New
Feb 11, 2015 11:01 PM
#2151
LucianRoy said: Brynhildr said: coromandel said: The_Pyromaani said: Loudmouth was visited by Llafos So Llafos (Cop) investigated Palm. That wouldn't have helped us anyway. Actually it means that we have to look at people Llafos would have a huge reason to suspect. I don't know him, but if I was the cop, first targets would be players I know somewhat - and I judge a big threat if they are on the opposite faction. So just come to think of it, it means +1 probs townie. Nonononononono... That's a role we actually don't want to out. It's more dangerous for mafia than it is for us. Eh? O_o All I am saying is - for whoever knows a bit Llafos, he/she has a list of more possible townies. But it's also a double edged sword if you think of it: if it's a mafia who knows Llafos better than us - it means they can use that info against us. So which option is better in your opinion. Trying to figure it out here, where anyone can make observation or being deceived in the shadows? |
Feb 11, 2015 11:02 PM
#2152
Brynhildr said: LucianRoy said: Brynhildr said: coromandel said: The_Pyromaani said: Loudmouth was visited by Llafos So Llafos (Cop) investigated Palm. That wouldn't have helped us anyway. Actually it means that we have to look at people Llafos would have a huge reason to suspect. I don't know him, but if I was the cop, first targets would be players I know somewhat - and I judge a big threat if they are on the opposite faction. So just come to think of it, it means +1 probs townie. Nonononononono... That's a role we actually don't want to out. It's more dangerous for mafia than it is for us. Eh? O_o All I am saying is - for whoever knows a bit Llafos, he/she has a list of more possible townies. But it's also a double edged sword if you think of it: if it's a mafia who knows Llafos better than us - it means they can use that info against us. So which option is better in your opinion. Trying to figure it out here, where anyone can make observation or being deceived in the shadows? I think Himikoi knows Llafos pretty well. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:02 PM
#2153
Juzzywuzzy said: LucianRoy said: Matoro_Mahri said: LucianRoy said: Juzzywuzzy said: I, for one, thinks grave is town. But she's constantly battering and it doesn't make sense. Wai? On what basis? More evidence to support my claim that Juzzywuzzy and grave are on the same team. Yeah, Juzzy is the only on who's done ample amounts of buddying in both day phases. Right now, I can't tell if he's after something, or just a friendly person. Conflictions. I'm not after anything. As far as grave is concerned, I just liked her grave insights and would very much like to see her play more and be less suspected people. But as I have said, she keeps on battering and baiting and it's actually making me feel suspicious towards her. Lol |
Feb 11, 2015 11:05 PM
#2154
My nap turned into a full 7 hours of sleep. Will catch up soon, but for the time being I got anime to watch. Hei Hei |
Feb 11, 2015 11:05 PM
#2155
Matoro_Mahri said: Brynhildr said: x_at_home said: sasayamei said: x_at_home said: I think Saya is online, too or is she? Yep, I am :3 Hey there^^ Although the mentor seems to have unlimited conversion charges if I read the OP right. No need to conserve anything. Eh? O_o If I analised it correctly the mentor will have the possibility to convert someone else only if his mentee dies. If the servant dies, you can convert another player next night Well yeah but he has to convert the first one. He doesn't start out with a servant. Read the bold part. I interpreted it as: *The mentor can convert someone every night = unlimited charges* - which honestly would be too much op. :/ |
Feb 11, 2015 11:06 PM
#2156
-MidnightOwl- said: Matoro_Mahri said: -MidnightOwl- said: If I told you guys that I was the Cop, I investigated Brynhildr, and got scum as a result, would you believe me? Food for thought. I'm going to bed too. I can hear the roosters singing. So uh...are you talking now? The cop is dead, in case you haven't noticed. If you're talking earlier, I wouldn't be terribly surprised. There really wasn't a significant reason to bet on him being town. That Cop is fake. I have a secret ability where I can take a dead person and make him look like a Cop. Remember when I said that I bought a disguise last night? I went to Party City and bought a cop outfit for the fake Cop. What? Unless I'm absolutely glossing over something there's neither an ability nor an item that allows you to do this... |
Feb 11, 2015 11:10 PM
#2157
-MidnightOwl- said: Lambtron said: -MidnightOwl- said: Lambtron said: Why so silent when I'm here :'< Just wondering koz I can, Hazy, why target me of all people for night 1 ^^? What do you mean target? I'm sure you know what I mean I don't. If you're talking about abilities then I didn't target you. If you're talking about something else then I don't know what you're talking about. Implying you have an ability to display at night, Panda? |
Feb 11, 2015 11:18 PM
#2158
Feb 11, 2015 11:19 PM
#2159
Can't we all just agree to stop beating around the bush? If you have something obvious to say, don't use some obsolete references or superficial wisecracks to say it. Or if you can't stop your huge egos, at least, explain the obvious when asked. Meta-proving that you're somehow intellectually superior doesn't help town in any way, and no one provided helpful town information in the last three pages. -.- |
Sometimes, I face up before I sneeze and let spit shower my face. Just me things. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:20 PM
#2160
Matoro_Mahri said: -MidnightOwl- said: Matoro_Mahri said: -MidnightOwl- said: If I told you guys that I was the Cop, I investigated Brynhildr, and got scum as a result, would you believe me? Food for thought. I'm going to bed too. I can hear the roosters singing. So uh...are you talking now? The cop is dead, in case you haven't noticed. If you're talking earlier, I wouldn't be terribly surprised. There really wasn't a significant reason to bet on him being town. That Cop is fake. I have a secret ability where I can take a dead person and make him look like a Cop. Remember when I said that I bought a disguise last night? I went to Party City and bought a cop outfit for the fake Cop. What? Unless I'm absolutely glossing over something there's neither an ability nor an item that allows you to do this... Troll -_-''' |
Feb 11, 2015 11:22 PM
#2161
Brynhildr said: -MidnightOwl- said: I'm voting for Haine. I feel like either Soren or Haine has to be scum, or both for the ultimate plot twist. Lynch: Haine- Matoro_Mahri said: @Soren333: My conclusions have changed slightly since then but they are mostly the same. I can say with very strong conviction that -MidnightOwl- is the Jester. It's quite obvious he's trying to get himself attacked it some way, either during the day or at night. The second possibility means he could be one of the few roles that gains something instead of dying by being attacked at night, but I didn't see any at a quick glance. So the clearest possibility is the Jester. It's important to look at -MidnightOwl- compared to s3bEg. They both have highly antagonistic playstyles, almost inviting themselves to get hurt. However, -MidnightOwl-'s is focused on flinging around wild analyses, and generally sowing confusion. In fact, not only is he one of the few who have actively claimed something (the other being DoubleC who claimed mafia) but he has claimed two contradictory roles (Brother in Arms and Doctor). He himself acknowledged this, meaning it wasn't a slip-up. s3bEg on the other hand seems to play the same, but in my opinion actually doesn't. I haven't played with him before so I can't say whether it's a personality or a purposeful thing but he seems to be focusing on holding a façade while still slipping out analyses every so often. It's up to the rest of the players what to make of this but for me, I'm getting the strongest town readings from him. My second conclusion is that grave_robber and JuzzyWuzzy are from the same faction, regardless of what that might be. If they are hunters, they are most likely Knuckle & Shoot. When JuzzyWuzzy is around, their posts seem to synergize in a weird way. Their responses to this might shed a little light on the subject. Lastly my two less-founded suspicious are on Haine and you. You two have just had the most mafia-esque posts out of everybody. Meaning I'd join a lynch train against you, but I wouldn't start one. I wish I had time to comb through 90+ pages and quote evidence, but I have a calculus test tomorrow. So I'll just post an updated questionnaire. Dead players have been colored their faction. Try to read what they said and see if you can draw any conclusions. What is your approach to this game? Will you lurk or contribute when you can? -Blonde-: Contribute, Lurking isn't pro-town, we should we pushing to get as much information out of everyone as we can. LucianRoy: I'll scumhunt till' I'm dead. I'm the only confirmed town player in this game. x_at_home: Well. I will contribute, but also lurk at times. I will be busy at times, so my presence will be inconsistent. I'm also pretty excited about this game, so who knows where I will end up. DoubleC: I'm usually fairly active. I've taken a liking to the idea of staying somewhat reserved for the first 2 days or so as to not draw attention from the mafia. Haine-: Contribute when I can but the problem I'm not as experienced as others in reading posts now. SodaWithYoda: I will contribute when i can, I am on here for like 16 hours a day... Consider it suspicious if i am not online for at least 12 hours Llafos: First time as town. lol? Soren333: I point things out when I notice them and try to generate discussion. grave_robber: My approach will be my usual one, being proactive which means I will contribute as much as I can and I will engage and question others during the course of the game. For example: Soren, you should answer your own questions and thanks for posting them ^^ s3bEg: I will approach it with elephant tranquilizers and a net. coromandel: First day is usually where I’m least active, because I never really know what to talk about.. but I’ll try to contribute as much as possible. In general, I like to observe and start posting when I’ve found something worth mentioning (a bad habit – sometimes I keep things to myself for too long). Lambtron: The same as usual ^^, fuhk around for the first day, potentially 2. ( depending on wasted pressure and role ). Contribution will be when I'm around though this is in most cases not the best time compared to the mass of players and I avoid what I need to say if it's been done by that point in time. Suzune-chan: I enjoy playing with everyone here. While I am certain almost everyone here knows, I will say again. I do work during the day and that cuts into the time that I can play. I believe the roleover is while I am at work so if everyone decides that an end vote is on the table, I will not be of much help. However, I am on the same hours everyday~ Matoro_Mahri: I will contribute as often as classes allow, which will apparently be not often. NessieFynn: I'm going to contribute as much as I can, 'cause if I'm town I ought to help out my side, and if I'm a maf everyone will get suspicious of me. I'll just point out whoever's acting sneaky, and try to convince everyone if I think I've found scum. ChaosSavior: i would love to contribute but often time i come out it's already empty. i will try to help here and there though Verumir: I don’t want to be sleep deprived, and I have a lot of things to do, but I’ll not lurk, and try to contribute when I can. SuzakuTsubasa: I usually don't talk when I don't have anything to say. shap111: I have uni at noon, so ill be active in the mornings/nights Shadowsnake777: Hmm I have school and it's the start of the week so I would mostly be lurking but I would contribute as much as I can. (I'll contribute on weekends though haha) Asunyan: asu will contribute wen asu can Smurphinator: I'm always a bit of a mix of lurking and being extremely active depending on the timing. I think my biggest problem will be that I'm going to miss a few days, and catching up is going to be a bit of a challenge. Juzzywuzzy: I'm playing it smooth. I'll lurk smooth and contribute smooth. turtlebandit: Can't I do both? MrHawkeye: My strategy involves lone wolf type play, it's suspicious and that is unavoidable however it lets me have freedom if I am either mafia or townie. Am suspected of being neither nyancat2506: I will try to contribute as much as i do to lurking How do you feel about inactive players? -Blonde-: Don't like inactive players because of the same reason as above. LucianRoy: The mod will deal with them. Specifically in the means of replacements. Other than that, we don't have much to worry about inactives. x_at_home: Should be replaced. There are some promising players that deserve to play DoubleC: Depends which faction I am. Haine-: They might lurkers or trying to hide their presence sometimes SodaWithYoda: I think replacing them is best because I like when everyone in the game is active makes it a lot more fun Llafos: Really? I guess I like them to be different. Soren333: Tricky if they don't get replaced. You can't read them at all and become a gamble if you choose to lynch them. grave_robber: They hurt the town/hunters. Bad guys can easily lurk and hide amongst inactives. Players who pretend to be inactive put themselves at a risk since townies can't read them and will most likely suspect them at one point or another. s3bEg: They are better than outactive players at the very least. coromandel: I don’t think it’s too much of a big deal on the first day, but it gets frustrating when they never post. Pressure-voting is a good strategy to get them to talk. Lambtron: Meh 50/50, it doesn't help nor ruin chances on the more experianced players and I'm not too concerned about the others that are just slack or bad at what they do ^^ Suzune-chan: Personally, I do not like them because they do not help the game. Then the town worthlessly lynches each other. By