| Because hating something that has been deemed as 'trashy show' by elitists is very popular now especially in MAL |
Lontaku said: otherwise why would I sit through the show? In my opinion, if you don't like the show, don't watch it. If you're watching a show you don't enjoy you are wasting time. Well i think i can clarify on this one...the show only started to get bad halfway...by that time its too late to stop...(since its just 12eps, what the hell, might as well finish and get over with it) I dun like to watch anime halfway and stop unless its a long ass shounen anime...and i dun find myself really hate this anime...more like disappointed with the direction it goes Reikuo said: but the relationship between Sagiri and Masamune is far more interesting and complex then anything shown in Saekano. If that is not the most trollish way of incite anger..then i dunno what that is...especially when you added the word complex in it...seriously, complex...haha, i seriously have to give a golf clap on that one...goddamnit whatever it takes to make a point eh? Since i have few mins to spare, why not? By 3rd or 4th eps, we can already tell sagiri love her brother... By 7th ep muramasa confessed By 9th ep yamada confessed In one season, everyone already confessed (its not even a year have passed in the anime timeline, and everyone barely know each other in less than few months) The answer is damn obvious too, no matter how you look at it (masamune will pick his sister)...so you can throw that complexity out of the board...zero effort in attempt to make any romance rivalry Try watch oreimo again...look at the anime timeline, and how long it takes for Kirino to admit she actually have feeling for her brother...its not easy journey for her...even when Kousaka confessed to her, she still have mixed feeling and angry at him...kirino is far more complex than eromanga... Saekano is generic harem...that's for sure...but atm i cant tell if MC going to pick katou or utaha...i did not read the novel...i think he might pick katou, but im rooting for utaha...point is...the characters is lovable...by s2 everyone kinda shine.. Its funny you call me hypocrite in your literal sense that both show are exact same quality... yet i rated saekano higher....sorry to tell you, both MAL and BD sales clearly prove which show is far more superior.... In reality is, saekano is better...dont look at my rating...look at MAL, ANN or BD sales...fact need no explanation...you being delusional is the issue here... |
Baron85Aug 25, 2017 10:01 PM
Rayzer said: @Nevalopo You know, those people who already hate the premise/plot but still bothered watching it anyway. They are just typical haters who do anything just to hate on something pointlessly. You wanna know what to do with those HATERS... DAB ON THEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! |
 |
Baronight said: Lontaku said: otherwise why would I sit through the show? In my opinion, if you don't like the show, don't watch it. If you're watching a show you don't enjoy you are wasting time. Well i think i can clarify on this one...the show only started to get bad halfway...by that time its too late to stop...(since its just 12eps, what the hell, might as well finish and get over with it) I dun like to watch anime halfway and stop unless its a long ass shounen anime...and i dun find myself really hate this anime...more like disappointed with the direction it goes Reikuo said: but the relationship between Sagiri and Masamune is far more interesting and complex then anything shown in Saekano. If that is not the most trollish way of incite anger..then i dunno what that is...especially when you added the word complex in it...seriously, complex...haha, i seriously have to give a golf clap on that one...goddamnit whatever it takes to make a point eh? Since i have few mins to spare, why not? By 3rd or 4th eps, we can already tell sagiri love her brother... By 7th ep muramasa confessed By 9th ep yamada confessed In one season, everyone already confessed (its not even a year have passed in the anime timeline, and everyone barely know each other in less than few months) The answer is damn obvious too, no matter how you look at it (masamune will pick his sister)...so you can throw that complexity out of the board...zero effort in attempt to make any romance rivalry Try watch oreimo again...look at the anime timeline, and how long it takes for Kirino to admit she actually have feeling for her brother...its not easy journey for her...even when Kousaka confessed to her, she still have mixed feeling and angry at him...kirino is far more complex than eromanga... Saekano is generic harem...that's for sure...but atm i cant tell if MC going to pick katou or utaha...i did not read the novel...i think he might pick katou, but im rooting for utaha...point is...the characters is lovable...by s2 everyone kinda shine.. Its funny you call me hypocrite in your literal sense that both show are exact same quality... yet i rated saekano higher....sorry to tell you, both MAL and BD sales clearly prove which show is far more superior.... In reality is, saekano is better...dont look at my rating...look at MAL, ANN or BD sales...fact need no explanation...you being delusional is the issue here... The show outright explains from the start what happened and how they came to be in the situation they are in. Then the story starts on an ordinary day in their lives. There is no narration, there is nothing to tell you what your supposed to be feeling. When we do get internal dialogue, its always about the scenario at hand. We dont have any moments with the characters laying in bed thinking out loud. They only share the past with the audience during scenes in which Sagiri and Masamune are talking about it with each other. The reason for mentioning this is because the trauma both have experienced does play a part in their characters, its just not upfront. If we look at Sagiri in the first few episodes sure she is cute, but if you really look at her behaviors, mannerisms, and reactions towards Masamune its quite odd and bizarre. She comes off frail in a way that almost seems sickly, I honestly thought. Its really not until Elf comes in and starts to stir things up in their lives, even well before she met Sagiri. While not explained until episode 11, Sagiri is quite cold until she knows who Masamune really is. Even after finding out, she does not warm up instantly. She has no idea what to think or do. She just got back a piece of her past she probably never thought she would get back, only when Elf comes does Sagiri spring into action. She has lost essentially everything, she seemed to live