May 17th, 2020
Toucanbird's 40 Favorite Anime Of The Decade (2010-19)
Man, it sure took me a while to get around to this, but I've finally compiled the list of my 40 favorite anime that aired between 2010-19. This was not an easy task. I didn't even know if I wanted to do this as a "top" list or how I wanted to go about it. I didn't even know how I wanted to go about a cutoff (10? 25? 50?). I also didn't know if I wanted to count separate seasons...but ultimately, this is the rules structure that I went with to narrow down my list...
1. Anime must have debuted between 2010 and 2019.
2. All seasons will be included in the same entry, regardless of sequel airdate.
3. No sequels of anime that debuted prior to 2010 will be included.
As I was piecing this list together, I struggled to determine a cutoff, but I found 40 to be a strong number to cutoff at. It felt like I was leaving off a lot of great anime if I made it 25, but at the same time, it felt like if I went with 50, I'd be including anime that I'm not sure I'd consider "great."
To conclude this summary, I'll be listing the anime based off of when it debuted instead of how I scored it...so it's not really a "top" list or "countdown" list...it's simply listed based on when it made its debut. Now, with no further ado, here is my list..
Katanagatari
Air Date: Jan. 26, 2010 - Dec. 11, 2010
MAL Score: 8.39
Thoughts: I actually watched this after the entry I listed after this one, but still, it was definitely worth it to go back and watch this anime that began the decade. Katanagatari has one of the most art styles of any anime I've ever watched. It was also one of the more compelling romance anime I've seen since it does a nice job of blending action and romance. The only real downside to this masterpiece is I personally wasn't the biggest fan of the ending. It wasn't terrible by any means, but it wasn't quite what I was hoping for.
Angel Beats
Air Date: Apr. 3, 2010 - Jun. 26, 2010
MAL Score: 8.21
Thoughts: Man, what a way to start the decade. I'll just flat out admit that watching Angel Beats completely changed how I viewed anime. Previously, I was mostly just an action/shounen anime fan, but after a friend recommended this to me, I gave it a watch and absolutely loved it. It really allowed me to broaden my horizons to watch more of the drama/romance genres, which I'd now even argue are my favorite genres in anime. Even 10 years later, Angel Beats is still one of my favorite anime of all-time.
Seitokai Yakuindomo
Air Date: Jul. 4, 2010 - Sep. 26, 2010, Jan. 4, 2014 - Mar. 30, 2014
MAL Scores: 7.63, 7.77
Thoughts: While I wouldn't call the comedy genres one of my "favorites" when it comes to anime, there are a handful that I look back on quite fondly. Seitokai Yakuindomo is definitely one of the most memorable comedies in the genre I've watched because of how hilarious it was in its raunchiness. When it comes to sexual humor, you will be hard pressed to find an anime that's funnier than Seitokai Yakuindomo. I couldn't believe some of the things and situations it joked about and I was continuously amazed at how it could turn every situation sexual. The funny thing is, there was little to no "fan service" in this show. The sexual content was purely within the script writing...which is absolutely amazing to see how the writers managed to pull that off.
Gosick
Air Date: Jan. 8, 2011 - Jul. 2, 2011
MAL Score: 8.13
Thoughts: I'll flat out admit that I'm a huge Sherlock Holmes fan. I'll even confess that I have a collection of all of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes. I think Gosick is truly the first anime I've ever watched that felt "inspired" by Sherlock Holmes and even now, I can't help but look back fondly at how masterfully this series handled the mystery genre. This anime hooked me from its first episode and it was a wild ride from start to finish. However, much like Katanagatari, the only thing I didn't like about this anime was its ending. I thought it had a pretty disappointing finish...so much so that I stewed on my thoughts about it for a couple years...but after a while, I managed to swallow my pride and consider it a great series.
(Rest to be published later)
1. Anime must have debuted between 2010 and 2019.
2. All seasons will be included in the same entry, regardless of sequel airdate.
3. No sequels of anime that debuted prior to 2010 will be included.
As I was piecing this list together, I struggled to determine a cutoff, but I found 40 to be a strong number to cutoff at. It felt like I was leaving off a lot of great anime if I made it 25, but at the same time, it felt like if I went with 50, I'd be including anime that I'm not sure I'd consider "great."
To conclude this summary, I'll be listing the anime based off of when it debuted instead of how I scored it...so it's not really a "top" list or "countdown" list...it's simply listed based on when it made its debut. Now, with no further ado, here is my list..
Katanagatari
Air Date: Jan. 26, 2010 - Dec. 11, 2010
MAL Score: 8.39
Thoughts: I actually watched this after the entry I listed after this one, but still, it was definitely worth it to go back and watch this anime that began the decade. Katanagatari has one of the most art styles of any anime I've ever watched. It was also one of the more compelling romance anime I've seen since it does a nice job of blending action and romance. The only real downside to this masterpiece is I personally wasn't the biggest fan of the ending. It wasn't terrible by any means, but it wasn't quite what I was hoping for.
Angel Beats
Air Date: Apr. 3, 2010 - Jun. 26, 2010
MAL Score: 8.21
Thoughts: Man, what a way to start the decade. I'll just flat out admit that watching Angel Beats completely changed how I viewed anime. Previously, I was mostly just an action/shounen anime fan, but after a friend recommended this to me, I gave it a watch and absolutely loved it. It really allowed me to broaden my horizons to watch more of the drama/romance genres, which I'd now even argue are my favorite genres in anime. Even 10 years later, Angel Beats is still one of my favorite anime of all-time.
Seitokai Yakuindomo
Air Date: Jul. 4, 2010 - Sep. 26, 2010, Jan. 4, 2014 - Mar. 30, 2014
MAL Scores: 7.63, 7.77
Thoughts: While I wouldn't call the comedy genres one of my "favorites" when it comes to anime, there are a handful that I look back on quite fondly. Seitokai Yakuindomo is definitely one of the most memorable comedies in the genre I've watched because of how hilarious it was in its raunchiness. When it comes to sexual humor, you will be hard pressed to find an anime that's funnier than Seitokai Yakuindomo. I couldn't believe some of the things and situations it joked about and I was continuously amazed at how it could turn every situation sexual. The funny thing is, there was little to no "fan service" in this show. The sexual content was purely within the script writing...which is absolutely amazing to see how the writers managed to pull that off.
Gosick
Air Date: Jan. 8, 2011 - Jul. 2, 2011
MAL Score: 8.13
Thoughts: I'll flat out admit that I'm a huge Sherlock Holmes fan. I'll even confess that I have a collection of all of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes. I think Gosick is truly the first anime I've ever watched that felt "inspired" by Sherlock Holmes and even now, I can't help but look back fondly at how masterfully this series handled the mystery genre. This anime hooked me from its first episode and it was a wild ride from start to finish. However, much like Katanagatari, the only thing I didn't like about this anime was its ending. I thought it had a pretty disappointing finish...so much so that I stewed on my thoughts about it for a couple years...but after a while, I managed to swallow my pride and consider it a great series.
(Rest to be published later)
Posted by Toucanbird | May 17, 2020 2:59 AM | 0 comments
October 17th, 2015
Indierant: Undertale
As a gamer, it was been a bizarre experience to look back through my chronicled history of gaming to see how everything has played out.
I never used to be much of an "indie gamer." In fact, I somewhat scoffed at the thought of even playing an indie game a few years ago. I wondered, "why would I play such a low-quality game? In what way would a game like that be better than a big budget game?"
Words truly spoken by an ignorant fool. As someone that knew nothing about indie games and websites like Steam, I never truly knew the beauty that indie games possessed.
As soon as it started, I was an immediate fan of Game Grumps. Even when Game Grumps had that "transitional" phase with JonTron leaving and Danny Sexbang joining, I kept my passion for Game Grumps. The one thing that concerned me at the time was adding Steam Train, as I never considered myself an indie gamer, so I wondered what the point of watching indie game let's plays? As it turned out, I discovered this series left one of the biggest impacts on me as a gamer.
As I watched Ross, Danny, Arin, and Barry (the three primary people that show up on Steam Train w/Ross) play these indie games, I discovered there was more to these games that meet the eye. I checked out other indie games played by other let's players and that's when I discovered games like To The Moon, Shovel Knight, Bastion, Transistor, A Bird Story, Castle Crashers, Battleblock Theatre. I could go on-and-on because to this day, To The Moon and Dust: An Elysian Tail are two of my favorite games of all-time, let alone indie games (and as soon as I play Shovel Knight, that might be added in there).
I started playing indie games about 10 months ago. Just before Christmas, I started playing Dust: An Elysian Tail, my first indie game play through. It was simply marvelous. I poured 29 hours into Dust and it was 29 INCREDIBLY enjoyable hours. After I finished Dust, I started playing what would be one of my all-time favorite video games period...To The Moon. This game possessed the most heart and soul of any game I've ever played. It had extremely well-written characters and a soundtrack to die for. In fact, the concept itself is truly marvelous. Even as a short game with what I'd call "stale gameplay," I consider it more of an "interactive experience" more so than a game. Despite it's "game" status, it left an emotional impact on me that I can never forget.
Since then, I've played a handful of other indie games, but lately, one has come to the forefront and completely captured my attention (as if you don't know what game that is by now...it's right in the title...Undertale). I'm sure many people have heard the positive reviews about Undertale. Part of the reason why I got so heavily involved with it is due to it being played on LP's like Commander Holly Plays, Steam Train, and Cry Plays. After seeing their playthroughs, I decided to buy the game and give it a chance.
All I will say is that I have an incredible amount of admiration for Toby Fox for what he has put together. This game takes some of the most conceptually creative concepts in games with a well-crafted, character-driven story that has me completely amazed. If we're talking graphics, of course this doesn't hold up with the likes of AAA games...but...this game has something that those games don't...heart. I have a hard time putting into words what it's like actually having feelings and concerns toward an 8-bit character...but that is what Toby was able to do. He was able to make a game that you can develop an emotional attachment toward the "quirky" cast of characters in this game.
I won't say much else for the sake of "spoilers," but this is a game that I feel everyone at some point must play. Despite it's rather "cheap" look, this game is worth every penny. The amount of detail that Toby put into this game is unlike any game I've ever played before and I can't recommend this game enough. It really should put into perspective the impact our choices make and the consequences we have to deal with in regards to those choices.
