Bokutachi wa Benkyou ga Dekinai Chapter 150 Discussion

Offline

Nov 2018

396

Hey (5x) calm down please.. Specially the commentator who already lost their waifu because of Uruka arc...

When Uruka arc (chapter 141-150) come out, that was a completed alternative arc.. And there will be another character will come out for the next alternative arc series..
The next character will start next week will be Rizu Ogata alternative arc.. Then followed by Fumino Furuhashi, Asumi Senpai and lastly Mafuyu Sensei for the alternative arc...
Alternative arc series:

All 5 routes are:

Uruka, the Shimmering Ebony Mermaid Princess. (Completed alternative arc)
Rizu, the Thumbelina Supercomputer Princess.
Fumino, the Sleeping Princess of the Literature Forest.
Asumi, the Little Fairy of the Night.
Mafuyu, the Ice Queen

And by the way, these alternative arc will be a climax arc that will be found in fireworks festival arc...

Which means, that Nariyuki did not decided yet until the alternative arc will be completed... So the story will continued until the final conclusion (Nariyuki decision to choose the right person to become future wife) will come...

Mar 5, 2020 8:43 AM

shanimebib

Offline

Nov 2007

9157

PersiaJuliet23 said:
So the story will continued until the final conclusion (Nariyuki decision to choose the right person to become future wife) will come...

No. There will not be any post alternative route decisions.

Stay Home and Wash Your Hands.
Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones.
Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus.

Mar 5, 2020 9:03 AM

Offline

Jan 2015

326

I'm not sure why are you pushing so hard the [main story] phrase

There is no main story and 22i said so himself. We're officially reading manga version of a VN

Mar 5, 2020 9:04 AM

Offline

Feb 2020

So, in fact, do we have a canon end or not ?

Because how can be Rizu final be canon without the reste of the manga to support it ?

So, the author have no balls.

The author said it himself ? He really has no balls.

It's ok to listen the reader to improve your work but sacrifice the coherence of your story it's an another story.

A manga is not a VN.

Mar 5, 2020 9:05 AM

Offline

Jan 2015

326

Elverost said:
So, in fact, do we have a canon end or not ?

Because how can be Rizu final be canon without the reste of the manga to support it ?

So, the author have no balls.

We do not.

In the magazine 22i said that manga will consist of total 5 versions of ending and which one is true is up to us readers to decide.

Mar 5, 2020 9:07 AM

#10

Offline

Feb 2020

Zinzoo said:

In the magazine 22i said that manga will consist of total 5 versions of ending and which one is true is up to us readers to decide.

That's pathethic. It's must be the Corona Virus ah ah ah.

Mar 5, 2020 9:16 AM

#11

MegamiRem

Offline

Oct 2017

27178

So the Uruka route is over with this chap. Not a Uruka fan/hater but the last few chaps felt really rushed to me. I guess Tsutsui already made the decision to end the manga with 5 alternate ends so he rushed it a bit at the end.

Anyway looking forward to the other endings. This will be fun with every girl getting a end of their own.

Mar 5, 2020 10:04 AM

#12

Offline

Jan 2019

I think the title of this post is a bit misleading since this is not the end of the main arc, but the end of the Uruka route and you can see it at the end of the chapter since it's clearly written : Route [1/5]
spoiler : https://imgur.com/a/3AognZY

There isn't something like "true/main ending" basically all the endings are canon and it's up to you to decide which one is the "real"

EliAyaseLLMar 5, 2020 10:38 AM

Mar 5, 2020 10:07 AM

#13

evoniee

Offline

Feb 2017

1032

THERE IS NO TRUE ENDING, Reader decide it.
Good salt and tears from diehard uruka fan Kreygasm

MAL score and most user-based rating system are all joke, Imagine trusting plebs and hivemind. Find users who have good sense and rating and use them as a reference. Check my guide to rate
Your taste is trash. Cope, seethe, mald

Mar 5, 2020 10:35 AM

#14

Aika

Offline

May 2010

801

We are getting 5 different endings, why did OP put "main story" in the title?

Mar 5, 2020 10:54 AM

#15

ArimaKana

Offline

Sep 2019

553

That's it for Uruka. Can't wait to see the ending for other four.

@shanimebib change the title lmao. Now I know u are a die hard Uruka fan but that doesn't mean u can just put "MAIN STORY ENDS" on the title and mislead people who dunno that the author decided to leave the true ending for the readers to decide.