alone with her mom. So now she finds this person she has cared about for a long time, and someone is already here to take someone away from her again. This to me explains what seems until episode 11 and a bit of thought, her rapid transition into swooning over him. Thus the start of the harem, which admittedly is not the most impressive harem from a story standpoint. Not by a longshot, but the only one getting character development is Sagiri. Sure Elf confesses, but nothing has changed much afterwards. Maramusa was in love from the start. While minor as it may be, Sagiris small changes are the core of the show. Small in each instance its presented, but when you compare episode 12 to the first few episodes her changes are quite apparent. Just like at the end of episode 12, in my interpretation if it was Masamune walking off she would not have told him good bye. However with Muramasa and Elf there, she did not want to feel left out and wanted to fit in as best she could. Which led to her awkward wave goodbye to the group. In addition to this, Masamunes expression is one of shock, and then happy relief. This is because he does not see the change in Sagiri happening until its placed directly in front of him. Sagiri is often disappointed in his responses and statements, because he sees her as his little sister and he needs to do this, this and this to keep himself, the house, and her all going. Keeping the house and Sagiri under his control, but not in a menacing way, are just what keeps him going. The best glimpse into this scenario I can think of is when he spent the night at work and called Sagiri and only ended up asking if she ate her meal, to which she was disappointed in that being the reason why. As for complaints about how unrealistic the whole concept is, how the odds of them having met in the past online and Sagiri being his first fan and all that... Well romance fiction tends to be a bit ethereal in nature to begin with, its just a modern theme and setting. 1 in a billion odds in regards to romantic chance encounters or "red string of fate" scenarios just dont get points off for me. I did not tune into the show expecting them to meet in a gas station. Another way I saw it was the fact that Masamune pretty much has his shit together from episode 1, goes to school, very polite, clearly a hard worker, etc. He does not undergo a ton of change throughout the series because its all about Sagiri opening up. To which she does a decent amount by the end. The show was only ever about Sagiri and Masamune. The only time we have private narrration, and moments alone with characters, are with Sagiri and Masamune. We dont have internal dialogue nor meaningful alone scenes with Elf or Maramusa. These two characters exist as a tool to force Sagiri out of her room. Regardless of whether or not you like the show, you clearly know absolutely nothing about the plot. |
| Annoying characters. Dropped cause I couldn't stand the noisy voice of this girl who played piano naked and the attitude of the one who loves dick... well, all this in itself was enough reason too. |
Reikuo said: The show outright explains from the start what happened and how they came to be in the situation they are in. I never touch on this subject...i just say the story is weak and feel rushed...you might feel differently, but this is essentially the same generic reuse plot of "suddenly cute little sister staying with you"....I'm not gonna blame on the generic part...i watch a lot of romance anime, and these doesnt bother me that much....its the pacing of the romance that tick me off the most Reikuo said: If we look at Sagiri in the first few episodes...yadayadayada.. While not explained until episode 11, Sagiri is quite cold until she knows who Masamune really is. This is contradicting statement....the moment she knew her brother is the author of the novel she love..., she is all head over heel for him...mere mentioning of other girl name or every time he mention sagiri just as his sister and nothing more, her jealousy pops up immediately... Remember that little novel contest between masamune and elf? and he wrote about how he love his sister? sagiri probably masturbate on that every night...you cant tell me with straight face she is cold toward her brother until ep.11...that is all charade, waste of time "cold shoulder" moment that we can't take seriously... this ultimately make her a shallow character, void of any possible development...try compare that with kirino....i would not have imagine kirino finally admitted to her feeling...but there she is...finally after almost 24eps of hate of her brother and self denying... this make kirino far more interesting sister...every time kyosuke make her heart go kyun...she instantly retort and say stuff like "disgusting, fuck off, etc"..she genuinely hate her brother, but every time kyosuke save her and being a reliable brother...she cant help but actually feel grateful and happy...these little moment that change kirino slowly through out the course of the anime... Reikuo said: As for complaints about how unrealistic the whole concept is, how the odds of them having met in the past online and Sagiri being his first fan and all that... Although i did touch abt this issue, i never actually complain abt the whole "red string of fate".....what i do complain is how fast muramasa and elf fall in love with the main guy...they barely know him at all and they confessing in a blink of an eye? that's shallow character development...sagiri is different case, coz she actually lived with him long enough to know him well... Reikuo said: Regardless of whether or not you like the show, you clearly know absolutely nothing about the plot. Anyone with IQ less than two digits would understand the plot immediately after watching the show once, it doesnt take rocket science interpretation of what is happening in the show...this is not Evangelion. again, this is not my issue, romance anime doesnt need to be complex and gritty as fuck to be considered good...what it needs to be, is to keep us invested with all the potential candidates MC can choose... But like you said...other candidate are merely stepping stone for sagiri development...they serve no purpose in enriching the story...its there to give the illusion of non-existence romance conflict... some romance anime can do this... "tsuki ga kirei" is a good example of romance anime that doesnt need conflict to be good...eromanga fail in every single romance department...With the recent BD uncensored release of distasteful and inappropriate elf cameltoe, its obvious that this anime was never about romance...its just ecchi, slice of life anime...i was a fool to think this anime might have decent romance plot like oreimo |