I never used to be much of an "indie gamer." In fact, I somewhat scoffed at the thought of even playing an indie game a few years ago. I wondered, "why would I play such a low-quality game? In what way would a game like that be better than a big budget game?"
Words truly spoken by an ignorant fool. As someone that knew nothing about indie games and websites like Steam, I never truly knew the beauty that indie games possessed.
As soon as it started, I was an immediate fan of Game Grumps. Even when Game Grumps had that "transitional" phase with JonTron leaving and Danny Sexbang joining, I kept my passion for Game Grumps. The one thing that concerned me at the time was adding Steam Train, as I never considered myself an indie gamer, so I wondered what the point of watching indie game let's plays? As it turned out, I discovered this series left one of the biggest impacts on me as a gamer.
As I watched Ross, Danny, Arin, and Barry (the three primary people that show up on Steam Train w/Ross) play these indie games, I discovered there was more to these games that meet the eye. I checked out other indie games played by other let's players and that's when I discovered games like To The Moon, Shovel Knight, Bastion, Transistor, A Bird Story, Castle Crashers, Battleblock Theatre. I could go on-and-on because to this day, To The Moon and Dust: An Elysian Tail are two of my favorite games of all-time, let alone indie games (and as soon as I play Shovel Knight, that might be added in there).
I started playing indie games about 10 months ago. Just before Christmas, I started playing Dust: An Elysian Tail, my first indie game play through. It was simply marvelous. I poured 29 hours into Dust and it was 29 INCREDIBLY enjoyable hours. After I finished Dust, I started playing what would be one of my all-time favorite video games period...To The Moon. This game possessed the most heart and soul of any game I've ever played. It had extremely well-written characters and a soundtrack to die for. In fact, the concept itself is truly marvelous. Even as a short game with what I'd call "stale gameplay," I consider it more of an "interactive experience" more so than a game. Despite it's "game" status, it left an emotional impact on me that I can never forget.
Since then, I've played a handful of other indie games, but lately, one has come to the forefront and completely captured my attention (as if you don't know what game that is by now...it's right in the title...Undertale). I'm sure many people have heard the positive reviews about Undertale. Part of the reason why I got so heavily involved with it is due to it being played on LP's like Commander Holly Plays, Steam Train, and Cry Plays. After seeing their playthroughs, I decided to buy the game and give it a chance.
All I will say is that I have an incredible amount of admiration for Toby Fox for what he has put together. This game takes some of the most conceptually creative concepts in games with a well-crafted, character-driven story that has me completely amazed. If we're talking graphics, of course this doesn't hold up with the likes of AAA games...but...this game has something that those games don't...heart. I have a hard time putting into words what it's like actually having feelings and concerns toward an 8-bit character...but that is what Toby was able to do. He was able to make a game that you can develop an emotional attachment toward the "quirky" cast of characters in this game.
I won't say much else for the sake of "spoilers," but this is a game that I feel everyone at some point must play. Despite it's rather "cheap" look, this game is worth every penny. The amount of detail that Toby put into this game is unlike any game I've ever played before and I can't recommend this game enough. It really should put into perspective the impact our choices make and the consequences we have to deal with in regards to those choices.
Posted by Toucanbird | Oct 17, 2015 2:05 AM | 0 comments
June 9th, 2015
Top 10 Anime Of The Year (June Edition)
Anime Relations: Non Non Biyori Repeat, Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku, Kekkai Sensen, Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki, Re-Kan!, Owari no Seraph, God Eater, Aldnoah.Zero Part 2, Tokyo Ghoul √A, Hibike! Euphonium, K: Return of Kings, Ore Monogatari!!, Kyoukai no Rinne, Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo, Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works 2nd Season, Owari no Seraph: Nagoya Kessen-hen, Charlotte, Koukaku Kidoutai Arise: Alternative Architecture, Sakurako-san no Ashimoto ni wa Shitai ga Umatteiru, One Punch Man, Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen
I decided to start a weekly blog updating the anime I'm going to pick for my Top 10 of the year list. Of course, I should mention that I've only watched 11 anime so far between the Winter and Spring seasons, so this list is going to look far different seven months from now when I do my unofficial list (or 10 for the official) of best anime of the year.
Either way, I will map out the Top 10 anime that I completed or am watching as well as list other anime that didn't make the list, dropped anime, and plan to watch anime from the upcoming seasons. For the record, there are some anime that aren't listed that I might end up watching WAY down the line. For example, Durarara. I have not watched the first series of Durarara, so it is a series that I need to catch up with eventually. Of course, perhaps eventually down the line it makes it on its list, but I need to catch up with the original material before I watch this year's series. At any rate, here is my countdown of Top 10 Anime Of 2015 (so far).
Completed/Airing Top 10
10. Owari no Seraph (Airing)
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.77
Analysis: This is a series where I feel like the best way I can describe my feelings on the series is that "the jury is still out." I have to blame the pacing of this series. I found the first few episodes of this anime to be quite fascinating, but then it seemed to hit a stumbling block through the mid parts of the season, and is finally starting to redirect now toward the latter part of the season. I also don't think this is one of Wit Studio's best works. Considering these guys just made Shingeki no Kyojin a couple years ago, I expected higher quality animation than what we're getting. The characters also seem to be lacking some depth. The one thing that has me coming back to this series is the plot. I am fascinated by the plot as a whole and I want to see where the story goes, but on the whole, I'm not overly impressed with the series.
9. Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki (Airing)
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.99
Analysis: I'm having a hard time with this one. I really liked the first season of Sidonia no Kishi and I am fascinated by the plot of this one. However, this one seems to have the same problems Owari no Seraph has. The pacing is incredibly slow and the so called "character development" seems to keep bashing us on the head with the same developmental brick over-and-over again. However, unlike Owari no Seraph, I do like the characters a little more and each one does have a developed back story (at least the MCs and the one that needs to remain mysterious and unsolved is). I think this is a series that could climb a spot or two by the time the series is said and done. I do feel like the best parts of this series have yet to come, but so far, I can only say its a decent series.
8. Tokyo Ghoul: Root A (Completed)
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.60
Analysis: I really feel like Studio Pierrot really screwed the pooch with this series. The original Tokyo Ghoul was a fascinating series, but its cliffhanger ending really brought the series down for me. Unfortunately, Root A has the same problem, but this time the series as a whole didn't seem to be as good. However, I will give Root A this...it does have one of my favorite scenes in anime from the entire year. However, it follows it up IMMEDIATELY with another cliffhanger ending that seems to sour the mood of the series as a whole. Quite frankly, that one scene is really the only reason why I have it in the eight spot.
7. Ghost In The Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture (Airing)
My Score: 7
MAL Average: 7.26
Analysis: I might be a bit biased, but the Ghost In The Shell franchise might be my favorite overall anime franchise. I found the original movies to be fascinating and Stand Alone Complex is one of my favorite TV series of all-time...period, even extending beyond anime. However, the only thing I can say about Arise is that it just seems to be good and not much else. The characters are still the same old, same old with the exception of Motoko having a bit more personality to her than in Stand Alone Complex. My problem with the series though is that it seems to be underutilizing its resources. For whatever reason, Production I.G. had the opportunity to at least create a full 12-13 episode series, develop the characters even more, and create possibly the next Stand Alone Complex. Instead, it seems like all they did is took the movies, cut out some material so that it will fit within two episodes of a TV series, and add JUST ONE additional story/case. Boy, Production I.G. really didn't go the extra mile when it came to the originality of this series. If they were hoping to reinvigorate the GITS franchise within the anime community with this series, they sure failed by doing the bare minimum. Still, I'm enjoying this series. The characters are extremely likable and the animation is pretty damn good. Like I said, my biggest problem is this series doesn't "develop" its characters as much as it should and Production I.G. is not utilizing their resources as much as they should. In the past, this franchise would probably get a two-cour run.
6. Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (Airing)
My Score: 7
MAL Average: 8.01
Analysis: Okay, let me just say that the "harem hater" in me should loathe this series. I mean, LOATHE! However, I am fascinated with myself really because I am actually legitimately enjoying this series...and I'm not entirely sure why. I guess the one thing I will say is its nice to see a series completely throw away this "shy kissing" concept that you see in most other anime. It's also fascinating that this is the second anime I've watched that revolves around supernatural powers perpetuated by kissing (the other being Campione!). I think part of the reason why I'm enjoying this series is that there does feel like a genuine romance in this series, despite the "haremness" of this series. I also find the characters to be extremely likable and fascinating. The only thing that is keeping me from giving this an 8 or higher is the fact that the pacing is just kinda wonky. I won't lie that a few of the episodes bored me to tears because it felt like the story was making zero progress and the character development held at a stand still. However, like a fine wine, I think this series is going to do better with age and I feel the "best is yet to come."
And now, on to the top five...
5. Hibike! Euphonium (Airing)
My Score: 8
MAL Average: 7.63
Analysis: For the first time so far on the list, I actually feel like the fans on MAL are selling this anime short. In my honest opinion, I feel like Hibike is the most "realistic" anime airing this season, at least in terms of being relatable. This series hits a chord with me (no pun intended) because I used to be in a high school band as well and used to partake in parades and music competitions. While the models are slightly different between the U.S. and Japan, there is still a constant and that is the act of making music and the amount of "work" it takes to become a great musician. I feel this series does a great job at drawing the parallels. In typical Kyoto Ani fashion, the series is beautiful to look at and the music is outstanding. I'd say the one downside to this series is that Kumiko is not the most likable protagonist in the world. In fact, I'm sure there are a lot of people that think she's quite unlikable. However, this is what I do like about her...she's a flawed character. She's a character that is wishy-washy in her decision making and can be somewhat cold to some of her peers...or at the very least not honest with them, but you know what that sounds like to me? A typical high schooler. I feel like she embodies a high school character better than most of the high school set anime out there. I believe this series does need to develop some of its other characters a little more, but at the same time, this is a pretty darn good series that I firmly believe is under appreciated.
4. Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 8.52
Analysis: This series reminds of Little Busters in the sense of just how radically different the second season differs from the first...or Clannad for that matter. I tell you what, if you're being compared to the likes of Clannad: After Story and Little Busters: Refrain, you're in good company. In my case, the best company. I found the first season to be pretty good...at least enjoyable. However, this season has been much more dramatic than the last and has a lot of great things going for it. It really dives in to the personal struggles of each character and builds them to their fullest extent...or at the very least our main characters. Its also fascinating to see not only the tonal shift, but the GREAT leap in animation quality between the first season and the second season...with Feel taking over the second season from Brains Base. I'll admit, it's a welcome sight and the anime is fantastic to look at. I don't think this series is quite utilizing everything to its fullest potential, but at the same time, if a series can capture my attention and hold it as long as this one does, I'll give it due respect.
