Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
Attack on Titan
Available on Manga Store
New
Mar 12, 2022 7:35 AM
#1
Offline
Dec 2020
68
[This post won't contain anything related to manga ending, AnR ending etc. This post is created to create an awareness to the animeonlies of the AOE]
[Also i had tried to make this thread as much manga spoiler free as possible]

The changes in the anime version of AOT


This was shown in ep 78 in the memory panel when eren enters the path
This was in the manga and it basically shows that there exists multiple timelines besides the current one

There is also a new Shard in anime ver which wasn't shown in the manga memory panel(aka shards)


This is an event that had happened at the end of the manga, (this wasn't shown in the manga shards)
All the events that had happened in the memory shards was from the past, otherwise it wouldn't be memory shards then how is it possible to show the future if it already had not happened before the anime timeline??means manga timeline had happened before anime timeline. Basically confirming AOE

For reference manga shards from chapter 120



Does this means that eren actually knows the end outcome??
Maybe....



This is a scene that was shown in ep 78 after he enters the path, you can see both expression error and dialogue error in the anime ver compared to manga ver



This anime only scene can also be a direct comparison when eren was kidnapped to the royal family's hideout

You can see here that eren already knows this place(from his fathers memories)

Manga eren when he entered paths he didn't know where he was and was really astonished to see the paths.
You might be thinking that studio might have changed his expression like they always makes some changes from the initial ver, which i don't think so because mappa is adapting the manga 1:1




Mikasa

To show that the anime and manga are different timelines you can check out Mikasa's scarf in the manga ver it is black and zeke has white hair and beard in manga



To add more to this theory, when eren entered paths he saw manga mikasa in shards i.e, mikasa in black scarf (not his memories of the anime mikasa from ep 1)

Its not just about the scarf, look at the way she is turning to the right to look at eren(clearly different from anime ver), the petals falling near her these are all greatly similar to the manga ver, if you think the black scarf was artistic choice to match the colour, no its not. someone had to spend days drawing it. its not like they just added filter over it and called it a day, its 100% intentional

This isn't all, you can even check the first chapter of eren sleeping under the tree in the manga (chapter 1 and anime ep 1 both differs greatly)

Isayama's inspiration










[The below text isn't anything from aot manga, click on it only if you already know / got spoiled if eren is alive in the manga ver or not]

amalshajiMar 31, 2022 10:28 PM
Mar 12, 2022 7:44 AM
#2
Offline
Dec 2020
68
Also wanted to say that don't create threads like
Japanese liked the ending why would isayama change the ending
I liked the ending it was great, why change it

The answer is with aoe they can redefine anime-manga relation by making manga a different entity of its own.
Meaning isayama doesn't hate the ending he was planning this from the very beginning to create an ending by relating it with another timeline (if aoe happens that is)
Mar 12, 2022 7:44 AM
#3
Offline
Feb 2021
34
amalshaji said:
[This post won't contain anything related to manga ending, AnR ending etc. This post is created to create an awareness to the animeonlies of the AOE]
[Also i had tried to make this thread as much manga spoiler free as possible]

The changes in the anime version of AOT


This was shown in ep 78 in the memory panel when eren enters path
This was in the manga and it basically shows that there are multiple timelines besides the current one

Do you know what wasn't in the manga memory panel(aka shardes)


This is an event that had happened at the end of the manga, (this wasn't shown in the manga shards), showing this in anime actually means the event has already happened somewhere. ie the manga timeline

For reference manga shards from chapter 120



Does this means that eren actually knows the end outcome??
Maybe....



This is a scene that was shown in ep 78 after he enters the path, you can see both expression error and dialogue error in the anime ver compared to manga ver



This anime only scene can also be a direct comparison when eren was kidnapped to the royal family's hideout

You can see here that eren already knows this place(from his fathers memories)

Manga eren when he entered paths he didn't know where he was and was really astonished to see the paths.
You might be thinking that studio might have changed his expression like they always makes some changes from the initial ver, which i don't think so because mappa is adapting the manga 1:1




Mikasa

To show that the anime and manga are different timelines you can check out Mikasa's scarf in the manga ver it is black and zeke has white hair and beard in manga



To add more to this theory, when eren entered paths he saw manga mikasa in shards not his memories of the anime mikasa from ep 1


This isn't all you can check the first chapter of eren sleeping under the tree in manga chapter 1 and anime ep 1 both differs greatly