Baron85Aug 27, 2017 3:00 AM
| Speaking about blatant fanservice... Remember the episode where Kyosuke push kirino down and we get a glimpse of her panty? Kyosuke knee was on Kirino crotch but we barely can see the cameltoe..., just small glimpse of it...if you blink you could probably missed it....pretty tame fan service... Here...Elf simply standing and her cameltoe exposed 100% right up to her clit...not only its overkill (i feel its impossible unless she forcefully pull her panty upwards...but hey, logic doesnt apply in anime)...but it set different tone of what could have become on the beach episode...more cameltoe and maybe protruding nipples I find it a bit tacky though...for me, cameltoe is a bit more offensive than simply exposing tits... |
Baron85Aug 27, 2017 3:33 AM
| It is pretty trashy. I figured a 6/10 was too good for it so I lowered it to a 4. I at least loved the Toradora cameos. |
  |
Syrup- said: It's shit, but it's fun shit. Also lol at all that TLDR text spams; I think this should mean a lot coming from me: get a hobby. Nevalopo said: Google inseki. That's what he means. Normal people don't approve of a "brother" and a "sister" having a relationship, and it's heavily implied that they want each other. This is from the same author of Oreimo, where Kirino won. It's clear that the author's endgame in Eromanga is to get those two together.How is it incest? A girl moves into another guys house -> incest? wut they are not blood-related Linerax said: It's literally this. This is definitely where the "hate" comes from. It's so perfectly identical to his previous work that it's just boring to watch since we know what's going to happen. The only reason I watched the whole thing was because there were cute girls and that's never a negative.I dropped this anime because I already watched Tsukasa Fushimi's other work, Ore Imo. Eromanga Sensei and Ore Imo have similar main features: incestuous tension between brother and sister, brother unexpectedly forms a harem, love conflict between one of the harem girls and sister, and the sister being a secret otaku. I might also add the main character brothers have similar hairstyles they might as well be lost twins. Do I have a personal vengeance as to try to erase Eromanga Sensei off the face of this planet? No. I already saw what the plot for Ore Imo is like - twice, then Eromanga Sensei kinda rehash the same plot. I felt exhausted watching Eromanga Sensei. Contrary, Eromanga is a great show for someone who did not watch Ore Imo. You know, it is strange, people say "they aren't related by law" as an excuse for why it is OK that there was tension. But I found Oriimo superior because well, they were actually related and well, obviously they should 10/10 not hook up but I thought the point of Oreiimo was to make me WISH they would smash anyway lol. But I thought the entire point of making the characters in Eromanga sensei not related, that they would end up together. But then they didn't really (like I feel there was way more going on in Oreimo... which is weird). Like what was even the point in making them not related? What was the point in that backstory? And yeah I was familiar with his other works which is exactly why I thought the reason to make them not related this time was.... to make them hook up. But what was with all the detours along the way to make it happen in the end and make it feel so shallow? I really find these shows frustrating. Koi Kaze FTW. |
Energetic-NovaAug 27, 2017 4:01 AM
The anime community in a nutshell.  |
| Everything is wrong with it |
 |
TriZen said: Because hating something that has been deemed as 'trashy show' by elitists is very popular now especially in MAL Well, I like plenty of trashy shows. I just don't like this one because of the level of pointlessness. Heck I liked Love Tyrant. I LOVE Keijo. I got Moldiver in my faves (but yeah I also got Evangelion in there but you know I like it for the gay kay!). There is plenty of trash I like. I even like season 1 of Oreimo... |
Energetic-NovaAug 27, 2017 3:54 AM
| The anime community in a nutshell. |
Baronight said: Reikuo said: The show outright explains from the start what happened and how they came to be in the situation they are in. I never touch on this subject...i just say the story is weak and feel rushed...you might feel differently, but this is essentially the same generic reuse plot of "suddenly cute little sister staying with you"....I'm not gonna blame on the generic part...i watch a lot of romance anime, and these doesnt bother me that much....its the pacing of the romance that tick me off the most Reikuo said: If we look at Sagiri in the first few episodes...yadayadayada.. While not explained until episode 11, Sagiri is quite cold until she knows who Masamune really is. This is contradicting statement....the moment she knew her brother is the author of the novel she love..., she is all head over heel for him...mere mentioning of other girl name or every time he mention sagiri just as his sister and nothing more, her jealousy pops up immediately... Remember that little novel contest between masamune and elf? and he wrote about how he love his sister? sagiri probably masturbate on that every night...you cant tell me with straight face she is cold toward her brother until ep.11...that is all charade, waste of time "cold shoulder" moment that we can't take seriously... this ultimately make her a shallow character, void of any possible development...try compare that with kirino....i would not have imagine kirino finally admitted to her feeling...but there she is...finally after almost 24eps of hate of her brother and self denying... this make kirino far more interesting sister...every time kyosuke make her heart go kyun...she instantly retort and say stuff like "disgusting, fuck off, etc"..she genuinely hate her brother, but every time kyosuke save her and being a reliable brother...she cant help but actually feel grateful and happy...these little moment that change kirino slowly through out the course of the anime... Reikuo said: As for complaints about how unrealistic the whole concept is, how the odds of them having met in the past online and Sagiri being his first fan and all that... Although i did touch abt this issue, i never actually complain abt the whole "red string of fate".....what i do complain is how fast muramasa and elf fall in love with the main guy...they barely know him at all and they confessing in a blink of an eye? that's shallow character development...sagiri is different case, coz she actually lived with him long