Kabukichou Sherlock

In Shinjuku ward's east side lies Kabukichou, a vibrant city of chaos that glows brilliantly with neon lights but also hides unseen darkness. Employed at a university hospital on the west side, John H. Watson is looking for someone who can assist him with an odd case. His search leads him to the Pipe Cat, an underground bar that serves as a meetup venue and job board for some of the best detectives in Shinjuku, the most prominent among them being Sherlock Holmes.

Upon finding the bar and meeting the peculiar investigators, John learns that they are pursuing a case involving Jack the Ripper, an infamous serial killer. Due to subsequent events, John ends up driving Sherlock to the crime scene of a murder supposedly carried out by Jack the Ripper. Even though John is only there to enlist Sherlock's help with his case, he witnesses Sherlock brilliantly uncover the truth behind the crime scene. However, he begins to realize that Sherlock is not only a genius detective but also an eccentric character.

As John continues to request Sherlock to assist him with his case, he finds himself spiraling into the detective lifestyle of solving cases beyond the minds of ordinary civilians. Through this work, John begins to see the true colors of the chaotic city that is Kabukichou and starts to unravel the unsettling mystery behind his own case.

[Written by MAL Rewrite]

Holmes, Sherlock Main

Konishi, Katsuyuki Japanese

H. Watson, John Main

Nakamura, Yuuichi Japanese

Moriarty, James Supporting

Yamashita, Seiichirou Japanese

Mrs. Hudson Supporting

Suwabe, Junichi Japanese

Morstan, Lucy Supporting

Higashiuchi, Mariko Japanese

Kyougoku, Fuyuto Supporting

Saitou, Souma Japanese

Kobayashi, Toratarou Supporting

Tachibana, Tatsumaru Japanese

Belmont, Michel Supporting

Aoyama, Yutaka Japanese

Morstan, Mary Supporting

Touyama, Nao Japanese

Hokari, Maki Supporting

Murase, Ayumu Japanese

Cook, Justin Producer

Maeda, Toshihiro Producer

Kawamoto, Sachi Producer

Shimizu, Norie Producer

Reviews

Sep 22, 2020

mushi_Jyou

Recommended

Reason for watching: The show looks like it will be fun and pack with Mysteries too; I am looking for something lighthearted to watch for a change of pace.

TL;DR: This show which revolves around mystery cases is fun at the start, then took an escalator down to the entrance of the psychotic realm, all while having the consistent subjects of what is considered as dark and taboo(in many cultures in our real world) as the underlying setting for most storylines. Due to its cross-overs with vastly different genres, that are strongly depicted in the show, if you were to slightly dislike one of them, this ... show will most probably be unbearable.

After watching the show and reading the reviews, I would have to say, this is the kind of show that picks its audience, not the other way around. IYKYK though~
I am going to have to put this forward and say that I was not watching this show wholeheartedly, I was in a state of grieve while I was watching this show. (Is just how I was trying to cope with my grief.) I will try to write my review as objective as I can to do the show justice.


Story: Concept and Execution
Concept
This is somewhat a parody of the famous Sherlock Holmes novels, there is of course many versions and adaptations throughout our time and we won't know what exactly the creators/author referenced, but they all revolves around Mystery cases. As in all parodies, there is of course the element of comedy, but this show incorporated both slapstick comedy and dark humour into the story. Comedy in general is already a very difficult genre to exhibit, but to weave two different types of humour into a story that possess quite a load of seriousness, just seem to be a lot of work. Comedy and Mystery are just two of the more outstanding genres that can be seen throughout the show. The unique environment the characters are placed in, the characters design itself, and the characters' background themselves are all interesting. With this setting and the mix of genres, this show is the definition of peculiar.
And so from my point of view, I can't see how this show is transphobic, in fact part of this show's peculiarity is its diversity of characters from all walks of life. (Well there is a diversity of characters, but not to say the show is about diversity, is really not about any particular group or category of people)

