| One-shots: - Embracing The Canvas - Itoshii Yubisaki - Don't Call Me Master!, and - Kitsune no Yome were merged into the anthology: Canvas ni Kuchizuke wo The one-shot Bathed in Sunlight Filtering Through the Trees was merged into the anthology Rakuen no Jouken |
|
KinetaMay 3, 2009 10:44 PM
| Mephisto was included in the published volume of Baku. I really hate you daddy and Daddy is dog were one-shots of the anthology Papa Nanka Daikirai |
KinetaMay 13, 2009 9:25 PM
| I denied that I won't Let You Be A Star oneshot by watase Yuu, since it is included in the last volume of zettai Kareshi. I also denied a pile of Fullmetal Alchemist doujinshi submissions and a yami no matsuei doujinshi, as they are not original doujinshi created by the original mangaka Also denied the Bijo ga Yajuu submission because the title is already in the database under Beauty is the Beast |
| Like Shoujo? Visit: Emily's Random Shoujo Manga Page |
| Denied DragonBobobo as no info could be found no it. LOTS of dj denied. Please remember we only accept original dj into the DB. |
| Poking around a bit.. The submission of Kono Mahou ga Sugoi! (One Shot) (14295) was denied because the correct one volume entry already exists here. I edited the title and synonyms to reflect the exclamation point that should be included in the main title. kiss happiness kiss (14298) was denied because the oneshot is already here in the db. The three oneshots: Proof_of_Love (1425) Kiss_and_Cry (11262) Escape (13928) were compiled in: Renai Shoumei Another entry of Escape (14340) was denied because it was the same as the included oneshot in this volume. Jounetsu no Shinshoku (3505) is part of Renai Dokusenyoku Shinyuu Henjou! (14054) was denied since it's already in the database here. The title was updated to reflect the exclamation mark. Lovers Pledge (14139) was denied because it already exists here. rust buster (14292) was denied because it's known as Rust Blaster. It's also a one volume manga, not a oneshot. Iron Venus (9262) oneshot was included in Body Talk ~Junai Yuugi~. Seiritsu Shinai Asa (2898) oneshot was included in Bi no Isu. Aka no ori (14172) was denied because it's already in the db. Wisteria-Colored Sky Apartment (14174) was denied because it's already in the db. There were three submissions for the oneshot Ometura, so only one (w/the pic) was approved. Shinkuu Yuusetesu (14023) was denied because it already technically exists in the db, but had the incorrect reading. The title and synonyms were updated accordingly. The submission was also incorrect, so I included all the misspellings. It's Yuusetsu. Don't say gold (14370) was denied because it's Don't Stay Gold. I stole the larger pic though, thanks. Zettai Fukujuu (2717) was published in Kumo no Ue de Kiss wo Shiyou. The Outside Inflation (14052) was denied because another oneshot published in the same book, Nejishiki, already exists in the database. The entry was updated to reflect both. |
shinkeikakuJun 7, 2009 5:31 AM
| Pahanjip and (12289)Time_and_Again were merged together because they are the same manwha. I kept the earlier entry. And along with that: These 2 people are the same person. Originally (2087) JiUn Yun was listed as Ji Un Yoon, but I changed the spelling. Checking for matching names I came up with the 7101 entry Jiun Yun which only had one manwha, Time and Again, which is actually Pahanjip already listed as the 2087 entry. (7101) Jiun Yun merged into: JiUn Yun (2087) |
animedreamerJun 7, 2009 5:54 AM
 |
| |
| KOIBITO NO NEDAN (14254) was denied because it technically exists in the database, but was misspelled as Nendan. Spelling updated and color pic stolen. :3 A Morning That Rarely Comes (One Shot) was collected in Tsuyoku Yowaku Kitsuku. There were two submissions for Blood Rain. I approved the one that was far more complete, so please readd if needed. |