enough to know him well... Reikuo said: Regardless of whether or not you like the show, you clearly know absolutely nothing about the plot. Anyone with IQ less than two digits would understand the plot immediately after watching the show once, it doesnt take rocket science interpretation of what is happening in the show...this is not Evangelion. again, this is not my issue, romance anime doesnt need to be complex and gritty as fuck to be considered good...what it needs to be, is to keep us invested with all the potential candidates MC can choose... But like you said...other candidate are merely stepping stone for sagiri development...they serve no purpose in enriching the story...its there to give the illusion of non-existence romance conflict... some romance anime can do this... "tsuki ga kirei" is a good example of romance anime that doesnt need conflict to be good...eromanga fail in every single romance department...With the recent BD uncensored release of distasteful and inappropriate elf cameltoe, its obvious that this anime was never about romance...its just ecchi, slice of life anime...i was a fool to think this anime might have decent romance plot like oreimo YES! EVERYTHING YOU SAID YES! And I LIKE incest stuff. It isn't like I don't like incest stuff, I totally do. I just wow yeah I felt all the side bitches were such a distraction from the real thing that was supposed to happen and I just DID NOT EVEN WANT TO WATCH after that. And I LIKE these shows. You know what show does step siblings issues infinitely better? I hate saying it but... Super Lovers. At least they address the issues. Koi Kaze is also a great incest anime that is ACTUALLY INCEST doesn't just go herpa derpa maybe also here some kawaii fanservice. Though not like I don't mind it. If this wanted to be a cute little sister show, that is what it should have been. but no, had to complicate it with lots of other random girls. Why? I don't even know! And as much as you can say both Super Lovers and Koi Kaze are fanservice stuff filled with tropes of their own... well... yeah! Everything is. The point of an incest show is to be WRONG. It isn't supposed to be OK. And you know, part of the issue with Eromanga might even be that it tried to make things TOO OK. Because of how rapey every other relationship with characters were, the relationship between brother an sister seemed more innocent and that is just simply not how it should be! GOSH! We old school fans thought Shinji x Rei was wrong even if we liked it. lol. AND YEAH THANKS FOR MENTIONING EVANGELION. Because when I think show that handled it's incest themes well, I think Evangelion. Evangelion's women didn't only exist to sell figurines to otaku. |
Energetic-NovaAug 27, 2017 4:19 AM
| The anime community in a nutshell. |
Baronight said: Reikuo said: If we look at Sagiri in the first few episodes...yadayadayada.. While not explained until episode 11, Sagiri is quite cold until she knows who Masamune really is. This is contradicting statement....the moment she knew her brother is the author of the novel she love..., she is all head over heel for him...mere mentioning of other girl name or every time he mention sagiri just as his sister and nothing more, her jealousy pops up immediately... Remember that little novel contest between masamune and elf? and he wrote about how he love his sister? sagiri probably masturbate on that every night...you cant tell me with straight face she is cold toward her brother until ep.11...that is all charade, waste of time "cold shoulder" moment that we can't take seriously... this ultimately make her a shallow character, void of any possible development...try compare that with kirino....i would not have imagine kirino finally admitted to her feeling...but there she is...finally after almost 24eps of hate of her brother and self denying... this make kirino far more interesting sister...every time kyosuke make her heart go kyun...she instantly retort and say stuff like "disgusting, fuck off, etc"..she genuinely hate her brother, but every time kyosuke save her and being a reliable brother...she cant help but actually feel grateful and happy...these little moment that change kirino slowly through out the course of the anime... I clearly said "explained"... Until episode 11 its not clear why Sagiri suddenly like Masamune so much. So up until she found out he was the author of the novels she illustrates for she was quite cold to him. As for the rest of your rant im just going to assume English is not your first language. Its hard to read and your coming from left, right, and center and cant seem to cope with the fact this is not a direct scene for scene copy of Oreimo. It makes much more sense from the standpoint of the author to have a more lightweight, silly, and fan servicey series the second time around considering they are both about little sisters. What you wanted out of Eromanga Sensei was Oreimo direct copy 2.0 and you did not get it. If you dont like fan service then thats a fine personal choice but if your really gonna complain about it in 2017 then you just have your work cut out for you. Its in essentially every show and actually, people overblow how bad it is in Eromanga Sensei. Your complaining about a camel toe that only the blu-ray buyers get... How stuck up are you on actual criticisms? Your just a rapid fanboy. This show is not Oreimo and your constant comparisons to it make 0 sense. Its. Not. Oreimo. Get over it and find a new hobby. I for one appreciated Elfs glorious camel toe :> Side note, have you seen any Oreimo merchandise? Kirino has been stripped and posed in everyway imaginable.... Why are you acting like its some gold standard for romance anime? Its full of tropes and fan service in itself. |