3. Kekkai Sensen (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 7.83
Analysis: Again, this feels like another one that's generally under appreciated. Kekkai Sensen is one of my personal favorites this season. This series is REALLY fun to watch. I'll admit that it does have quite a few flaws, but it makes up for it with stylish animation and a fantastic cast of characters. This is one of the most likable cast of characters I've seen in anime this year and I love how much chemistry they all have with each other. I think before long, Zapp Renfro is going to be one of my favorite characters of all-time and Klaus von Reinherz is not far behind. This series has a lot going for it as well. The plot and setting are extremely fascinating. However, unlike a lot of anime that I have listed below it, this series has a pacing problem as well...the pacing is too fast. It feels like this series crams an awful lot of information and dialogue into a short run time and it feels like I'm missing some important plot points in the meantime. I'm not sure if this is a subbing issue where if you're a Japanese audience, you can pick up on it faster due to the use of native language, but as someone reading subs, it can become a bit daunting. My other problem with this series is that Leonardo Watch's development seems a bit fragmented and not properly explained. However, I do enjoy how much of an aloof protagonist he is and how accepting he is of everything. The best way I can describe this series is that it is a fun watch. It reminds me of Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, except with more polished animation.
2. Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works Second Season (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 8.68
Analysis: Ufotable seems to constantly again and again knock anime out of the park with its fantastic animation of great visual/light novels. It's no secret that the Fate and Kyoukai no Kanata franchises have enormous budgets and you can see them flow out. While I do feel like the fight scenes were better in Fate/Zero, I do like Fate/stay night's story a lot more. I also feel as though a lot of general viewers don't understand Shirou's character and that there's more to it than "he's just some kid with a hero complex." The whole point to this series is to show the complexities to his character through Archer and I'm loving how this series is tying that all together. It's also funny that while I am not a big fan of tsundere characters, Rin is my favorite girl in the franchise and I'm glad this series shines the spotlight on her. The ONE area this series needed to improve on (too late now) was that some characters (such as Illya) needed more development. Considering how tightly nit this series is with Fate/Zero, I feel only having essentially one episode dedicated to her character development didn't do the series justice. Still, small potatoes in the grand scheme of things. FSN: UBW is one of my favorite series of the year thus far, much like I expected it to be. Hell, I thought it could've been #1...but there is one series that came out of nowhere and surprised the ever living shit out of me...
1. Ore Monogatari!! (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 8.24
Analysis: Okay, take every romantic comedy stereotype in anime and throw it out the fucking window with this series. Ore Monogatari!! is, at this moment, one of the best romance series I've ever watched...and considering my anime viewing history and my "resume," THAT is really saying something. Madhouse caught lightning in a bottle with this series. It has a perfect balance of comedy, drama, and romance with an incredibly likable cast. Gouda is that ultimate "good guy" that everyone likes to have within their clique, but can turn a few people off with his looks and mannerisms, Makoto is the ultimate best friend. He might seem cold to some people, but he's the ultimate friend you could have because he always has your back and always supports you...and of course, there's Rinko. What a sweet heart. I love girls like her and I think its beautiful how her and Gouda hooked up. Hell, I'm just glad we have an anime where the couple in question actually "hooked up" by the third episode. While Ore Monogatari!! might not be as pretty or as stylish as a few of the series I listed behind it, what it ultimately has going for it is the best characters...and to me, characters are the most important part of the series. No anime has captured my heart more this year than Ore Monogatari!! and I think a lot of series (even the upcoming ones) are going to have a hard time knocking this one off its #1 perch.
Completed
Aldnoah.Zero Second Season
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.29
Analysis: I won't go into too many details since its not in my top 10. All I will say is it logically jumped the shark in a lot of ways and while I enjoyed the first season, the second season left too much unanswered and the character decisions/motivations didn't seem all that plausible or realistic. Overall, this series was incredibly disappointing.
Dropped (I don't score dropped anime...anymore)
Re-Kan!
MAL Average: 6.59
Analysis: I only watched a handful of episodes. Overall, the series didn't utilize a fascinating concept and instead made it more about the "slapstick, silly humor" than about what a girl who can see ghosts probably goes through in an everyday life. I felt like this series made a mockery of the paranormal and I don't feel that its something you can really turn into a pure comedy. I'm not mocking this series for having comedic elements, but for making it the overarching theme of the series, I feel it wasn't the right move. This could've been good, but it had some bad direction.
Kyoukai no Rinne
MAL Average: 7.03
Analysis: I just got bored with this series. Considering this is from the same creator as InuYasha and Ranma 1/2, I thought it could be a good series. Unfortunately, it didn't really seem to do a whole lot of anything. Brains Base didn't exactly go the extra mile to make the animation or action scenes seem all that entertaining either. Overall, all I can chalk this series being up to is being a boring series with an interesting plot...but that's it.
Plan To Watch (subject to addition/change)
Charlotte (Summer)
God Eater (Summer)
Non Non Biyori Repeat (Summer)
K: Return of Kings (Fall)
One Punch Man (Fall)
Owari no Seraph 2 (Fall)
Sakurako-san no Ashimoto ni wa Shitai ga Umatteiru (Fall)
Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen (Fall)
Either way, I will map out the Top 10 anime that I completed or am watching as well as list other anime that didn't make the list, dropped anime, and plan to watch anime from the upcoming seasons. For the record, there are some anime that aren't listed that I might end up watching WAY down the line. For example, Durarara. I have not watched the first series of Durarara, so it is a series that I need to catch up with eventually. Of course, perhaps eventually down the line it makes it on its list, but I need to catch up with the original material before I watch this year's series. At any rate, here is my countdown of Top 10 Anime Of 2015 (so far).
Completed/Airing Top 10
10. Owari no Seraph (Airing)
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.77
Analysis: This is a series where I feel like the best way I can describe my feelings on the series is that "the jury is still out." I have to blame the pacing of this series. I found the first few episodes of this anime to be quite fascinating, but then it seemed to hit a stumbling block through the mid parts of the season, and is finally starting to redirect now toward the latter part of the season. I also don't think this is one of Wit Studio's best works. Considering these guys just made Shingeki no Kyojin a couple years ago, I expected higher quality animation than what we're getting. The characters also seem to be lacking some depth. The one thing that has me coming back to this series is the plot. I am fascinated by the plot as a whole and I want to see where the story goes, but on the whole, I'm not overly impressed with the series.
9. Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki (Airing)
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.99
Analysis: I'm having a hard time with this one. I really liked the first season of Sidonia no Kishi and I am fascinated by the plot of this one. However, this one seems to have the same problems Owari no Seraph has. The pacing is incredibly slow and the so called "character development" seems to keep bashing us on the head with the same developmental brick over-and-over again. However, unlike Owari no Seraph, I do like the characters a little more and each one does have a developed back story (at least the MCs and the one that needs to remain mysterious and unsolved is). I think this is a series that could climb a spot or two by the time the series is said and done. I do feel like the best parts of this series have yet to come, but so far, I can only say its a decent series.
8. Tokyo Ghoul: Root A (Completed)
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.60
Analysis: I really feel like Studio Pierrot really screwed the pooch with this series. The original Tokyo Ghoul was a fascinating series, but its cliffhanger ending really brought the series down for me. Unfortunately, Root A has the same problem, but this time the series as a whole didn't seem to be as good. However, I will give Root A this...it does have one of my favorite scenes in anime from the entire year. However, it follows it up IMMEDIATELY with another cliffhanger ending that seems to sour the mood of the series as a whole. Quite frankly, that one scene is really the only reason why I have it in the eight spot.
7. Ghost In The Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture (Airing)
My Score: 7
MAL Average: 7.26
Analysis: I might be a bit biased, but the Ghost In The Shell franchise might be my favorite overall anime franchise. I found the original movies to be fascinating and Stand Alone Complex is one of my favorite TV series of all-time...period, even extending beyond anime. However, the only thing I can say about Arise is that it just seems to be good and not much else. The characters are still the same old, same old with the exception of Motoko having a bit more personality to her than in Stand Alone Complex. My problem with the series though is that it seems to be underutilizing its resources. For whatever reason, Production I.G. had the opportunity to at least create a full 12-13 episode series, develop the characters even more, and create possibly the next Stand Alone Complex. Instead, it seems like all they did is took the movies, cut out some material so that it will fit within two episodes of a TV series, and add JUST ONE additional story/case. Boy, Production I.G. really didn't go the extra mile when it came to the originality of this series. If they were hoping to reinvigorate the GITS franchise within the anime community with this series, they sure failed by doing the bare minimum. Still, I'm enjoying this series. The characters are extremely likable and the animation is pretty damn good. Like I said, my biggest problem is this series doesn't "develop" its characters as much as it should and Production I.G. is not utilizing their resources as much as they should. In the past, this franchise would probably get a two-cour run.
6. Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo (Airing)
My Score: 7
MAL Average: 8.01
Analysis: Okay, let me just say that the "harem hater" in me should loathe this series. I mean, LOATHE! However, I am fascinated with myself really because I am actually legitimately enjoying this series...and I'm not entirely sure why. I guess the one thing I will say is its nice to see a series completely throw away this "shy kissing" concept that you see in most other anime. It's also fascinating that this is the second anime I've watched that revolves around supernatural powers perpetuated by kissing (the other being Campione!). I think part of the reason why I'm enjoying this series is that there does feel like a genuine romance in this series, despite the "haremness" of this series. I also find the characters to be extremely likable and fascinating. The only thing that is keeping me from giving this an 8 or higher is the fact that the pacing is just kinda wonky. I won't lie that a few of the episodes bored me to tears because it felt like the story was making zero progress and the character development held at a stand still. However, like a fine wine, I think this series is going to do better with age and I feel the "best is yet to come."
And now, on to the top five...