Isayama's inspiration





Muv luv has 5 alternative endings

[The below text isn't anything from aot manga, click on it only if you already know / got spoiled if eren is alive in the manga ver or not]


the people who don't like the manga ending are childish,not every story has a happy ending
Mar 12, 2022 7:47 AM
#4
Offline
Apr 2021
392
BBjornn said:
amalshaji said:
[This post won't contain anything related to manga ending, AnR ending etc. This post is created to create an awareness to the animeonlies of the AOE]
[Also i had tried to make this thread as much manga spoiler free as possible]

The changes in the anime version of AOT


This was shown in ep 78 in the memory panel when eren enters path
This was in the manga and it basically shows that there are multiple timelines besides the current one

Do you know what wasn't in the manga memory panel(aka shardes)


This is an event that had happened at the end of the manga, (this wasn't shown in the manga shards), showing this in anime actually means the event has already happened somewhere. ie the manga timeline

For reference manga shards from chapter 120



Does this means that eren actually knows the end outcome??
Maybe....



This is a scene that was shown in ep 78 after he enters the path, you can see both expression error and dialogue error in the anime ver compared to manga ver



This anime only scene can also be a direct comparison when eren was kidnapped to the royal family's hideout

You can see here that eren already knows this place(from his fathers memories)

Manga eren when he entered paths he didn't know where he was and was really astonished to see the paths.
You might be thinking that studio might have changed his expression like they always makes some changes from the initial ver, which i don't think so because mappa is adapting the manga 1:1




Mikasa

To show that the anime and manga are different timelines you can check out Mikasa's scarf in the manga ver it is black and zeke has white hair and beard in manga



To add more to this theory, when eren entered paths he saw manga mikasa in shards not his memories of the anime mikasa from ep 1


This isn't all you can check the first chapter of eren sleeping under the tree in manga chapter 1 and anime ep 1 both differs greatly

Isayama's inspiration





Muv luv has 5 alternative endings

[The below text isn't anything from aot manga, click on it only if you already know / got spoiled if eren is alive in the manga ver or not]


the people who don't like the manga ending are childish,not every story has a happy ending

childish for having an opinion
Tokyo ghoul is a great manga with a trash anime adaptation

Mar 12, 2022 7:49 AM
#5
Offline
Feb 2021
34
nonofyourbeeswax said:
BBjornn said:

the people who don't like the manga ending are childish,not every story has a happy ending

childish for having an opinion
no, the people who hate the ending hate it because its not a happy ending,they can't give any other argument why it's bad
Mar 12, 2022 7:50 AM
#6
Offline
Dec 2020
68
BBjornn said:

the people who don't like the manga ending are childish,not every story has a happy ending


Bruh did you even read the #2 thread saying don't create threads like this😐
Mar 12, 2022 7:56 AM
#7
Offline
Jul 2018
564072
Okay, but these little glimpses are definitely not enough to make any reasonable assumptions that there will be AOE . In order to completely change the ending (that it would make sense) some plot points had to be changed earlier.
removed-userMar 12, 2022 8:01 AM
Mar 12, 2022 8:02 AM
#8
Offline
Sep 2021
582
I can’t wait to see the actual manga ending adapted. Not only because I liked it but also because I want to see the hilarious reactions of a bunch of idiots who are still crying about the ending
Mar 12, 2022 8:03 AM
#9
Offline
Nov 2010
100
BBjornn said:

no, the people who hate the ending hate it because its not a happy ending,they can't give any other argument why it's bad


er...There are two factions who hate the ending. One side hates it for the extra pages. The other side hates it because it's not dark enough.
Mar 12, 2022 8:04 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
68
ReadyForTheSmoke said:
Okay, but these little glimpses are definitely not enough to make any reasonable assumptions that there will be AOE . In order to completely change the ending (that it would make sense) some plot points had to be changed earlier.


These aren't all the details, there are still way more deatils that i haven't discussed to make it anime only friendly
Mar 12, 2022 8:05 AM

Offline
Jul 2021
208
Wait, so how does eren know anything about paths when he had entered it for the first time?? This' interesting. Isayama's planning something fishy.....
Check out SNAFU
Mar 12, 2022 8:07 AM
Offline
May 2020
101
(No direct spoilers)
It's been like many months after the end of the SNK manga. Manga readers had taken the ending into their heart and criticised it for some days but now, they have accepted the ending and have moved on and are now waiting to watch the ending in anime form. AOE would again make the manga readers to outrage and criticise telling that when they have accepted the ending, they can't just change the ending. Just a manga reader telling his POV. I don't want AOE. I want the manga ending. Let's be a part of the end of a great epic in anime history the same way as the manga ended.
:)
Mar 12, 2022 8:12 AM
Offline
Nov 2010
100
Regarding OP:

GothKasa/Nerdmin panel could be alt-timeline, but it's also possible to be future of current timeline.