| woaw..totally can't retort my point about how bad the story is...all you do is attacking me personally...great way to do a healthy argument I never say it has to be Oreimo 2.0....i just say its trash story and pale in comparison to oreimo...(and i didnt knew you were dumb enough not to realize why everyone compare eromanga with oreimo..like seriously do we have to explain that? same author? same setting? same animation style? like duhh?) Its funny if you think i consider oreimo to be the gold standard of romance anime...its not even my top10...i suggest you try to watch more romance anime to expand your horizon...atm, you considering eromanga to be awesometacular romance anime clearly show you havent watch enough of good one... Nope...it deserve the criticism it get..it jump down the hill faster than most romance anime i've watched...i speak mainly on the romance plot point...people might feel differently abt the slice of life and fan service aspect though, so i wont judge on that... It has got nothing to do with the anime though...and its off topic in regard to the quality of the anime...i guess you wanna point out that oreimo merchandise is erotic, therefore the anime is erotic too? That's soooooooooo far-fetch and you are stretching the argument so thinly i feel you run out of material to defend the show...which is why you keep attacking people who criticize it with legitimate point... By which, every time i point out how shallow the romance progression is...you have not be able to give any kind of constructive opinion of WHY its not shallow...All you did is glorify Sagari development from shut-in into slightly less shut-in otaku....like woaw that's the only redeeming quality that make you feel, it worth 10 point masterpiece anime? Seems to me you consider Sagiri as top class waifu material? not that im gonna bash on her or anything like that...i just feel like your stance in defending the anime is not because its good, but because there is one character you like in the anime.. |
Baronight said: woaw..totally can't retort my point about how bad the story is...all you do is attacking me personally...great way to do a healthy argument I never say it has to be Oreimo 2.0....i just say its trash story and pale in comparison to oreimo...(and i didnt knew you were dumb enough not to realize why everyone compare eromanga with oreimo..like seriously do we have to explain that? same author? same setting? same animation style? like duhh?) Its funny if you think i consider oreimo to be the gold standard of romance anime...its not even my top10...i suggest you try to watch more romance anime to expand your horizon...atm, you considering eromanga to be awesometacular romance anime clearly show you havent watch enough of good one... Nope...it deserve the criticism it get..it jump down the hill faster than most romance anime i've watched...i speak mainly on the romance plot point...people might feel differently abt the slice of life and fan service aspect though, so i wont judge on that... It has got nothing to do with the anime though...and its off topic in regard to the quality of the anime...i guess you wanna point out that oreimo merchandise is erotic, therefore the anime is erotic too? That's soooooooooo far-fetch and you are stretching the argument so thinly i feel you run out of material to defend the show...which is why you keep attacking people who criticize it with legitimate point... By which, every time i point out how shallow the romance progression is...you have not be able to give any kind of constructive opinion of WHY its not shallow...All you did is glorify Sagari development from shut-in into slightly less shut-in otaku....like woaw that's the only redeeming quality that make you feel, it worth 10 point masterpiece anime? Seems to me you consider Sagiri as top class waifu material? not that im gonna bash on her or anything like that...i just feel like your stance in defending the anime is not because its good, but because there is one character you like in the anime.. Dude your English sucks. You went on a big rant because I brought up Oreimo merchandise when I clearly said "side note" which means "The phrase introduces a bit of information that is connected to the topic at hand, but that is not part of your main narrative. A similar term is "by the way."" As for the plot... I already explained my interpretation of it, what more is there to say? Also can you quote me in this thread any one time where I said anything about how good I actually felt Eromanga Sensei was? I have not said it was anything other then better then Seakano in this thread. I am simply pointing out the hypocrites in this thread, including yourself. You pretend to have such a bone to pick with the plot, but in reality its because your triggered by the fan service. You even double posted to talk about Elfs camel toe when you already brought it up in the first post... That is the tell tale signs of a rabid fanboy. You dont like Elfs camel toe or Sagiris waggling ass fine but why are you still here? Not to mention you did not even see her camel toe watching the show, it was a freaking blu-ray buyers exclusive.... Yet your here crying and double posting about it? Sad What makes this anime so different then the countless other fan service harem animes? I bet you dont distribute your disdain equally, your just coming here to cry and complain because it was the flavor of the month to do so last season. You have 0 insight, you dont even understand the plot as I pointed out with a direct response you happily completely ignored. Your just triggered and butt sore. Your just another one of the victims I have strung along effortlessly in this thread to prove none other then 1 thing, Eromanga Sensei haters are the biggest losers in the entire anime fandom. You even criticized the show for NOT being a typical harem. Lmao  MMmmmm looks great ~ stay triggered buttmad so glad I bought the blu-rays <3 |
Again attacking me personally instead of focusing on the topic...English is my 4th language...so im sorry if it couldnt live up to the expectation of angry fanboy who have no other way of defending the show other than attacking the critics I'm not crying about the cameltoe..i mean the show have no other way of pulling customers other than using blatant fanservices so 14yo kids will go apeshit over it...no good story, no good characters...just fanservice... This is the question that you should direct to yourself...not me...what make this anime so different it deserve a 10 masterpiece? i think its worst than other top tier harem anime... Reikuo said: so glad I bought the blu-rays <3 I dont think you bought the blueray...more like you "bought" the torrent like everybody else And eromanga sensei lover are the biggest losers in the entire anime fandom...it goes both way too...have fun defending the show and become the one and only guy who fit to claim sagiri as your waifu...you deserve a pat on the back... |
Baron85Aug 29, 2017 12:21 AM