5. Hibike! Euphonium (Airing)
My Score: 8
MAL Average: 7.63
Analysis: For the first time so far on the list, I actually feel like the fans on MAL are selling this anime short. In my honest opinion, I feel like Hibike is the most "realistic" anime airing this season, at least in terms of being relatable. This series hits a chord with me (no pun intended) because I used to be in a high school band as well and used to partake in parades and music competitions. While the models are slightly different between the U.S. and Japan, there is still a constant and that is the act of making music and the amount of "work" it takes to become a great musician. I feel this series does a great job at drawing the parallels. In typical Kyoto Ani fashion, the series is beautiful to look at and the music is outstanding. I'd say the one downside to this series is that Kumiko is not the most likable protagonist in the world. In fact, I'm sure there are a lot of people that think she's quite unlikable. However, this is what I do like about her...she's a flawed character. She's a character that is wishy-washy in her decision making and can be somewhat cold to some of her peers...or at the very least not honest with them, but you know what that sounds like to me? A typical high schooler. I feel like she embodies a high school character better than most of the high school set anime out there. I believe this series does need to develop some of its other characters a little more, but at the same time, this is a pretty darn good series that I firmly believe is under appreciated.
4. Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 8.52
Analysis: This series reminds of Little Busters in the sense of just how radically different the second season differs from the first...or Clannad for that matter. I tell you what, if you're being compared to the likes of Clannad: After Story and Little Busters: Refrain, you're in good company. In my case, the best company. I found the first season to be pretty good...at least enjoyable. However, this season has been much more dramatic than the last and has a lot of great things going for it. It really dives in to the personal struggles of each character and builds them to their fullest extent...or at the very least our main characters. Its also fascinating to see not only the tonal shift, but the GREAT leap in animation quality between the first season and the second season...with Feel taking over the second season from Brains Base. I'll admit, it's a welcome sight and the anime is fantastic to look at. I don't think this series is quite utilizing everything to its fullest potential, but at the same time, if a series can capture my attention and hold it as long as this one does, I'll give it due respect.
3. Kekkai Sensen (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 7.83
Analysis: Again, this feels like another one that's generally under appreciated. Kekkai Sensen is one of my personal favorites this season. This series is REALLY fun to watch. I'll admit that it does have quite a few flaws, but it makes up for it with stylish animation and a fantastic cast of characters. This is one of the most likable cast of characters I've seen in anime this year and I love how much chemistry they all have with each other. I think before long, Zapp Renfro is going to be one of my favorite characters of all-time and Klaus von Reinherz is not far behind. This series has a lot going for it as well. The plot and setting are extremely fascinating. However, unlike a lot of anime that I have listed below it, this series has a pacing problem as well...the pacing is too fast. It feels like this series crams an awful lot of information and dialogue into a short run time and it feels like I'm missing some important plot points in the meantime. I'm not sure if this is a subbing issue where if you're a Japanese audience, you can pick up on it faster due to the use of native language, but as someone reading subs, it can become a bit daunting. My other problem with this series is that Leonardo Watch's development seems a bit fragmented and not properly explained. However, I do enjoy how much of an aloof protagonist he is and how accepting he is of everything. The best way I can describe this series is that it is a fun watch. It reminds me of Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, except with more polished animation.
2. Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works Second Season (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 8.68
Analysis: Ufotable seems to constantly again and again knock anime out of the park with its fantastic animation of great visual/light novels. It's no secret that the Fate and Kyoukai no Kanata franchises have enormous budgets and you can see them flow out. While I do feel like the fight scenes were better in Fate/Zero, I do like Fate/stay night's story a lot more. I also feel as though a lot of general viewers don't understand Shirou's character and that there's more to it than "he's just some kid with a hero complex." The whole point to this series is to show the complexities to his character through Archer and I'm loving how this series is tying that all together. It's also funny that while I am not a big fan of tsundere characters, Rin is my favorite girl in the franchise and I'm glad this series shines the spotlight on her. The ONE area this series needed to improve on (too late now) was that some characters (such as Illya) needed more development. Considering how tightly nit this series is with Fate/Zero, I feel only having essentially one episode dedicated to her character development didn't do the series justice. Still, small potatoes in the grand scheme of things. FSN: UBW is one of my favorite series of the year thus far, much like I expected it to be. Hell, I thought it could've been #1...but there is one series that came out of nowhere and surprised the ever living shit out of me...
1. Ore Monogatari!! (Airing)
My Score: 9
MAL Average: 8.24
Analysis: Okay, take every romantic comedy stereotype in anime and throw it out the fucking window with this series. Ore Monogatari!! is, at this moment, one of the best romance series I've ever watched...and considering my anime viewing history and my "resume," THAT is really saying something. Madhouse caught lightning in a bottle with this series. It has a perfect balance of comedy, drama, and romance with an incredibly likable cast. Gouda is that ultimate "good guy" that everyone likes to have within their clique, but can turn a few people off with his looks and mannerisms, Makoto is the ultimate best friend. He might seem cold to some people, but he's the ultimate friend you could have because he always has your back and always supports you...and of course, there's Rinko. What a sweet heart. I love girls like her and I think its beautiful how her and Gouda hooked up. Hell, I'm just glad we have an anime where the couple in question actually "hooked up" by the third episode. While Ore Monogatari!! might not be as pretty or as stylish as a few of the series I listed behind it, what it ultimately has going for it is the best characters...and to me, characters are the most important part of the series. No anime has captured my heart more this year than Ore Monogatari!! and I think a lot of series (even the upcoming ones) are going to have a hard time knocking this one off its #1 perch.
Completed
Aldnoah.Zero Second Season
My Score: 6
MAL Average: 7.29
Analysis: I won't go into too many details since its not in my top 10. All I will say is it logically jumped the shark in a lot of ways and while I enjoyed the first season, the second season left too much unanswered and the character decisions/motivations didn't seem all that plausible or realistic. Overall, this series was incredibly disappointing.
Dropped (I don't score dropped anime...anymore)
Re-Kan!
MAL Average: 6.59
Analysis: I only watched a handful of episodes. Overall, the series didn't utilize a fascinating concept and instead made it more about the "slapstick, silly humor" than about what a girl who can see ghosts probably goes through in an everyday life. I felt like this series made a mockery of the paranormal and I don't feel that its something you can really turn into a pure comedy. I'm not mocking this series for having comedic elements, but for making it the overarching theme of the series, I feel it wasn't the right move. This could've been good, but it had some bad direction.
Kyoukai no Rinne
MAL Average: 7.03
Analysis: I just got bored with this series. Considering this is from the same creator as InuYasha and Ranma 1/2, I thought it could be a good series. Unfortunately, it didn't really seem to do a whole lot of anything. Brains Base didn't exactly go the extra mile to make the animation or action scenes seem all that entertaining either. Overall, all I can chalk this series being up to is being a boring series with an interesting plot...but that's it.
Plan To Watch (subject to addition/change)
Charlotte (Summer)
God Eater (Summer)
Non Non Biyori Repeat (Summer)
K: Return of Kings (Fall)
One Punch Man (Fall)
Owari no Seraph 2 (Fall)
Sakurako-san no Ashimoto ni wa Shitai ga Umatteiru (Fall)
Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen (Fall)
Posted by Toucanbird | Jun 9, 2015 12:41 AM | 0 comments
May 15th, 2015
The Start Of Summer: 2015 Spring Season's Midway Point
Anime Relations: Kekkai Sensen, Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki, Owari no Seraph, Hibike! Euphonium, Ore Monogatari!!, Kyoukai no Rinne, Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo, Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works 2nd Season, Koukaku Kidoutai Arise: Alternative Architecture
Okay, I called out about a month ago saying that perhaps this summer season will be the best season of anime ever. We're at the midway point, so I suppose I have a more polished outlook on that. Midway through the season, is it the best season of anime ever?
It's going to be a tough call. Fall 2012 was such a great season with Shinsekai yori, Little Busters!, Robotics;Notes (personally enjoyed, but not overall well received), Chuunibyou (fun series), and Psycho-Pass. Spring 2012 was a strong season too with Hyouka, Fate/Zero Second Season, Sankarea, Tasogare Otome x Amnesia, and both Acchi Kochi and Kore wa Zombie desu ka? Of the Dead for some solid comedies to mix in there.
Although, I think Spring 2011 is the thing of legend. Steins;Gate, Ano Hana, and Hanasaku Iroha were all anime I gave 10s, a score I give out maybe two or three times a year at most. Nichijou was also one of the best comedies I've ever seen, if not the best as well, with some other decent anime that came out as well, such as Ao no Exorcist, Deadman Wonderland, and Hoshizora e Kakaru Hashi. I'd have to say, it's going to take A LOT for this legendary anime season to get toppled. I'm sure a lot of Gintama fans would like to chip in their two cents as well. It's crazy to think that this anime season produced the #2, #3, #36, #52, #67, and #69 best shows of all-time (according to MAL).
When I saw the anime list for Spring 2015, I felt like it had the potential to be great (should be obvious from my opening statement).
So is it? I'd say it's pretty good, but not all I hoped for. Here is my breakdown of the best-to-worst anime I'm watching this season (in my opinion).
1. Ore Monogatari!!
My Score - 9
MAL Score - 8.26
Let me just say for the record I didn't expect this to be my favorite anime from the season going into it, nor would I have thought a romantic comedy would be my top anime coming out of a season with some ridiculously hyped shows. However, what more can I say that this anime is a fantastic example of unique storytelling and character build and kicking the typical anime stereotypes to the curb. This anime was so good that it got me to read the manga...let me just add this to the record. The anime has to REALLY DAMN GOOD for me to want to read ahead in the manga. Hell, I essentially did what the anime industry is made for and that's get viewers interested in buying the manga. Well played, Ore Monogatari!! You won! I'm sold!
2. Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works Second Season
My Score - 9
MAL Score - 8.74
I actually thought this would probably be my top anime from the season. Unfortunately, it's not...but that's not trying to take anything away from this series. I think F/SN:UBW is FANTASTIC! That's just how good Ore Monogatari!! has been. Also, the best has yet to come for F/SN. It is one of those series that just slowly builds. So far, I have to applaud ufotable. They do a pretty damn good job of adapting things.
3. Hibike! Euphonium
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 7.47
I'd say this is where the list falls from great to pretty good. I'm seriously having a hard time ranking the anime I have between 3-7 because they are all pretty even kiel and each one I like for different reasons. I ultimately chose Hibike! just because I find it relatable. When I was in high school, I performed in concert band and I also found Oomoe's character relatable to my own situation. If an anime can relate to me on the personal level, I like that. You throw in some great animation, some outstanding music, fun and likable characters, you've got a great mix. Much like F/SN, I do also think the best has yet to come with this series. I do think a lot of people on MAL are giving this series a bit of a bad wrap, but then again, I think people are expecting a lot more from Kyoto Ani than K-ON! 2.0.
4. Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 7.99
Much like the theme of this anime, this series has cast a spell on me. Considering how I judge anime, I really shouldn't be enjoying this series as much as I am. However, I'm actually quite amazed at how well this series is playing out so far. While I don't think the series is really all that "original," I think the way its handled is rather fun to watch. It is also nice that the main protagonist isn't the "smoothest," but he's got an interesting character to work around. I'm having a hard time putting this one into words, but I just downright enjoy this.
5. Kekkai Sensen
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 7.75
Speaking of hard time putting descriptions into words, I don't know what I'm gonna be able to say about Kekkai Sensen. It's probably the most stylish and original series I've watched in quite some time. The series reminds me of a more polished version of Soul Eater, but it's probably more along the lines of a Durarara meets Deadman Wonderland than a Soul Eater. The art and animation of this series is also incredibly polished and well-crafted. I'm actually extremely engrossed in how this series enraptures the city of New York in it, although I'd say it feels more like a 1980s (or earlier) New York than a modern day/futuristic one. The only thing keeping this series off near the top of my list is its episodic nature and lack of proper character development.
6. Knights of Sidonia: Battle For Planet Nine
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 8.01
Rating it sixth on my list might not be doing it justice, but I actually am enjoying the second season of Sidonia more than the first. Conceptually and visually, it's not really a whole lot different than the first season. It's still essentially humans on their last legs traveling around the galaxy fighting creatures that are trying to drive them into extinction. The only real big difference between this season and last season is the "integration" between humans and gauna. The fight scenes are still really good and the character development isn't too shabby either. My biggest beef with Sidonia is that it (hard finding the words) doesn't have a whole lot to it in terms of depth. Perhaps it is because the story itself has been done a million times over, but I don't really feel anything while watching this series. I'm not saying it's bad, as entertainment, it's pretty good. It just doesn't really connect with me on the personal level for me to think it is a great anime. It's good, but not great.
7. Ghost In The Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture
My Score - 7
MAL Score - 7.31
My rating of this series might be a bit biased since I watched (half) of the movies and this basically feels like a dissection of the movies. As a series, I do feel it does well. It's great to look at, the action scenes might actually be BETTER than Fate/Stay Night (which I never thought I'd ever say), and the characters are the same old, same old. The only thing that's keeping me from LOVING this series is just the fact that the structure of this series is that of a two-episode dissection of hour-long movies and the episodes don't "transition" very well. I do think the final four episodes of this series will bring out the best for last, but at the same time, I feel like this series squandered some opportunities to be great, just by how awful the episode transitions are. This is no where even close to how good Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex was, but then again, Stand Alone Complex consisted of 52 episodes to develop its plot and characters. This just has 10...I think Production I.G. missed out on something great here.
8. Owari no Seraph
My Score - 6
MAL Score - 7.75
Ugh, if I had to define the "typical shounen" of the season, it's this one. I'm actually somewhat mad at this one. I thought it was going to be probably one of my top five anime of the season and it probably won't even be the best "vampire" anime of the season since I think Kekkai Sensen is MUCH better. My problem with this series is its AWFUL pacing and choppy animation. I am actually appalled that this series is done by Wit Studio, because I expected A WHOLE LOT MORE from the same people that brought us Attack On Titan. With that being said, I don't "hate" Owari no Seraph nor do I think it's "bad." It's just incredibly disappointing because I had high hopes for this series and it has not delivered. I do think it can only go up from here considering how it started off on the wrong foot and there is tension building in the series, but I really don't think it can overtake the seven series I have rated ahead of it.
9. Kyoukai no Rinne
My Score - 6
MAL Score - 7.09
I didn't expect to rate this anime particularly high. This is essentially rom-com Bleach/Soul Eater (a second Soul Eater reference today? Really?). There isn't anything I'd say makes this series standout. The comedy is pretty pedestrian, the action is pretty non-existent. At least comparing it to its InuYasha counterpart, at least the action was decent in that series. This one? Not so much. The only thing that has me coming back every week is that the characters are somewhat likable and I do like its concept. It does, at the very least, have me interested in the plot. However, there isn't really anything else that has me thinking that this is a nice way to kill 25 minutes of my week. Best way I can describe this series? It hasn't surprised or disappointed. It's just done what I expected of it, which was not set the bar high, but do enough to at least entertain.
It's going to be a tough call. Fall 2012 was such a great season with Shinsekai yori, Little Busters!, Robotics;Notes (personally enjoyed, but not overall well received), Chuunibyou (fun series), and Psycho-Pass. Spring 2012 was a strong season too with Hyouka, Fate/Zero Second Season, Sankarea, Tasogare Otome x Amnesia, and both Acchi Kochi and Kore wa Zombie desu ka? Of the Dead for some solid comedies to mix in there.
Although, I think Spring 2011 is the thing of legend. Steins;Gate, Ano Hana, and Hanasaku Iroha were all anime I gave 10s, a score I give out maybe two or three times a year at most. Nichijou was also one of the best comedies I've ever seen, if not the best as well, with some other decent anime that came out as well, such as Ao no Exorcist, Deadman Wonderland, and Hoshizora e Kakaru Hashi. I'd have to say, it's going to take A LOT for this legendary anime season to get toppled. I'm sure a lot of Gintama fans would like to chip in their two cents as well. It's crazy to think that this anime season produced the #2, #3, #36, #52, #67, and #69 best shows of all-time (according to MAL).
When I saw the anime list for Spring 2015, I felt like it had the potential to be great (should be obvious from my opening statement).
So is it? I'd say it's pretty good, but not all I hoped for. Here is my breakdown of the best-to-worst anime I'm watching this season (in my opinion).
1. Ore Monogatari!!
My Score - 9
MAL Score - 8.26
Let me just say for the record I didn't expect this to be my favorite anime from the season going into it, nor would I have thought a romantic comedy would be my top anime coming out of a season with some ridiculously hyped shows. However, what more can I say that this anime is a fantastic example of unique storytelling and character build and kicking the typical anime stereotypes to the curb. This anime was so good that it got me to read the manga...let me just add this to the record. The anime has to REALLY DAMN GOOD for me to want to read ahead in the manga. Hell, I essentially did what the anime industry is made for and that's get viewers interested in buying the manga. Well played, Ore Monogatari!! You won! I'm sold!
2. Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works Second Season
My Score - 9
MAL Score - 8.74
I actually thought this would probably be my top anime from the season. Unfortunately, it's not...but that's not trying to take anything away from this series. I think F/SN:UBW is FANTASTIC! That's just how good Ore Monogatari!! has been. Also, the best has yet to come for F/SN. It is one of those series that just slowly builds. So far, I have to applaud ufotable. They do a pretty damn good job of adapting things.
3. Hibike! Euphonium
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 7.47
I'd say this is where the list falls from great to pretty good. I'm seriously having a hard time ranking the anime I have between 3-7 because they are all pretty even kiel and each one I like for different reasons. I ultimately chose Hibike! just because I find it relatable. When I was in high school, I performed in concert band and I also found Oomoe's character relatable to my own situation. If an anime can relate to me on the personal level, I like that. You throw in some great animation, some outstanding music, fun and likable characters, you've got a great mix. Much like F/SN, I do also think the best has yet to come with this series. I do think a lot of people on MAL are giving this series a bit of a bad wrap, but then again, I think people are expecting a lot more from Kyoto Ani than K-ON! 2.0.
4. Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 7.99
Much like the theme of this anime, this series has cast a spell on me. Considering how I judge anime, I really shouldn't be enjoying this series as much as I am. However, I'm actually quite amazed at how well this series is playing out so far. While I don't think the series is really all that "original," I think the way its handled is rather fun to watch. It is also nice that the main protagonist isn't the "smoothest," but he's got an interesting character to work around. I'm having a hard time putting this one into words, but I just downright enjoy this.
5. Kekkai Sensen
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 7.75
Speaking of hard time putting descriptions into words, I don't know what I'm gonna be able to say about Kekkai Sensen. It's probably the most stylish and original series I've watched in quite some time. The series reminds me of a more polished version of Soul Eater, but it's probably more along the lines of a Durarara meets Deadman Wonderland than a Soul Eater. The art and animation of this series is also incredibly polished and well-crafted. I'm actually extremely engrossed in how this series enraptures the city of New York in it, although I'd say it feels more like a 1980s (or earlier) New York than a modern day/futuristic one. The only thing keeping this series off near the top of my list is its episodic nature and lack of proper character development.
6. Knights of Sidonia: Battle For Planet Nine
My Score - 8
MAL Score - 8.01
Rating it sixth on my list might not be doing it justice, but I actually am enjoying the second season of Sidonia more than the first. Conceptually and visually, it's not really a whole lot different than the first season. It's still essentially humans on their last legs traveling around the galaxy fighting creatures that are trying to drive them into extinction. The only real big difference between this season and last season is the "integration" between humans and gauna. The fight scenes are still really good and the character development isn't too shabby either. My biggest beef with Sidonia is that it (hard finding the words) doesn't have a whole lot to it in terms of depth. Perhaps it is because the story itself has been done a million times over, but I don't really feel anything while watching this series. I'm not saying it's bad, as entertainment, it's pretty good. It just doesn't really connect with me on the personal level for me to think it is a great anime. It's good, but not great.
7. Ghost In The Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture
My Score - 7
MAL Score - 7.31
My rating of this series might be a bit biased since I watched (half) of the movies and this basically feels like a dissection of the movies. As a series, I do feel it does well. It's great to look at, the action scenes might actually be BETTER than Fate/Stay Night (which I never thought I'd ever say), and the characters are the same old, same old. The only thing that's keeping me from LOVING this series is just the fact that the structure of this series is that of a two-episode dissection of hour-long movies and the episodes don't "transition" very well. I do think the final four episodes of this series will bring out the best for last, but at the same time, I feel like this series squandered some opportunities to be great, just by how awful the episode transitions are. This is no where even close to how good Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex was, but then again, Stand Alone Complex consisted of 52 episodes to develop its plot and characters. This just has 10...I think Production I.G. missed out on something great here.