Execution (Story-telling)
The execution of this concept is considerably good, for all its strange events and characters that it has. They were able to smoothly transition from slapstick to mystery to dark humour to psychological to thriller and many more. The first half of the show is definitely more lighthearted and "detached", in the sense that is pretty much episodic and there's little personal involvement from the characters. Right at the ending of the first half is when the story took a turn and continued into the second half of the show with the characters getting more personal and more involved with the cases on a emotional/psychological level. In the first half, there are some dark humour lurking around in the background while slapstick plots are everywhere, but in the second half, the slapstick humour toned down a lot, but the dark humour did not "took its place". They did increase more storylines with dark humour, but not by a lot, instead the psychological aspect of the show comes straight up in your face, paired with the thriller element. So much so that, even while grieving, I knew that if I were to watch this on some other normal days, I would have been pretty emotional more than a couple of times. I actually have to stop watching the show a couple of days because I know I am ruining the show for myself by not being able to be invested in it wholeheartedly. But I do understand logically how the storylines unfold and how they linked to each other in the most simplest way. There is nothing confusing in how the events are told, yet the events all habour the mysteries that they should have properly. Very nimble way of executing the story. Throughout the show, there are many instances of mature and taboo subjects that appears on the scene so very "casually". Is only casual due to the premise of the show of course. The way the story throws in the mature-taboo contents in is quite smart, imo. They are not explicit and focused on enough to "scar" anyone, but they are not hidden like "easter eggs". They were conveyed on to the scenes like how natural the topic of "what new animes are there this coming season?" can be brought up in real life. They aren't taboo in the show, they are as normal as any of the characters in the show. Is possible that these scenes of "sensitive" topics are more noticeable to me due to my experience too. Hence, this is especially subjective, but I like (mildly appreciate it even) how this show engineered its depth into the story. The show is deeper and darker and more real than I had expected.


Art and Sound
Character art style is not the typical bishoujo, bishounen art. They are not pretty, they are not unique, they are just interestingly normal. Normal as in, they don't have all the same eyes where only the eye colour differs, or they don't have the same face shape where only the hairstyle tells them apart. Is almost like they are as close to real life as an anime style drawing can get ("almost" because I think the anime <Monster> have a more real life drawing style). Well overall the character art style isn't wack, is interesting but not eye-catching. The background and scenery on the other hand, are a sight for sore eyes. They are pretty, colourful yet not obscenely bright, and very detailed. Opening and ending scenes are very fun to watch too. Animation is also what you can expect of a quality work in this day and age. To sum it out, Art is above average with very good colour matching senses.
There are no issues with the Sound of this anime. VAs are good, sound effects are on point, opening and ending songs are above average. All is good.


Character
Well it is a parody of Sherlock Holmes, so the main characters' design are based upon the characters of the original of course, but with a twist. Sherlock is quirky, but in what way? That is in the way he deduces the mystery with a performance, his eating preferences of unthinkable combination, and many more. Can't really go on describing the characters since they are all so very distinct, I would have to write an essay just to cover them. So, yes, the characters may be based on the originals but they all have their own twists and are rightfully exclusive to this show. The characters design are mostly interesting and entertaining (there are some which are really boring and possess the personality of a mob character) that I wouldn't have mind a minor 2 - 3 episodes arc of these characters' origin story or development storyline. The show did at least dedicate 1 episode to some of the characters (But it focuses more on the cases than the characters). For the few characters that we do get to know more about their past, their backstories are refreshingly "normal" as compared to the current premise of their life in the show, which further highlights the peculiarity of the story. Hahah~ The show also established a vastly different relationship between the characters than that of the original. The twists in the characters, and their relationships to each other, along with a vivacious environment where the story takes place in, makes for a cast of mysterious characters (which also helps in making the story more dynamic actually). Out of those entertaining characters, only several of them are as deep as the story, or probably deeper though (the others are just the "you get what you see"). But then due to the execution of the story, there are hardly any character developments in the first half, and the second half only develops the very main characters (the minuscule development of the side characters are just predictable). There is a slight discrepancy here though, where the main characters that have depth develops and grow, they don't actually mesh well with the other characters. (Or maybe is just me, since the characters that have depth developed through a psychological narrative, I may have felt like they were more than just simple fictitious characters) But then, due to the nature of the show focusing on the mysterious cases to be solved, the lack of character development isn't very obvious, after all, the story itself develops well.

FYI: Moriarty is a main character in my opinion~

Hint: Don't expect anything from this show, let it take you on this ride~ Hahaha~

Reviewer’s Rating: 8

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by mushi_Jyou (28)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Aug 22, 2020

MewMeowth

Mixed Feelings

Spoiler

Major spoilers ahead.

I still don't understand this anime's insistence in generating empathy for Moriarty's character in the audience. He's one of the most ruthless killers I have seen in anime recently. He had a total disdain for human life and was obviously a sadist POS as exemplified when he had Mary choose between her sister and Watson. And he was only 16 years old. *facepalm* No matter how much of a tearjerker his dumb backstory was made to be--in fact, the more it's shown the more you realise his family was quite alright without him.