shinkeikakuJun 11, 2009 6:53 AM
|
AaranaJun 11, 2009 5:07 PM
| MP0 is the first chapter in the Snow in the Dark compilation; former page should be removed/merged. May I also request the title for deleted I.D. number 14208? If it is mentioned in here, I'm unable to spot the I.D. |
| Bakazuki, I'll tell an admin to fix it. Undying Flower (14030) was rejected; it's a oneshot in Dear Mine. |
| There were two submissions for the oneshot/pilot Miyama Uguisu Yashika Jiken. Two Code Geass doujinshi were denied. We don't accept doujin made by anyone other than the original creator. |
shinkeikakuJun 12, 2009 5:31 PM
| There were two submissions for Yandere Kanojo. One approved. Another after I posted this, so please search it. red (14134) was denied because it's already in the db. Gakuen Tokkei Dyukarion (14534) was denied because it's already here. It is CLAMP, after all. cyber friends (14153) was denied because it's the French? (not sure, but it certainly wasn't English lol) release of Cy-Believers, which is already in the database. Pickle (14209) was denied because no information was given besides a non-English summary, the shounen genre, and that it was one volume long. I can't find any manga named just "Pickle." If it's Hanma Baki 10.5 Gaiden - Pikuru (?!), please submit the entry with more information filled out (in English) please. |
shinkeikakuJun 14, 2009 3:46 PM
| Duplicates in the Queue that have been deleted: Akurei Tsukai (14543) Tsugumomo (14506) Hakkeyoi (14575) BEAUTY RESEARCH CLUB (14639) Kiben Gakuha, Yotsuya-sensei no Kaiden (14538) Oh! My Dog (14652) Under the Cherry Trees (14542) Storm (14596) and STORM (14607) Umi No Chikyuugi Nocturne (14786) Other: Akatsukiss (14277) -Doujin. Denied |
AaranaJun 29, 2009 5:12 PM
| Demon Diary (14566) was a duplicate of this entry. A Togainu no Chi doujinshi was denied. Ingenuo (14589) was a duplicate of this. Le Roi des Ronces (14164) was denied because it's the French publication of King of Thorn. I denied another submission of Imadoki! too. Serenade (14210) was denied because it was published in volume 2 of Scandalous Seiryo University. Loveless (14600) was denied because it's uhh... Loveless. Sekirei -Engagement- (3907) was deleted because it was an artbook/visual guide. We don't catalog either. |
shinkeikakuJun 20, 2009 7:48 AM
| Hodokeru Shinon (14662) was denied because it was published in Namida mo Tooku -Aonibi no Nemuri-. Tokimeku Oujisama (14673) was denied because it's in the same book. Both synonyms are there, so please remember we don't accept individual entries of oneshots published in books. Akagame no Shirayukihime (14688) is actually AkagaMI no Shirayuki Hime. There were 3 submissions of Super Dreadnought Girl 4946. The one with the most information was approved, so please readd if needed. Yondaime Gaiden was denied. The description said it all--"fan made manga." Sleeping Beauty wa nemurenai (14284) was published in Hoshiiro no Okurimono. I also denied a duplicate entry of X/1999? (by CLAMP.. it's there). Shadow (14273) was denied because it was published in Renai Junkie. SILVER STREET ROMANTIC (14529) was published in REC. Koukou Debut (14713) is a dupe of Koukou Debut. I Won't Let You Become a Star! (14724) was published at the end of Zettai Kareshi. Shining Star (14053) was published in Shoten 5. |
shinkeikakuJun 28, 2009 8:24 PM
| Warau Kanoko-sama (14798) was denied because it's already in the database. It was under a very weird and wrong name, so synonyms were juggled. The One (14778) was a dupe of this. My most beloved one is still you (14754) was published in Usotsuki. The short story titles were added as synonyms so it will show up in search results. |