Baronight said: Again attacking me personally instead of focusing on the topic...English is my 4th language...so im sorry if it couldnt live up to the expectation of angry fanboy who have no other way of defending the show other than attacking the critics I'm not crying about the cameltoe..i mean the show have no other way of pulling customers other than using blatant fanservices so 14yo kids will go apeshit over it...no good story, no good characters...just fanservice... Im not "attacking" you... Im letting you know your responses do not make any sense. Yes you are crying about the cameltoe, you never saw it, its blu-ray buyers only, it did not detract from your experience whatsoever yet you double posted complaining about it. If the show had no other way of pulling customers, can you care to explain why the light novel sold so well considering it has nearly 0 fan service? Baronight said: I dont think you bought the blueray...more like you "bought" the torrent like everybody else Nope I bought them, I have 2 volumes and the 3rd is still in the mail. The rest are not out yet. Baronight said: And eromanga sensei lover are the biggest losers in the entire anime fandom...it goes both way too...have fun defending the show and become the one and only guy who fit to claim sagiri as your waifu...you deserve a pat on the back... Sagiri is not my waifu, that would be Rin Shibuya. Im only defending the show against rabbid buttmad losers who pretend they disliked for the plot but in reality they are just upset over the loli fan service and rather then dropping the show and moving on they come here to complain and their arguments fall flat because they are disingenuous and illegitimate and it always shows. |
Nevalopo said: Fun Is it because SJW's wants to remain "im a good boy" in the public eye? It's all i can think of nah because most people dont want to fuck a 5 year old |
Karl_Marx_Sensei said: Nevalopo said: Fun Is it because SJW's wants to remain "im a good boy" in the public eye? It's all i can think of nah because most people dont want to fuck a 5 year old ????? Who said anything about fucking a 5 year old? What is wrong with you lol |
 |
Nevalopo said: What can you say? Eromanga Sensei haters are very sick people...????? Who said anything about fucking a 5 year old? What is wrong with you lol |
| Probably the worst thing about Eromanga sensei is not the incest, but the commentary about the LN industry. You can tell both A1 and the author of the Eromanga Light Novel know exactly that they produce shit and are completely fine with it. There is even a scene early on, when Izumi (who also has the same face as Kirito and the same voice actor -.-) mentions how much he respects SAO. This entire show is just a huge middle finger to quality entertainment in general. |
JonasTheJay said: Probably the worst thing about Eromanga sensei is not the incest, but the commentary about the LN industry. You can tell both A1 and the author of the Eromanga Light Novel know exactly that they produce shit and are completely fine with it. There is even a scene early on, when Izumi (who also has the same face as Kirito and the same voice actor -.-) mentions how much he respects SAO. This entire show is just a huge middle finger to quality entertainment in general. Yes because everyone who bought SAO was forced out of their home at gunpoint to purchase it. Get over yourself. This same thing has been going on in other industries for years. Its no different then whats been going on with wrestling or the WWE for the past 40 years. Everyone who is not a fan cant stand the stuff and talks about how fake it is since the first day it aired, here we are nearly 40 years later and its still going strong as fuck. The fans determine what sells and what does not. The only people not having fun are the whine asses. |
Reikuo said: JonasTheJay said: Probably the worst thing about Eromanga sensei is not the incest, but the commentary about the LN industry. You can tell both A1 and the author of the Eromanga Light Novel know exactly that they produce shit and are completely fine with it. There is even a scene early on, when Izumi (who also has the same face as Kirito and the same voice actor -.-) mentions how much he respects SAO. This entire show is just a huge middle finger to quality entertainment in general. Yes because everyone who bought SAO was forced out of their home at gunpoint to purchase it. Get over yourself. This same thing has been going on in other industries for years. Its no different then whats been going on with wrestling or the WWE for the past 40 years. Everyone who is not a fan cant stand the stuff and talks about how fake it is since the first day it aired, here we are nearly 40 years later and its still going strong as fuck. The fans determine what sells and what does not. The only people not having fun are the whine asses. So just because SAO is succesfull means everyone should worship it and Reki Kawahara should be everyone's rolemodel? It doesn't matter how much it sells, that doesn't improve SAO's quality in the slightest. The same goes for Eromanga and evey other anime. |
JonasTheJay said: Reikuo said: Yes because everyone who bought SAO was forced out of their home at gunpoint to purchase it. Get over yourself. This same thing has been going on in other industries for years. Its no different then whats been going on with wrestling or the WWE for the past 40 years. Everyone who is not a fan cant stand the stuff and talks about how fake it is since the first day it aired, here we are nearly 40 years later and its still going strong as fuck. The fans determine what sells and what does not. The only people not having fun are the whine asses. So just because SAO is succesfull means everyone should worship it and Reki Kawahara should be everyone's rolemodel? It doesn't matter how much it sells, that doesn't improve SAO's quality in the slightest. The same goes for Eromanga and evey other anime. SAO fans dont care about your wimpy definition of "quality" its going to continue being a success no matter how often the legion of fanboys who would not be spending money on the show anyway bitch and moan on the computer about it. I highly doubt you watched SAO years ago and became just that scarred by the bad quality and have been shaken all these years since. You just see people bash it all the time and continue to pass and receive the torch of being a little wussy whenever someone mentions SAO. Personally, I do think SAO is shit but it also dont scratch an itch for me. I moved on, and I dont think about it. Eromanga Sensei caters with immense success to its target demographic that your clearly not a part of but rather then dropping it and moving on you try and draw conclusions that are simply not there. I have my own gripes with the industry, like Eromanga Sensei doubling the sales of Little Witch Academia. Thats a damn shame, really, but hate the player not the game. What people enjoy is up to them and just because a ton of people like SAO and I dont does not make it a middle finger to any show or piece of content I like. Spreading negativity about shows you dont like only invites others to do the same to shows you like. Thats definitely not to say you cant criticize a show for being terrible to your tastes, but your original post was just dumpster teir commentary. |
