RobertBobert said:gintokisbicep said:RobertBobert said:gintokisbicep said:RobertBobert said:gintokisbicep said:RobertBobert said:gintokisbicep said:LETS GOOOOOOOOOOO SHOUJO VILLAINESS ROMANCE IS TAKING OVER ISEKAI INSTEAD OF THE BORING MAGIC MC!!!!!!! THIS IS A WIN FOR THE GIRLS WOO WOO
That was sarcasm, right?
what?? no. im genuinely hyped for this. im always craving more shoujo romances.
My point is that it's literally a sub-genre of isekai and at the moment Hamefura is the only work that can really compete with the "regular" isekai, mainly because the concept of a bisexual harem broadens the audience of the work quite well.
not really???? maybe bc not a lot of them are in mal but villainess shoujo romance isekais are blowing up. they've always been pretty big but maybe that's because im more in the female side of the anime community.
Just because they've gotten more adaptations, primarily due to the success of Hamefura (which parodying it), doesn't mean it wasn't great before then. You are making the same mistake as people who think that isekai wasn't a big thing before SAO since they weren't familiar with the LN market. But then again, why should a female LN compete with a male one at all if they have different audiences? These LNs have different audiences and their market does not affect each other.
uhhhhh i am quite aware that isekai was always big before sao. everyone and their mum knows about .hack, familiar of zen and whatever and everybody who does watch those shows do not let you forget that they were THE isekais before sao. isekai in literature itself has always been big even outside of anime. but female oriented isekai have only been blowing up in the last couple of years rather than the decades.
and shoujo animes in itself have been in heavy decline in numbers compared to shounen. so when it's a shoujo, especially one that doesn't seem just romance based im very happy.
It's dwindled for the simple reason that it's very hard for you to sell women-only content that isn't a cash cow like idol franchises. Therefore, for many years, most adaptations have been in the live action format. For now, the green light is being given to everyone indiscriminately (in a good way), so shoujo work is getting relative attention again. But if we are not talking about a purely female market, but about any shows that, among other things, appealed to a female audience as well, then there have always been a lot of them. For example, the more family-friendly segment of all-female franchises.
its a shame because when it comes to sales, shoujos do just as well but due to anime being more taken up by dudes im guessing studios dont think its worth it. and since a lot of shoujo is romance plus the manga format is different i can see why it might be harder to create shoujo/josei animes.
and with the "family-friendly segment" are you talking about magical girl shows like precure??? because that i agree with completely. i swear there's one like every season, they're legit the one piece of shoujo. but since that's targeted towards young girls it's defo not as big in the west. like i remember being young and watching sailor moon and precure but now i dont think thats the case.