For a long time I avoided the mahou shoujo genre of anime like the plague, until a friend recommended the series Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha. After that, my perception of "magical girls" changed completely, and for the first time I realised the potential of the genre. Nanoha was like no other anime of its type, combining shounen action with a rather dark storyline, all packaged in a "cute" anime (complete with small fluffy sidekick).
It's unfortunate then, that the stereotypical mahou shoujo anime still reigns supreme.
The rather strangely titled Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha The MOVIE 1st (simply calling it Nanoha: The Movie would have sufficed as
...
there's only one Nanoha in anime as far as I'm aware - feel free to correct me on this point though), is, as many anime fans may already know, about 9 year old Takamichi Nanoha, who answers a ferret's cry for help, obtains an intelligent device named Raising Heart (or Raging Heart, I'm still not sure which is correct), and becomes a magical girl tasked with finding "Jewel Seeds".
Cue the twinkly effects and soppy romance? Hell no! This is Nanoha, and she'd kick Sailor Moon's arse from here to the next dimension.
As far as the story goes, the movie is nothing more than a condensed retelling of the first series. Now some have tried to claim that the movie is a parallel history rather than a straightforward rehash (I'm looking at you Tsuzuki Masaki), however the differences between the two are very small indeed. While the movie takes liberties in an effort to condense information, the content is still pretty much the same (the major points anyway), so it puzzles me how anyone could consider this an alternative take on the original series.
Which brings me to a major problem I had with the movie. The plot flows rather nicely throughout the film, and the story has been compacted to a pretty good degree, however sacrifices have been made in order to accomodate the shortening of a 13 episode series into just over 2 hours. The biggest problem with the movie is that it has lost much of the charm the original series had, something which affects the characters in a big way. Granted there's more focus on the action, but one of the reasons why the whole Nanoha franchise works is because we see her grow from being a young, naive girl into the Ace of Aces, and much of that growth is missing from the movie.
Here's what I mean. Part of what I liked about the original Nanoha series was seeing how she came to terms with her new role and how it affected her relationship with her family and friends. Unfortunately, the movie doesn't have the time to go into this kind of detail so much of this is missing, and the upshot of this is that many of Nanoha's later actions, her fights with Fate and such, don't really have the same level of justification that they did in the series. The movie is nothing more than action for the sake of action, and the whole "alternate history" concept is only really noticable in a few small scenes..
But it's still enjoyable nonetheless :)
As for the effect of the shortened plot on the other characters, while the original series made some effort to round out certain individuals, the movie does nothing of the sort. Granted this is because of time constraints, however one can't help but wonder how fans of the series will take this distinct lack of characterisation and development, although in fairness to the movie, the viewer does get a good idea of Fate's motivations.
One thing that I did like is the fact that the cast from the original series and it's sequels have reprised their roles here, and their familiarity with the characters is telling as the performances are very good throughout. The only real downside to the acting is that there aren't too many opportunities for the seiyuu to display their talents because of the nature of the movie (i.e. it's far more action oriented), which limits their performances to a degree. As for the sound, the effects are exceptional throughout, especially during the combat sequences, while the music is very good not only in the scope of tracks, but also in their choregraphy.
In terms of looks, the movie is very clearly a reflection of the first series, and the characters and settings will be very familiar to those who have watched the original. The only real differences between the movie and the series are that the animation is, on the whole, better in the new version, and the action sequences are much more exciting now than they were before. Granted there are some minor visual alterations between the two, however these are nothing more than cosmetic changes to facilitate the belief that this is an "alternate history".
Now, did I enjoy the movie? Damn right I did. While I may not be a diehard fan of the franchise, Nanoha really did change my opinion of mahou shoujo, and while I may seem critical of the flaws in the film, that doesn't mean I didn't like it. The movie is very much an action based affair, and while this is an enjoyable romp in the realm of Nanoha, in all honesty I would much prefer to watch the original series. While the movie is a great way to while away a couple of hours, there is a distinct lack of character interaction that was part of the charm of the original series.
I doubt whether fans of the Nanoha franchise will find this a bad film as it enompasses a good deal of the plot from the original series. That said, while I enjoyed the movie a lot, there really is no competition as I much prefer the series. This isn't a bad film, not at all. It simply lacks some of the things that I liked about the original, and the fact that this is being pushed as an "alternate history" doesn't help matters.
