Uncanny said:johnyjohny said: It does not deserve a 10, cuz for it to be 10 it should score 10 on more things than the anime does now. It's like spitting on the anime that actually did score a 10. Also i actually do care cuz it is you guys taste what will decide which type of anime becomes available in the future. As it is now we will get even more characters and even less storytelling anime in the future with lots of overused melodrama en clishes for example. That's the pad anime is walking the past 3 years. As a fan of well told story and animation i actually do care people are satisfied so easily with anime like these.
People keep saying haters shouldn't care and just blindly accept what other people like, just becouse it is the right thing to do. But i disagree with that since I'm a anime fan too and wish for it to make masterpieces again, but that all starts with what the majority wants. If the majority want cute girls anime for example that is what they will get a bunch of becouse it will make money. I just like for people to strife for quality again.
But that's your opinion. Thankfully since many people watch anime opinions on whether something is good or not are entirely subjective. :) If anything liking Haikyuu!! would merely impact any future sports anime, not fantasy or anything like that, I think that's an opinion based on conjecture.
Personally, I think the best place to lodge complaints about the future of anime would be on run of the mill stereotypical shitty ecchi anime series discussions.
Whether someone thinks something is a masterpiece or not is something that is a matter of opinion. And honestly it's fairly childish to state that just because you think it's not worth a 10 it therefore shouldn't be considered a 10 by anyone else.
This anime has a great plot, though perhaps simplistic it achieves good story telling. There is wonderful character development. There is a back story for a number of the characters. There's a goal. The team doesn't always win, etc. formulaically speaking it's not quite a generic shounen anime like say Bleach or Naruto, simply because it has better character development and backstory. The sound production is good, the music is good. It may not be a masterpiece on the same level of say Akira, but it cannot necessarily be compared to Akira because Akira is not a sports anime. Likewise it cannot necessarily be compared to fantasy anime's because it is not fantasy, it's sports. Perhaps that's why people actually enjoy this show and you know, give it a 10, or a 9, or an 8.
To me, the ranking system is based on how much one derives enjoyment out of said anime. If I derive as much enjoyment from this as I do say from Akira, then I'm damn well going to give them similar ratings. But can it be compared to Akira, no.
Also, where are these cute girls you're speaking of? This anime doesn't have anything of the sort.
Really though all I'm hearing from you is: "I'm butthurt no one agrees with me QQQQQQQ. But in reality because no one agrees with me anime is doomed!!!!11" For someone who claims to dislike arrogant people, you're pretty arrogant yourself. You are of course welcome to your own opinion, but I think posting a negative blanket statement towards all people who enjoy this show is rather rude and pointless.
Anyway that's just my two cents. I have actual work that I need to do now so I'll just leave this as is. Have a nice night.
Subjective really is a stupid word. The word subjective makes the word discussion utterly pointless. I believe with a well carved out discussion and admitting from both parties truth can come to light. There cant be both people right, thats just all good guys talk. I think it is not worth a 10 on points like animation and the actual story telling. The characters talk way more than is needed and the anime is (like i already stated (and you ignored)) bursting with whiny melodrama. The cute girls statement was just a example btw, was not really speaking in Haikyuus case here. That last tekst I'm not even going to defend, since i already explained why that is not the case.