Mar 5, 2020 11:00 AM

#16

Offline

Jan 2019

Eon00 said:
That's it for Uruka. Can't wait to see the ending for other four.

@shanimebib change the title lmao. Now I know u are a die hard Uruka fan but that doesn't mean u can just put "MAIN STORY ENDS" on the title and mislead people who dunno that the author decided to leave the true ending for the readers to decide.

I honestly agree this is a bit too much biased and it's literally spreading misinformations

Mar 5, 2020 11:14 AM

#17

Offline

Feb 2020

Misinformations... The problem is the only logical end is with Uruka with all the hint in the manga.

The rest is fantasy to satisfy the reader.

I repeat but it's very sad. Because it's take all value of the manga.

Just the Firework girl, when you see the chapter, you know it can't be Fumino or Rizu because they are not at the same place at this moment. Only Asumi, Mafuyi or Uruka can do it. And expose romantic feeling of Nariyuki for Fumino, in particulary Rizu and Asumi in just few chapter destroy all credibility about Nariyuki feeling and the precedent construction.

What the meaning of Nariyuki Flash Back if it's alternative road ? What the meaning of all this if the rest of the manga don't justify it ?

A story is a story with a begining, a middle and an end, not just some bullshit fantasy with pseudo harem ending.

With this poor choice, afraid of the reader, to satisfy the mass, it's all the manga who take a big strike, who become totally obsolet.

But it's Japan edition, it's Japan production, i am not surprised. It was too beautifull to be true, an Uruka ending, risky, a little original, etc. Too much ball to do that, and a japenese author in the WSJ, not really famous, can't have this.

It was a good 8 for me, now Bokuben with this type of end, because the end is everything, deserve at maximum 5.

What is a story where the reader decide what is the true end. That's not a story, that bull****.

In this case, we need a new end to GOT, with different alternative story, one with Jon Snow King, one with Daenarys Queen, one with Joffrey.

And we must not be happy about it, it's not a good thing. But, maybe, harem manga fanbase deserve it... They don't have interest in the story or the MC, but only on the girl and their projection.

Finally Bokuben the modern version of Love Hina can't approach his ancestor. Love Hina rest a way better manga because of the last choice of Tsutsui (or the editor, i think it's the editor not the author choice).

Even the anime had more balls than the manga ah ah.

ElverostMar 5, 2020 12:27 PM

Mar 5, 2020 11:59 AM

#18

testamentKAISER

Offline

Dec 2014

6433

EliAyaseLL said:
I think the title of this post is a bit misleading since this is not the end of the main arc, but the end of the Uruka route and you can see it at the end of the chapter since it's clearly written : Route [1/5]
spoiler : https://imgur.com/a/3AognZY

There isn't something like "true/main ending" basically all the endings are canon and it's up to you to decide which one is the "real"

Hmm, just noticed this. You are correct. The ending of Bokuben will be like

. Now I am happier.

And Mr Shane's post title is really misleading.

Mar 5, 2020 12:36 PM

#19

TsukuyomiREKT

Offline

May 2015

5410

Aika said:
We are getting 5 different endings, why did OP put "main story" in the title?

Because he's an insanely biased Uruka fan.

Mar 5, 2020 12:47 PM

#20

Offline

Feb 2020

He doesn't need to change the title. It's the true end, because all the other, we will have a time rewind to explain it. How you can consider it like a true end ? If you have a time rewind to do it ah ah.

If you read the story in a direct line, you will end with Uruka who correspond at all the story (and the anime), it's a tricks of Tsutsui, to calm the fans, the alternative end.

Finally if i think about it, it's a very tricky move. Tsutsui regain some respect.

ElverostMar 5, 2020 12:56 PM

Mar 5, 2020 12:59 PM

#21

Offline

Jan 2015

326

Elverost said:
He doesn't need to change the title. It's the true end, because all the other, we will have a time rewind to explain it. How you can consider it like a true end ? If you have a time rewind to do it ah ah.

If you read the story in a direct line, you will end with Uruka who correspond at all the story (and the anime), it's a tricks of Tsutsui, to calm the fans, the alternative end.

Finally if i think about it, it's a very tricky move. Tsutsui regain some respect.