The parallels they continuously try to draw in the last episodes ... between Moriarty and Sherlock are preposterous. Sure, Sherlock's an odd character, eating gummy bears with rice and all, but nothing he ever did would lead you to conclude he's a hidden serial murderer... somehow restrained by Watson's goodness and naïveté. So in the logic of this anime anyone with an odd personality is a potential serial murderer? Ridiculous.

The only positive I can see in this anime is the other characters. Mrs. Hudson carried the whole show honestly. I wish there was an episode focused on her backstory. Fuyuto and Toratarou were also interesting. The Maki story was also OK.

I'm not familiar with the source material so I wonder, this anime could have been much better if it didn't have that stupid Moriarty story arch and was instead a bunch of crime-solving plots that would span 1-2 episodes each.

Reviewer’s Rating: 6

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by MewMeowth (2)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Sep 26, 2020

Junnnz

Not Recommended

I watch anime, and I never have an account for MyAnimeList because I’m simply too lazy, but guess what? I want to vent about this one so much that I open up an account for it.

I’m a really big Sherlock Holmes fan for years, and I love to see all kinds of adaptions. When Kabukichou Sherlock had its first trailer, I was so excited! All the novelty, the setting, the weird characters! I waited and waited, watched the trailer over and over. Well, the bigger the anticipation, the worse the disappointment.

Dreadful characterization, so dreadful that by the end of the anime the only person I ... still actually like is Mrs. Hudson.

I welcome innovative approach to Sherlock Holmes adaptations, in fact I love it. Innovation toward characterization? Marvelous! But you have to make them into actual people, sane rational human beings. I don’t see any of that with this anime.

I typed and deleted, typed and deleted. Just writing this review brings me back the anger I had when I tried finish watching this anime months ago.

If you like Sherlock Holmes in the ACD novel, or actually, any good adaptations, don’t watch it, you’ll likely be disgusted.

If you want to watch characters with sane minds interacting, don’t watch it, there’re very few in the anime, and none of them is the main characters.

If you want to completely disregard the actual Sherlock Holmes novel, watch characters interact in ways you think “why would you do that???”, enjoy non-mystery mystery. Go ahead, I guess when you don’t think about it, pretending everything is okay, it might be somehow fun. I mean, it’s supposed to be funny. Although by the end of the anime, I was nothing near being entertained.

Reviewer’s Rating: 3

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by Junnnz (1)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Trans Anime part 3

by Keizakomu

50 Entries · 28 Restacks

Not Your Average Mystery

by OhlLonesomelMe

24 Entries · 45 Restacks

Boys Kissing Boys

by floopydisk

31 Entries · 75 Restacks

North American Anime & Manga Releases for January

Here are the North American anime & manga releases for January Week 1: January 5 - 11 Anime Releases Black Bullet Blu-ray [2021 re-release] Conception Blu-ray [E...read more

Jan 5, 2021 2:08 PM by ImperfectBlue | Discuss (8 comments)

North American Anime & Manga Classes for December

Here are the North American anime & manga releases for December Week 1: December 1 - 7 Anime Releases Ajin OVA [incl. Ajin 2nd Season OVA] (Ajin: Demi-Human - Th...read more

Dec 1, 2020 8:59 AM by ImperfectBlue | Discuss (9 comments)

	Poll: Kabukichou Sherlock Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 ) Stark700 - Mar 27, 2020	54 replies	by SenChen »» Apr 14, 2024 1:45 AM
	Poll: Kabukichou Sherlock Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 ) Stark700 - Dec 20, 2019	59 replies	by naturalbrawler »» Jan 15, 2024 12:10 AM
	Poll: Kabukichou Sherlock Episode 7 Discussion Stark700 - Nov 22, 2019	27 replies	by naturalbrawler »» Jan 14, 2024 11:39 AM
	Poll: Kabukichou Sherlock Episode 12 Discussion Stark700 - Dec 27, 2019	39 replies	by OneFaintingRobin »» Mar 14, 2023 12:16 PM
	Poll: Kabukichou Sherlock Episode 9 Discussion Stark700 - Dec 6, 2019	34 replies	by EratiK »» Sep 4, 2022 3:58 PM

In Numbers: The Best and Worst Anime of Fall 2019

Scores, members, favorites — everything you need to know about who won and lost Fall 2019.

by Shymander

112,672 views

Spoiler

Fall 2019 Anime Premiere Impressions

We went and watched the first episode of nearly every single anime this season so you don't have to!

by MAL_Articles

63,288 views

Spoiler