8. Owari no Seraph
My Score - 6
MAL Score - 7.75
Ugh, if I had to define the "typical shounen" of the season, it's this one. I'm actually somewhat mad at this one. I thought it was going to be probably one of my top five anime of the season and it probably won't even be the best "vampire" anime of the season since I think Kekkai Sensen is MUCH better. My problem with this series is its AWFUL pacing and choppy animation. I am actually appalled that this series is done by Wit Studio, because I expected A WHOLE LOT MORE from the same people that brought us Attack On Titan. With that being said, I don't "hate" Owari no Seraph nor do I think it's "bad." It's just incredibly disappointing because I had high hopes for this series and it has not delivered. I do think it can only go up from here considering how it started off on the wrong foot and there is tension building in the series, but I really don't think it can overtake the seven series I have rated ahead of it.
9. Kyoukai no Rinne
My Score - 6
MAL Score - 7.09
I didn't expect to rate this anime particularly high. This is essentially rom-com Bleach/Soul Eater (a second Soul Eater reference today? Really?). There isn't anything I'd say makes this series standout. The comedy is pretty pedestrian, the action is pretty non-existent. At least comparing it to its InuYasha counterpart, at least the action was decent in that series. This one? Not so much. The only thing that has me coming back every week is that the characters are somewhat likable and I do like its concept. It does, at the very least, have me interested in the plot. However, there isn't really anything else that has me thinking that this is a nice way to kill 25 minutes of my week. Best way I can describe this series? It hasn't surprised or disappointed. It's just done what I expected of it, which was not set the bar high, but do enough to at least entertain.
Posted by Toucanbird | May 15, 2015 5:52 AM | 0 comments
April 13th, 2015
2015 Spring Season First Impression (Potentially The Best Anime Season Ever?)
Anime Relations: Kekkai Sensen, Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki, Digimon Adventure tri. 1: Saikai, Re-Kan!, Owari no Seraph, Hibike! Euphonium, Ore Monogatari!!, Kyoukai no Rinne, Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works 2nd Season, Koukaku Kidoutai Arise: Alternative Architecture
The title might be a little too misleading. You cannot judge how good an anime season is going to be based on the first few weeks of it. However, my goodness it seems like there are a ton of really good anime airing this season. However, I guess I'll start by discussing the series that have really garnered my attention.
Ghost In The Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture
Honestly, when I heard that there is going to be a brand new anime season of Ghost In The Shell, I lost it. Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex is one of my favorite anime series of all-time. It was one of the groundbreaking anime that truly got me invested in anime. So when I heard about Arise, even with some new visuals, I was stoked. Just a few episodes in, I already feel enamored with the new plot and how Section 9 is going to come together. Production I.G., please stick to things like these. This is what you're good at. I think this has the potential to be my Anime of the Year.
Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works 2nd Season
Speaking of anime of the year candidates, this one is certainly one of the frontrunners. The first season of F/SN:UBW was my #2 anime of 2014 and I have the feeling the second season will be even better. So far, it's off to a pretty good start getting right into the thick of things in regards to the plot. This series has me looking forward to an episode week...which is something I can't say about a lot of anime lately.
Owari no Seraph
I can't quite put my finger on this one. Generally speaking, it's your typical vampire apocalypse plot (as if there is anything so typical about that). There were also a few little nuances in the first two episodes that I found confusing. However, at the same time, I'm entranced by this series. I feel like it can be something more than just your generic shonen vampire series. It obviously isn't as dark as something like, say, Hellsing...but it seems like it could have its gripping and emotional scenes. This is a series I'll need to feel out a little more in the coming episodes, but so far I like what I see.
Ore Monogatari!
This series is expected to be one of the best romance series of the year and understandably so. I thought Ao Haru Ride was one of, if not, the best romance series of 2014 and I think Ore Monogatari is of equal potential. Obviously there are some differences. I don't think Ore Monogatari will be quite as heavy-handed as Ao Haru Ride was at times. The comedy also generally has a better feel with Ore Monogatari as I'll admit, the comedy in Ao Haru Ride was a little less than stellar. I think there's something to really like in this series with a main protagonist that isn't charismatic. This could be a very charming series and quite funny at that.
Hibike! Euphonium
This seems like the K-On! for concert band with the visual style of modern day Kyoto Ani. The result? I think is going to be pretty damn good...mostly for the fact that I don't think Hibike is going to slam you over the head with a moe stick like K-On! did. The first episode was enjoyable and for the most part, the character motivations seemed pretty realistic. I was slightly worried coming into this that this was going to be kinda hammy with typical high school girl tropes, but I was pleasantly surprised by the first episode. It seems like there is some depth to the characters that can be explored. I'll probably stick with this one for quite a while.
Kekkai Sensen
I'll be honest, a big reason why I decided to watch this anime was because it is one of the few anime I've ever heard of that is set in the United States. Finally, an anime that's no longer set in Japan or in a fictional universe! (sort of). At any rate, I'm having a hard time feeling this one out after two episodes. I wouldn't call it a massive disappointment, but I feel like Leonardo Watch (main protagonist) is lacking a bit. I'm two episodes in and his back story is really confusing...and to be honest, a lot of the character motivations in this series are confusing. The social structure of this new universe as a whole is pretty baffling and that's not really a good thing since the first two episodes were supposed to be about New York's new social structure after the alien invasion (or whatever it is). This series has some things to work on, but it does have the potential to be an outstanding anime series.
Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki
I was looking forward to this series for almost an entire year. I really enjoyed the first Sidonia no Kishi...I almost put it in my Top 25 Anime Of The Decade (that I watched) list...I'll be coming out with that list on here eventually. Still, after the first episode of the second season, I'm a little mixed. I think the time off from the first Sidonia no Kishi has my understanding of the plot a little off the mark. This might even be a case where I need to re-watch the first season just to acclimate to what the second season is presenting. I'm not by any means calling the start of season two bad. I just think it's a little bizarre and hard to follow. However, maybe I'll just need to watch a few more episodes to jog my memory and get me back into the flow of this series. It certainly has the potential to be a top 5 anime of the year.
Kyoukai no Rinne
Okay, I'll be honest. There are two reasons why I'm watching this. The first is my anime plate feels extremely action-heavy with little comedy. The second is we're talking about the same creators of InuYasha...not that I am a huge InuYasha fan, but what I am a fan of is characters with psychic or supernatural powers. So what are my opinions of this series two episodes in? It's pretty tame. It seems really heavy with the comedy elements...which is fine, but I was hoping for a little more balance in the comedy, drama, romance and action. The action elements of this series weren't quite what I was expecting. I think I'll like this series, but I don't see myself falling in love with it.
Re-Kan!
If I had to say there is a series that's disappointing me so far, it would be Re-Kan. My biggest problem with it is that it seems to be hitting up too much of the school girl stereotypes for it being about such a unique character (or not so unique since it has the same plot element as Kyoukai no Rinne). We've got the overly passive and accepting protagonist, check. The tsundere psycho friend of the lead character? Check. The cookie cutter supporting staff? Check. The one boy that is the target of all violence? Check. God, if it would just tone it down with the stereotypes, this would be an enjoyable series. However, the element of this series that I really do like is how the characters are trying to help these ghosts. Although, I don't like how they handled the element of how accepting everyone is of ghosts. Let's face it, hauntings are unusual and eerie. Yet, by the actions of this series, you'd think hauntings are everywhere and everyone is accepting of that. I want to enjoy this anime, but it's gotta tone it down with the cliche character tropes.
To Be Determined...
Digimon Adventure tri.
Digimon is the anime that got me into anime...so I can't wait to see what this has in store.
Ghost In The Shell: Arise - Alternative Architecture
Honestly, when I heard that there is going to be a brand new anime season of Ghost In The Shell, I lost it. Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex is one of my favorite anime series of all-time. It was one of the groundbreaking anime that truly got me invested in anime. So when I heard about Arise, even with some new visuals, I was stoked. Just a few episodes in, I already feel enamored with the new plot and how Section 9 is going to come together. Production I.G., please stick to things like these. This is what you're good at. I think this has the potential to be my Anime of the Year.
Fate/Stay Night: Unlimited Blade Works 2nd Season
Speaking of anime of the year candidates, this one is certainly one of the frontrunners. The first season of F/SN:UBW was my #2 anime of 2014 and I have the feeling the second season will be even better. So far, it's off to a pretty good start getting right into the thick of things in regards to the plot. This series has me looking forward to an episode week...which is something I can't say about a lot of anime lately.
Owari no Seraph
I can't quite put my finger on this one. Generally speaking, it's your typical vampire apocalypse plot (as if there is anything so typical about that). There were also a few little nuances in the first two episodes that I found confusing. However, at the same time, I'm entranced by this series. I feel like it can be something more than just your generic shonen vampire series. It obviously isn't as dark as something like, say, Hellsing...but it seems like it could have its gripping and emotional scenes. This is a series I'll need to feel out a little more in the coming episodes, but so far I like what I see.
Ore Monogatari!
This series is expected to be one of the best romance series of the year and understandably so. I thought Ao Haru Ride was one of, if not, the best romance series of 2014 and I think Ore Monogatari is of equal potential. Obviously there are some differences. I don't think Ore Monogatari will be quite as heavy-handed as Ao Haru Ride was at times. The comedy also generally has a better feel with Ore Monogatari as I'll admit, the comedy in Ao Haru Ride was a little less than stellar. I think there's something to really like in this series with a main protagonist that isn't charismatic. This could be a very charming series and quite funny at that.
Hibike! Euphonium
This seems like the K-On! for concert band with the visual style of modern day Kyoto Ani. The result? I think is going to be pretty damn good...mostly for the fact that I don't think Hibike is going to slam you over the head with a moe stick like K-On! did. The first episode was enjoyable and for the most part, the character motivations seemed pretty realistic. I was slightly worried coming into this that this was going to be kinda hammy with typical high school girl tropes, but I was pleasantly surprised by the first episode. It seems like there is some depth to the characters that can be explored. I'll probably stick with this one for quite a while.