No lol
22i didn't call these 'alternate' endings for a reason
He specifically said that all 5 are parallel and all are true

Mar 5, 2020 1:02 PM

#22

Offline

Jan 2019

Or maybe you Uruka fans are just in denial since you can't accept that Uruka is one of the 5 route and not the "true winner"

the title must be changed because is disrespectful to people who know nothing about the fact that all endings are equal

Mar 5, 2020 1:23 PM

#23

Offline

Feb 2020

EliAyaseLL said:
the fact that all endings are equal

But they can't be egual when one follow the story since the begining to the end, like the first we see and the other, the story need to go back in time to start the new end.

But it's foolish to explain it, it's amazing the facility you reader accept this type of end without question but with a great relief.

Mar 5, 2020 1:39 PM

#24

Offline

Jan 2019

Elverost said:

EliAyaseLL said:
the fact that all endings are equal

There are 5 arcs for each ending
Uruka, the Shimmering Ebony Mermaid Princess.[1/5] (Complete Arc)
Rizu, the Thumbelina Supercomputer Princess. [2/5]
Fumino, the Sleeping Princess of the Literature Forest.[3/5]
Asumi, the Little Fairy of the Night. [4/5]
Mafuyu, the Ice Queen. [5/5]

What we have now is just the Uruka route, so now we go back and take the Rizu route and the others, uruka just happened to be the first one but this doesn't mean that it's the *true ending* and that's why the author specified that all the routes are canon and which one is the true ending is up to you.

I prefer harems with only one winner, but this is much better than the ending we thought we had, so it's fine for me.

Mar 5, 2020 1:41 PM

#25

-Stray

Offline

Jul 2014

2850

I didn't plan on commenting about this anymore but people on discord spammed the shit out of me about this whole thing and asked for my opinion on it, I couldn't believe it at first so I did some more digging on twitter and reddit to get an actual source, once I found out it was true I laughed my ass out and said "22i you fcking pussy" hahahahaha.
I despise...hate what I'm about to say but... at least fucking Nisekoi's author (Komi) had the balls to end with just one girl (still a bad series but I appreciate his guts) but this man tho... it felt like he had no idea what the fuck he was doing or that he himself knows having an Uruka end would bullfuckingshit make no sense so he had this end game plan so people wouldn't be bitter and still support his shit. You Goddamn coward hahahaha!

Deep down.. I feel like the reason he didn't have the other girls confess during Uruka's parallel part is because he knows Nariyuki is a prop mc that would accept any girl that would confess to him and fall inlove with her or get conscious the moment she confesses. Just reading his confession.... it literally could be any girl in Uruka's place and it still would make sense, just change the "swimming" part to the preferred subject of that character and done.

I'm just having fun I still love 22i, but damn man you shoulda just sticked with one girl, it doesnt work with how you set up your story on only having one girl.

Anyways the thread title is misleading. Hopefully a mod fixes it. From what I got at the end of this chapter it had a "route 1/5" meaning Uruka's route is considered as canon as the other heroines, they're all parallel and you decide which ending is for you, its like a damn game lol.

Mar 5, 2020 5:28 PM

#26

Ne_fi

Offline

Sep 2017

241

I liked the series overall and I'm very interested on how will this turn out to be, even though I'm not totally a fan of this kind of developments.

But man, I'm so tired of the toxic manchildren with their asslong paragraphs about 'why this series suck because of the ending/why Uruka is the next coming of Jesus'.

Mar 5, 2020 6:07 PM

#27

Offline

Nov 2018

396

EliAyaseLL said:

Elverost said:

If there will be a special popularity poll that will appeared without notice...

Mar 5, 2020 6:09 PM

#28

Offline

Nov 2018

396

If the alternative arc will continued then it will be finish all the arcs next year (10 chapters per arc)... What do you think??

Mar 5, 2020 11:21 PM

#29

Offline

Jan 2019

shanimebib said:

Edit: These losers commenting below really intend to remain losers just because they cannot read Japanese.

The title of the manga has been changed after this chapter. The manga is now called Bokutachi ga Benkuou ga Dekinai ~ Route: If with new assistant working with the upcoming chapters replacing one of the long standing previous ones.

This is why this chapter is officially "the end of the main story" and hence I put it inside the parenthese. Stop being salty about it. Uruka is also given the closest fireworks girl perspective compared to other girls so there is that.