doing that we are killing the team rather then rooting out mafia members. Matoro_Mahri: They shouldn't have signed up in the first place. Replace 'em if it's easy, kill 'em if it's not. NessieFynn: They should get their butts onto the thread and play some more! Its boring if no one talks. ChaosSavior: they should contribute even if it's only small. Verumir: Mod kill or replacement, they add nothing to the game, if they are mafia, then it’s a cheap trick to stay alive for the first phases. SuzakuTsubasa: Why going in a game [sic] when you don't want to play? shap111: with inactives you mean lurkers? if yes, mafias. if not, then they should be kicked Shadowsnake777: Hmm well we've gotta think about timezones and school/work + IRL thingamabobs but if they do it without warning for ages I say replace em with someone else ^ ^ Asunyan: asu dislikes inactive players Smurphinator: Sometimes it can't be helped, sometimes is can. I just don't waste my time with inactives, since there's never enough information to make any solid decisions regarding them unless it's really late in the game. Juzzywuzzy: Inactivity is smooth. Mafia smooth. turtlebandit: Apathic [sic] MrHawkeye: If there is no one to lynch, I would go for one of the inactives, this of course does not excerpt me from getting lynched as well since I am usually pretty inactive nyancat2506: some cant help it if theyre are inactive, but as per say, if they are super busy, and really cant attend any of the discussion, i believe the player should inform it to the host because oh well, as the player is inactive, it will be hard to mark a suspect on those people and we might ended up killing a hunters If you are mafia, who would you kill tonight? -Blonde-: Ok, I would go for a big threat, like you or Grave. LucianRoy: Hehe, you. x_at_home: Dunno. For me Night 1 is like a Random Killing stage, lol. Except if you already have a plan or found some dangerous roles. There are players I wouldn't kill though DoubleC: Bryn, grave, suzu are my top choices. Attempting to kill Lucian would be a risk. Haine-: Hmmm First person who posted in this thread [I'm always sure those who post first are townie....Mafia always have the longest time to read ....to discover their fellow members lawl] SodaWithYoda: Either soren or Blonde Llafos: A player I think is strong. Soren333: Depends how I feel like playing. The rational thing to do is to target two specific type of players. 1. Experience/analytical players 2. Those that are active The first choice is an obvious thing to do and will become a pain later on if you don't get rid of them sooner. The second choice is to eliminate active players, so that most that are left are players that don't post much. If players don't post much then they don't really suspect people and/or contribute to scumhunting. However, I may feel like having a fun game and want to keep players that I enjoy playing with (whom are usually the experienced players) alive. And so I might kill some oddballs. As to who I would kill in this game. It's a big pool of players so hard to tell at this point. However, if I was mafia I would probably go for one of those that post quite a lot which does not include one of the experienced players because I would like to have an interesting game. And I like reading experienced players' posts. grave_robber: The players who are either an immediate threat or the ones who tend to lead and get the town to think. On night 1 my primary targets would be: Verumir, coromandel, Llafos(mvp of v1), Brynhildr, x_at_home. I would try to keep the most powerful ones alive so I can frame them, mainly: Soren333 (say he's scummy for posting these questions and posing as town), LucianRoy(say he was converted), Jackrito(I'll keep him alive till day 3, that will get him lynched), Suzune-chan(say that Jack & Lucian are being framed by a master mindl)& sasayamei(same way as suzune-chan). s3bEg: The moderator. coromandel: Depends on how this day develops. I’d probably not target the experienced, active players, because there’s a higher chance that someone protects them. So, I’d probably try to kill an inexperienced lurker, who didn’t attract too much attention during the day. Lambtron: Tonight more specifically I don't have anyone in particular to kill though I usually wouldn't opt for any high tier targets for the first couple of days. Though in this bigger game I'd probably hit one early ( day 2 ) and then leave them be till half way or so again ^^ Chances are I'd let one of the less experienced players make the call so as to throw people off a little, or just hit in-actives. Suzune-chan: [no answer] Matoro_Mahri: Someone inactive. NessieFynn: Shrug, maybe Soren? He seems like a fine target. ChaosSavior: i'll kill someone that are [sic] way too active Verumir: I can’t be “the mafia”, since there is a team to discuss, I would however suggest the first kill to be a RNG, it would stir the guilty for everyone, plus people tend to overthink players death so something good might come out of it. SuzakuTsubasa: I wouldn't say it. shap111: some random probably Shadowsnake777: Hmm dunno, most of the people here I haven't really played against but I would have to say Bryn for 2 reasons. Game V10 and battleship -_- Asunyan: asu has no ideas this game is very large and has many peeps asu has nvr played w/befores so asu cant tell whose dangerous and whose not Smurphinator: Not sure in all honesty. This game has two mafia factions, so I probably wouldn't even be sure if I was killing a townie night one. Not going to lie, it's probably advantageous from a mafia standpoint to hold off on killing leaders like Soren in case their leadership works in your favor. So to sum up, I guess I'd kill someone with a medium activity and who is kind of a sheep. Juzzywuzzy: Won't tell. It won't be smooth if I do. turtlebandit: This is a dangerous question. MrHawkeye: The usual suspects: Grave, suzu, soren nyancat2506: urm well let see, i really have no damn idea, maybe those who gang up upon razor? as a beginning i mean. ok now i have no idea How often do you expect to be on and posting? -Blonde-: Maybe 3-4 hours a day, I'm busy with school and I do a lot of sport [sic]. LucianRoy: I'm kind of busy today, but I should definitely stop by on roughly every hour mark. x_at_home: See Answer 1 DoubleC: Most of the day and whenever I'm on I'll try my best to post and keep up with the general direction of the discussion. Haine-: When I comeback from school and daily I'm taking hiatus from everything to play hxh xD SodaWithYoda: Pretty often, though i do have school work and other things to be doing sometimes (Like training) Llafos: When I am not asleep or got things I have to do. Soren333: I check MAL quite often and so I will probably post whenever I'm online. grave_robber: As often as possible, assuming it doesn't conflict with my other club duties, real life work. s3bEg: Seasonal. coromandel: I’m usually online every 3 hours or so. Problem is that I’m from a different time zone than most of you (GMT+1), so I’m always online when no one else is. I’m a fairly active player (just not on day 1 ^^’). Lambtron: Some-what often, once again this will be thrown off due to time zones and how long the people doing my work prior to me being available lasts. Suzune-chan: I believe that I covered this in my first question. I guess, I am on the same hours everyday. So I will be as active as I can during those times. My hours usually expand during a game that I enjoy playing. Matoro_Mahri: As I said before, this thread is apparently flying by at mach speed, so comparatively not often. NessieFynn: Only after 4-5 o' clock where I live. I'll be on pretty often after that, but I'll most likely be absent all morning. ChaosSavior: i'm expecting to be as active as possible Verumir: Not much, and I won’t be able to be online during phase changes which is a bummer. SuzakuTsubasa: I should be here on evening/night (earlier than today, it's really late here) shap111: check question 1 Shadowsnake777: Well as I said I got school so every now and then after school (year 11 so lots of work) and definitely weekends Asunyan: asu will be posting every day phase asu will be on less often on days taht asu has homeworks tho asu will nvr ignore this games Smurphinator: Mostly at night in my time zone. I'm going to be missing a bit though, so I apologize in advance for my absence from Thursday to Saturday. Juzzywuzzy: I'm smoothly in a different timezone. It's a little bit smoothly difficult to answer that question. turtlebandit: Pretty often MrHawkeye: No idea to be honest, exam tryouts have been eating my life this week, so there is that. nyancat2506: wow, erm this one, well technically, i wake up at noon, i need to fetch my siblings from school, send them to tuition, and fetch them back again, and playing video games and probably only will online at nights or midnights time, i mean according to the time of my place, in which i live in southeast asia.. How much experience do you have playing as a mafia role? Have you won any games where you was a mafia? -Blonde-: I'm a terrible mafia player, never won playing as mafia and usually die after the first couple days. LucianRoy: I cam [sic] close to winning as scum, once. But the best laid plans of mice and men are laid waste. x_at_home: I think the only one I won was with you. I'm sadly or gladly not often mafia. DoubleC: 7 or 8 times. I've won 3 at the most. Haine-: Yups, I did won before with mafia role....but that was back in summer ._. zero experience at the moment SodaWithYoda: I don't think i have ever won as a mafia role and i don't really like being a mafia, I always die in the first few days when i am a mafia unless i kill other mafia to gets creds Llafos: Played it once, lost because one bad choice from me. (My first game) Soren333: I don't get mafia much. I think I've played as mafia like 3-6 games? Probably won like a bit over half of them. grave_robber: About 30% of my experience has been as mafia, I've won twice as mafia. s3bEg: I am literally Al Capone. coromandel: I’ve been a villain about 5-7 times so far, and I’ve never won. Lambtron: A bit, though some patterns aren't quite on my side in these cases ^^ Usually find myself dead or at least a couple other scum going down very early in these games and having to play it on the back foot straight off the bat, though this is usually the more entertaining way to have it. A couple or so, but not in this club so much. *I also seem to meet Jack every time I'm scum or a role that is paired in some way ( lovers or a modification of ). Suzune-chan: Um, I have played a few. I would be lying if I said I was a good mafia and I do not think I have ever won as a mafia... Matoro_Mahri: Have played as mafia before. Was pretty close, but I don't have that much experience. NessieFynn: Not a lot. I've played mafia before, but never in a game formatted like this, and not for a long while. ChaosSavior: i have played two times as a mafia and i never won any of it Verumir: I was converted once, but even then I was playing truly as a third party, so I would say none. SuzakuTsubasa: Only been mafia once. And I lost. shap111: dunno to be honest since i never played as a mafia before, someone random maybe? Shadowsnake777: Well I have been mafia twice. 1st one I was first to get lynched and second won we technically won but lost at the same time. We killed all townies but there was a traitor sothey killed all of us (I think it was Haine :/) Asunyan: asu was mafia for asus first two games and has been mafia a few times since then asu has won as mafia Smurphinator: I'm pretty evenly split. I tend to last longer as mafia, people are always suspicious of me for no reason when I'm a townie and lynch me... I will never understand. Juzzywuzzy: I've smoothly played mafia on camps before. I have a positive record IRL. -1 on MAL forums. smooth turtlebandit: Roughtly zero MrHawkeye: I am mafia 80% time, RNGesus hates me or loves me depending on who you're asking, have won 2 games as mafia. nyancat2506: well the last i play a mafia game is practically before i start my degree which is on september 2014, as a mafia? yup ive been like maybe twice or thrice nad i never get a decent role, i played as a janitor .. thats as far as i can remember. yup i won a game where i was a mafia but i was dead.. so someone else won it for us What are your thoughts on mass claiming? [i]-Blonde-: Mass claiming? Is that where lots of people claim? Don't like it, it's not really advantageous, it gives the mafia an opportunity to take their pick of the roles. LucianRoy: Hell no. x_at_home: If too early, ruins the fun, late game often a necessity and perfectly fine. In a game like this, it should also be fun. DoubleC: I see it as a decent last ditch strategy. Or if the townie has a huge lead on the mafia and it's an almost guaranteed win then mass claiming is the safest route to go. Haine-: Google chrome crash SodaWithYoda: When there are only a few people left like final 8 or something. Also depends on how many mafias died Llafos: It changes the entire dynamic of a game. I don't see it as bad or good. But it is chaos. It also makes the cops job easier, as one of his checks is pretty much 2. Soren333: For townies, it is a great because using the process of elimination you can easily pin down the mafias. However, I do feel as though mass claiming takes away the fun of the game and puts mafias in a really tight spot. grave_robber: I'm pro-mass claims but never early, and players with critical roles shouldn't claim unless they have to. Informative roles should only claim when they have solid info and enough time has passed(day 3 or later). s3bEg: Yeah mass claiming is a pretty cool guy. coromandel: Mass-claiming can be done as a last resort, but it’s a double-edged sword. Villains often manage to blend in by fake-claiming, and when 2 players claim the same role, sometimes the town lynches the wrong person -.