Regarding Scarf color change: the original color change was proposed by the anime director, not the author.

Muv-luv inspiration for alt-timeline: the final school caste chapter mentioned about the ending being kept simple or something to blow people's mind.

So all in all, things can go either way.
Mar 12, 2022 8:13 AM
Offline
Jul 2021
457
amalshaji said:
[This post won't contain anything related to manga ending, AnR ending etc. This post is created to create an awareness to the animeonlies of the AOE]
[Also i had tried to make this thread as much manga spoiler free as possible]

The changes in the anime version of AOT


This was shown in ep 78 in the memory panel when eren enters path
This was in the manga and it basically shows that there are multiple timelines besides the current one

Do you know what wasn't in the manga memory panel(aka shardes)


This is an event that had happened at the end of the manga, (this wasn't shown in the manga shards), showing this in anime actually means the event has already happened somewhere. ie the manga timeline

For reference manga shards from chapter 120



Does this means that eren actually knows the end outcome??
Maybe....



This is a scene that was shown in ep 78 after he enters the path, you can see both expression error and dialogue error in the anime ver compared to manga ver



This anime only scene can also be a direct comparison when eren was kidnapped to the royal family's hideout

You can see here that eren already knows this place(from his fathers memories)

Manga eren when he entered paths he didn't know where he was and was really astonished to see the paths.
You might be thinking that studio might have changed his expression like they always makes some changes from the initial ver, which i don't think so because mappa is adapting the manga 1:1




Mikasa

To show that the anime and manga are different timelines you can check out Mikasa's scarf in the manga ver it is black and zeke has white hair and beard in manga



To add more to this theory, when eren entered paths he saw manga mikasa in shards not his memories of the anime mikasa from ep 1


This isn't all you can check the first chapter of eren sleeping under the tree in manga chapter 1 and anime ep 1 both differs greatly

Isayama's inspiration





Muv luv has 5 alternative endings

[The below text isn't anything from aot manga, click on it only if you already know / got spoiled if eren is alive in the manga ver or not]


if AOE happens I'll post a video of myself eating the last chapter of aot
Mar 12, 2022 8:22 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
68
kension said:


Regarding Scarf color change: the original color change was proposed by the anime director, not the author.

So all in all, things can go either way.


So why do you think it was shown as a black scarf when eren entered the paths
Mar 12, 2022 8:24 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
68
I just updated the "isayama's inspiration" with a third image (just saying for those who has already read my thread and are here to read the comments)
Mar 12, 2022 8:28 AM
Offline
Nov 2010
100
amalshaji said:
kension said:


Regarding Scarf color change: the original color change was proposed by the anime director, not the author.

So all in all, things can go either way.


So why do you think it was shown as a black scarf when eren entered the paths


Either u are correct, or it's just to match the color of the falling petals.
Mar 12, 2022 8:53 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
37
amalshaji said:
I just updated the "isayama's inspiration" with a third image (just saying for those who has already read my thread and are here to read the comments)

Cause the scene was all black & white except for the purple petals… it’s called creative choice. Also as the other person mentioned the scarf color was changed in the anime without Isayama’s input, but a lot of people like to pretend like he meticulously planned everything out for the sake of their theories.

Honestly I’m not against an AOE as long as it’s better than the canon one which is going to be hard to pull off. If we do get a different ending I doubt it’s going to be this different timelines shit cause it would only make everything more confusing and complicated for no reason and it would honestly ruin the serious themes of the story.
Mar 12, 2022 9:58 AM
Offline
Jan 2019
14
amalshaji said:
[This post won't contain anything related to manga ending, AnR ending etc. This post is created to create an awareness to the animeonlies of the AOE]
[Also i had tried to make this thread as much manga spoiler free as possible]

The changes in the anime version of AOT


This was shown in ep 78 in the memory panel when eren enters path
This was in the manga and it basically shows that there are multiple timelines besides the current one

Do you know what wasn't in the manga memory panel(aka shards)


This is an event that had happened at the end of the manga, (this wasn't shown in the manga shards), showing this in anime actually means the event has already happened somewhere. ie the manga timeline

For reference manga shards from chapter 120



Does this means that eren actually knows the end outcome??
Maybe....