shinkeikakuJun 30, 2009 11:37 AM
| Denied - Magi (14684) as it was the same as Magi (14790). Denied - Mitsu Aji Burrado (14784) already in database as Mitsu Aji Blood (11553). Denied - The Secret Recipe (14783) part of the anthology Bud (13137) in the database. Denied - Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Ginji's Rescue Team (14768) already in the database as Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Ginji's Rescue Team (1693). Denied - Kusame and Komaki and the Key of Love (14714) already in the database as Kusame and Komaki and the Key of Love (14785). Denied - Northmen (14801) part of the anthology Yojouhan Sweet Home (2407). |
BrandJul 1, 2009 10:11 AM
| An Angel through a Lens (14645) was denied because I couldn't find any info (even on the supposed scanner webpage) and the entry was too bare-boned itself to help. Please resubmit with enough information so we can confirm it, such as a picture that is appropriately censored. T-MOON Complex X (14571) was denied. It appears to be an unofficial dj by the Crazy Clover Club circle. |
shinkeikakuJul 1, 2009 4:47 PM
| Denied - Halfway (14808) same as HALFWAY (14806) |
| Denied Silver Diamond (14809). It's here. Denied Lair Game (14822). It's Liar Game. Girl got game (14832) is in the database, aka Power!!. Tsuki to Himawari (14839) was published in Faster than a Kiss. Berserk (14862) was denied. It was the second manga added to MAL's database. |
shinkeikakuJul 5, 2009 2:11 PM
| Denied - Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings And The Lost Ocean (14866) same as Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings And The Lost Ocean (14865) Denied - Tonari no Minano Sensei (14854) same as Tonari no Minano Sensei (14853) Denied - Good Luck, Nina! (14851) same as Nina Jalhae (4211) Denied - Boku Wa Kissu De Uso Wo Tsuku (14845) same as Boku wa Kisu de Uso wo Tsuku (8340) Denied - Viox (14190) could not find any information for this title. Please resubmit with more information. Denied - Dear School Gang Leader (14873) same as Ah! Itoshi no Banchousama (4471). |
BrandJul 6, 2009 7:48 AM
| Invisible World (14879) is actually Land of the Blindfolded. |
| Denied - Umineko no Naku Koro ni (14880) looked it up on wikipedia and it seems there are only two manga for this series currently both of which are in the database currently; Umineko no Naku Koro ni - Episode 1: Legend of the Golden Witch (3749) and Umineko no Naku Koro ni - Episode 2: Turn of the Golden Witch (9547). Denied - Haru wa Sakura (14881) this one shot is in WANTED (1191). Denied - Tsubasa: Reservoir Chronicles (14891) already in the database as Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE (9). Denied - Sheherezade (14890) part of this anthology Sheet no Sukima (7465). Denied - Naniwa Tiger: Hajime no Ippo Gaiden (14888) appears to be in the collected volumes of Hajime no Ippo (7). |
BrandJul 8, 2009 5:08 AM
| Two duplicates of Kanga na Spoon were denied. |
| Denied - ITAZURA OUJI (14903) contained in Gokujou Twins (14690) Denied - Ikenai Candy Love (14900) contained in Koi wa Tenka no Mawarimono (14882) |
| Denied Tonari no Heya no Paronoia (14907). It's not a doujinshi, but a full manga volume. I saw no indication that the mangaka has published a doujinshi related to this story either. Urimasu! (14908) is in Thunderbolt Boys Excite. Denied a Togainu no Chi doujinshi. |
shinkeikakuJul 9, 2009 9:06 PM
| Denied - Ichiban Ushiro No Daimaou (?) same as Ichiban Ushiro No Daimaou (14923) Denied - Shitsurakuen (14919) same as Shitsurakuen (14922) Denied - Special A (14924) same as Special A (1271) |