- *speaks from experience*. Lambtron: Not particularly a fan of this, it usually only goes well at a set point in time but it's not always that easy to pinpoint this for each separate case/game. Suzune-chan: From my standpoint as a host it was not fun because it takes away the mystery. While from a player perspective I can appreciate it. Someone always steals my role though and I usually lose the debate on roles because it is so much harder to tell the truth then to lie. Just my perspective. Matoro_Mahri: Hate it. This might be biased since I got bitten by it as a mafia, but it forces a seriously aggressive playstyle that severely punishes players for even momentary lapses in activity. In other words it harms the less active and helps the more active, which I am not. NessieFynn: Why not? It can be chaotic and confusing, but thats what makes it fun. ChaosSavior: it's a good idea i guess Verumir: For most cases, I do not like it, it ruins the fun. SuzakuTsubasa: Mass claiming? When everyone is saying "his" role? As long as there's no way to prove it, I stay suspicious. shap111: double edged sword,its a mafia killer if used correctly Shadowsnake777: If you mean where evryone reveals their roles to find out the mafia i'm not a big fan of it because it takes the fun away from the game. It kinda gets a lil boring when you figure out all roles day 1 and all you do is wait for the next day, lynch and so on. Asunyan: asu sees no point in it Smurphinator: It can work sometimes. It depends on how and when in the game you're doing it. I think doing it too early just causes confusion. Juzzywuzzy: Claiming's fine as long as the claim is smoth [sic]. turtlebandit: It's confusing and counterproductive MrHawkeye: Cheap but effective. nyancat2506: i think sometimes if overdone might be a little bit annoying. claiming to be certain role is okay depends on how the situation or event. but sometimes, but i have tendency of being suspicious to everyone If you are townie, how would you play to ensure your victory? -Blonde-: Like I said before, I would get as much information as possible, we can then calculate who's most and least suspicious. LucianRoy: I'm town, so I'll just be town. x_at_home: Try to find mafia DoubleC: Discreetly ask the players who should a certain role(my own) use their ability. Actually if we should all give our thoughts on how certain roles should use their abilities every night. This will give good insight to the player with that role and lead to better choices and more info from everyone. Haine-: I always use notepad and separate whoever is trusted........which is only lucian right now ,And try to find mafia tho reading posts. SodaWithYoda: I would play to ensure a good relationship with everyone in the town so i don't get mislynched Llafos: [no answer] Soren333: Try to contribute to discussion if I can. Point out things that I find suspicious. Make a read list if necessary. grave_robber: Find mafia, trust no one after night 1(even the innocent girl since we have a converter), use my abilities, votes and even die if it helps the town win. A townie should never be afraid! Question everyone and everything! If someone claims your role, remember that you are a townie and you will prove it eventually. s3bEg: Sarcastically answer theses [sic] questions. coromandel: Contribute as much as possible. Observe. Lambtron: Staying alive and having a role I can use in the background without needing to reveal gained information from whatever method this might be until the endgame kicks in ^^ Alternatively acting anti-town is always a fun way to go. Suzune-chan: I mean I would play the way I usually do. I suppose. I love being town and my usual town strategy works for me. Matoro_Mahri: Can't really answer this without giving away my role. NessieFynn: I'll just try to not be bad and vote to kill the mafias and not the townies. ChaosSavior: i will try to open up every possibility on my head before voting for someone and i will try keep someone as long as they are useful Verumir: I’ll play as I always did, follow any leads, make questions, and vote for the ones who gets on top of the suspicious list until something a new one takes his place. SuzakuTsubasa: How would I play... I would try to avoid lynching a townie. shap111: avoid fucking up town strats with my night skills Shadowsnake777: How I do it every game. Read people or see how they act to certain events Asunyan: asu would flatline always there but never at teh forefront appearing to be neither mafia nor townie nor third party Smurphinator: I'm not sure. I think the best game I had as a townie was when I sacrificed myself in a sense, but it ended up being for the betterment of the town. So, I'll try not to be afraid of the mafia, and embrace attempts to lure them out. Juzzywuzzy: I was a psych major for two years before dropping out. (dropped out smoothly) I think I have a few smooth tricks up my smooth sleeves. turtlebandit: Lurk, see everything, contribute MrHawkeye: Pay attention, look for clues, suspect everyone. nyancat2506: of course, as a townies i really want to get rid of all the mafioso but as someone who holds no power i will make sure to keep track on everyone words ( which is literally semi possible at this moment) and try to keep an eye on someone suspicious. at least by day 3, that if im survive, or probably depends on how much info i have . but so far, as far as my reading goes, the most noticeable player would be haine, grave, soren, lucian, blonde, and lamb. for me. If you are mafia, how would you play to ensure that you win? -Blonde-: My experience as mafia isn't great, but with such a large field, lurking would be a lot easier than in a smaller game. Although, I couldn't do that because I've already said I don't like lurking xD I would avoid giving away any info because I seem to give away a lot when I play as mafia. LucianRoy: Kill Saya, Grave, Soren, Jack, and basically all the experianced people. x_at_home: Try to kill other mafia/mislead town/appear town. DoubleC: Try to fit in. Say pro-townie stuff and divert attention towards other players. Or if I'm lazy go for a super lurker playstyle. Haine-: Kill all experienced people [?] But right now I don't really now who's most experienced player ^^'' SodaWithYoda: Lynch one of my friends at the start of the game to get credit then attack the town from the inside Llafos: Low risk, low reward, and if I feel like it is needed I would go for the high risk, high reward play. I would play way more conservative if I was mafia. As I would get more from blending in. I just don't believe that questionnaire is pure benefit. Soren333: I haven't got much experience as mafia but I would probably play the same as usual. grave_robber: Kill the most experienced players, immediate threats, make sure I have a role I can fake claim, confuse players, lie, use the truth to my advantage, and sacrifice fellow mafiosos if needed, all while pretending to be a good little townie. s3bEg: Sarcastically answer theses [sic] questions. coromandel: Make the others think I’m innocent. Kill dangerous players/roles. Lambtron: Making myself or letting someone else have a lingering presence that will leave them as a likely lynch target for when town have nothing to go off, as opposed to using day/night phases for "saving" the rest of the scum. Being a mess with some of the choices to snake between actions, if this doesn't work after a few phases it would hopefully throw some of the towns actions off. Suzune-chan: As I have never won...I would try a bunch of things and hope for the best. I mean, I really have no mafia tricks. Matoro_Mahri: Hit and miss usually. As mafia I tend to rely on my teammates a lot more than as town. NessieFynn: Kill off the smartest seeming townies and other mafs, and make sure to leave behind all the suspicious seeming towns. ChaosSavior: i would go for the chain kill by converting someone who is following someone and kill that follower Verumir: This mafia has an advantage, I would try to hunt the third parties, and the other mafia. If I’m good at it, I would even try a bus vote. SuzakuTsubasa: I would probably try to kill the most dangerous ones. shap111: teamwork with the other mafias? Shadowsnake777: Hmmm dunno. The previous mafia games I was pretty inactive so there wasn't really a strategy, only pure lucked I wasn't lynched on those days! XD Asunyan: same as if asu was a townie Smurphinator: Act the exact same as when I'm town? There's nothing else really that I think would work better than that. Juzzywuzzy: Same as above. Only smoother. turtlebandit: [no answer] MrHawkeye: Work together, think carefully, survive. nyancat2506: as far as my exp goes, there are type of mafioso who like to be secretive and introverted and just observing and talk less and some are dominating by leading the crowd and ensure that they are townies. Which players here do you think are the best liars/the ones who can manipulate others well? [i]-Blonde-: Lucian can keep control of the thread nicely and as a confirmed townie, that's an advantage to us. Also, Grave is pretty good at manipulating, I've never seen him play mafia, but he seems like a really good townie player. LucianRoy: Grave, you, Jack, Saya, maybe me. x_at_home: Such a hit list. You should know better then me. All players can be good at it, but I'm curious what other people think of this. DoubleC: coro, I saw her play in Crow's game. Would've convinced me if I weren't mafia. Haine-: Jackrito,Asunyan,DoubleC SodaWithYoda: Me, CC, Trijugate, Soren (I haven't played with a lot of people) Llafos: [no answer] Soren333: Llafos. Goddamn he threw me off in that game. grave_robber: I can only list the players I've played with before or have seen playing: Soren333, LucianRoy, Suzune-chan, Brynhildr, verumir, Jackrito, karote, sasayamei, Iasuru, coromandel and myself of course. s3bEg: Whoever posted these questions would probably like to think he can manipulate others, and the fact I am actually answering these proves that a bit. The guy with the deviantart lookin fox-man avatar is certainly active so he will likely care enough to try and manipulate people. coromandel: [no answer] Lambtron: I'll leave this short ^^ Bryn - though this is mostly a potential player for others not quite myself, I like their style and seems easier to follow than others. But I eagerly wait to see it uses in a more entertaining way. Suzune-chan: Hm, I suppose I would choose Lucian, Grave, Jack, Ver, Sasa, and several others but I would have to really check the player list. Matoro_Mahri: trij is good. x_at_home puts up a good effort. NessieFynn: No idea. ChaosSavior: eh i'm not too great at reading someone so i don't know about this one Verumir: Grave and Jack, for opposite reasons. SuzakuTsubasa: I don't know a lot of people here, I can't answer. shap111: from my exp of previous games: soren,jack,karrote Shadowsnake777: Hmm dunno, I haven't played for a LONG time (valentines/NGNL ones didn't really count) and most of these people I have never played against Asunyan: asu has nvr played w/most of teh players heres so asu doesnt knos Smurphinator: Probably Soren and Grave just from my experience. Honestly, everyone has the potential to be, we all fit different roles differently and lie differently while in them. Juzzywuzzy: I wouldn't know. But it'll come to me smoothly after a couple of days of not dying and not being lynched. turtlebandit: Everyone MrHawkeye: Lucian and trijugate nyan2506: I havent played with most of u guys but maybe i'll say Jack or pyro Which players do you have the hardest time to read? -Blonde-: DoubleC, Soda, MrHawkEye all kind of post every so often with little info and they do that every game whether they are mafia or not. It annoys me a bit to be honest xD LucianRoy: Grave, you, sometimes Jack, but he's been really easy to read in the last couple games we've played. Suzune is really easy to read too. I don't know about Saya. I haven't seen her play as scum yet. x_at_home: In such a huge list? Hmm. The good players and the ones I don't know, lol. DoubleC: Lucian, turtlebandit, Hawkie, and Suzu. Hawkie posts so sporadically and usually his posts never reveal much. Lucian is confirmed! turtle... too random Suzu has a way with words. Haine-: I can't answer this either as I haven't played mafia for a long time SodaWithYoda: The ones listed above + MrHawkeye Llafos: Obviously players I haven't really seen play before, as I don't have no [sic] comparison. Soren333: Inactive players - they don't post, so I can't read Helpful players - I find it hard tell if they are a townie being helpful, or a mafia being helpful to blend in. Also those that posts every now and then, but don't really say too much. I find it hard to tell if they're a mafia post to ensure that "blend" in. Or just a townie who doesn't have much to say. Someone like x_at_home grave_robber: All the ones I haven't played with, the trolls and the following: Soren, LucianRoy, Jackrito, suzune-chan and Brynhildr s3bEg: I can't even read. coromandel: The ones who I can’t read are probably also the best liars. DoubleC, Bryn, Grave, Soren, Jack, ... But this game has almost 40 players and there are a lot of new faces. So I’m not too worried about the few experienced players I know. The newbies are more intimidating tbh. Lambtron: Turtle - Though I think this might just be more of an early game thing. Hawkeye - Good at sitting around.... Don't even know if they are a Hawk. Nyancat - Dies good. Asunyan - Also a good sitter, usually don't have the role to read what is purely night actions and smiley faces. meruledaworld - Due to what are they even saying. Suzune-chan: Jack is the hardest for me to read. However, I tend to view everyone with suspicion until I can clear them Matoro_Mahri: DoubleC. HazyPanda kind of, although that's sort of guessing since I knew his role last time. NessieFynn: No idea. ChaosSavior: most of the time grave_robber (he looks like townies no matter what faction he is in) and MrHawkeye (often time feels like my reflection) and there is a lot people i don't know on this game Verumir: The ones who doesn’t write proper English SuzakuTsubasa: Same thing. shap111: damn hazypanda,lucian, and the ones abov [sic] Shadowsnake777: We'll have to wait and see haha XD Asunyan: all of teh players heres Smurphinator: [no answer] Juzzywuzzy: Everyone's smooth at the moment. turtlebandit: [no answer] MrHawkeye: everyone to be honest nyancat2506: wow, i have no idea. mostly i try to attain my focus ability to read a very long long post like the one im typing so probably myself.. lol joke maybe grave Are you mafia? -Blonde-: Nope. LucianRoy: Lol, no. x_at_home: No. DoubleC: I'm still waiting for my club invite. Haine-: Nopes SodaWithYoda: Nope I am a townie, Llafos: No? Yes? Maybe? - How would you know from a bunch of generic questions? Soren333: If I said no would you believe me? grave_robber: No. s3bEg: What's a mafia? Lambtron: Ask -Blonde- about this question ^^ P.S - Wayne Rooney's smarter than you~ Suzune-chan: No, and I cannot complain. Matoro_Mahri: Not going to answer this yet, take what you will from it. I will say that I am not a third party though. NessieFynn: Not since last time I checked. I'm pretty town, I'm pretty sure. ChaosSavior: nope Verumir: No. SuzakuTsubasa: Let me ask my brain what I should answer. shap111: whats the point of this question? everyone is going to answer no anyways Shadowsnake777: Is this one of those trick questions where no matter what you say is wrong? XD haha no i'm not XD Asunyan: nopes asu is not mafias Smurphinator: What I say here won't really influence anyone, but no. Juzzywuzzy: I wouldn't know, buddy. But I DO know that I'm smooth. turtlebandit: nep MrHawkeye: Who knows? nyancat2506: i assure u i am a comrades [sic] of high loyalty and noble to the hunters -MidnightOwl-: Those questions are a waste of time. Jackrito: I do normally lurk on day one but when something gets my attention and I see it as been a potential mafia ploy to get info on the sly I will question it and that is what I saw that quiz as. REMAINING INACTIVE PLAYERS: Jackrito Brynhildr PandaCake militus Himikoi sasyamei LoveandHate91 meruledaworld Karote MarvTheMan Iasuru OTHER trijuagate Had the same impression on Panda at first, but his current vote and reading back the posts with more attention makes me think otherwise. About Grave and Juzzy, the latter seems a newbie [ ? ] to me, so just backing up with whom, among leading players, she finds less suspicious [ ? ]. You, yourself, said at a certain point yesterday you were going to follow Saya's lead, so it's not as outstanding as Coro + Grave buddying. :/ Also, not a newbie. Also, to everyone, feel free to stop babying newbies, or newbies(?). |
Sometimes, I face up before I sneeze and let spit shower my face. Just me things. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:23 PM
#2162
SodaWithYoda said: LucianRoy said: grave_robber said: LucianRoy said: That's pretty defensive over a Day 1 scumread. Got something on your mind, Grave? Threatening players isn't the most town thing that comes to mind, and I can't remember you doing it before in any of our games... ever. I have several things on my mind, not about to share them with you though ^^ I didn't threaten anyone, I merely informed saya-chan of my intention of going after her on day 2, why are you so worried about that? Scared you're going to lose control of the game? Poor lucian, can't control every player and dictate their every action. Wow, I felt the jab. You really do get defensive. Lol, "control" is a very general word, and it's determined by a multitude of arbitrary things that I can't control. Ha, fallacies. Setting yourself up to vote someone... no it's not even that. Stating that you're going to accuse someone the following day for basically, (at the time), the exact same reasons that you spoke of yesterday raises a field of red flags. Vig, or SK, kill grave. I don't want to wait for the cop, oh wait, they're dead. Is this a set up i see here? As in Grave setting up Saya? Definitely. |
"If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Feb 11, 2015 11:26 PM
#2163
I'll just hop in so hopefully no one will yell at me for hiding or whatever, I have nothing to add but if anyone has salt with me, i'll be here lurking for a bit. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:29 PM
#2164
-MidnightOwl- said: If I told you guys that I was the Cop, I investigated Brynhildr, and got scum as a result, would you believe me? Food for thought. I'm going to bed too. I can hear the roosters singing. Sleep deprivation really does have the worst effects. Cop is dead, but if the cop wasn't dead, and you claimed day 2, I'd lynch you for making such a stupid claim. If this was a normal game, under normal circumstances, I'd say I actually find your accusation plausible. Bryn was my first thought when Karote turned up dead. I feel like she'd be the only person to ever pull a specific kill on Karote. I forget if it was due to past games, but it has some kind of deja vu to it. |
"If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Feb 11, 2015 11:32 PM
#2165
LucianRoy said: -MidnightOwl- said: If I told you guys that I was the Cop, I investigated Brynhildr, and got scum as a result, would you believe me? Food for thought. I'm going to bed too. I can hear the roosters singing. Sleep deprivation really does have the worst effects. Cop is dead, but if the cop wasn't dead, and you claimed day 2, I'd lynch you for making such a stupid claim. If this was a normal game, under normal circumstances, I'd say I actually find your accusation plausible. Bryn was my first thought when Karote turned up dead. I feel like she'd be the only person to ever pull a specific kill on Karote. I forget if it was due to past games, but it has some kind of deja vu to it. But that didn't sound like a claim? |
Sometimes, I face up before I sneeze and let spit shower my face. Just me things. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:32 PM
#2166
If i told you that i investigated someone last night and didn't get any results, who would i sound like? |
Feb 11, 2015 11:45 PM
#2167
SodaWithYoda said: If i told you that i investigated someone last night and didn't get any results, who would i sound like? |
Feb 11, 2015 11:45 PM
#2168
Lambtron said: SodaWithYoda said: If i told you that i investigated someone last night and didn't get any results, who would i sound like? Exactly my point... |
Feb 11, 2015 11:48 PM
#2169
-MidnightOwl- said: The_Pyromaani said: [b]Votes so far... DoubleC - 1 (MrHawkeye) Llafos - 2 (-blonde-, coromandel) -MidnightOwl- - 1 (grave_robber) grave_robber - 5 (-MidnightOwl-, s3bEg, LucianRoy, Llafos, turtlebandit) ChaosSaviour - 1 (Lambtron) Soren333 - 1 (Suzune-chan) s3bEg - 1 (Verumir) -Haine - 1 (NessieFynn) militus - 7 (Asunyan, x_at_home, Juzzywuzzy, Soren333, shap111, Haine-, trijugate) No lynch - 1 (Matoro_Mahri) People not voting - 18 Jackrito, Brynhildr, PandaCake, militus, Himikoi, sasayamei, LoveandHate91, SodaWithYoda, meruledaworld, Shadowsnake777, ChaosSaviour, Karote, SuzakuTsubasa, Lambtron, MarvTheMan, Smurphinator, nyancat2506, Iasuru. Time until phase change! Timer This is when trijugate voted for militus.[/b][/b] Let me throw in some half assed, 3 AM, analysis someone probably already came up with- if I am repeating what someone said then just take it as I am agreeing with them. Militus and Grave were both very close to eachother in votes, so if someone from their mafia wanted to bail them out it would make sense to vote for the other person. Using that logic you can speculate on anyone who voted for either of them, really. I will throw out the possibility that Trijugate voted for Militus to help Grave. If Trijugate did not give a valid reason to vote the way he did this would enforce this idea, I am too lazy to look into it further though. If Grave turns out to be mafia I would also look more into Haine. Feel free to tear this apart, it is quite probable I am too tired to see blatant holes. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:48 PM
#2170
SodaWithYoda said: Lambtron said: SodaWithYoda said: If i told you that i investigated someone last night and didn't get any results, who would i sound like? Exactly my point... What...? You'd sound like a person with a mafia NK death wish. |
"If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Feb 11, 2015 11:51 PM
#2171
LucianRoy said: SodaWithYoda said: Lambtron said: SodaWithYoda said: If i told you that i investigated someone last night and didn't get any results, who would i sound like? Exactly my point... What...? You'd sound like a person with a mafia NK death wish. Thank you for that info, Question is do i throw this game away, or do you think i am a valuable member of the community? |
Feb 11, 2015 11:52 PM
#2172
SodaWithYoda said: Lambtron said: SodaWithYoda said: If i told you that i investigated someone last night and didn't get any results, who would i sound like? Exactly my point... If + didn't is too empty, but you are asking for a bullet at the same time :S |
Feb 11, 2015 11:52 PM
#2173
s3bEg said: -MidnightOwl- said: The_Pyromaani said: [b]Votes so far... DoubleC - 1 (MrHawkeye) Llafos - 2 (-blonde-, coromandel) -MidnightOwl- - 1 (grave_robber) grave_robber - 5 (-MidnightOwl-, s3bEg, LucianRoy, Llafos, turtlebandit) ChaosSaviour - 1 (Lambtron) Soren333 - 1 (Suzune-chan) s3bEg - 1 (Verumir) -Haine - 1 (NessieFynn) militus - 7 (Asunyan, x_at_home, Juzzywuzzy, Soren333, shap111, Haine-, trijugate) No lynch - 1 (Matoro_Mahri) People not voting - 18 Jackrito, Brynhildr, PandaCake, militus, Himikoi, sasayamei, LoveandHate91, SodaWithYoda, meruledaworld, Shadowsnake777, ChaosSaviour, Karote, SuzakuTsubasa, Lambtron, MarvTheMan, Smurphinator, nyancat2506, Iasuru. Time until phase change! Timer This is when trijugate voted for militus.[/b][/b] Let me throw in some half assed, 3 AM, analysis someone probably already came up with- if I am repeating what someone said then just take it as I am agreeing with them. Militus and Grave were both very close to eachother in votes, so if someone from their mafia wanted to bail them out it would make sense to vote for the other person. Using that logic you can speculate on anyone who voted for either of them, really. I will throw out the possibility that Trijugate voted for Militus to help Grave. If Trijugate did not give a valid reason to vote the way he did this would enforce this idea, I am too lazy to look into it further though. If Grave turns out to be mafia I would also look more into Haine. Feel free to tear this apart, it is quite probable I am too tired to see blatant holes. But is that a reason to build a case? Doe this not provoke anything... at three am. I'm going to be, I'm sorry guys, I had quite a bit of work to do tonight, and I did it while checking this thread occasionally. I might not have a chance to vote, so here's this quote: "Do what you feel in your heart to be right, for you'll probably be criticized anyway." -Eleanor Roosevelt |
"If you look for a ghost, you'll find one." |
Feb 11, 2015 11:54 PM
#2174
Dw Foxy, unless there is a near definite reason to vote for scum early on in the phase, I don't exactly get a chance to do a proper vote..... every day phase. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:55 PM
#2175
LucianRoy said: s3bEg said: -MidnightOwl- said: The_Pyromaani said: [b]Votes so far... DoubleC - 1 (MrHawkeye) Llafos - 2 (-blonde-, coromandel) -MidnightOwl- - 1 (grave_robber) grave_robber - 5 (-MidnightOwl-, s3bEg, LucianRoy, Llafos, turtlebandit) ChaosSaviour - 1 (Lambtron) Soren333 - 1 (Suzune-chan) s3bEg - 1 (Verumir) -Haine - 1 (NessieFynn) militus - 7 (Asunyan, x_at_home, Juzzywuzzy, Soren333, shap111, Haine-, trijugate) No lynch - 1 (Matoro_Mahri) People not voting - 18 Jackrito, Brynhildr, PandaCake, militus, Himikoi, sasayamei, LoveandHate91, SodaWithYoda, meruledaworld, Shadowsnake777, ChaosSaviour, Karote, SuzakuTsubasa, Lambtron, MarvTheMan, Smurphinator, nyancat2506, Iasuru. Time until phase change! Timer This is when trijugate voted for militus.[/b][/b] Let me throw in some half assed, 3 AM, analysis someone probably already came up with- if I am repeating what someone said then just take it as I am agreeing with them. Militus and Grave were both very close to eachother in votes, so if someone from their mafia wanted to bail them out it would make sense to vote for the other person. Using that logic you can speculate on anyone who voted for either of them, really. I will throw out the possibility that Trijugate voted for Militus to help Grave. If Trijugate did not give a valid reason to vote the way he did this would enforce this idea, I am too lazy to look into it further though. If Grave turns out to be mafia I would also look more into Haine. Feel free to tear this apart, it is quite probable I am too tired to see blatant holes. But is that a reason to build a case? Doe this not provoke anything... at three am. I'm going to be, I'm sorry guys, I had quite a bit of work to do tonight, and I did it while checking this thread occasionally. I might not have a chance to vote, so here's this quote: "Do what you feel in your heart to be right, for you'll probably be criticized anyway." -Eleanor Roosevelt Nah, I certainly wouldn't build a case off it, but I do think it is worth a thought if Grave is ever seriously questioned. And as more people are discovered, looking back at this using my reasoning could be valuable. |
Feb 11, 2015 11:59 PM
#2176