This is a scene that was shown in ep 78 after he enters the path, you can see both expression error and dialogue error in the anime ver compared to manga ver



This anime only scene can also be a direct comparison when eren was kidnapped to the royal family's hideout

You can see here that eren already knows this place(from his fathers memories)

Manga eren when he entered paths he didn't know where he was and was really astonished to see the paths.
You might be thinking that studio might have changed his expression like they always makes some changes from the initial ver, which i don't think so because mappa is adapting the manga 1:1




Mikasa

To show that the anime and manga are different timelines you can check out Mikasa's scarf in the manga ver it is black and zeke has white hair and beard in manga



To add more to this theory, when eren entered paths he saw manga mikasa in shards (not his memories of the anime mikasa from ep 1)


This isn't all, you can even check the first chapter of eren sleeping under the tree in the manga (chapter 1 and anime ep 1 both differs greatly)

Isayama's inspiration










Muv luv has 5 alternative endings

[The below text isn't anything from aot manga, click on it only if you already know / got spoiled if eren is alive in the manga ver or not]


I like where you are going with this theory, & it’s Eren’s reaction when he arrived at the paths is what making this a real possibility, although the others not very much
Mar 12, 2022 10:24 AM

Offline
Apr 2021
1576
MugenDarou said:
amalshaji said:
[This post won't contain anything related to manga ending, AnR ending etc. This post is created to create an awareness to the animeonlies of the AOE]

if AOE happens I'll post a video of myself eating the last chapter of aot

Sheesh Isayama gon cry bro
Mar 12, 2022 10:36 AM
Offline
Nov 2010
100
AshiraWies said:

I like where you are going with this theory, & it’s Eren’s reaction when he arrived at the paths is what making this a real possibility, although the others not very much


Eren already saw all the memories before "this place is..." scene. So it makes more sense that he's not surprised. This part in the manga was flawed and the anime fixed it.
Mar 12, 2022 11:10 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
68
kension said:
AshiraWies said:

I like where you are going with this theory, & it’s Eren’s reaction when he arrived at the paths is what making this a real possibility, although the others not very much


Eren already saw all the memories before "this place is..." scene. So it makes more sense that he's not surprised. This part in the manga was flawed and the anime fixed it.




Memory shards never shown us the future outcome.(in the manga)
Only 2 people had entered paths before eren which are zeke and ymir(historia's friend)
Eren didn't eat either of them then
How is it possible for Eren to know there exists a path
Mar 12, 2022 11:16 AM
Offline
Nov 2010
100
amalshaji said:

Memory shards never shown us the future outcome.(in the manga)


"that scenery" or "what a sight that was".

Mar 12, 2022 11:22 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
68
kension said:
amalshaji said:

Memory shards never shown us the future outcome.(in the manga)


"that scenery" or "what a sight that was".




That scene was removed from the anime ver

Mar 12, 2022 11:27 AM
Offline
Nov 2010
100
The line's still there, but they tone down the reaction entirely because they couldn't even reference it properly in the manga.
Mar 12, 2022 10:54 PM

Offline
Dec 2020
1487
Dark_Axgel said:
(No direct spoilers)
It's been like many months after the end of the SNK manga. Manga readers had taken the ending into their heart and criticised it for some days but now, they have accepted the ending and have moved on and are now waiting to watch the ending in anime form. AOE would again make the manga readers to outrage and criticise telling that when they have accepted the ending, they can't just change the ending. Just a manga reader telling his POV. I don't want AOE. I want the manga ending. Let's be a part of the end of a great epic in anime history the same way as the manga ended.
:)

you are so wrong. Manga readers who didn't liked the ending aren't waiting or excited for the anime to end, they are either neutral abt it or doesn't give af abt aot anymore after that disastrous ending. Also if you think they moved on and doesn't criticize aot now then habibi come to Twitter and reddit.

You probably liked the ending.
But let me tell you as a ending hater pov, I want aoe that is completely different from manga ending. I don't know if aoe will happen or not but I am willing to accept anything that isnt the manga ending.
Mar 12, 2022 11:32 PM
Offline
Sep 2020
2292
TheFounder131 said:
Dark_Axgel said:
(No direct spoilers)
It's been like many months after the end of the SNK manga. Manga readers had taken the ending into their heart and criticised it for some days but now, they have accepted the ending and have moved on and are now waiting to watch the ending in anime form. AOE would again make the manga readers to outrage and criticise telling that when they have accepted the ending, they can't just change the ending. Just a manga reader telling his POV. I don't want AOE. I want the manga ending. Let's be a part of the end of a great epic in anime history the same way as the manga ended.
:)

you are so wrong. Manga readers who didn't liked the ending aren't waiting or excited for the anime to end, they are either neutral abt it or doesn't give af abt aot anymore after that disastrous ending. Also if you think they moved on and doesn't criticize aot now then habibi come to Twitter and reddit.

