Aug 9, 7:52 AM

Offline
Feb 2014
7830
Looking better than "noble at the brick of bankruptcy", at least.

More topics from this board

» Staff, Cast of 'Mahou Shoujo Ikusei Keikaku: Restart' Announced

DatRandomDude - 7 hours ago

8 by RobertBobert »»
7 minutes ago

» Second Season of '2.5-jigen no Ririsa' Announced

DatRandomDude - 11 hours ago

2 by IzayoiSk »»
2 hours ago

» Manga 'Champignon no Majo' Receives TV Anime Adaptation

Vindstot - 8 hours ago

2 by livexevil »»
3 hours ago

» Web Manga 'Food Court de, Mata Ashita.' Gets TV Anime in 2025

DatRandomDude - 9 hours ago

1 by RobertBobert »»
7 hours ago

» 'Kono Manga ga Sugoi!' 2025 Rankings Revealed

Snow - Dec 12

15 by RobertBobert »»
10 hours ago
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login