| As you can see in the title the Manga: Tales of demons and Gods is not listed on MAL. Even though the anime is on here... |
| Suggested many times before. Denied many times before. Next please. |
 |
juandmarco said: If it doesn't have an official physical release (which includes release in a manga magazine), it doesn't get to be in the site. I assume this doesn't. Sorry to respond after many years. There is now a physical version (licenced by Nazca Editions in France), so do you think we can re-suggest this very good Manga to be listed on mal ? |
OoggleMay 26, 2020 11:39 AM
juandmarco said: Ooggle said: Sorry to respond after many years. There is now a physical version now (licenced by Nazca Editions in France), so do you think we can re-suggest this very good Manga to be listed on mal ? Is that physical release available on the original country or only in France? No, there is no physical release in China who is the original country. I don't know if it can be added to the database therefore. You can see some of the releases at the official Twitter account of Nazca Editions : https://twitter.com/nazcaeditions |
OoggleMay 26, 2020 3:24 PM
juandmarco said: Ooggle said: No, there is no physical release in China who is the original country. I don't know if it can be added to the database therefore. You can see some of the releases at the official Twitter account of Nazca Editions : https://twitter.com/nazcaeditions I see. If the physical release is not available in the original country, it still doesn't get in. I recommend you to use Baka-Updates for stuff that isn't on MAL. The only thing stopping a series from getting approved if it is porn and there's no translation. It also allows stuff from more regions of Asia. lol I understand, of course thanks for Baka-Updates, i'll check it :D |
juandmarco said: It can still counts as doujin right?If it doesn't have an official physical release (which includes release in a manga magazine), it doesn't get to be in the site. I assume this doesn't. |
 |
FaiZhang said: Nearly 300,000,000 reads on mangakalot and still not on MAL? Doesn't make much sense to me. Number of reads is irelevant, what matters is whether it got released physically or not. This isn''t a webcomic database, webcomics are added only if they got released as regular comics too. |
You all need to watch Nami. |
FaiZhang said: Nearly 300,000,000 reads on mangakalot and still not on MAL? Doesn't make much sense to me. It doesn't matter how many people read this manhua on an illegal website. |
 |
| Hello everyone, I'm quite surprised since a year that this manga isn't in the myanimelist database. If the problem is currently if the manga was released or not, it is currently edited in France under Nazca Editions and available throughout the country in different libraries and eCommerce website such as Amazon and other popular eCommerce website available in France. Can we also consider that the anime Yaoshenji characters database is currently using the manga drawings to display characters pictures? Edit : Corrected typo |
| It doesn't, because this isn't a database for webtoons. If you want that, use M-U. |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
| @Alanski You could make the same exact argument for MAL to start including western cartoons or parody doujinshi. Also, unlike regular manga, literally anyone can make a webtoon. I could throw in together some stick figures in MsPaint and it's a webtoon. Also, 500 users are not even nearly enough to get a relevant sample of the MAL userbase option. |
abystoma2Aug 27, 2021 1:29 PM
| You all need to watch Nami. |
| Except databases are not a democracy. Users don't get to vote on the content standard. Plant database isn't going to add rocks just because the users would kinda like that. Webtoons aren't manga. Even having regular manhwa and manhua in the database in the first place is already quite borderline. |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
| If money is involved it might be tempting, but it would tremendously weaken the page's identity. It would no longer be *the* plant database, just "database of some stuff". Manga has been part of MAL since 2007, practically almost from the beginning. Myanimeandmangalist just doesn't sound that good as a domain. And honestly it would make more sence to add live action section than to add webtoons. Live action adaptations of anime and manga make sense as part of anime and manga community. But webtoon community isn't manga community. MAL simply isn't site for webtoon community. And just because someone happens to be part of both manga and webtoon community doesn't need MAL needs to change. Alanski said: Discord is a successful example of pivoting to satisfy more users and gain more users too https://www.protocol.com/discord Not really, as the article says, it was published as a replacement for Skype and TeamSpeak and that's exactly what it did. |
abystoma2Aug 27, 2021 1:53 PM
| You all need to watch Nami. |
JayeshB69 said: And I think its officially published too now from Bilibili Comics and you can say its more than official now, not any translation scans. Still just a web publication though, not a physical print. |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
JayeshB69 said: Simple, because this isn't a database for webcomics.So how am I wrong here that we can't try it, hmmm?π€ JayeshB69 said: Lot of chapters, sure. But the quality is usually shit. It's pretty rare to find a manhwa that can rival at least an average manga quality. Well, popularity is irrelevant for this discussion anyway.I can see that after manga, all fans will take go for manhua. Due to its high frequency chapter rate and its pretty popular nowadays. |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
JaviXR said: Swapped to Anilist back then, and I have nothing to regret. Now I have a real unified list of all type of anime and manga/manhwa/manhua/webtoons i've seen without useless, disfunctional exclusions. Anime-Planet is also a great option, and they have a larger selection of webtoons in their database, including this one. They also have OEL, which Anilist doesn't allow. |
abystoma2 said: I don't really get your point here. Websites exist for the users. If the users want it, what's the harm in giving it to them? Having just *some* manhwa as it is right now is just confusingExcept databases are not a democracy. Users don't get to vote on the content standard. Plant database isn't going to add rocks just because the users would kinda like that. Webtoons aren't manga. Even having regular manhwa and manhua in the database in the first place is already quite borderline. |
Aarlon said: Exists for the users, not managed by users.abystoma2 said: I don't really get your point here. Websites exist for the users. If the users want it, what's the harm in giving it to them? Having just *some* manhwa as it is right now is just confusingExcept databases are not a democracy. Users don't get to vote on the content standard. Plant database isn't going to add rocks just because the users would kinda like that. Webtoons aren't manga. Even having regular manhwa and manhua in the database in the first place is already quite borderline. |
| You all need to watch Nami. |
| I think I've seen more Manhwa be added recently So hopefully Tales of Demons and Gods gets added soon. |
Shidoteki said: I think I've seen more Manhwa be added recently So hopefully Tales of Demons and Gods gets added soon. MAL changed its policy regarding Manhwas some months ago. Before , they were only adding those who got a phisical release in Korea (Which is not really frequent) , but now they also allow those who are digitally published by a few white-listed site such as Line Webtoon , KakaoPage or Lezhin. Unfortunately , it's only for Manhwas , and Manhuas are excluded for the moment. Since Tales Of Demons And Gods also doesn't have a physical release in China , it can't be added , as of now. |
 "Genius lives only one story above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |
Reply to juandmarco
If it doesn't have an official physical release (which includes release in a manga magazine), it doesn't get to be in the site. I assume this doesn't.