Juzzywuzzy said: Brynhildr said: -MidnightOwl- said: I'm voting for Haine. I feel like either Soren or Haine has to be scum, or both for the ultimate plot twist. Lynch: Haine- Matoro_Mahri said: @Soren333: My conclusions have changed slightly since then but they are mostly the same. I can say with very strong conviction that -MidnightOwl- is the Jester. It's quite obvious he's trying to get himself attacked it some way, either during the day or at night. The second possibility means he could be one of the few roles that gains something instead of dying by being attacked at night, but I didn't see any at a quick glance. So the clearest possibility is the Jester. It's important to look at -MidnightOwl- compared to s3bEg. They both have highly antagonistic playstyles, almost inviting themselves to get hurt. However, -MidnightOwl-'s is focused on flinging around wild analyses, and generally sowing confusion. In fact, not only is he one of the few who have actively claimed something (the other being DoubleC who claimed mafia) but he has claimed two contradictory roles (Brother in Arms and Doctor). He himself acknowledged this, meaning it wasn't a slip-up. s3bEg on the other hand seems to play the same, but in my opinion actually doesn't. I haven't played with him before so I can't say whether it's a personality or a purposeful thing but he seems to be focusing on holding a façade while still slipping out analyses every so often. It's up to the rest of the players what to make of this but for me, I'm getting the strongest town readings from him. My second conclusion is that grave_robber and JuzzyWuzzy are from the same faction, regardless of what that might be. If they are hunters, they are most likely Knuckle & Shoot. When JuzzyWuzzy is around, their posts seem to synergize in a weird way. Their responses to this might shed a little light on the subject. Lastly my two less-founded suspicious are on Haine and you. You two have just had the most mafia-esque posts out of everybody. Meaning I'd join a lynch train against you, but I wouldn't start one. I wish I had time to comb through 90+ pages and quote evidence, but I have a calculus test tomorrow. So I'll just post an updated questionnaire. Dead players have been colored their faction. Try to read what they said and see if you can draw any conclusions. What is your approach to this game? Will you lurk or contribute when you can? -Blonde-: Contribute, Lurking isn't pro-town, we should we pushing to get as much information out of everyone as we can. LucianRoy: I'll scumhunt till' I'm dead. I'm the only confirmed town player in this game. x_at_home: Well. I will contribute, but also lurk at times. I will be busy at times, so my presence will be inconsistent. I'm also pretty excited about this game, so who knows where I will end up. DoubleC: I'm usually fairly active. I've taken a liking to the idea of staying somewhat reserved for the first 2 days or so as to not draw attention from the mafia. Haine-: Contribute when I can but the problem I'm not as experienced as others in reading posts now. SodaWithYoda: I will contribute when i can, I am on here for like 16 hours a day... Consider it suspicious if i am not online for at least 12 hours Llafos: First time as town. lol? Soren333: I point things out when I notice them and try to generate discussion. grave_robber: My approach will be my usual one, being proactive which means I will contribute as much as I can and I will engage and question others during the course of the game. For example: Soren, you should answer your own questions and thanks for posting them ^^ s3bEg: I will approach it with elephant tranquilizers and a net. coromandel: First day is usually where I’m least active, because I never really know what to talk about.. but I’ll try to contribute as much as possible. In general, I like to observe and start posting when I’ve found something worth mentioning (a bad habit – sometimes I keep things to myself for too long). Lambtron: The same as usual ^^, fuhk around for the first day, potentially 2. ( depending on wasted pressure and role ). Contribution will be when I'm around though this is in most cases not the best time compared to the mass of players and I avoid what I need to say if it's been done by that point in time. Suzune-chan: I enjoy playing with everyone here. While I am certain almost everyone here knows, I will say again. I do work during the day and that cuts into the time that I can play. I believe the roleover is while I am at work so if everyone decides that an end vote is on the table, I will not be of much help. However, I am on the same hours everyday~ Matoro_Mahri: I will contribute as often as classes allow, which will apparently be not often. NessieFynn: I'm going to contribute as much as I can, 'cause if I'm town I ought to help out my side, and if I'm a maf everyone will get suspicious of me. I'll just point out whoever's acting sneaky, and try to convince everyone if I think I've found scum. ChaosSavior: i would love to contribute but often time i come out it's already empty. i will try to help here and there though Verumir: I don’t want to be sleep deprived, and I have a lot of things to do, but I’ll not lurk, and try to contribute when I can. SuzakuTsubasa: I usually don't talk when I don't have anything to say. shap111: I have uni at noon, so ill be active in the mornings/nights Shadowsnake777: Hmm I have school and it's the start of the week so I would mostly be lurking but I would contribute as much as I can. (I'll contribute on weekends though haha) Asunyan: asu will contribute wen asu can Smurphinator: I'm always a bit of a mix of lurking and being extremely active depending on the timing. I think my biggest problem will be that I'm going to miss a few days, and catching up is going to be a bit of a challenge. Juzzywuzzy: I'm playing it smooth. I'll lurk smooth and contribute smooth. turtlebandit: Can't I do both? MrHawkeye: My strategy involves lone wolf type play, it's suspicious and that is unavoidable however it lets me have freedom if I am either mafia or townie. Am suspected of being neither nyancat2506: I will try to contribute as much as i do to lurking How do you feel about inactive players? -Blonde-: Don't like inactive players because of the same reason as above. LucianRoy: The mod will deal with them. Specifically in the means of replacements. Other than that, we don't have much to worry about inactives. x_at_home: Should be replaced. There are some promising players that deserve to play DoubleC: Depends which faction I am. Haine-: They might lurkers or trying to hide their presence sometimes SodaWithYoda: I think replacing them is best because I like when everyone in the game is active makes it a lot more fun Llafos: Really? I guess I like them to be different. Soren333: Tricky if they don't get replaced. You can't read them at all and become a gamble if you choose to lynch them. grave_robber: They hurt the town/hunters. Bad guys can easily lurk and hide amongst inactives. Players who pretend to be inactive put themselves at a risk since townies can't read them and will most likely suspect them at one point or another. s3bEg: They are better than outactive players at the very least. coromandel: I don’t think it’s too much of a big deal on the first day, but it gets frustrating when they never post. Pressure-voting is a good strategy to get them to talk. Lambtron: Meh 50/50, it doesn't help nor ruin chances on the more experianced players and I'm not too concerned about the others that are just slack or bad at what they do ^^ Suzune-chan: Personally, I do not like them because they do not help the game. Then the town worthlessly lynches each other. By doing that we are killing the team rather then rooting out mafia members. Matoro_Mahri: They shouldn't have signed up in the first place. Replace 'em if it's easy, kill 'em if it's not. NessieFynn: They should get their butts onto the thread and play some more! Its boring if no one talks. ChaosSavior: they should contribute even if it's only small. Verumir: Mod kill or replacement, they add nothing to the game, if they are mafia, then it’s a cheap trick to stay alive for the first phases. SuzakuTsubasa: Why going in a game [sic] when you don't want to play? shap111: with inactives you mean lurkers? if yes, mafias. if not, then they should be kicked Shadowsnake777: Hmm well we've gotta think about timezones and school/work + IRL thingamabobs but if they do it without warning for ages I say replace em with someone else ^ ^ Asunyan: asu dislikes inactive players Smurphinator: Sometimes it can't be helped, sometimes is can. I just don't waste my time with inactives, since there's never enough information to make any solid decisions regarding them unless it's really late in the game. Juzzywuzzy: Inactivity is smooth. Mafia smooth. turtlebandit: Apathic [sic] MrHawkeye: If there is no one to lynch, I would go for one of the inactives, this of course does not excerpt me from getting lynched as well since I am usually pretty inactive nyancat2506: some cant help it if theyre are inactive, but as per say, if they are super busy, and really cant attend any of the discussion, i believe the player should inform it to the host because oh well, as the player is inactive, it will be hard to mark a suspect on those people and we might ended up killing a hunters If you are mafia, who would you kill tonight? -Blonde-: Ok, I would go for a big threat, like you or Grave. LucianRoy: Hehe, you. x_at_home: Dunno. For me Night 1 is like a Random Killing stage, lol. Except if you already have a plan or found some dangerous roles. There are players I wouldn't kill though DoubleC: Bryn, grave, suzu are my top choices. Attempting to kill Lucian would be a risk. Haine-: Hmmm First person who posted in this thread [I'm always sure those who post first are townie....Mafia always have the longest time to read ....to discover their fellow members lawl] SodaWithYoda: Either soren or Blonde Llafos: A player I think is strong. Soren333: Depends how I feel like playing. The rational thing to do is to target two specific type of players. 1. Experience/analytical players 2. Those that are active The first choice is an obvious thing to do and will become a pain later on if you don't get rid of them sooner. The second choice is to eliminate active players, so that most that are left are players that don't post much. If players don't post much then they don't really suspect people and/or contribute to scumhunting. However, I may feel like having a fun game and want to keep players that I enjoy playing with (whom are usually the experienced players) alive. And so I might kill some oddballs. As to who I would kill in this game. It's a big pool of players so hard to tell at this point. However, if I was mafia I would probably go for one of those that post quite a lot which does not include one of the experienced players because I would like to have an interesting game. And I like reading experienced players' posts. grave_robber: The players who are either an immediate threat or the ones who tend to lead and get the town to think. On night 1 my primary targets would be: Verumir, coromandel, Llafos(mvp of v1), Brynhildr, x_at_home. I would try to keep the most powerful ones alive so I can frame them, mainly: Soren333 (say he's scummy for posting these questions and posing as town), LucianRoy(say he was converted), Jackrito(I'll keep him alive till day 3, that will get him lynched), Suzune-chan(say that Jack & Lucian are being framed by a master mindl)& sasayamei(same way as suzune-chan). s3bEg: The moderator. coromandel: Depends on how this day develops. I’d probably not target the experienced, active players, because there’s a higher chance that someone protects them. So, I’d probably try to kill an inexperienced lurker, who didn’t attract too much attention during the day. Lambtron: Tonight more specifically I don't have anyone in particular to kill though I usually wouldn't opt for any high tier targets for the first couple of days. Though in this bigger game I'd probably hit one early ( day 2 ) and then leave them be till half way or so again ^^ Chances are I'd let one of the less experienced players make the call so as to throw people off a little, or just hit in-actives. Suzune-chan: [no answer] Matoro_Mahri: Someone inactive. NessieFynn: Shrug, maybe Soren? He seems like a fine target. ChaosSavior: i'll kill someone that are [sic] way too active Verumir: I can’t be “the mafia”, since there is a team to discuss, I would however suggest the first kill to be a RNG, it would stir the guilty for everyone, plus people tend to overthink players death so something good might come out of it. SuzakuTsubasa: I wouldn't say it. shap111: some random probably Shadowsnake777: Hmm dunno, most of the people here I haven't really played against but I would have to say Bryn for 2 reasons. Game V10 and battleship -_- Asunyan: asu has no ideas this game is very large and has many peeps asu has nvr played w/befores so asu cant tell whose dangerous and whose not Smurphinator: Not sure in all honesty. This game has two mafia factions, so I probably wouldn't even be sure if I was killing a townie night one. Not going to lie, it's probably advantageous from a mafia standpoint to hold off on killing leaders like Soren in case their leadership works in your favor. So to sum up, I guess I'd kill someone with a medium activity and who is kind of a sheep. Juzzywuzzy: Won't tell. It won't be smooth if I do. turtlebandit: This is a dangerous question. MrHawkeye: The usual suspects: Grave, suzu, soren nyancat2506: urm well let see, i really have no damn idea, maybe those who gang up upon razor? as a beginning i mean. ok now i have no idea How often do you expect to be on and posting? -Blonde-: Maybe 3-4 hours a day, I'm busy with school and I do a lot of sport [sic]. LucianRoy: I'm kind of busy today, but I should definitely stop by on roughly every hour mark. x_at_home: See Answer 1 DoubleC: Most of the day and whenever I'm on I'll try my best to post and keep up with the general direction of the discussion. Haine-: When I comeback from school and daily I'm taking hiatus from everything to play hxh xD SodaWithYoda: Pretty often, though i do have school work and other things to be doing sometimes (Like training) Llafos: When I am not asleep or got things I have to do. Soren333: I check MAL quite often and so I will probably post whenever I'm online. grave_robber: As often as possible, assuming it doesn't conflict with my other club duties, real life work. s3bEg: Seasonal. coromandel: I’m usually online every 3 hours or so. Problem is that I’m from a different time zone than most of you (GMT+1), so I’m always online when no one else is. I’m a fairly active player (just not on day 1 ^^’). Lambtron: Some-what often, once again this will be thrown off due to time zones and how long the people doing my work prior to me being available lasts. Suzune-chan: I believe that I covered this in my first question. I guess, I am on the same hours everyday. So I will be as active as I can during those times. My hours usually expand during