If this doesn't make these losers understand nothing will. The author categorically said he intends to write the parallel routes 2-5 and giving them titles "What If" 1-4 starting with Rizu, followed by Fumino, Senpai and rounding it off with Sensei so all of the remaining heroines get an ending so that the fans can consider their own canon ending. It's opening the door for all the fans to have a happy ending of their own. But the fact remains the same that the main story ends with Uruka being the end girl.

It can be easily explained why she is the only heroine with a dual cover with Nariyuki or the cover heroine of the fireworks festival arc.

Don't you realize that you are the only loser who is convincing himself that his favorite is true ending when it's NOT like that and you don't need to be a genius to understand it?

In the "what if" project Uruka is INCLUDED because there are 5 arcs for EACH girl and what we have now, at the end oh ch 150 is THE END of the Uruka's arc :
Uruka, the Shimmering Ebony Mermaid Princess.[1/5] -> https://imgur.com/a/3AognZY
Rizu, the Thumbelina Supercomputer Princess. [2/5]
Fumino, the Sleeping Princess of the Literature Forest.[3/5]
Asumi, the Little Fairy of the Night. [4/5]
Mafuyu, the Ice Queen. [5/5]

if it had been the end of the main story, at the end of the chapter it would have written "end of the main story" and NOT end of uruka arc [1/5]
Uruka is not the "true" winner, they're all equal, deal with it and stop spreading misinformations.

Mar 6, 2020 12:10 AM

#30

splash7279

Offline

Nov 2014

lol I saw a bunch of Korean fans talking about burning Tsutsui's house down. Hopefully they don't follow up on it

Mar 6, 2020 12:13 AM

#31

Offline

Jan 2019

If Uruka is the true ending ( unlikely since it's pretty stated that there is no true ending) unlike you I will not cry and I will not behave in a toxic way
there's really no need to offend people, you know?
get a life

Mod Edit: reply to deleted post removed

Fleeting_DreamMar 6, 2020 7:47 AM

Mar 6, 2020 1:48 AM

#32

Devil_Slayer

Offline

Jul 2014

1061

So the author will do an ending for each of the girls? Cool count me in then.

So it's basically like a visual novel now with the readers deciding which end is the true one, most fans will likely says it's sensei and close off the book lol.
But yeah, looking forward to read the other 4 girls arcs.

What with the biased title btw? Lol

Devil_SlayerMar 6, 2020 1:52 AM

Mar 6, 2020 2:47 AM

#33

Offline

Nov 2018

396

Since the Uruka arc is already over and all the fans are very happy, then it's time to rest for a while and get prepare all the tissue paper because all the four characters will got revenge and let Uruka will cyry again 4 times in a row, so that the other waifu fans will getting satisfy on what happened during the previous chapter specially the first arc (Uruka arc)...😂😂😂

Mar 6, 2020 3:02 AM

#34

Offline

Jan 2015

326

Looking at how mad shanimebib is getting is honest to god making my day better.

Just go to any post on this forum, he's most likely there either arguing with someone or talking to himself

Mar 6, 2020 3:10 AM

#35

Judgment526

Offline

Mar 2016

569

I’ll take what I can get. I was originally pretty bummed that I might never get to see what a Mafuyu route would look like except in doujins, so this is a good compromise.

You could argue that 22i chickened out at the end, but whatever, it’s better than giving us the ending no one wanted and the other girls nothing, not even proper closure. I’m down.

Mar 6, 2020 4:57 AM

#36

Offline

Feb 2020

Maybe the author have no balls, but with this chapter, it's totally complet. The Uruka "True" (ah ah) End, with all element, nothing really forget.

And because it's the first, in direct line with all the manga, if you read it in a straight line.

Bah, that's cool. It's concord, all the element, since the begining are present for this. As a reader i'm satisfy. The rest doesn't matter ah ah ah.

For the other end, i am very curious how 22i will proceed. Where in the timeline he will rewind to justify it. For Rizu, it's almost he need to make a new manga ah ah ah ah.

For Fumino, if you really want a good end with her, a real one, coherent one, he need to go back just after her arc, and Uruka never kiss Nariyuki and Nariyuki didn't fall the day of the exam (So Uruka never help him) and the scene at Uruka home (when she take his hand) can stay but more like a friend not a lover, and it will work, with a new manga at this point. For Sempai, it's alternative world, in every way it doesn't exist.

For sensei, at every moment, she attack him a little, make a big move, and it's done. It's sensei after all. I will stay decent, but you know what i mean.

