DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE. ---------------------------------------- So Kyoutarou managed to use a bit of his powers at the right time....no surprise there. It looks like they resumed the play on stage. Put some damn clothes on Pretty song though this episode. I figured they might go for some kind of happy ending here; felt forced though. |
 |
| I was about to ask what happened to Kodachi since it was looking like she was gonna become a shepherd and be forgotten, which woulda been a major bummer, but I guess since she'll be the shepherd for their school she'll now somehow NOT be forgotten and live with her brother? I really didn't think they explained that too well. I'm still left feeling like Kodachi shoulda been the female lead instead of Shirasaki, she definitely had more screen time, and her reveal to be his sister felt tacked on for plot convenience. Aside from that I also had trouble investing in the conflict with the student council vice president. The president's given reason for not stopping her earlier felt extremely asinine, and considering the only thing that really came from it was an apology it just felt really unnecessary. If the show was trying to make a point through Shirasaki's speech it also fell flat for me. Ultimately I think this series was pretty forgettable, 6/10. |
| Vice president bitch got REKT! I rejoiced so much when she got busted in front everyone, even though Kakei asspulled there quite hard. Since when he learned the art of teleportation as a Shepherd? The main Shepherd (Nanai-san) also asspulled a good deal. When he told Kakei he'll be forgotten by people since his book has been burned, it seemed like Kakei had no choice but to forcibly become a Shepherd. But towards the end, he gave into Kakei stubbornness and restored his book like all that talk about being a Shepherd didn't mean a thing at all. The speech was friggin' boring, yet it took almost half of the episode. Kakei only said it was good just to keep her in his harem. Somehow, Kodachi can now hang around everyone while being a Shepherd. I didn't get that properly. Is the Sherpherd department making up new rules at the last moments? Below average episode to end the Rail Wars! of this season. 5/10, only because of bro Ikkei and his substitute acting in the play. |
 |
| Well, I liked it. Really not bad series, 7/10 for me. Happy ending, but it was predictable. I don't regret time spent on watching this show. |
| Dub = fake crap. Always. |
| average show but it was a fun ride. |
| Oh god who are you people? |
| It was nice to see that Minafes was really successful and how the vice president got caught by Kodachi and Kakei. That being the event that ends Minafes! I was happy that Kodachi got what she wanted to become. Kakei losing his right to be a shepherd if he keeps up his mindset. The speech was decent and a wrap-up for the things they did together. I still can't shed this vibe on that Nanai is Kakei's dad or something. Mentioning the stubbornness and sin just really hinted towards being related to Kakei at least. Shepherd having rules, but the ones willing to break rules for the better are perhaps the ideal of being a shepherd. Still feeling the sympathy as a relative of sorts to restore his book. I sort of liked this and was glad that Kodachi stayed even though this last episode wasn't that nice of a "tie everything down" episode but I did enjoy it. 7/10 would be a fair score, a somewhat below average anime though I did enjoy it. |
 |
| One less annoying thing off my list. 5/10 |
 |
| The end was average, but it was satisfying. It avoided ending in any of the girl's ending and even a harem ending to an open route, the safest one. I'm really curious if the Boss is actually Nagi and Kakei's dad? It was a fun ride, it was well written and nicely paced storyline. It definitely entertained me from start to finish. I think it isn't too much if I gave the whole series an 8/10. |
Jarkzy said: Well it is more into Kakei and Shirasaki than the others so I consider this to be a more Shirasaki ending. So it was a harem ending at the end? How dissapointing That end card though. Not too bad. Definitely going to play the VN soon to see if it's constant with the VN. Magito said: Same. Any VN players know the answer?I'm really curious if the Boss is actually Nagi and Kakei's dad? |
  |
| Even tho it's clear who won they ended with an open ending A well not that it really matters. The anime was pretty nice to watch with all the things going on and it was a nice ending. |
| -Vice Prez got PWNED. -"Large breasts are merely lumps of fat. But I love them!" LOL -Skipped the speech. overall average but rate it 7/10 to be generous. |
 |
P0K3Gaming said: Magito said: Same. Any VN players know the answer?I'm really curious if the Boss is actually Nagi and Kakei's dad? Yea it's revealed in the VN. |
 |
| The expected happy harem ending. I've gotten so used to it so I won't bother complaining. Although I would've preferred if Kakei had at least kissed Shirasaki or vice versa. Overall, the anime wasn't bad. It was quite good. I liked how they stuck to the plot for the majority of the anime. It was good. They didn't waste much time on individual character development unlike Inou-Battle. The only complain i have is that the girls weren't kawaii. Nope. Not at all. Tamamo was the cutest and even she wasn't all that would rape type. It didn't interest me at first and I planned on dropping it halfway through before starting. Changed my mind when I reached the halfway point. Was not dissappointed. Not a masterpiece or a spectacular anime, but very enjoyable. No regrets here. |
Jarkzy said: So it was a harem ending at the end? How dissapointing I was very very surprised that it was a harem ending. I really thought he was going to pick someone at the end. Oh well |
| Moral of the anime: If you're a male, and you want females to notice you, READ A BOOK AROUND THEM!!!!!! |
y123y said: Moral of the anime: If you're a male, and you want females to notice you, READ A BOOK AROUND THEM!!!!!! In real life though, you need to read/watch Yaoi/Shounen Ai series if you wanna catch their attention. |
|
Swerv said: One less annoying thing off my list. 5/10 Same. |
 |