Kekkai Sensen
I'll be honest, a big reason why I decided to watch this anime was because it is one of the few anime I've ever heard of that is set in the United States. Finally, an anime that's no longer set in Japan or in a fictional universe! (sort of). At any rate, I'm having a hard time feeling this one out after two episodes. I wouldn't call it a massive disappointment, but I feel like Leonardo Watch (main protagonist) is lacking a bit. I'm two episodes in and his back story is really confusing...and to be honest, a lot of the character motivations in this series are confusing. The social structure of this new universe as a whole is pretty baffling and that's not really a good thing since the first two episodes were supposed to be about New York's new social structure after the alien invasion (or whatever it is). This series has some things to work on, but it does have the potential to be an outstanding anime series.
Sidonia no Kishi: Daikyuu Wakusei Seneki
I was looking forward to this series for almost an entire year. I really enjoyed the first Sidonia no Kishi...I almost put it in my Top 25 Anime Of The Decade (that I watched) list...I'll be coming out with that list on here eventually. Still, after the first episode of the second season, I'm a little mixed. I think the time off from the first Sidonia no Kishi has my understanding of the plot a little off the mark. This might even be a case where I need to re-watch the first season just to acclimate to what the second season is presenting. I'm not by any means calling the start of season two bad. I just think it's a little bizarre and hard to follow. However, maybe I'll just need to watch a few more episodes to jog my memory and get me back into the flow of this series. It certainly has the potential to be a top 5 anime of the year.
Kyoukai no Rinne
Okay, I'll be honest. There are two reasons why I'm watching this. The first is my anime plate feels extremely action-heavy with little comedy. The second is we're talking about the same creators of InuYasha...not that I am a huge InuYasha fan, but what I am a fan of is characters with psychic or supernatural powers. So what are my opinions of this series two episodes in? It's pretty tame. It seems really heavy with the comedy elements...which is fine, but I was hoping for a little more balance in the comedy, drama, romance and action. The action elements of this series weren't quite what I was expecting. I think I'll like this series, but I don't see myself falling in love with it.
Re-Kan!
If I had to say there is a series that's disappointing me so far, it would be Re-Kan. My biggest problem with it is that it seems to be hitting up too much of the school girl stereotypes for it being about such a unique character (or not so unique since it has the same plot element as Kyoukai no Rinne). We've got the overly passive and accepting protagonist, check. The tsundere psycho friend of the lead character? Check. The cookie cutter supporting staff? Check. The one boy that is the target of all violence? Check. God, if it would just tone it down with the stereotypes, this would be an enjoyable series. However, the element of this series that I really do like is how the characters are trying to help these ghosts. Although, I don't like how they handled the element of how accepting everyone is of ghosts. Let's face it, hauntings are unusual and eerie. Yet, by the actions of this series, you'd think hauntings are everywhere and everyone is accepting of that. I want to enjoy this anime, but it's gotta tone it down with the cliche character tropes.
To Be Determined...
Digimon Adventure tri.
Digimon is the anime that got me into anime...so I can't wait to see what this has in store.
Posted by Toucanbird | Apr 13, 2015 7:47 PM | 0 comments
January 22nd, 2015
Kyoto Animation: My Favorite Studio Is Driving Me Crazy!
Anime Relations: Full Metal Panic!, Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu, Full Metal Panic! The Second Raid, Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu, Kanon (2006), Lucky☆Star, Clannad, Clannad: After Story, Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuuutsu (2009), K-On!, K-On!!, Nichijou, Hyouka, Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!, Tamako Market, Kyoukai no Kanata, Free!, Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren, Amagi Brilliant Park, Free! Eternal Summer, Hibike! Euphonium
Personally speaking, Kyoto Animation has been my favorite anime production studio for quite a long time. Although, Kyoto Ani was an acquired taste for me at first. I'm going to talk about my experience with Kyoto Ani from a chronological perspective and give my personal feelings about the series I was watching at the time.
For the longest time, I was a fan of Production I.G., mostly due to their work with Ghost In The Shell. However, as I was introduced to more and more Kyoto Ani anime, the more I realized I loved what the company did.
I remember my first exposure to Kyoto Ani came to the roots as a company as a whole. I saw Full Metal Panic?! Fumoffu a few years after it came out and it was one of the funniest anime I had ever seen, even to this day. I was a fan of the original FMP series and even though the series changed hands from Gonzo to Kyoto Ani, I was pleasantly surprised by the work Kyoto Ani did on the continuation. While I didn't enjoy The Second Raid as much, I still found it entertaining.
My next exposure to Kyoto Animation came in the form of Haruhi Suzumiya. At the time, Haruhi and Aya Hirano were the greatest things in Japan since sliced bread. While I did find Haruhi's character to be extremely grating, I found the series itself to be pretty remarkable and as an anime viewer, there might be something to this romance genre I might like.
However, I went back to my comfort zone when I was exposed to Lucky Star. While on the outside it seems like an annoyance, I found Lucky Star to be downright hilarious and actually a stark contradiction of what I normally watch. Still, it ended up being a downright hilarious comedy for me and this is when I started to realize that Kyoto Ani might be a pretty good production company.
I did end up trying to watch the sequel series to Haruhi Suzumiya in 2009...which ended up being an enormous mistake. The Endless Eight was so damn aggravating that I dropped the series after the fifth or sixth episode. This was my first exposure to Kyoto Ani failure, but it would end up being a while before I would see another failure from the company.
A few years passed and I didn't really give them much thought until about 2011 came about. I really had no interest in watching the K-On! series, so I really wouldn't get back into Kyoto Ani until 2011. At that time, it was the first time I watched the Key adaptations of Clannad and Kanon. I didn't watch these anime for the longest time because I was not a fan of the character design, but they both turned out to be two of the best anime I have ever seen. To this day, I consider Clannad: After Story to be the greatest anime ever made. No anime has ever quite been able to move me in the same way Clannad: After Story did and I found its storytelling, albeit roundabout to be brilliantly written. This is the moment I became a true, die hard Kyoto Ani fan and the point where I considered Kyoto Animation to be my favorite anime production company.
My positive exposure to Kyoto Ani didn't stop there as I watched Nichijou next and along with its two comedic predecessors in Fumoffu and Lucky Star, I consider Nichijou to be one of the greatest anime comedies ever written.
2012 was another fantastic year in my eyes as a Kyoto Ani came out with Hyouka, a series I consider to be one of the most underrated series of all-time. It was a series with unbelievably strong character development and atmosphere. I considered my viewing of Hyouka to be euphoric and as someone that rarely ever re-watches series, Hyouka was one I absolutely loved to go back to and watch again. Chuunibyou came out that fall and while I didn't love it as much as many, I still considered it to be a strong, likable series.
...so where did it all go wrong?
In my opinion, the last two years for Kyoto Ani have been abysmal. 2013 got off to such an awful start. Tamako Market was so conceptually unremarkable that I didn't even bother wasting my time watching it and from the advice I received, that was the appropriate move. At the time, all the buzz was about the promotions for their upcoming series, Free! However, as a devout Kyoto Animation viewer, I was reluctant to watch Free! I was obviously not the demographic for this series, but I watched it regardless. Unfortunately, Free! received mixed reviews. It seemed to have a "Sword Art Online" type of reception where people either loved the series or downright hated it. I was one of the few that actually felt indifferent about the series where I found the hate for the series to be unjustified, while the praise for the series to be giving it more credit than what its worth. From an actual narrative standpoint, Free! was one of the weakest stories I have seen out of Kyoto Ani, but I will admit the animation was quite remarkable.
While first two series of 2013 from Kyoto Ani had me beside myself about the major drop in quality, promotions for their upcoming fall series Kyoukai no Kanata (Beyond the Boundary) had me excited beyond all belief. I truly believed going into that season that Kyokai no Kanata was going to be one of Kyoto Ani's best works, just from a conceptual and visual perspective. It is quite unfortunate that Kyoukai no Kanata was not all that it was cracked up to be. Granted, it had some of the best action visuals I had seen that year, but the series itself didn't have a well-written antagonist, the characters weren't as memorable, the plot took a rather unorthodox (and not in a good way) turn, and it left on one of the most aggravating cliffhangers/deus ex machina scenes I have seen in anime to date. I was downright enraged at the end of the series and could only wonder why Kyoto Ani would falter so bad on a series that could have been their flagship series for many years?
After the disappointment that was Kyoukai no Kanata, I hoped that the second season of Chuunibyou could rebuild my confidence in the company. I did highly enjoy the first season of Chuunibyou after all, so I figured that perhaps another season could bring my love for Kyoto Ani back. I kept telling myself that 2014 had to be a better year for Kyoto Ani anime than 2013, because my God 2013 was an awful year for Kyoto Ani. I was wrong yet again, as I found the second season of Chuunibyou to be the weakest series Kyoto Ani has put out since the second season of Haruhi. It was a downright disappointment. I wouldn't say the series was bad, but it was painfully average. Of all the words I could use to describe Kyoto Ani's previous works, average is not one that comes to mind so it actually hurts to call a Kyoto Ani series "average," but that's what Chuunibyou Ren was to me, just an average series.
I was extremely hesitant at first to watch Free! Eternal Summer. I was not a fan of the first season and I essentially only watched Eternal Summer just out of completionist complex. It's actually a good thing I did, because Free! Eternal Summer was BY FAR the best anime Kyoto Ani had put out in the last two years. I was remarkably surprised at the tonal shift it had from the first season and I applaud the direction the series went. The series had remarkably better character development than the first season, which is what Free needed in the worst way.
However, Kyoto Ani yet again let me down at the end of the year with Amagi Brilliant Park. Of course, I'm not saying Amagi Brilliant Park was bad. In fact, it had some downright hilarious scenes. I was expecting Amagi Brilliant Park to be the next Nichijou or Lucky Star in some sense. However, in my opinion, it was just an okay comedy. It had some pretty funny moments in it but it didn't have me rolling on the floor like the aforementioned Kyoto Ani comedies. There were some episodes I found to be a downright waste of time because not only did it not advance plot or develop characters, but were not funny on-top of that. The worst part about this series though? It had a deus ex machina plot with an unresolved conflict with the antagonist and ended on a filler episode. YOU...CANNOT...END...A...SERIES...ON...A...WORSE...NOTE! I liked the series going into the last few episodes but the last two episodes of Amagi really let me down.
I found it fascinating looking at the MAL stats of Kyoto Ani series. As of January 20, this is how each Kyoto Ani TV series ranked just by rating...