a game that I enjoy playing. Matoro_Mahri: As I said before, this thread is apparently flying by at mach speed, so comparatively not often. NessieFynn: Only after 4-5 o' clock where I live. I'll be on pretty often after that, but I'll most likely be absent all morning. ChaosSavior: i'm expecting to be as active as possible Verumir: Not much, and I won’t be able to be online during phase changes which is a bummer. SuzakuTsubasa: I should be here on evening/night (earlier than today, it's really late here) shap111: check question 1 Shadowsnake777: Well as I said I got school so every now and then after school (year 11 so lots of work) and definitely weekends Asunyan: asu will be posting every day phase asu will be on less often on days taht asu has homeworks tho asu will nvr ignore this games Smurphinator: Mostly at night in my time zone. I'm going to be missing a bit though, so I apologize in advance for my absence from Thursday to Saturday. Juzzywuzzy: I'm smoothly in a different timezone. It's a little bit smoothly difficult to answer that question. turtlebandit: Pretty often MrHawkeye: No idea to be honest, exam tryouts have been eating my life this week, so there is that. nyancat2506: wow, erm this one, well technically, i wake up at noon, i need to fetch my siblings from school, send them to tuition, and fetch them back again, and playing video games and probably only will online at nights or midnights time, i mean according to the time of my place, in which i live in southeast asia.. How much experience do you have playing as a mafia role? Have you won any games where you was a mafia? -Blonde-: I'm a terrible mafia player, never won playing as mafia and usually die after the first couple days. LucianRoy: I cam [sic] close to winning as scum, once. But the best laid plans of mice and men are laid waste. x_at_home: I think the only one I won was with you. I'm sadly or gladly not often mafia. DoubleC: 7 or 8 times. I've won 3 at the most. Haine-: Yups, I did won before with mafia role....but that was back in summer ._. zero experience at the moment SodaWithYoda: I don't think i have ever won as a mafia role and i don't really like being a mafia, I always die in the first few days when i am a mafia unless i kill other mafia to gets creds Llafos: Played it once, lost because one bad choice from me. (My first game) Soren333: I don't get mafia much. I think I've played as mafia like 3-6 games? Probably won like a bit over half of them. grave_robber: About 30% of my experience has been as mafia, I've won twice as mafia. s3bEg: I am literally Al Capone. coromandel: I’ve been a villain about 5-7 times so far, and I’ve never won. Lambtron: A bit, though some patterns aren't quite on my side in these cases ^^ Usually find myself dead or at least a couple other scum going down very early in these games and having to play it on the back foot straight off the bat, though this is usually the more entertaining way to have it. A couple or so, but not in this club so much. *I also seem to meet Jack every time I'm scum or a role that is paired in some way ( lovers or a modification of ). Suzune-chan: Um, I have played a few. I would be lying if I said I was a good mafia and I do not think I have ever won as a mafia... Matoro_Mahri: Have played as mafia before. Was pretty close, but I don't have that much experience. NessieFynn: Not a lot. I've played mafia before, but never in a game formatted like this, and not for a long while. ChaosSavior: i have played two times as a mafia and i never won any of it Verumir: I was converted once, but even then I was playing truly as a third party, so I would say none. SuzakuTsubasa: Only been mafia once. And I lost. shap111: dunno to be honest since i never played as a mafia before, someone random maybe? Shadowsnake777: Well I have been mafia twice. 1st one I was first to get lynched and second won we technically won but lost at the same time. We killed all townies but there was a traitor sothey killed all of us (I think it was Haine :/) Asunyan: asu was mafia for asus first two games and has been mafia a few times since then asu has won as mafia Smurphinator: I'm pretty evenly split. I tend to last longer as mafia, people are always suspicious of me for no reason when I'm a townie and lynch me... I will never understand. Juzzywuzzy: I've smoothly played mafia on camps before. I have a positive record IRL. -1 on MAL forums. smooth turtlebandit: Roughtly zero MrHawkeye: I am mafia 80% time, RNGesus hates me or loves me depending on who you're asking, have won 2 games as mafia. nyancat2506: well the last i play a mafia game is practically before i start my degree which is on september 2014, as a mafia? yup ive been like maybe twice or thrice nad i never get a decent role, i played as a janitor .. thats as far as i can remember. yup i won a game where i was a mafia but i was dead.. so someone else won it for us What are your thoughts on mass claiming? [i]-Blonde-: Mass claiming? Is that where lots of people claim? Don't like it, it's not really advantageous, it gives the mafia an opportunity to take their pick of the roles. LucianRoy: Hell no. x_at_home: If too early, ruins the fun, late game often a necessity and perfectly fine. In a game like this, it should also be fun. DoubleC: I see it as a decent last ditch strategy. Or if the townie has a huge lead on the mafia and it's an almost guaranteed win then mass claiming is the safest route to go. Haine-: Google chrome crash SodaWithYoda: When there are only a few people left like final 8 or something. Also depends on how many mafias died Llafos: It changes the entire dynamic of a game. I don't see it as bad or good. But it is chaos. It also makes the cops job easier, as one of his checks is pretty much 2. Soren333: For townies, it is a great because using the process of elimination you can easily pin down the mafias. However, I do feel as though mass claiming takes away the fun of the game and puts mafias in a really tight spot. grave_robber: I'm pro-mass claims but never early, and players with critical roles shouldn't claim unless they have to. Informative roles should only claim when they have solid info and enough time has passed(day 3 or later). s3bEg: Yeah mass claiming is a pretty cool guy. coromandel: Mass-claiming can be done as a last resort, but it’s a double-edged sword. Villains often manage to blend in by fake-claiming, and when 2 players claim the same role, sometimes the town lynches the wrong person -.- *speaks from experience*. Lambtron: Not particularly a fan of this, it usually only goes well at a set point in time but it's not always that easy to pinpoint this for each separate case/game. Suzune-chan: From my standpoint as a host it was not fun because it takes away the mystery. While from a player perspective I can appreciate it. Someone always steals my role though and I usually lose the debate on roles because it is so much harder to tell the truth then to lie. Just my perspective. Matoro_Mahri: Hate it. This might be biased since I got bitten by it as a mafia, but it forces a seriously aggressive playstyle that severely punishes players for even momentary lapses in activity. In other words it harms the less active and helps the more active, which I am not. NessieFynn: Why not? It can be chaotic and confusing, but thats what makes it fun. ChaosSavior: it's a good idea i guess Verumir: For most cases, I do not like it, it ruins the fun. SuzakuTsubasa: Mass claiming? When everyone is saying "his" role? As long as there's no way to prove it, I stay suspicious. shap111: double edged sword,its a mafia killer if used correctly Shadowsnake777: If you mean where evryone reveals their roles to find out the mafia i'm not a big fan of it because it takes the fun away from the game. It kinda gets a lil boring when you figure out all roles day 1 and all you do is wait for the next day, lynch and so on. Asunyan: asu sees no point in it Smurphinator: It can work sometimes. It depends on how and when in the game you're doing it. I think doing it too early just causes confusion. Juzzywuzzy: Claiming's fine as long as the claim is smoth [sic]. turtlebandit: It's confusing and counterproductive MrHawkeye: Cheap but effective. nyancat2506: i think sometimes if overdone might be a little bit annoying. claiming to be certain role is okay depends on how the situation or event. but sometimes, but i have tendency of being suspicious to everyone If you are townie, how would you play to ensure your victory? -Blonde-: Like I said before, I would get as much information as possible, we can then calculate who's most and least suspicious. LucianRoy: I'm town, so I'll just be town. x_at_home: Try to find mafia DoubleC: Discreetly ask the players who should a certain role(my own) use their ability. Actually if we should all give our thoughts on how certain roles should use their abilities every night. This will give good insight to the player with that role and lead to better choices and more info from everyone. Haine-: I always use notepad and separate whoever is trusted........which is only lucian right now ,And try to find mafia tho reading posts. SodaWithYoda: I would play to ensure a good relationship with everyone in the town so i don't get mislynched Llafos: [no answer] Soren333: Try to contribute to discussion if I can. Point out things that I find suspicious. Make a read list if necessary. grave_robber: Find mafia, trust no one after night 1(even the innocent girl since we have a converter), use my abilities, votes and even die if it helps the town win. A townie should never be afraid! Question everyone and everything! If someone claims your role, remember that you are a townie and you will prove it eventually. s3bEg: Sarcastically answer theses [sic] questions. coromandel: Contribute as much as possible. Observe. Lambtron: Staying alive and having a role I can use in the background without needing to reveal gained information from whatever method this might be until the endgame kicks in ^^ Alternatively acting anti-town is always a fun way to go. Suzune-chan: I mean I would play the way I usually do. I suppose. I love being town and my usual town strategy works for me. Matoro_Mahri: Can't really answer this without giving away my role. NessieFynn: I'll just try to not be bad and vote to kill the mafias and not the townies. ChaosSavior: i will try to open up every possibility on my head before voting for someone and i will try keep someone as long as they are useful Verumir: I’ll play as I always did, follow any leads, make questions, and vote for the ones who gets on top of the suspicious list until something a new one takes his place. SuzakuTsubasa: How would I play... I would try to avoid lynching a townie. shap111: avoid fucking up town strats with my night skills Shadowsnake777: How I do it every game. Read people or see how they act to certain events Asunyan: asu would flatline always there but never at teh forefront appearing to be neither mafia nor townie nor third party Smurphinator: I'm not sure. I think the best game I had as a townie was when I sacrificed myself in a sense, but it ended up being for the betterment of the town. So, I'll try not to be afraid of the mafia, and embrace attempts to lure them out. Juzzywuzzy: I was a psych major for two years before dropping out. (dropped out smoothly) I think I have a few smooth tricks up my smooth sleeves. turtlebandit: Lurk, see everything, contribute MrHawkeye: Pay attention, look for clues, suspect everyone. nyancat2506: of course, as a townies i really want to get rid of all the mafioso but as someone who holds no power i will make sure to keep track on everyone words ( which is literally semi possible at this moment) and try to keep an eye on someone suspicious. at least by day 3, that if im survive, or probably depends on how much info i have . but so far, as far as my reading goes, the most noticeable player would be haine, grave, soren, lucian, blonde, and lamb. for me. If you are mafia, how would you play to ensure that you win? -Blonde-: My experience as mafia isn't great, but with such a large field, lurking would be a lot easier than in a smaller game. Although, I couldn't do that because I've already said I don't like lurking xD I would avoid giving away any info because I seem to give away a lot when I play as mafia. LucianRoy: Kill Saya, Grave, Soren, Jack, and basically all the experianced people. x_at_home: Try to kill other mafia/mislead town/appear town. DoubleC: Try to fit in. Say pro-townie stuff and divert attention towards other players. Or if I'm lazy go for a super lurker playstyle. Haine-: Kill all experienced people [?] But right now I don't really now who's most experienced player ^^'' SodaWithYoda: Lynch one of my friends at the start of the game to get credit then attack the town from the inside Llafos: Low risk, low reward, and if I feel like it is needed I would go for the high risk, high reward play. I would play way more conservative if I was mafia. As I would get more from blending in. I just don't believe that questionnaire is pure benefit. Soren333: I haven't got much experience as mafia but I would probably play the same as usual. grave_robber: Kill the most experienced players, immediate threats, make sure I have a role I can fake claim, confuse players, lie, use the truth to my advantage, and sacrifice fellow mafiosos if needed, all while pretending to be a good little townie. s3bEg: Sarcastically answer theses [sic] questions. coromandel: Make the others think I’m innocent. Kill dangerous players/roles. Lambtron: Making myself or letting someone else have a lingering presence that will leave them as a likely lynch target for when town have nothing to go off, as opposed to using day/night phases for "saving" the rest of the scum. Being a mess with some of the choices to snake between actions, if this doesn't work after a few phases it would hopefully throw some of the towns actions off. Suzune-chan: As I have never won...I would try a bunch of things and hope for the best. I mean, I really have no mafia tricks. Matoro_Mahri: Hit and miss usually. As mafia I tend to rely on my