In truth, while Nanoha: The Movie (see how much easier that is?), may be good, it's not the re-envisioning I expected or hoped for. The film could have been so much more if writer Tsuzuki Masaki, and director Kusakawa Keizou, had decided to follow one route only - either a complete alternate history, or a condensed retelling of the original series.
That said, this is a good action movie that suitably pays homage to the original, and while it can't really compare to the series in terms of depth, it will serve as a great introduction for new viewers who, like me, simply haven't realised just how good a mahou shoujo anime can be if done right.
Alternative Titles
Japanese: 魔法少女リリカルなのは The MOVIE 1st
More titlesInformation
Type:
Movie
Episodes:
1
Status:
Finished Airing
Aired:
Jan 23, 2010
Producers:
Aniplex
Licensors:
None found, add some
Studios:
Seven Arcs
Source:
Original
Theme:
Mahou Shoujo
Duration:
2 hr. 10 min.
Rating:
R+ - Mild Nudity
Statistics
Ranked:
#8052
2
based on the top anime page. Please note that 'Not yet aired' and 'R18+' titles are excluded.
Popularity:
#3980
Members:
31,470
Favorites:
198
Available AtResources | Reviews
Filtered Results: 16 / 16
Sort
Your Feelings Categories May 15, 2010
For a long time I avoided the mahou shoujo genre of anime like the plague, until a friend recommended the series Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha. After that, my perception of "magical girls" changed completely, and for the first time I realised the potential of the genre. Nanoha was like no other anime of its type, combining shounen action with a rather dark storyline, all packaged in a "cute" anime (complete with small fluffy sidekick).
It's unfortunate then, that the stereotypical mahou shoujo anime still reigns supreme. The rather strangely titled Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha The MOVIE 1st (simply calling it Nanoha: The Movie would have sufficed as ... Aug 20, 2010
Having just came back from watching Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha The MOVIE 1st at a movie theater and feeling very inspired, I felt like writing a review for it.
First off, as any Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha fan can tell by the title alone, Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha The MOVIE 1st is basically a recap of the first season. Things like reused elements to keep the whole feel of the series coherent, summarized version of the story to stay on track with the original, and on occasions seemingly reused portions from the original series... all of these are to be expected I guess. I'm pretty sure ... Nov 27, 2010
As a big fan of Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha since its beginning, I have been anticipating this movie for a very, very long time. It did not let me down in any department. It's a recap of season 1 - so of course, many plot details are lost.
However, this movie was clearly designed for a target audience of people who enjoy Nanoha but want to see it in high definition with updated animation. For that, it succeeds greatly. As such, I would not recommend watching this movie in place of the anime. Instead, it should be treated as ... Jul 27, 2012
"Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha: The Movie 1st" is, as stated in the synposis, a re-telling of all the major events that took place in the series, "Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha." While this movie does indeed cover all you really need to know about the overall story and plot, it's highly recommended that you've at least seen season one of Lyrical Nanoha before viewing this movie - mostly since the series touches on a larger variety of characters and gets you more familiar with the entire cast.
For the movie itself, I won't be reviewing it as a comparison to the series but as a standalone, ... Jan 7, 2014
"Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha" is one of the more true to form Magical Girl works that I've personally seen (the only other one being Madoka Magica), and personally I wasn't all that impressed. That being said Nanoha still manages to deliver on some level despite its quirks.
Story: 6 Execution wise the story could of panned out slightly better. Bogged down with pacing issues, and a few mechanical problems with the plot. These mechanical issues pertain to mainly: Nanoha herself (more on that later), some lack luster dialogue, and the powers of the girls. The overall tale lost impact due to some less than stellar writing, ... May 7, 2010
I REALLY enjoyed this movie! It is basically an alternate retelling of the first season. Its hard to not give things away, but ostly rthe sounds were remixes of the first season score, which is why i gave it only an 8. And mkost of the events were those I had already seen (although much of the pacing flaws were repaired) so I gave it a 9. Besides that, everything is a 10! For those who have never heard of Nanoha before, go and watch this movie instead of the first season, and then watch the second! This was truly an excellent film, but it
...
Mar 10, 2012
befriend (v.) - to inflict grievous bodily harm in the process of proving the validity of your beliefs
If there was one word to sum up "Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha the MOVIE: 1st", it would be that. "Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha the Movie: 1st" (which will hereon be referred to as Nanoha: The Movie) is a remake of the first season of the Lyrical Nanoha franchise, featuring Nanoha as a magical girl who causes massive property damage in the process of befriending her adversaries, and a rival magical girl, Fate. Both of them are after the twenty-one dangerous artifacts known as "Jewel Seeds". Let's sum up what ... May 10, 2010
The movie is a retelling of the first season for the Nanoha TV series. For those that don't know about Nanoha, the story is about the young protagonist, Nanoha Takamachi who comes across a magical device and must hunt for magical treasures before the bad guys get to them. However, this seemingly shallow and typical story hides its true nature which contains very well defined character interactions, relationships, and giant beam cannons.