Voidseer said: So in your world people don't have the right to freely express their opinion? People watch it for many reasons. For example because it's so famous so they want to give it a try. I watched it with my friends. My best friend loved it, I hated it. He can laugh and express his joy, but I.... I must be silent and am absolutely not allowed to express my negative feelings..... because we live in a world where you just.. can't express negative feelings. WTF. When you watch the show, come to the forum for the show and say the shows existence is a middle finger to all quality entertainment simply because you dont like it, yea your opinion sucks. I push people to actually post coherent thoughts and analysis, we dont really need a thread full of people going "it sucked, its trash, its garbage" this is a discussion board. His commentary was dumpster teir and he left holding his head down. |
Voidseer said: So in your world people don't have the right to freely express their opinion? People watch it for many reasons. For example because it's so famous so they want to give it a try. I watched it with my friends. My best friend loved it, I hated it. He can laugh and express his joy, but I.... I must be silent and am absolutely not allowed to express my negative feelings..... because we live in a world where you just.. can't express negative feelings. WTF. In a world of weeaboo... positive review = legit opinion bad review = hater gonna hate You can post full detail of analysis of why you think its bad, and people gonna say you cherry-pick certain flaws, blow it out of proportion, or give unfair treatment when compared to other show....end of the day, hater gonna hate... Its no difference that waifu wars...the only negative opinion you are allowed to say in anime community without getting scorn is "the anime is average/bad, but somehow i still enjoy it blablabla... not my cup of tea, but it was okay blablabla"....Give it a cushion, dun bash it too hard and people will leave you alone...everyone is sensitive nowadays... |
Baronight said: Voidseer said: So in your world people don't have the right to freely express their opinion? People watch it for many reasons. For example because it's so famous so they want to give it a try. I watched it with my friends. My best friend loved it, I hated it. He can laugh and express his joy, but I.... I must be silent and am absolutely not allowed to express my negative feelings..... because we live in a world where you just.. can't express negative feelings. WTF. In a world of weeaboo... positive review = legit opinion bad review = hater gonna hate You can post full detail of analysis of why you think its bad, and people gonna say you cherry-pick certain flaws, blow it out of proportion, or give unfair treatment when compared to other show....end of the day, hater gonna hate... Its no difference that waifu wars...the only negative opinion you are allowed to say in anime community without getting scorn is "the anime is average/bad, but somehow i still enjoy it blablabla... not my cup of tea, but it was okay blablabla"....Give it a cushion, dun bash it too hard and people will leave you alone...everyone is sensitive nowadays... I agree completely, well said. |
| Probably is because of the show being lolicon and too similar to Oreimo Oreimo fans and lolicon haters gonna hate it |
 Life is empty without anime |
Nevalopo said: Fun Well animated Well directed Great character designs Adorable imouto Good fanservice, not too much nor too little Twists the average siscon harem plot into something amusing to watch Great fanart incoming ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) This GIF is the epitome of my initial reaction when I read this.  Ohmygod. |
     "Maybe he's trying to take a shit, but the shit just won't come out." Captain Levi, 2014 (／^-^)／☆♪  ♪☆＼(^０^＼) |
| Eromanga sensei was a masterpiece compared to some other shows this year. An example of an Anime that is complete SHIT but noone even talks about it is Isekai wa Smartphone to Tomo ni. That Shit was boring as hell with a Asspull OP Protagonist, A easy mode Harem and Shitty Animation, Eromanga sensi the Only thing I see bad about it is the Easymode harem and the Undecisive endin but it is Probably going to have a second season so I didnt Really Care about that. And Also the most important thing.... IF YOU DON'T LIKE THE SHOW THEN DROP IT AND DONT EVEN BOTHER WATCHING IT!!! |
GokaiKingSep 20, 2017 6:30 PM
  愛がなければ、見えない。 Without Love, the truth cannot be seen. |
TriZen said: Because hating something that has been deemed as 'trashy show' by elitists is very popular now especially in MAL I Call the People who do this PsuedoCrtics since they are not really Critics. They Just Say everything That they don't like is ABSOLUTE Trash instead o just saying That its "their" opinion (Their in Qotations because it isn't even their popinion) |
| 愛がなければ、見えない。 Without Love, the truth cannot be seen. |
-KaneKo- said: Eromanga sensei was a masterpiece compared to some other shows this year. masterpiece masterpiece masterpiece It seems to me that popular show were granted immunity from criticism because they are popular....Therefore, whoever bashed popular anime must be elitist or asshole who try to stir up the flame... Popular = masterpiece.... I should have know this fact before even trying to say why im disappointing with the anime..could have saved several hours of typing... |
-KaneKo- said: An example of an Anime that is complete SHIT but no one even talks about it is Isekai wa Smartphone to Tomo ni This is one of the reason people keep repeating, when they feel Eromanga being a scapegoat...which by the way, is pretty shallow point... You are assuming everybody watch all anime that season and draw conclusion that eromanga is the worst...the fact is, many people can't keep up with dozen of show being released every season...so they cherry pick which anime to watch based around the hype and popularity No one talk about smartphone because its probably shit, there is no hype surround it, and almost everybody say its bad...there is no reason to beat a dead horse just to prove a point... I dunno about other, but what draw me to Eromanga is the author and animation style (oreimo is good, and classroom crisis is even better - i bet no one know about it though) And the reason why so many hate for the show is simply because the hype doesnt match the quality...as for me, you can cross off several of these reasons: - Oreimo salt (im glad kirino got picked) - Gigguk video (he does bring more exposure though) - Trying to become elitist (if that's even a thing...) Btw, just because i wrote shit load of paragraphs, doesnt mean this show is really that bad...sure i throw word like "shitty" and "trash" to describe the anime...but you could probably still get some enjoyment from it... my only gripe is the romance aspect and that alone is enough for me to give it 5/10....(in my book, 5/10 is not trash score, but for this anime, i categorize it as trash....as it shatter all my expectation what this anime could have become - too much expectation from the author, as i really like oreimo) |