teammates a lot more than as town. NessieFynn: Kill off the smartest seeming townies and other mafs, and make sure to leave behind all the suspicious seeming towns. ChaosSavior: i would go for the chain kill by converting someone who is following someone and kill that follower Verumir: This mafia has an advantage, I would try to hunt the third parties, and the other mafia. If I’m good at it, I would even try a bus vote. SuzakuTsubasa: I would probably try to kill the most dangerous ones. shap111: teamwork with the other mafias? Shadowsnake777: Hmmm dunno. The previous mafia games I was pretty inactive so there wasn't really a strategy, only pure lucked I wasn't lynched on those days! XD Asunyan: same as if asu was a townie Smurphinator: Act the exact same as when I'm town? There's nothing else really that I think would work better than that. Juzzywuzzy: Same as above. Only smoother. turtlebandit: [no answer] MrHawkeye: Work together, think carefully, survive. nyancat2506: as far as my exp goes, there are type of mafioso who like to be secretive and introverted and just observing and talk less and some are dominating by leading the crowd and ensure that they are townies. Which players here do you think are the best liars/the ones who can manipulate others well? [i]-Blonde-: Lucian can keep control of the thread nicely and as a confirmed townie, that's an advantage to us. Also, Grave is pretty good at manipulating, I've never seen him play mafia, but he seems like a really good townie player. LucianRoy: Grave, you, Jack, Saya, maybe me. x_at_home: Such a hit list. You should know better then me. All players can be good at it, but I'm curious what other people think of this. DoubleC: coro, I saw her play in Crow's game. Would've convinced me if I weren't mafia. Haine-: Jackrito,Asunyan,DoubleC SodaWithYoda: Me, CC, Trijugate, Soren (I haven't played with a lot of people) Llafos: [no answer] Soren333: Llafos. Goddamn he threw me off in that game. grave_robber: I can only list the players I've played with before or have seen playing: Soren333, LucianRoy, Suzune-chan, Brynhildr, verumir, Jackrito, karote, sasayamei, Iasuru, coromandel and myself of course. s3bEg: Whoever posted these questions would probably like to think he can manipulate others, and the fact I am actually answering these proves that a bit. The guy with the deviantart lookin fox-man avatar is certainly active so he will likely care enough to try and manipulate people. coromandel: [no answer] Lambtron: I'll leave this short ^^ Bryn - though this is mostly a potential player for others not quite myself, I like their style and seems easier to follow than others. But I eagerly wait to see it uses in a more entertaining way. Suzune-chan: Hm, I suppose I would choose Lucian, Grave, Jack, Ver, Sasa, and several others but I would have to really check the player list. Matoro_Mahri: trij is good. x_at_home puts up a good effort. NessieFynn: No idea. ChaosSavior: eh i'm not too great at reading someone so i don't know about this one Verumir: Grave and Jack, for opposite reasons. SuzakuTsubasa: I don't know a lot of people here, I can't answer. shap111: from my exp of previous games: soren,jack,karrote Shadowsnake777: Hmm dunno, I haven't played for a LONG time (valentines/NGNL ones didn't really count) and most of these people I have never played against Asunyan: asu has nvr played w/most of teh players heres so asu doesnt knos Smurphinator: Probably Soren and Grave just from my experience. Honestly, everyone has the potential to be, we all fit different roles differently and lie differently while in them. Juzzywuzzy: I wouldn't know. But it'll come to me smoothly after a couple of days of not dying and not being lynched. turtlebandit: Everyone MrHawkeye: Lucian and trijugate nyan2506: I havent played with most of u guys but maybe i'll say Jack or pyro Which players do you have the hardest time to read? -Blonde-: DoubleC, Soda, MrHawkEye all kind of post every so often with little info and they do that every game whether they are mafia or not. It annoys me a bit to be honest xD LucianRoy: Grave, you, sometimes Jack, but he's been really easy to read in the last couple games we've played. Suzune is really easy to read too. I don't know about Saya. I haven't seen her play as scum yet. x_at_home: In such a huge list? Hmm. The good players and the ones I don't know, lol. DoubleC: Lucian, turtlebandit, Hawkie, and Suzu. Hawkie posts so sporadically and usually his posts never reveal much. Lucian is confirmed! turtle... too random Suzu has a way with words. Haine-: I can't answer this either as I haven't played mafia for a long time SodaWithYoda: The ones listed above + MrHawkeye Llafos: Obviously players I haven't really seen play before, as I don't have no [sic] comparison. Soren333: Inactive players - they don't post, so I can't read Helpful players - I find it hard tell if they are a townie being helpful, or a mafia being helpful to blend in. Also those that posts every now and then, but don't really say too much. I find it hard to tell if they're a mafia post to ensure that "blend" in. Or just a townie who doesn't have much to say. Someone like x_at_home grave_robber: All the ones I haven't played with, the trolls and the following: Soren, LucianRoy, Jackrito, suzune-chan and Brynhildr s3bEg: I can't even read. coromandel: The ones who I can’t read are probably also the best liars. DoubleC, Bryn, Grave, Soren, Jack, ... But this game has almost 40 players and there are a lot of new faces. So I’m not too worried about the few experienced players I know. The newbies are more intimidating tbh. Lambtron: Turtle - Though I think this might just be more of an early game thing. Hawkeye - Good at sitting around.... Don't even know if they are a Hawk. Nyancat - Dies good. Asunyan - Also a good sitter, usually don't have the role to read what is purely night actions and smiley faces. meruledaworld - Due to what are they even saying. Suzune-chan: Jack is the hardest for me to read. However, I tend to view everyone with suspicion until I can clear them Matoro_Mahri: DoubleC. HazyPanda kind of, although that's sort of guessing since I knew his role last time. NessieFynn: No idea. ChaosSavior: most of the time grave_robber (he looks like townies no matter what faction he is in) and MrHawkeye (often time feels like my reflection) and there is a lot people i don't know on this game Verumir: The ones who doesn’t write proper English SuzakuTsubasa: Same thing. shap111: damn hazypanda,lucian, and the ones abov [sic] Shadowsnake777: We'll have to wait and see haha XD Asunyan: all of teh players heres Smurphinator: [no answer] Juzzywuzzy: Everyone's smooth at the moment. turtlebandit: [no answer] MrHawkeye: everyone to be honest nyancat2506: wow, i have no idea. mostly i try to attain my focus ability to read a very long long post like the one im typing so probably myself.. lol joke maybe grave Are you mafia? -Blonde-: Nope. LucianRoy: Lol, no. x_at_home: No. DoubleC: I'm still waiting for my club invite. Haine-: Nopes SodaWithYoda: Nope I am a townie, Llafos: No? Yes? Maybe? - How would you know from a bunch of generic questions? Soren333: If I said no would you believe me? grave_robber: No. s3bEg: What's a mafia? Lambtron: Ask -Blonde- about this question ^^ P.S - Wayne Rooney's smarter than you~ Suzune-chan: No, and I cannot complain. Matoro_Mahri: Not going to answer this yet, take what you will from it. I will say that I am not a third party though. NessieFynn: Not since last time I checked. I'm pretty town, I'm pretty sure. ChaosSavior: nope Verumir: No. SuzakuTsubasa: Let me ask my brain what I should answer. shap111: whats the point of this question? everyone is going to answer no anyways Shadowsnake777: Is this one of those trick questions where no matter what you say is wrong? XD haha no i'm not XD Asunyan: nopes asu is not mafias Smurphinator: What I say here won't really influence anyone, but no. Juzzywuzzy: I wouldn't know, buddy. But I DO know that I'm smooth. turtlebandit: nep MrHawkeye: Who knows? nyancat2506: i assure u i am a comrades [sic] of high loyalty and noble to the hunters -MidnightOwl-: Those questions are a waste of time. Jackrito: I do normally lurk on day one but when something gets my attention and I see it as been a potential mafia ploy to get info on the sly I will question it and that is what I saw that quiz as. REMAINING INACTIVE PLAYERS: Jackrito Brynhildr PandaCake militus Himikoi sasyamei LoveandHate91 meruledaworld Karote MarvTheMan Iasuru OTHER trijuagate Had the same impression on Panda at first, but his current vote and reading back the posts with more attention makes me think otherwise. About Grave and Juzzy, the latter seems a newbie [ ? ] to me, so just backing up with whom, among leading players, she finds less suspicious [ ? ]. You, yourself, said at a certain point yesterday you were going to follow Saya's lead, so it's not as outstanding as Coro + Grave buddying. :/ Also, not a newbie. Also, to everyone, feel free to stop babying newbies, or newbies(?). Remove the newbie part [ sorry, wasn't sure about it ] - though, the rest remains. Unless that's something else which I didn't catch while reading your exchanges, but I doubt it. |
Feb 12, 2015 12:02 AM
#2177
LucianRoy said: -MidnightOwl- said: If I told you guys that I was the Cop, I investigated Brynhildr, and got scum as a result, would you believe me? Food for thought. I'm going to bed too. I can hear the roosters singing. Sleep deprivation really does have the worst effects. Cop is dead, but if the cop wasn't dead, and you claimed day 2, I'd lynch you for making such a stupid claim. If this was a normal game, under normal circumstances, I'd say I actually find your accusation plausible. Bryn was my first thought when Karote turned up dead. I feel like she'd be the only person to ever pull a specific kill on Karote. I forget if it was due to past games, but it has some kind of deja vu to it. Fite me foxy! He did pull on a kamikaze stunt on us when we were lovers [ Zombie V.2 ] - which was right indeed, since I was scum. Salty at that time - but I voted for him first on the DBZ game so I would of opted for Coro instead this time. Free strategy ;D |
Feb 12, 2015 12:07 AM
#2178
s3bEg said: -MidnightOwl- said: The_Pyromaani said: [b]Votes so far... DoubleC - 1 (MrHawkeye) Llafos - 2 (-blonde-, coromandel) -MidnightOwl- - 1 (grave_robber) grave_robber - 5 (-MidnightOwl-, s3bEg, LucianRoy, Llafos, turtlebandit) ChaosSaviour - 1 (Lambtron) Soren333 - 1 (Suzune-chan) s3bEg - 1 (Verumir) -Haine - 1 (NessieFynn) militus - 7 (Asunyan, x_at_home, Juzzywuzzy, Soren333, shap111, Haine-, trijugate) No lynch - 1 (Matoro_Mahri) People not voting - 18 Jackrito, Brynhildr, PandaCake, militus, Himikoi, sasayamei, LoveandHate91, SodaWithYoda, meruledaworld, Shadowsnake777, ChaosSaviour, Karote, SuzakuTsubasa, Lambtron, MarvTheMan, Smurphinator, nyancat2506, Iasuru. Time until phase change! Timer This is when trijugate voted for militus.[/b][/b] Let me throw in some half assed, 3 AM, analysis someone probably already came up with- if I am repeating what someone said then just take it as I am agreeing with them. Militus and Grave were both very close to eachother in votes, so if someone from their mafia wanted to bail them out it would make sense to vote for the other person. Using that logic you can speculate on anyone who voted for either of them, really. I will throw out the possibility that Trijugate voted for Militus to help Grave. If Trijugate did not give a valid reason to vote the way he did this would enforce this idea, I am too lazy to look into it further though. If Grave turns out to be mafia I would also look more into Haine. Feel free to tear this apart, it is quite probable I am too tired to see blatant holes. Apply this to Coro and Soren then, since they all tried with all their effort to not get Grave lynched. Though, I doubt it team-mates would back on each other so openly. It basically give us the list of their team members if one of them happens to be a mafia. :/ Anyway, I analised again Grave's statements and whatever and I can actually think of just one role [ that isn't among the ones with unknown abilities ] - which can prove himself even from conversion. And this basically, disassembles my theory on why Coro was defending Grave so much. :/ |
Feb 12, 2015 12:21 AM
#2179
Juzzywuzzy said: SodaWithYoda said: Both the people that died on night 1 were voting for Trijugate, Coincidence? Probably… Of course the question remains who killed who? Did the phantom Troupe kill the cop? Possibly How can you explain Iasuru’s death? Well, look at the description… its pretty short, “Someone chopped his head off” not a whole lot of thought in that one so it may have been another killing role that doesn’t belong to the two mafia factions. I think that the two mafia factions killed the townies, and another role killed the chimera ant Just a little bit of speculation and that I don't think so about this. Look closely at what else Pyro has said: The_Pyromaani said: While Cheetu was laughing. Some chopped his head off. Cheetu: Eeh... Person: Finally you stopped. Iasuru - Cheetu (Thief) was killed. Doesn't this sound like some sort of vendetta? It's as if to say that they have the same goal and yet they're enemies. Don't you think it's a clash of two mafia factions? Cheetu is the fastest Chimera Ant. In one episode, the Hunters had trouble catching up with him – I think that’s why Pyro wrote it like that, it’s a reference to the anime. I think some people actually haven’t watched HxH, so they’re kind of in a disadvantage. About the 3 roles with unknown abilites: Ging might be a jack-of-all-trades player, similar to Bulma from the DBZ game. He also might have an ability similar to Goku's role, someone who can challenge another player (that would fit the Chairman Election arc from HxH). Tonpa is a manipulative character in the anime. He tried to poison people by giving them certain drinks, in the older version he made people hallucinate. Probably has an ability that sabotages others. Might also be a traitor-role, he tried to make others fail the Hunter exam. Pokkle is an archer who uses poisonous arrows. |