| So, looks like that ticket kept the guy from being forgotten. Not a bad ending. |
| The show wasn't bad, but the ending left way too many questions open. Am I the only one disappointed he didn't become a shepperd? 6/10, one more off the list! |
| shirasaki was too innocent for my taste. kodachi was awesome. i stayed w/ this show cuz kodachi was in it. 8/10 overall |
| Kodachi best girl to the very end |
  |
| Conclusion a bit lame >___>" , Still enjoy it overall. 7/10 |
 |
| The ending in the manga wasn't like this :P Bah |
HESTIA   APPROVES |
| Hmm. A decent harem ending. Kodachi for life though <3 |
| This anime started slow, was inconsistent at first and its first half was just okay. Things became really interesting once we reached the 2nd half, some of the episodes were really good. I liked the ED, too. Wish Kodachi and Kakei could become shepherds together tho, would've been more satisfying. 8/10, very decent. |
 |
zerorequiem_ said: P0K3Gaming said: Same. Any VN players know the answer? Yea it's revealed in the VN. Got that impression when he recovered the book as penance for his selfishness. 6/10 nothing special. Some cute romance scenes, the Shepherd supernatural stuff was kind of (kind of) interesting but nothing special in the end. Harem ending although it was a happy transformation for MC. The speech at the end of Minafes was weirdly passionate imo. Kodachi thighs that's all I'll remember. |
| The girls were asking for a reward, too bad they didn't show Kyoutarou giving it to them. |
| eh this show was a okay time killer and it did have some funny moments 6/10 for the harem ending |
 |
| an okay ending to an okay anime. defiantly wasn't good but it wasn't bad either and i enjoyed it. 4/5 for the episode, 6/10 for the anime. |
| Loved it! 8/10 is the score I give this anime! |
| So glad that I'm not a huge manga reader, because the manga readers WHINE WAY TOO MUCH and have to RUIN every adapted anime for the ANIME ONLY WATCHERS! |
| Did you really just turn those fantastic vocals into BGM? How extremely disappointing. |
| I guess I could call that a happy ending for the guys at the Happy Project. The Minafes was a huge success indeed. Everyone gave their very best. At the end, Kakei was fired from Shepherd job. Kodachi got to become the Shepherd for their school. Everyone was happy in the end at least. It was fine, but not really what I call good. A solid 6/10. |
| Way too much hate in here, tse tse~ :P As someone who hasn't played the VN yet and just witnessed this anime as a story itself - I loved it. I thought the speech gave a good 'Yep, this is the end. The story of this little group of weaklings is done.'-feeling and wasn't boring at all to me. I haven't thought about that guy being his dad actually, even though it wasn't a big twist in the 1st place. In my opinion, it's not even an open ending, where do u all get this idea from? ^^ Shirasaki and Kakei got together in my book, which is fine by me but that's up to you~ I didn't got dissappointed by that ending at all, I mean.. the last episodes of some animes in this season fu**'d it up gooood in comparison to Daitoshokan. ^^ I support his decision to stay true to himself instead of changing his opinions just to become a shepard. I mean, the intention behind the speech etc is that u don't need super-powers (like the shepards) to make ppl happy, so what would have been interesting about Kakei being a shepard in the end~ What started out as an ordinary harem comedy thingy become an interesting light-hearted little story that I enjoyed a lot. Only 2 things I could criticize - I hate harem, so that was a bit annoying at some points + those mood-changes from serious to comedy in the blink of an eye were a bit disappointing sometimes. Fu** it, I'll give it a 9, go hard or go home~ ( ‘з’)/ |
| Well it's an average romcom show, it was a good ride. :3 |
 |
| It was pretty average, honestly. Kakei very predictably did not continue as shepherd and went back to the neutral harem... 5/10. Cat was the best character. |
| I have no strong feelings for this show one way or another. I presume the card which she kept was a prayer? 5/10. |
| Well we had a good ending, something fulfilling at least. The series was average, nothing groundbreaking. The Shepard system at least gave it some flair but in general i'm giving it a flat 6.0 out of 10. I'm honestly thinking this show should of had some more fan-service haha. |
  |
| what a good episode although kakei teleporting them into the presentation god damn. it sucks how nanai just returns kakei book saying "maybe this will atone my sin" ( I wish I knew what it was...) neat cameo from their spin off game! |
 |
| I wasn't expecting that but in the end this episode showed an important decision in their lifes. Kakei-kun earn his book again but he doesn't know that and Kodachi became a shepherd. So nice that everyone got their own wishes realized today... :) I'm can't say which mark, I'll give to this anime. It's an impossible task between a 9 and one 10..., but I'm glad that had a happy ending! :D |
| Maloween 2017 Main Candies   |
| I enjoyed this anime :) i hope there is OVA about Gizaemon. Nice ending 8/10 |
 |
| Dunno why people bashing on the show, I really enjoyed watching this anime. Give it a 7/10 :) |
 |
| Almost everything I enjoyed about this show came from Kodachi being in it. Best girl and character in general, made the show for me. |
| was a happy end :D decent anime I gave it a 7/10 |
 |
| It was a little bittersweet. This was based on a Visual Novel, right? Does it continues after this? It was a good episode, and it was an harem ending after all (males included). The anime suffered because of the slow start. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 17, 2014 |
52 |
by ViSpace
»»
Jun 19, 1:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 10, 2014 |
55 |
by ViSpace
»»
Jun 18, 8:06 PM |
|
Poll: » Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Dec 3, 2014 |
67 |
by ViSpace
»»
Jun 18, 7:36 PM |
|
Poll: » Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai Episode 8 DiscussionStark700 - Nov 26, 2014 |
38 |
by ViSpace
»»
Jun 18, 8:58 AM |
|
Poll: » Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Nov 19, 2014 |
76 |
by ViSpace
»»
Jun 18, 8:31 AM |