| Please remove/merge: http://myanimelist.net/manga/14910/Gantz:_Minus With the prequel one. |
| No less than 11 versions of L∞P were denied. We got a ton of submissions for that one. ^_^; Limlim Kiss (14955) was denied; it's Lilim Kiss. |
| I got more for Loop also... Denied - Fool on the Rock (14928) same as Fool on the Rock (14929) Denied - Meimu (14935) same as Meimu (14938) Denied - L∞P (14969) & L∞P (14976) same as L∞p (14943) Denied - My Boyfriend, The Rabbit (14905) same as My Boyfriend, The Rabbit (2843) |
BrandJul 15, 2009 4:22 PM
| Denied Darika (14977). It's published in Utahime. Denied a Fate/hollow ataraxia dj. Denied Struwwelpeter: Die Rückkehr (14980). This is an English site and no information was given (at all), let alone enough to point to the Japanese release/title. Denied Tell Me the Real Meaning of That Kiss (14937). It was published in Toraware no Minoue. Denied Fushidarana Karada (14983). There was another submission and the picture of the first was questionable. Denied Gkko Ja Iya (14927). It's in Honey na Koto, as stated in the description. We don't give collected oneshots separate entries. Denied Rave (15000). It's already in the database as Groove Adventure Rave. Denied Teasing Minuet (14995). The pic submitted with it was utterly inappropriate. Please review our image policy, which includes no nudity and certainly no graphic sex. |
shinkeikakuJul 14, 2009 11:33 AM
| Denied - Warriors: The Lost Warrior, Warrior's Refuge, Warrior's Return (14974) same as Warriors (3851) Denied - Akuma no eros (15005) same as Akuma na Eros (677) Denied - Ode to Kirihito (15008) same as Ode to Kirihito (1344) <---Srly?! This was one of the first titles I added to the database when I joined like two years ago. Denied - Railroad (15014) same as Railroad (15012) Denied - EAT-MAN (15015) same as Eat-Man (1800) |
| Denied Boy's Next Door (15029). It's already in the database. Denied 3 extra entries of Kagijin, likely made by the same person? Quality, not quantity. Related--denied a bunch of edits trying to turn the oneshot entry into this new serialization as well. |
shinkeikakuJul 18, 2009 7:23 PM
| Four - Seasons of August -- denied as it was included in volume 1 of Akagami no Shirayuki Hime. Bind Us -- merged with Akagami no Shirayuki Hime as it was included in volume 2. White and Black -- denied as it's already in the DB under White & Black. Marrieds -- merged with Rumic World as it was included in volume 3. Sukima-shiki -- denied as it's already listed here. Noël la neige -- denied as it's already listed here. Bitou na Koi -- denied as it's already listed in the anthology Kataomoi no Mukougawa |
KinetaJul 22, 2009 1:49 PM
| Denied Kingdom Hearts 358/2 Days (15100) in favor of the more complete duplicate (15104) entry. Denied a couple of Baby It's You submissions. The oneshot is published in this volume. There were multiple submissions of Undertrain. There were multiple submissions of Ageha wo Ou Monotachi. Denied Cantidate for Goddess (15075). It's Candidate for Goddess. Denied a Sailormoon dj. Denied a FMA dj. Denied a Naruto dj. Denied Neon Genesis Evangelion Re-take (15120). Unofficial dj. Denied Touhou dj - Unseasonable Summer Song (15125). Unofficial dj. We only accept stuff ZUN was involved in creating. Merged Leave Me Alone With First Love (5740) oneshot with Love Drug. |
shinkeikakuJul 24, 2009 3:04 PM
| Denied 3 submissions of Zettai Fukujuu. The oneshot was published in Kumo no Ue de Kiss wo Shiyou. Denied a number of works already in the database. They are searchable: Kimi ni Todoke Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei Toshishita no Ryuugi CLAMP School Paranormal Investigators (we don't do separate entries for extras) |