| @juandmarco it is released in manga magazines. Probably it’s because it’s Chinese which I think is wrong as it’s one of my favourites. There is an entry now but the poster shows an unknown female and there’s no button to add the entry https://myanimelist.net/manga/151171/Yao_Shen_Ji?q=Tales%20of%20demons%20and%20gods&cat=manga |
Cristina_G said: it is released in manga magazines. It's not, atleast not in the sense MAL mean. The chapters are posted on ac.qq, and a few platforms, like Bilibili or KuaikanManhua. Technically, ac.qq is a digital magazine of Tencent, but MAL do not regard it as such, but more like a platform. By magazine, MAL means traditional physical magazine, even if they started to open the gates to digital magazines when they are owned by a reputable print company (Shonen Jump + for example) or when they are popular enough (Naver and the likes for Manhwas). Still no news for Manhuas, tho. Cristina_G said: There is an entry now but the poster shows an unknown female and there’s no button to add the entry That's because it's pending approval; a user submitted it, but mods did not accepted or denied it yet. It can takes a few years for them to look at it, but a lot of such entries were already denied for TODAG. As for the female, that's Ye Ziyun. That picture is one of the official artworks made by Mad Snail for the Volumes (sales of chapters in batches). You can find more there : https://tales-of-demons-and-gods.fandom.com/wiki/Art_Gallery/Professional_Art |
"Genius lives only one story above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |
Reply to Alexioos95
Cristina_G said:
it is released in manga magazines.
it is released in manga magazines.
It's not, atleast not in the sense MAL mean. The chapters are posted on ac.qq, and a few platforms, like Bilibili or KuaikanManhua. Technically, ac.qq is a digital magazine of Tencent, but MAL do not regard it as such, but more like a platform.
By magazine, MAL means traditional physical magazine, even if they started to open the gates to digital magazines when they are owned by a reputable print company (Shonen Jump + for example) or when they are popular enough (Naver and the likes for Manhwas). Still no news for Manhuas, tho.
Cristina_G said:
There is an entry now but the poster shows an unknown female and there’s no button to add the entry
There is an entry now but the poster shows an unknown female and there’s no button to add the entry
That's because it's pending approval; a user submitted it, but mods did not accepted or denied it yet. It can takes a few years for them to look at it, but a lot of such entries were already denied for TODAG.
As for the female, that's Ye Ziyun. That picture is one of the official artworks made by Mad Snail for the Volumes (sales of chapters in batches). You can find more there : https://tales-of-demons-and-gods.fandom.com/wiki/Art_Gallery/Professional_Art
| @Alexioos95 Aww that’s such a shame π I love this story. Thank you for replying to something posted years ago ππ» Also, many thanks for the link. I can see who the female figure is now. I love the Art, it’s such an individual style, absolutely beautiful! This precious link, I’m saving it to my personal animation notes, tyyy π₯β€οΈπ₯π₯ |
More topics from this board
» Manga Not Found!GabrielSGI - Oct 31 |
2 |
by GabrielSGI
»»
Yesterday, 3:06 PM |
|
Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Modifications/Duplicates Here ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Aarana - Jan 4, 2009 |
8313 |
by KingPin
»»
Yesterday, 9:51 AM |
|
» Novel approvaldianielcoo - Jun 5, 2022 |
13 |
by YoshiYogurt
»»
Yesterday, 9:51 AM |
|
Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Genre/Theme Requests Here ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Kineta - Mar 28, 2022 |
248 |
by Inter_anime
»»
Oct 26, 2:16 PM |
|
» Recommended To me any Psychological Non-Action Shounen Published in a Seinen Magazinestefanoiulli1999 - Oct 15 |
0 |
by stefanoiulli1999
»»
Oct 15, 4:35 AM |