Fullmetal Alchemist
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- Hair joke was cut out. :( Other than that: - I am happy with Hohenheim's voice. Hohenheim' is one of my favourites so I'm glad for that. - Edward's dream was creepy. :O - More Edward with his hair down is always good. ♥ - Finding out the truth about Edward's mother was really sad. Such a heartbreaking scene. ;___; - Though Ed did channel Light quite a bit once he started laughing. - little!Alphonse eyecatch! :D - Just a note: I just realized some of the commercials for Monthly Shōnen Gangan spoil things for anime only watches. Lawl. - Edward's turn to get angry. Also, they kept the Ling and Lan Fan toss. xD - So, they finally realize the truth about the Human transmutation. And more about Al's situation. |
 ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| Starts with Ed/His-Father scene. The evening scene intact! :3 Ling!. On this week of "lets cut out the XIng character development"... Dig-up scene. Done. Brilliantly. Nothing more to say except that animation was quite...bad at times... 3/5 Edit: Damned ninjas. |
 |
Fai said: Yeah, that's going to be a problem. :|Ling!. On this week of "lets cut out the XIng character development"... |
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| lol you guys again, they cut that, they cut that.. -_- |
smokes said: I still loved the episode, they just cut one of my favourite jokes. xDlol you guys again, they cut that, they cut that.. -_- They can still add more Xing character development so it's hardly the end of the world. But while I can fangirl Ling and Lan Fan quite easily, I don't think non-manga readers can. Also, I'm finding it hard to skirt around spoilers here so I'll just stop speaking now. *flails* |
ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| No hair joke? :( But it's not the end of the world. :P Still no Xing character development, but in the next ep, will be more of Ling x Ran Fun action. Son x Father talk was good. Hohenheim is my favourite character of the series and the scenes abou the truth of Trisha's transmutation was splendid. So sad. Edward's maniac laugh was the best. The dream was so scary. What a nightmare. :P |
 |
| Yes, they did cut out a lot. They do this every time, we know that already. XP (I feel kind of sorry for the Xingese people for always being the ones cut out... o.o') Nevertheless, I think this ep was really great. I loved the skeleton-szene in the Manga and was really afraid they might mess it up, but the did a great job. At least I think so. It never fails to amaze me that Ed actually lookes like he lost his mind. His crazy laughting was creepy. Al was awesome too, I think it was pretty cool how they made him "cry". Hohenheim, I love thou. xD He's one of my favorits and I like his voice, althought I think it might be a bit deeper, but this is okay the way it is. When Winry thought Ed's back has gotten bigger, I just felt like this was wrong, because his back looked too small to me. >_> *goes rereading volume 11* His back really should have been a bit bigger. There was just one thing that kept irritating me. It does since ep 19. In the Manga, Ed starts to look older around somewhere here. Maybe it's because Arakawas style is changing, or he's just ageing, but he looks older. I think they try to do that in the Anime too, but sometimes he does look older and I have the feeling he needs a male voice actor and sometimes he looks like he does at the beginning. Maybe I'm wrong and I'm just talking crap, but it's irritating me. XP |
kennikitty said: There was just one thing that kept irritating me. It does since ep 19. In the Manga, Ed starts to look older around somewhere here. Maybe it's because Arakawas style is changing, or he's just ageing, but he looks older. I think they try to do that in the Anime too, but sometimes he does look older and I have the feeling he needs a male voice actor and sometimes he looks like he does at the beginning. Maybe I'm wrong and I'm just talking crap, but it's irritating me. XP Yes, Arakawa changes the way characters looked bit by bit, every chapter. |
|
Fai said: Yes, Arakawa changes the way characters looked bit by bit, every chapter. I absolutely love her for doing that. I remember then I was reading the Manga and suddenly realized: He's ageing, like in growing mentally and physically. And I love older!Ed... I hope they manage to get this done in the Anime, too. .__.' Like I said, in ep 20 I thought that it felt like he was jumping between being older and younger. XP |
| It was an ok episode but no really big reveals that couldn't have been plucked from past episodes. I kind of find it more interesting with Hohenheim talking as if the whole country's gonna blow up soon. Should be fun :) |
| Downloading at the speed of liiiiight. |
 |
| lol they showed Hohenheim only a few seconds and thats all lol. plus his character is annoying... =\ doesnt seem like a father lol |
| "Has he always had such a large back?" lol, he's still short : D Also, Hohenheim .. he's a pretty cool guy, and he's just as insensitive as I am xD |
| Protip: I don't really check the forums anymore, so if you want something, take it on my profile. Is it time for my long-awaited return to the forums? щ(ﾟДﾟщ) Nope™, probably not. |