shinkeikakuJul 26, 2009 6:55 AM
| Denied Dojins: Harry Potter dj - Jupiter (15151) Harry Potter dj - Cry For The Moon (15161) |
| Denied more duplicates of existing database entries: Kimi NI Todoke (Two of these now. It's "ni" not "no") Venus Versus Virus Groove Adventure Rave Terepari Kiss Captive Heart Denied another Harry Potter dj. Denied My girl seinen (15194). It's known as My Girl. Seinen is the demographic. Removed Sakkabasu no Yoru (1127). Unofficial Darkstalkers doujinshi. Related--Denied a submission of it: Night of the Succubus (15204) Denied a Lamento dj. Removed a number of Togainu no Chi and Lamento doujinshi. Denied Platinum (15211), Platinum (15213), Ichigo Namida (15214). All were published in Nine Puzzle. Denied Re-Take (15229). It's the (in)famous unofficial Eva dj. All in Russian (?!) too. |
shinkeikakuJul 31, 2009 4:18 PM
| Denied My 1/3 Boyfriend (15126), it's part of this collection. |
| Denied Dragon Ball Z (15261). The manga is known as Dragon Ball. Denied Torikagoshou no Kyou mo Nemutai Juunintachi (15265). It's already in the db. Denied ogawa to yukai na saitoutachi (15264). It's here. Denied milky way (15281). It's here. The submitted ANN description is off anyway. |
shinkeikakuAug 3, 2009 2:31 PM
| There's been a trend of double submissions for entries, particularly hentai. They look exactly the same, one directly after the other, and they're likely being added by the same person. Both will be denied if this continues, as some already were. Please don't clog the queue with double submissions. |
| Denied several submissions of Gankutsuou and D.Gray Man doujinshi. I Won't Let You Become a Star! (15397) is included in Zettai Kareshi. |
| Denied Mamiya Seitai Ningyouten (15384). It's here. Denied Sakkabasu no Yoru (15371). It's that unofficial Darkstalkers doujinshi again. Very Black White Day (7469) was merged with Otokomae! Beads Club (3493). Ten ni Todoku Shiro (11818) was merged with Osoba de Misasete! (15375). Milk Chocolate No Aji (3684) was merged with Kodomo no Shippo (15334). Denied Shut Hell (15483) and Shuto Heru (15431). It's already in the db. Please readd if needed. Yet another denial of NIGHT OF THE SUCCUBUS (15493). It's a Darkstalkers doujinshi and will not be approved. |
shinkeikakuAug 13, 2009 11:19 AM
| Denied: Kill Me, Kiss Me (15501) is here. Kusame and Komaki and the Key of Love (15506) is part of Shinshi Doumei Cross. iron vinus (15121) and Iron Venus (15267) are the same thing and part of Body Talk, so both were denied. Ouji-sama ni Narenai (15158) is part of this collection. Shin Angel (15191) seems to be an alternate name for Angel. I can find no indication that it exists as a separate series. How to Save the World! (15212) is part of Momo. |
AnomalousAug 15, 2009 10:21 AM
| Denied I'm at End of Your Sight (15494). It's here. Denied Kodoku Sensou (15238). The only info given was a title, which couldn't point to a known published work. Can be resubmited with more info. |
shinkeikakuAug 14, 2009 4:05 PM
More topics from this board
Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Modifications/Duplicates Here ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Aarana - Jan 4, 2009 |
7917 |
by Barbaduk
»»
10 hours ago |
|
» Her Summon/Geunyeoui Sohwansurrnzz - Nov 8, 2023 |
9 |
by Barbaduk
»»
Yesterday, 10:51 AM |
|
Sticky: » Manga DB - Post Genre/Theme Requests Here ( 1 2 3 4 )Kineta - Mar 28, 2022 |
176 |
by Loudcsharp
»»
Nov 29, 11:51 PM |
|
» How to add new digital publishers to the whitelist?Sollertia_ - Aug 16, 2023 |
8 |
by Amonimus
»»
Nov 28, 10:57 PM |
|
» I think the rules need an update, gatekeeping is dumbKingNoahTheThird - Sep 11 |
6 |
by Amonimus
»»
Nov 28, 10:51 PM |