Story: The story is far more coherent than its tv series part. It has essentially been streamlined and the boring filler parts have been excised. The story quickly establishes a focus on ... Oct 14, 2011
I've actually completed BOTH the original anime series and this, but I've decided to review this first because this movie is how I was introduced to the Lyrical Nanoha anime franchise.
STORY: Superb. That's all I can say for the story. Not only did the movie tied up a lot of loose ends which was a major flaw in the original anime series, it also included additional details such as the creation of Fate's weapon, as well as her magic teacher. It also explored more in-depth on the relationship between Fate and Precia Testarossa. Unnecessary elaboration from the original anime series was removed which made the plot ... Aug 30, 2011
If any of you have been around the anime block for the last six or so years, you've probably heard of a franchise called Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha. This is a series of anime tv shows, movies, manga, audio CDs, video games, and other stuff about a girl who gains a magical relic and uses it to fight bad guys. Yeah, I know, that sounds exactly like the premise for Sailor Moon or Cardcaptor Sakura, but what set Nanoha apart from other magical girl series was: 1) the "Magic" is really more like highly advanced technology from other planets. 2) There's a greater emphasis on
...
Nov 28, 2013
Nanoha is a bit of a strange franchise, it took the typically girly magical girl and injected into it a dose of gundam style action and a much grittier story than common for this kind of series. The result was something of a mixed bag, the early episodes were almost indistinguishable from many other mahou shoujo's. As it went on though the story improved and it turned into something that while no masterpiece could certainly hold its own.
So how does this movie version compare? Quite well. With a much shorter length the story has been compressed and streamlined down cutting out much of the early ... Jun 25, 2016
Mahou Shojo Lyrical Nanoha: The Movie 1st. The movie is great in all level. As a fan of Mahou Shojo, this story, is just outstanding. The movie takes a different approach from the series and changes in outfit: like Nanoha have more robotic arms instead of all cloth; the fighting scene have more flying than the original series, and it's also widescreen to fit our modern monitors; along with different audio improvements; and different story transition. However, having said all of that, story is the same as the original series. I tend to enjoy the original series a bit more as how the author depicted
...
Jan 8, 2020
It's no secret at this point that I'm a big fan of the Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha franchise, except for Triangle Heart but that barely counts as connected to the rest. And since Nanoha and Fate are one of my favourite anime couples, it seems like an ideal time to look at one of the films. We'll start with the oddly named Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha: The Movie 1st.
Story: The film basically gives an abridged account of the first Nanoha series. As such, I'm not going to worry about giving spoilers since I've already reviewed multiple series of Vivid and anyone who's read my reviews regularly ... Jun 2, 2013
To be perfectly honest, I never really gave the Nanoha series much of a look at. So I decided to rectify that by watching the first of the three movies.
Well, color me intrigued show. Story (8/10): From what I've heard, this is pretty much a recap of the whole first 13 episodes, with some bits cut out. It worked fairly well, to be honest. I think that the whole 'collect the Jewel Seed' plot was just rushed out as quick as possible so that they could get to the better parts of the story, but that's fine since the rest of the movie was paced ... Feb 4, 2022
Perhaps I'm just a sucker for high quality animation and the big budget production value that animated films have over their weekly counterparts, but I somehow found myself thoroughly enjoying this way more than I did the first season of the show. Maybe it's just that I've spent enough time with these characters at this point that I was more emotionally invested in their struggles. The story is exactly the same, so if you've already seen the first season of the show there's nothing new to be had there. I still think it's worth watching anyway.
For anyone completely new to the series I think this ... Jul 12, 2023
Lyrical Nanoha Movie - The 1st is an excellent movie that acts as an all-purposes recap/reboot for the first season of the eponymous anime. In my experience, rebooting a TV series or season can be a mixed bag: sometimes it can suffer from lack of originality or feel like it's simply re-hashing the plot. Sometimes, it gets worse than this even and can feel like pure pandering or simply trying to cash in on the franchise in a quick and lucrative way. While not necessarily a bad thing in itself, these can be detractors from the enjoyment of the movie.
It is with much joy then, ... |