 I love Lan Fan's face. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
HawthorneKitty said: I love Lan Fan's face. Yeah that was win :D Average episode. Coulda been better. 3/5 |
 |
ragnaroks said: HawthorneKitty said: I love Lan Fan's face. Yeah that was win :D Yeah it made my day : D Although Ling's face's not so bad either |
| Protip: I don't really check the forums anymore, so if you want something, take it on my profile. Is it time for my long-awaited return to the forums? щ(ﾟДﾟщ) Nope™, probably not. |
| I wish they didn't cut the Xing character development. Ling always finds a way to make me laugh. 3/5 |
 |
| wooh ... i like this episode .. i think is my favourite so far |
     |
smokes said: lol they showed Hohenheim only a few seconds and thats all lol. Yeah I thought more was going to happen with him in this episode. Although thinking about it we did get a couple major developments with his appearance that would not have happened otherwise. Ed realizes that it wasn't their mother they he and Al transmutated and we also get a warning that something really bad is going to happen in Resembool. |
   |
aaronluis26 said: smokes said: lol they showed Hohenheim only a few seconds and thats all lol. Yeah I thought more was going to happen with him in this episode. Although thinking about it we did get a couple major developments with his appearance that would not have happened otherwise. Ed realizes that it wasn't their mother they he and Al transmutated and we also get a warning that something really bad is going to happen in Resembool. Well, Hohenheim didn't really mean something's gonna happen in Resembool specifically, I got the idea that he said the whole country's gonna be in some kinda trouble. (And that's why he told Pinako to flee to another country) amirite? |
| Protip: I don't really check the forums anymore, so if you want something, take it on my profile. Is it time for my long-awaited return to the forums? щ(ﾟДﾟщ) Nope™, probably not. |
| Gah, Dl'ing right now. Can't wait. |
 |
| For me one of the best episodes so far. They did things exactly how I like ^^ No complains :D |
 |
| Good episode - I'd forgotten this part from the manga :D |
 |
| omg, i felt like the story is getting more and more ocmplicated! and i was a little worried about what hohenheim said : "something horrible will happen in this country" and blablabla, what will happen? >< |
| Oh yes the best episode so far! :D ...although it missed some things XD |
 |
| At last. Hohenheim! Good parts are approaching. I'm looking forward to Hohenheim's story (I love that part). :3 |
 |
| Great episode, haven't really read the manga so I don't know about the cut scenes. xD Glad that Alphonse sees the light and all, it was nice to see Izumi again! |
 |
| Well, this episode presents some things that i wanted to know, overall i cant wait to see how it all happens. |
 |
ntHai said: So actually they didn't revive anybody, they just created some random body? well actually this was also in the first season of the series. so nothing new here |
smokes said: ntHai said: So actually they didn't revive anybody, they just created some random body? well actually this was also in the first season of the series. so nothing new here It's very different from the first anime. The first anime had human transmutation create a human with the same appearance and memories of the person being revived. Arakawa's storyline's human transmutation=human(like) body unrelated to any existing or previously existing person is created(usually incomplete/deformed to the point of dying immediately if it could even sustain anything resembling life in the first place), no soul/memories/mind. Revival of the dead is treated as purely impossible. |
| I loved it, the storyline is fantastic, and I'm preferring this to the original :'D Would be nice to see a little bit more of the Sins sometime :] |
  |
| Interesting episode, more of a scenario development than anything. Nothing impressive visually. |
 In every age, in every place, the deeds of men remain the same. |
| wow.. this ep was loaded. |
| _____ _ _ ______ Within pain, there is desire. _____ _ _ ______ |
| What a weird episode. Hohenheim appears only to confront Ed on running away (which I loved, since it's far overdue), to say that Trish wasn't revived, and to portend impending doom. That really is quite random...and just for plot development. The stuff with Isumi, Ed, and Al discovering the meaning behind the failed transmutations was done a little too quickly for my taste. It could have felt more meaningful, but because of the pace, it was all breezed over for the lame ending with Winry talking about Ed's back; which is ironic because at the beginning of the episode I was thinking about how small Ed is when he was in that coat. An awkward episode, but Isumi hanging up the phone after calling Ed, and the lighting effect of making Al look like he was crying saved it. |
Zilpzalp said: How were the homunculi created then? how can you not know? they come right out and say homunculus are made by putting philosopher's stone in them in episode 19 |
| That's their way of indicating that Winry is starting to see Ed as a man. |