What i try to say, it's the over route are... Just for the fun. Even if the author say all the road are canon, if you really read the manga, without biais and waifu war, you will see. Mmm i don't remember the word. It's trickery ! Not really this word.

But if everyone buy it, it's his win. GG 22i. It was a good manga. Thank for the bonus.

ElverostMar 6, 2020 5:10 AM

Mar 6, 2020 5:04 AM

#37

Frenzify

Offline

Jan 2014

Well, I've only seen a few posts by this OP, and I already can't respect a thing he says when he has to resort to childish name calling just because others disagree with him. Good lord, the endings of harems and people getting unironically heated about waifu wars brings out the worst in people.

Mar 6, 2020 6:28 AM

#38

bastek66

Offline

May 2009

9175

Should have just ended. Endings for each girl is just shallow wishfullfilment for selfinserts.

Mar 6, 2020 7:03 AM

#39

SHlROHA

Offline

Jul 2015

Elverost said:
Misinformations... The problem is the only logical end is with Uruka with all the hint in the manga.

The rest is fantasy to satisfy the reader.

I repeat but it's very sad. Because it's take all value of the manga.

Just the Firework girl, when you see the chapter, you know it can't be Fumino or Rizu because they are not at the same place at this moment. Only Asumi, Mafuyi or Uruka can do it. And expose romantic feeling of Nariyuki for Fumino, in particulary Rizu and Asumi in just few chapter destroy all credibility about Nariyuki feeling and the precedent construction.

What the meaning of Nariyuki Flash Back if it's alternative road ? What the meaning of all this if the rest of the manga don't justify it ?

A story is a story with a begining, a middle and an end, not just some bullshit fantasy with pseudo harem ending.

With this poor choice, afraid of the reader, to satisfy the mass, it's all the manga who take a big strike, who become totally obsolet.

But it's Japan edition, it's Japan production, i am not surprised. It was too beautifull to be true, an Uruka ending, risky, a little original, etc. Too much ball to do that, and a japenese author in the WSJ, not really famous, can't have this.

It was a good 8 for me, now Bokuben with this type of end, because the end is everything, deserve at maximum 5.

What is a story where the reader decide what is the true end. That's not a story, that bull****.

In this case, we need a new end to GOT, with different alternative story, one with Jon Snow King, one with Daenarys Queen, one with Joffrey.

And we must not be happy about it, it's not a good thing. But, maybe, harem manga fanbase deserve it... They don't have interest in the story or the MC, but only on the girl and their projection.

Finally Bokuben the modern version of Love Hina can't approach his ancestor. Love Hina rest a way better manga because of the last choice of Tsutsui (or the editor, i think it's the editor not the author choice).

Even the anime had more balls than the manga ah ah.

I don't and also most of us don't care, We just want to read what ending we want.

Mar 6, 2020 7:19 AM

#40

Offline

Feb 2020

Yep, I undertsand, and it's why now, after reading the last chapter think what 22i do is a wise move.

Maybe it will create a precedent, a new way to make harem manga ah ah ah.

ElverostMar 7, 2020 7:11 AM

Mar 6, 2020 7:59 AM

#41

Fleeting_Dream

Offline

Oct 2018

1642

Thread Cleaned

Baiting and borderline abuse removed.

As per Site and Forum Guideline I.3., please refrain from posting content that would insult users or starting arguments or upsetting users by posting inflammatory, extraneous, or off-topic messages with the intent of provoking users into an emotional response or of otherwise disrupting normal on-topic discussion.

Summertime days, passing gently

Sunlight, leading to an encounter;

Dreams that don't want to end

Continue onwards toward the next day

While she waits in the air.

Mar 6, 2020 11:37 AM

#42

AsT5

Offline

Apr 2016

208

Though I support uruka
I am cool with the Harem ending too because I think each one deserves nariyuki

If quintuplets had ended like this shit it would have been great

So another 30 weeks to go for sensei arc

Anyways it'll be sad journey to see uruka getting rejected in the upcoming volumes 4 times

Mar 6, 2020 11:40 AM

#43

TsukuyomiREKT

Offline

May 2015

5410

Lol, why am I not surprised that you would call anyone that doesn't agree with you a loser. You were basically doing the same thing in 5-toubun threads.

Mar 6, 2020 11:45 AM

#44