coromandelFeb 12, 2015 12:24 AM
Feb 12, 2015 12:23 AM
#2180
Brynhildr said: s3bEg said: -MidnightOwl- said: The_Pyromaani said: [b]Votes so far... DoubleC - 1 (MrHawkeye) Llafos - 2 (-blonde-, coromandel) -MidnightOwl- - 1 (grave_robber) grave_robber - 5 (-MidnightOwl-, s3bEg, LucianRoy, Llafos, turtlebandit) ChaosSaviour - 1 (Lambtron) Soren333 - 1 (Suzune-chan) s3bEg - 1 (Verumir) -Haine - 1 (NessieFynn) militus - 7 (Asunyan, x_at_home, Juzzywuzzy, Soren333, shap111, Haine-, trijugate) No lynch - 1 (Matoro_Mahri) People not voting - 18 Jackrito, Brynhildr, PandaCake, militus, Himikoi, sasayamei, LoveandHate91, SodaWithYoda, meruledaworld, Shadowsnake777, ChaosSaviour, Karote, SuzakuTsubasa, Lambtron, MarvTheMan, Smurphinator, nyancat2506, Iasuru. Time until phase change! Timer This is when trijugate voted for militus.[/b][/b] Let me throw in some half assed, 3 AM, analysis someone probably already came up with- if I am repeating what someone said then just take it as I am agreeing with them. Militus and Grave were both very close to eachother in votes, so if someone from their mafia wanted to bail them out it would make sense to vote for the other person. Using that logic you can speculate on anyone who voted for either of them, really. I will throw out the possibility that Trijugate voted for Militus to help Grave. If Trijugate did not give a valid reason to vote the way he did this would enforce this idea, I am too lazy to look into it further though. If Grave turns out to be mafia I would also look more into Haine. Feel free to tear this apart, it is quite probable I am too tired to see blatant holes. Apply this to Coro and Soren then, since they all tried with all their effort to not get Grave lynched. Though, I doubt it team-mates would back on each other so openly. It basically give us the list of their team members if one of them happens to be a mafia. :/ Anyway, I analised again Grave's statements and whatever and I can actually think of just one role [ that isn't among the ones with unknown abilities ] - which can prove himself even from conversion. And this basically, disassembles my theory on why Coro was defending Grave so much. :/ grave_robber said: I have several things on my mind, not about to share them with you though ^^ I didn't threaten anyone, I merely informed saya-chan of my intention of going after her on day 2, why are you so worried about that? Scared you're going to lose control of the game? Poor lucian, can't control every player and dictate their every action. A couple other little things to use against Grave if it ever comes to it is how antagonistic she is being towards a confirmed town (and someone who I have a faint feeling is town). Just food for thought, like Lucian said, nothing to make a case over. |
Feb 12, 2015 12:32 AM
#2181
s3bEg said: Brynhildr said: s3bEg said: -MidnightOwl- said: The_Pyromaani said: [b]Votes so far... DoubleC - 1 (MrHawkeye) Llafos - 2 (-blonde-, coromandel) -MidnightOwl- - 1 (grave_robber) grave_robber - 5 (-MidnightOwl-, s3bEg, LucianRoy, Llafos, turtlebandit) ChaosSaviour - 1 (Lambtron) Soren333 - 1 (Suzune-chan) s3bEg - 1 (Verumir) -Haine - 1 (NessieFynn) militus - 7 (Asunyan, x_at_home, Juzzywuzzy, Soren333, shap111, Haine-, trijugate) No lynch - 1 (Matoro_Mahri) People not voting - 18 Jackrito, Brynhildr, PandaCake, militus, Himikoi, sasayamei, LoveandHate91, SodaWithYoda, meruledaworld, Shadowsnake777, ChaosSaviour, Karote, SuzakuTsubasa, Lambtron, MarvTheMan, Smurphinator, nyancat2506, Iasuru. Time until phase change! Timer This is when trijugate voted for militus.[/b][/b] Let me throw in some half assed, 3 AM, analysis someone probably already came up with- if I am repeating what someone said then just take it as I am agreeing with them. Militus and Grave were both very close to eachother in votes, so if someone from their mafia wanted to bail them out it would make sense to vote for the other person. Using that logic you can speculate on anyone who voted for either of them, really. I will throw out the possibility that Trijugate voted for Militus to help Grave. If Trijugate did not give a valid reason to vote the way he did this would enforce this idea, I am too lazy to look into it further though. If Grave turns out to be mafia I would also look more into Haine. Feel free to tear this apart, it is quite probable I am too tired to see blatant holes. Apply this to Coro and Soren then, since they all tried with all their effort to not get Grave lynched. Though, I doubt it team-mates would back on each other so openly. It basically give us the list of their team members if one of them happens to be a mafia. :/ Anyway, I analised again Grave's statements and whatever and I can actually think of just one role [ that isn't among the ones with unknown abilities ] - which can prove himself even from conversion. And this basically, disassembles my theory on why Coro was defending Grave so much. :/ grave_robber said: I have several things on my mind, not about to share them with you though ^^ I didn't threaten anyone, I merely informed saya-chan of my intention of going after her on day 2, why are you so worried about that? Scared you're going to lose control of the game? Poor lucian, can't control every player and dictate their every action. A couple other little things to use against Grave if it ever comes to it is how antagonistic she is being towards a confirmed town (and someone who I have a faint feeling is town). Just food for thought, like Lucian said, nothing to make a case over. I think I know what everything on her statement means - lol First line: might have something to do with her role, and from her exacts words she's able to both prove her role and that she's not been converted. Second line: the attack on Saya on day 1 served a specific purpose, if I read it correctly. Actually if Grave still suspects her for lurking or whatever needs to vote for her or the fighting might lose the charm and its purpose all of a sudden, and make it seem just a ploy, without actual meaning atm. Third line: both me and her have something against dictatorships-like games. But that usually happens when there's a mayor [ leader of the town and only confirmed role ]. Although, the *little girl* [ Lucian actual role ] is basically the same, with the exception that he's not the formal leader nor immune to conversion. |
Feb 12, 2015 12:33 AM
#2182
i'm back from school Summary pls |
"This is boring...I'm bored..." |
Feb 12, 2015 12:34 AM
#2183
ChaosSaviour said: i'm back from school Summary pls Read it yourself. -.- |
Feb 12, 2015 12:35 AM
#2184
ChaosSaviour said: i'm back from school Summary pls S**t went down EDIT: And i became active |
Feb 12, 2015 12:38 AM
#2185
coromandel said: ChaosSaviour said: i'm back from school Summary pls Read it yourself. -.- |
Feb 12, 2015 12:38 AM
#2186
Lambtron said: coromandel said: ChaosSaviour said: i'm back from school Summary pls Read it yourself. -.- xD |
Feb 12, 2015 12:39 AM
#2187
ty for rough feel on the 3 un-clarified characters btw ^^ Hunter X Sh*tpile isn't my thing |
Feb 12, 2015 12:40 AM
#2188
Brynhildr said: Matoro_Mahri said: I have seen almost nothing from coromandel. Do you happen to have any interactions between him and grave linked somewhere? Coro is a girl XD Well, the only game I'm sure they have interacted somewhat is the Zombie V.1 [ and the Zombie V.2 - but I died early and didn't check the game often ]. Anyway, my conclusion derives from the fact that Coro does never lean with [ protective actions ] such a great certainty and aggressiveness [ day 1 approach also was kinda unusual :/ ] toward other players. So there should be a reason behind this behaviour of hers. Should be done soon with backreading and my vote. I’m usually more quiet, that’s true. But when I’m convinced someone is town, I can get pretty protective of someone. Grave seemed very much like a townie to me during day 1 and I didn’t really get why she had the most votes. After that, her actions became a little extreme, so I’m not that sure anymore. I still wouldn’t vote for her now though. It’s possible that Grave is the Jester, though for me she still seems town for the most part. And I partly understand why she suspects Saya. Like Karote, Saya voted last minute for someone even though she hardly posted anything before that. And then she said something about Grave being not very analytic/helpful, which was odd as well (because it’s simply not true). |
Feb 12, 2015 12:41 AM
#2189
Lambtron said: ty for rough feel on the 3 un-clarified characters btw ^^ Hunter X Sh*tpile isn't my thing You're welcome. xD I'm off now, I have a test in an hour... |
Feb 12, 2015 12:42 AM
#2190
Lambtron said: ty for rough feel on the 3 un-clarified characters btw ^^ Hunter X Sh*tpile isn't my thing Hunter x Hunter is great! |
~I am just one sadist who supports friends~ |
Feb 12, 2015 12:43 AM
#2191
you guys are cruel. |
"This is boring...I'm bored..." |
Feb 12, 2015 12:45 AM
#2192
Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. |
Feb 12, 2015 12:48 AM
#2193
s3bEg said: Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. What reasons do I have to do so and well.... before that, defend? |
Feb 12, 2015 12:50 AM
#2194
grave_robber said: @ChaosSaviour, you like to lurk, but it makes me think you're a bad guy so come out and play. i was sleeping when you said this |
"This is boring...I'm bored..." |
Feb 12, 2015 12:52 AM
#2195
Lambtron said: s3bEg said: Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. What reasons do I have to do so and well.... before that, defend? If you don't defend yourself as a townie to me then I will just go ahead and assume you are mafia or third party and waste more of my time investigating you. |
Feb 12, 2015 12:57 AM
#2196
coromandel said: Brynhildr said: Matoro_Mahri said: I have seen almost nothing from coromandel. Do you happen to have any interactions between him and grave linked somewhere? Coro is a girl XD Well, the only game I'm sure they have interacted somewhat is the Zombie V.1 [ and the Zombie V.2 - but I died early and didn't check the game often ]. Anyway, my conclusion derives from the fact that Coro does never lean with [ protective actions ] such a great certainty and aggressiveness [ day 1 approach also was kinda unusual :/ ] toward other players. So there should be a reason behind this behaviour of hers. Should be done soon with backreading and my vote. I’m usually more quiet, that’s true. But when I’m convinced someone is town, I can get pretty protective of someone. Grave seemed very much like a townie to me during day 1 and I didn’t really get why she had the most votes. After that, her actions became a little extreme, so I’m not that sure anymore. I still wouldn’t vote for her now though. It’s possible that Grave is the Jester, though for me she still seems town for the most part. And I partly understand why she suspects Saya. Like Karote, Saya voted last minute for someone even though she hardly posted anything before that. And then she said something about Grave being not very analytic/helpful, which was odd as well (because it’s simply not true). I admitt at some point on day 1 I was kinda frustrated because I had not read everything yet and just throwing accusations or even defending was impossible to me. I had nothing to base my assumptions on. Then Grave did attack me on the fact I was inactive, saying she did a lot of important analisis and what not. Well, I read everything today, and I can safely say that to me, other than the fact she seemed more pro-town than the others who were on the verge of getting lynched, I didn't notice anything so worthy of getting her protected like it happened by you, Haine and Soren. What was that convinced you so much she was town? O_o Did I miss something? Saya just got defensive all of a sudden, though she posted her list of analisis on all players - which is the same she did on our first game. The only thing which stood out was her vote pattern and on that I do agree. Though, people noticed it just when Grave called Saya in the game and her lurking [ if I'm not wrong ] :/ |
Feb 12, 2015 12:58 AM
#2197
s3bEg said: Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. Bait is not going to be taken |
Feb 12, 2015 1:01 AM
#2198
s3bEg said: Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. There aren't - lol. He acts scummy even when he has town roles. I just like having him around - it adds some spice to the game, and he's a good bait if you wanna catch some mafia, since he's an easy target to get lynched. |
Feb 12, 2015 1:02 AM
#2199
s3bEg said: Lambtron said: s3bEg said: Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. What reasons do I have to do so and well.... before that, defend? If you don't defend yourself as a townie to me then I will just go ahead and assume you are mafia or third party and waste more of my time investigating you. You don't defend yourself against nothing, and I don't think defending yourself as a townie is something to be done until a vital point in time. Giving un-needed information to scum isn't really something I'd prefer to do ^^ |
Feb 12, 2015 1:03 AM
#2200
SodaWithYoda said: s3bEg said: Hrmmm. Can someone give me a few reasons to either trust or suspect Lamb? I would like you to defend yourself too lamb. I am working a case against you but I actually like you as a person. Bait is not going to be taken Which is unfortunate for both Lamb and I. |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated MEMBER Posts! v1 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )SoulEaterQUEEN - Mar 26, 2016 |
1990 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:42 PM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3811 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:42 PM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8751 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:41 PM |
|
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2867 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:41 PM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1160 |
by Serafos
»»
Aug 17, 9:41 PM |