You probably liked the ending.
But let me tell you as a ending hater pov, I want aoe that is completely different from manga ending. I don't know if aoe will happen or not but I am willing to accept anything that isnt the manga ending.



Everyone knows what ending we don't want ,the shitkasa and simpren curse🤦🏻,that is one of the most non buildup,non foreshadowing and non explained stuff in the manga

Also no actual manga readers like that,the ones who like that outcome are manga readers who only care about Mikasa and Eren's relationship ,the story themes and dynamics are thrown out of the window
Historia was ruined becoz of that ending🤦🏻
Mar 13, 2022 10:10 AM
Offline
Aug 2014
29
From what I have seen, these "inconsistences" are deliberate. You don't animate Mikasa's scarf black when it always have been red by mistake. You don't show the sauna scene and the cast of SnK Highschool for no reason. It isn't even an Easter egg. It is clear and straightforward.

However, that doesn't confirm AOE. It only confirms that in the world of SnK, multiple timelines exists. And MAYBE Eren knows this and would change his actions. I would hope Isayama does AOE though. I don't want to see all of this foreshadowing go to waste. Also, it would quite literally be the first in the industry. Exciting stuff.
Mar 14, 2022 2:20 AM
Offline
Feb 2021
83
well I don't really mind the manga ending. I'd probably be a masterpiece. but I also don't mind if it's an anime only. I'll just wait and see..



PS it's an amazing theory
Mar 14, 2022 4:53 AM
Offline
Dec 2020
68
Fernehem said:
#Stop spoiling muv luv to prove your theories


Can't you see a spoiler tag??
Mar 14, 2022 8:54 AM
The Komori

Offline
Mar 2013
7435
TheFounder131 said:
Dark_Axgel said:
(No direct spoilers)
It's been like many months after the end of the SNK manga. Manga readers had taken the ending into their heart and criticised it for some days but now, they have accepted the ending and have moved on and are now waiting to watch the ending in anime form. AOE would again make the manga readers to outrage and criticise telling that when they have accepted the ending, they can't just change the ending. Just a manga reader telling his POV. I don't want AOE. I want the manga ending. Let's be a part of the end of a great epic in anime history the same way as the manga ended.
:)

you are so wrong. Manga readers who didn't liked the ending aren't waiting or excited for the anime to end, they are either neutral abt it or doesn't give af abt aot anymore after that disastrous ending. Also if you think they moved on and doesn't criticize aot now then habibi come to Twitter and reddit.

You probably liked the ending.
But let me tell you as a ending hater pov, I want aoe that is completely different from manga ending. I don't know if aoe will happen or not but I am willing to accept anything that isnt the manga ending.
Thank you lol, when I read his post I was completely baffled by what he said lol

There's more people that hated the ending than the ones that liked it and I find it very hard to believe that the people that hated it, wouldn't welcome an alternate ending if we were to get one
Mar 14, 2022 11:46 AM

Offline
Jan 2016
136
Another anime-only change that I'm surprised more haven't caught onto occurs when Falco first awakes at the beginning of the time-skip. In the anime, he mentions having just been flying around fighting titans. No line at all similar to this was ever said in the manga.

Spoiler for a couple chapters from now:
Mar 14, 2022 4:42 PM

Offline
Jan 2009
101125
i really like the Multiverse theory aka Muv Luv Alternatve Ending theory but cope more my dude
Mar 14, 2022 4:58 PM

Offline
Oct 2018
179
I would like to have 2 endings like Evangelion, part 3 tv as the original manga ending, then AoE ending as a movie like End of Evangelion.

More topics from this board

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Jan 9, 2022

458 by yoshidas_wife23 »»
Nov 16, 11:40 PM

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Apr 3, 2022

553 by Wspolneogladnie »»
Nov 14, 2:38 PM

» Levi's injury

tazounti - Mar 11, 2022

13 by bre776b »»
Nov 13, 12:00 PM

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Mar 20, 2022

433 by sharosharo »»
Nov 10, 5:29 AM

Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

anime-prime - Mar 13, 2022

417 by sharosharo »»
Nov 10, 5:04 AM

Preview MangaManga Store

It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login