1. Clannad: After Story - 9.15 (2008)
2. Nichijou - 8.51 (2011)
3. Clannad - 8.46 (2007)
T4. Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu - 8.30 (2003)
T4. Kanon - 8.30 (2006)
6. Hyouka - 8.22 (2012)
7. K-On!! - 8.18 (2010)
8. The Melancholy Of Haruhi Suzumiya - 8.17 (2006)
9. Full Metal Panic: The Second Raid - 8.14 (2005)
T10. Chuunibyou - 8.07 (2012)
T10. Free!: Eternal Summer - 8.07 (2014)
12. Lucky Star - 7.97 (2007)
13. K-On! - 7.92 (2009)
14. Amagi Brilliant Park - 7.86 (2014)
15. Kyoukai no Kanata - 7.84 (2013)
16. Free! - 7.80 (2013)
17. Air - 7.60 (2005)
18. Chuunibyou Ren - 7.54 (2014)
19. Munto - 7.33 (2009)
T20. Haruhi Suzumiya 2 - 7.31 (2009)
T20. Tamako Market - 7.31 (2014)
What stood out to me was of the 21 anime series Kyoto Ani has produced, five of the six they've made in that stretch rank in the bottom half. The one that isn't in the bottom half is barely in the top half in a tie for 10th with Chuunibyou. In my experience of watching Kyoto Ani anime, I could believe that because it did feel like they were putting a lot of average anime the last two years and it seems the MAL community agrees with me.
I'm sure I'm not the only Kyoto Animation fan that isn't happy with the direction the company has taken the last couple of years. With a new year ushered in, I can only hope Kyoto Ani tries to improve upon the mess with their series the last two years. I can foresee Hibike! Euphonium being an interesting series from what I've read about the plot and am seeing with the visuals. It doesn't seem to quite be like a previous musical based series like K-On!...perhaps more like a Kids On The Slope type series than something like K-On! I can only hope that it's a VAST improvement form what we've seen the last two years.
For the longest time, I was a fan of Production I.G., mostly due to their work with Ghost In The Shell. However, as I was introduced to more and more Kyoto Ani anime, the more I realized I loved what the company did.
I remember my first exposure to Kyoto Ani came to the roots as a company as a whole. I saw Full Metal Panic?! Fumoffu a few years after it came out and it was one of the funniest anime I had ever seen, even to this day. I was a fan of the original FMP series and even though the series changed hands from Gonzo to Kyoto Ani, I was pleasantly surprised by the work Kyoto Ani did on the continuation. While I didn't enjoy The Second Raid as much, I still found it entertaining.
My next exposure to Kyoto Animation came in the form of Haruhi Suzumiya. At the time, Haruhi and Aya Hirano were the greatest things in Japan since sliced bread. While I did find Haruhi's character to be extremely grating, I found the series itself to be pretty remarkable and as an anime viewer, there might be something to this romance genre I might like.
However, I went back to my comfort zone when I was exposed to Lucky Star. While on the outside it seems like an annoyance, I found Lucky Star to be downright hilarious and actually a stark contradiction of what I normally watch. Still, it ended up being a downright hilarious comedy for me and this is when I started to realize that Kyoto Ani might be a pretty good production company.
I did end up trying to watch the sequel series to Haruhi Suzumiya in 2009...which ended up being an enormous mistake. The Endless Eight was so damn aggravating that I dropped the series after the fifth or sixth episode. This was my first exposure to Kyoto Ani failure, but it would end up being a while before I would see another failure from the company.
A few years passed and I didn't really give them much thought until about 2011 came about. I really had no interest in watching the K-On! series, so I really wouldn't get back into Kyoto Ani until 2011. At that time, it was the first time I watched the Key adaptations of Clannad and Kanon. I didn't watch these anime for the longest time because I was not a fan of the character design, but they both turned out to be two of the best anime I have ever seen. To this day, I consider Clannad: After Story to be the greatest anime ever made. No anime has ever quite been able to move me in the same way Clannad: After Story did and I found its storytelling, albeit roundabout to be brilliantly written. This is the moment I became a true, die hard Kyoto Ani fan and the point where I considered Kyoto Animation to be my favorite anime production company.
My positive exposure to Kyoto Ani didn't stop there as I watched Nichijou next and along with its two comedic predecessors in Fumoffu and Lucky Star, I consider Nichijou to be one of the greatest anime comedies ever written.
2012 was another fantastic year in my eyes as a Kyoto Ani came out with Hyouka, a series I consider to be one of the most underrated series of all-time. It was a series with unbelievably strong character development and atmosphere. I considered my viewing of Hyouka to be euphoric and as someone that rarely ever re-watches series, Hyouka was one I absolutely loved to go back to and watch again. Chuunibyou came out that fall and while I didn't love it as much as many, I still considered it to be a strong, likable series.
...so where did it all go wrong?
In my opinion, the last two years for Kyoto Ani have been abysmal. 2013 got off to such an awful start. Tamako Market was so conceptually unremarkable that I didn't even bother wasting my time watching it and from the advice I received, that was the appropriate move. At the time, all the buzz was about the promotions for their upcoming series, Free! However, as a devout Kyoto Animation viewer, I was reluctant to watch Free! I was obviously not the demographic for this series, but I watched it regardless. Unfortunately, Free! received mixed reviews. It seemed to have a "Sword Art Online" type of reception where people either loved the series or downright hated it. I was one of the few that actually felt indifferent about the series where I found the hate for the series to be unjustified, while the praise for the series to be giving it more credit than what its worth. From an actual narrative standpoint, Free! was one of the weakest stories I have seen out of Kyoto Ani, but I will admit the animation was quite remarkable.
While first two series of 2013 from Kyoto Ani had me beside myself about the major drop in quality, promotions for their upcoming fall series Kyoukai no Kanata (Beyond the Boundary) had me excited beyond all belief. I truly believed going into that season that Kyokai no Kanata was going to be one of Kyoto Ani's best works, just from a conceptual and visual perspective. It is quite unfortunate that Kyoukai no Kanata was not all that it was cracked up to be. Granted, it had some of the best action visuals I had seen that year, but the series itself didn't have a well-written antagonist, the characters weren't as memorable, the plot took a rather unorthodox (and not in a good way) turn, and it left on one of the most aggravating cliffhangers/deus ex machina scenes I have seen in anime to date. I was downright enraged at the end of the series and could only wonder why Kyoto Ani would falter so bad on a series that could have been their flagship series for many years?
After the disappointment that was Kyoukai no Kanata, I hoped that the second season of Chuunibyou could rebuild my confidence in the company. I did highly enjoy the first season of Chuunibyou after all, so I figured that perhaps another season could bring my love for Kyoto Ani back. I kept telling myself that 2014 had to be a better year for Kyoto Ani anime than 2013, because my God 2013 was an awful year for Kyoto Ani. I was wrong yet again, as I found the second season of Chuunibyou to be the weakest series Kyoto Ani has put out since the second season of Haruhi. It was a downright disappointment. I wouldn't say the series was bad, but it was painfully average. Of all the words I could use to describe Kyoto Ani's previous works, average is not one that comes to mind so it actually hurts to call a Kyoto Ani series "average," but that's what Chuunibyou Ren was to me, just an average series.
I was extremely hesitant at first to watch Free! Eternal Summer. I was not a fan of the first season and I essentially only watched Eternal Summer just out of completionist complex. It's actually a good thing I did, because Free! Eternal Summer was BY FAR the best anime Kyoto Ani had put out in the last two years. I was remarkably surprised at the tonal shift it had from the first season and I applaud the direction the series went. The series had remarkably better character development than the first season, which is what Free needed in the worst way.
However, Kyoto Ani yet again let me down at the end of the year with Amagi Brilliant Park. Of course, I'm not saying Amagi Brilliant Park was bad. In fact, it had some downright hilarious scenes. I was expecting Amagi Brilliant Park to be the next Nichijou or Lucky Star in some sense. However, in my opinion, it was just an okay comedy. It had some pretty funny moments in it but it didn't have me rolling on the floor like the aforementioned Kyoto Ani comedies. There were some episodes I found to be a downright waste of time because not only did it not advance plot or develop characters, but were not funny on-top of that. The worst part about this series though? It had a deus ex machina plot with an unresolved conflict with the antagonist and ended on a filler episode. YOU...CANNOT...END...A...SERIES...ON...A...WORSE...NOTE! I liked the series going into the last few episodes but the last two episodes of Amagi really let me down.
I found it fascinating looking at the MAL stats of Kyoto Ani series. As of January 20, this is how each Kyoto Ani TV series ranked just by rating...
1. Clannad: After Story - 9.15 (2008)
2. Nichijou - 8.51 (2011)
3. Clannad - 8.46 (2007)
T4. Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu - 8.30 (2003)
T4. Kanon - 8.30 (2006)
6. Hyouka - 8.22 (2012)
7. K-On!! - 8.18 (2010)
8. The Melancholy Of Haruhi Suzumiya - 8.17 (2006)
9. Full Metal Panic: The Second Raid - 8.14 (2005)
T10. Chuunibyou - 8.07 (2012)
T10. Free!: Eternal Summer - 8.07 (2014)
12. Lucky Star - 7.97 (2007)
13. K-On! - 7.92 (2009)
14. Amagi Brilliant Park - 7.86 (2014)
15. Kyoukai no Kanata - 7.84 (2013)
16. Free! - 7.80 (2013)
17. Air - 7.60 (2005)
18. Chuunibyou Ren - 7.54 (2014)
19. Munto - 7.33 (2009)
T20. Haruhi Suzumiya 2 - 7.31 (2009)
T20. Tamako Market - 7.31 (2014)
What stood out to me was of the 21 anime series Kyoto Ani has produced, five of the six they've made in that stretch rank in the bottom half. The one that isn't in the bottom half is barely in the top half in a tie for 10th with Chuunibyou. In my experience of watching Kyoto Ani anime, I could believe that because it did feel like they were putting a lot of average anime the last two years and it seems the MAL community agrees with me.
I'm sure I'm not the only Kyoto Animation fan that isn't happy with the direction the company has taken the last couple of years. With a new year ushered in, I can only hope Kyoto Ani tries to improve upon the mess with their series the last two years. I can foresee Hibike! Euphonium being an interesting series from what I've read about the plot and am seeing with the visuals. It doesn't seem to quite be like a previous musical based series like K-On!...perhaps more like a Kids On The Slope type series than something like K-On! I can only hope that it's a VAST improvement form what we've seen the last two years.
Posted by Toucanbird | Jan 22, 2015 6:30 AM | 0 comments