| pedopandering is not good! |
Nevalopo said: Fun Well animated Well directed Great character designs Adorable imouto Good fanservice, not too much nor too little Twists the average siscon harem plot into something amusing to watch Great fanart incoming ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) Is it because SJW's wants to remain "im a good boy" in the public eye? It's all i can think of But that's just like, your opinion, man. In the same way that you see all those things, think all those things and/or like all those things, you have people with different opinions who don't think the art is great, who don't like the animation, who don't like the fanservice and who don't like the siscon harem. They might even have more reasons, and they're in their every right to think and feel that. They wouldn't be wrong either. Because it's all opinions, no facts; it's what you prefer and what you like/dislike. It would be completely retarded to call an opinion wrong or right. Take it or leave it. |
...At least let me finish.   |
| How about you shouldn't care what other people think about this show and just enjoy it? |
 |
Nevalopo said: not related by blood? no, the author wrote all this based on a full siblings relationship. this setting are just prepared for the final marrige end to avoid ethnics criticism. u can never deduce this from the show itself, excluding they told u so.Black_Flower_1 said: Because its incest How is it incest? A girl moves into another guys house -> incest? wut they are not blood-related and more, marriage codes in many countries forbid marriage between adopted and step relatives, or demand special permission from the government. |
| LOL DICKS EROMANGA HAHAHAHA SO FUNNY BEST ANIME XDDDD 10/10 |
Nevalopo said: Zephaas said: Some people really don't like implied incest and fan-service. Honestly I don't even like that stuff I just had to finish the show. How is it incest? Ofcourse blood-related incest is fked up but this is not incest, They are not related in any way and Sagiri only lives there because she liked him since she was a kid and wrote letters to him before they met. I don't really enjoy fanservice either when its too much but this show doesn't really focus on fanservice it's not like it's another Highschool DxD/Highschool of the dead/Freezing/ToLoveRu and they didn't recieve this much hate. Even shows like kill la kill had alot of fanservice and everyone seemed to love it still. i agree its not incest & i have explained it in ep discussion ppl who call it incest don't know what the word mean & what incest is they should go to a special school that teaches that stuff Nevalopo said: Lordwen said: Boring af "Animated" when whole episodes take inside a room with almost all static images Terribly directed Average character designs Awkward hikikomori who is supposed to be the goddess of attraction for some reason Specially when it's made of impossible angles and some unimpressive voyeuristic shots There you go. If your interest is in the doujinshi you don't even need to watch this outrage in the first place. Just like a little kid who says the opposite of someone else. If you thought it was so boring why did you keep watching it. And if that's the case for everyones hate of it that it was "boring af" why not just drop the show? Maybe it's not to your liking no need to hate on it. If I don't enjoy a show i just drop it. i agree i finished ep5 i find that the comedy is good & series itself isn't bad CamiloJTM said: People is still angry with Oreimo ending...and Eromanga-sensei is from the same creators...so thats why so much hate WOW ppl are really that dumb to hate anime for stupid reason like this? its a new anime so i don't judge it paste on their previous work |
Sugram22Nov 26, 2017 6:29 AM
AmMar-Sama said: There is absolutely nothing wrong with it; people are just morons and can't understand true art. The ochinchin memes already make this show an automatic 10/10 material. so true :D finished ep5 & don't find it bad, i hope the misunderstanding gets cleared by the end of the season, if author doesn't want them to date right new he or she can just do it like make them prioritize their work for new so they can't date right away or can't date or so much at least they know cause i don't want to see NTR in future (like S2) that soe1 else takes him when he still have her in hes heart like in another anime i so Asa got hurt cause MC had still Eba in hes heart & ended up braking her heart its possible 8/10 from me at least 7/10 i don't think i go below 7 |
| Horrendous on so many levels. Probably my pick for Worst Anime of the Year. Made me quit anime for a few weeks because of how awful the experience was. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Haters are jealous and triggered that this will definitely get season 2 HAHAHAHAHAHA |
Cross  AngeHey guys check my profile for current airing season anime recommendation (guaranteed best taste) |
AndoCommando said: better watch out man; this thread's boogyman will prolly come after you now lolHorrendous on so many levels. Probably my pick for Worst Anime of the Year. Made me quit anime for a few weeks because of how awful the experience was. |
| Being wrong is just an occupational hazard. Follow me on twitter. I have an anitube channel so feel free to check it out and subscribe if you like what you see. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Eromanga-sensei Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 24, 2017 |
337 |
by Phoenix-5an
»»
Aug 26, 12:05 AM |
|
Poll: » Eromanga-sensei Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Jun 3, 2017 |
179 |
by Phoenix-5an
»»
Aug 13, 1:47 AM |
|
Poll: » Who's best girl? ( 1 2 3 )MIUUZICK - May 13, 2017 |
121 |
by CarbonMD
»»
Jun 14, 2:45 PM |
|
Poll: » Eromanga-sensei Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jun 10, 2017 |
118 |
by CarbonMD
»»
Jun 13, 11:58 PM |
|
Poll: » Eromanga-sensei Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Stark700 - Jun 17, 2017 |
219 |
by nichtink
»»
Apr 21, 5:57 AM |