| I very much liked this episode :). So far for the past few weeks - I think I like this episode the best in terms of character development. Last week's was epic, this week's is just emotional :P. For once, there was a specific part when the background music annoyed me a lot, I think it was the bedroom scene between Winry and Al. This surprised me, since I'm not too picky about background music. I really liked the part when Ed was fervently digging for the human remains of his "mother" - you can literally see him turning mad/crazy. Various moments when I was just awed by the animation/art. Like the moment when Al "cries" - god I thought that was genius As always, can't wait until the next episode! (Shoot I just remembered I have vacation, dammit I have to wait for two weeks!! NOOOOO) |
| Emotional episode with nice character development. It had good pacing too. |
 |
| :/ They really need to stop with all the cuts and start focusing more on the Xingese characters, especially with the big things up ahead that involve them. It's really starting to annoy me. Overall nothing really stood out and the BGM where Ed/Al were talking near the stairs and Izumi was crying was way off imo. So yeah I didn't enjoy this episode...at all. |
MonochromeAug 17, 2009 3:28 PM
 |
robbydesu said: For once, there was a specific part when the background music annoyed me a lot, I think it was the bedroom scene between Winry and Al. This surprised me, since I'm not too picky about background music. The music for the last 3-4 minutes was did not fit in at all, especially with the instantly dramatic sound followed by near silence to start that whole sequence... |
| Elsewhere, a somewhat startled Warren Worthington III finds that he has accidentally wandered into an electrified east-side world of post-twist teens and watsui-ing teeny-boppers... |
| Nicely done episode. But the upcoming ones would be great :D |
robbydesu said: I very much liked this episode :). So far for the past few weeks - I think I like this episode the best in terms of character development. Last week's was epic, this week's is just emotional :P. For once, there was a specific part when the background music annoyed me a lot, I think it was the bedroom scene between Winry and Al. This surprised me, since I'm not too picky about background music. I really liked the part when Ed was fervently digging for the human remains of his "mother" - you can literally see him turning mad/crazy. Various moments when I was just awed by the animation/art. Like the moment when Al "cries" - god I thought that was genius As always, can't wait until the next episode! (Shoot I just remembered I have vacation, dammit I have to wait for two weeks!! NOOOOO) lol there is no ep next week....so your safe :) awesome ep....cant wait to see recent chapters animat |
suigetsu00Aug 17, 2009 3:32 PM
smokes said: lol they showed Hohenheim only a few seconds and thats all lol. plus his character is annoying... = doesnt seem like a father lol Yeah I agree with you on that, from the lat episode, I thought it would be rather intimate and emotional between Ed and Hohenheim. The episode was good, but it was not all that was really meant to be, introduction of Hohhenheim in the last ep should have set the pace for this ep, but I just guess it did not happen, next ep looks good! XD |
| Wait, I'm confused. What the hell did I just watch? Let me get this straight: Ed transmuted some random guy from the other side of the gate instead of his mother and didn't know until this ep. And somehow that makes things possible to get Al's body back and Izumi's son back...? I don't understand how Ed didn't know what he transmuted wasn't his mother. And then why isn't his mother in her own grave? Where is his mother? Am I supposed to know these things by the episode? If not, please don't tell me. TL;DR: I'm confused about ep 20, someone help without spoiling the series for me. |
| Wait, so if they didn't transmutate their mom, what DID they transmutate? Like, some random body without a soul? :O Hmm. Also, Ed's dig up scene was done brilliantly ;( |
     |
NoyaChan said: Wait, so if they didn't transmutate their mom, what DID they transmutate? Like, some random body without a soul? :O Hmm. Also, Ed's dig up scene was done brilliantly ;( Thats what i was wondering too. Also if what Izumi transmuted was the same thing, or maybe like something from the same family |
     |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 60 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )lafuria_sux - Jun 5, 2010 |
352 |
by kyledluffy
»»
Yesterday, 12:28 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 59 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )Ahenshihael - May 30, 2010 |
234 |
by kyledluffy
»»
Nov 21, 3:42 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 56 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )DeviantKaos - May 9, 2010 |
211 |
by kyledluffy
»»
Nov 20, 1:55 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 53 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )DeviantKaos - Apr 18, 2010 |
252 |
by kyledluffy
»»
Nov 19, 1:24 AM |
|
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 64 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ahenshihael - Jul 4, 2010 |
1009 |
by Devonnius
»»
Nov 18, 1:28 PM |