It's an immensely enjoyable ride with this series. It's a relatively simple story, but it's easy to follow and it's a fun watch. The series composition is amazing in that I always feel satisfied after watching because most times it contains drama within the episode and also balances it out with lighthearted moments. It never gets too heavy even while you are emotionally moved by plot developments.
I first decided to try out this series because I saw a composer that I like was doing the soundtrack. Honestly this show wouldn't have attracted me otherwise since I like watching anime with action or romance, so I
didn't expect I would come to love this series.
The first episode will definitely catch viewers off guard. But even though you'll often be surprised by the sudden songs it's something you'll find yourself more or less getting used to. I recommend watching at least the first 3 episodes to see how you'll like it.
Starmyu appears to be this dumb silly show but if you go deeper you'll see the writers and director have put quite a bit of thought into it. There's symbolism here and there and I like how they lay down plotlines and details that are picked up later again in the show. And more than that, it's a classic story about youth and friendship, dealing with their own everyday troubles, chasing their dreams. I love the tagline on the show's promotional materials - "I don't know a way to give up my dream."
A big plus of Starmyu for me is that it takes away annoyances I've had with other anime. There's always the energetic and optimistic character type which appears here in form of Hoshitani, but the good thing about him is that he's surprisingly realistic when it counts. Also, the lack of a female MC in this show (it being an all-boys school) was especially refreshing, and it made the relationship between the guys shine even more instead of watching them vie over a girl.
If I had to name one fault that Starmyu had, it would probably be the animation, which sometimes looks derpy and low-budget. There were a couple of times where the characters didn't look themselves. But in return for that the staff puts special attention on the musical scenes. Some of them are really pretty and detailed, and the dance scene in one of the episodes was quite talked about thanks to the smooth hand-drawn animation.
No grouches about the voice acting. There are some good choices here in the cast since there is a lot of singing going on and for the most part they have good vocals, including even the least experienced member of the cast Lounsbery Arthur, who's playing a main character for the first time. Standout singing voices for me are KENN and Hanae Natsuki.
I think that the music is something that everyone can listen to. Personally the character songs are 50-50 hit and miss for me, but that's a very high rate by my standards. The good songs are really good, while the rest are just "meh" but not dislikable. Soundtrack BGM-wise, it's always excellent in this series.
Lastly while this series is obviously targeted at females, I've noticed that there is quite a handful of guys in Japan who enjoy it. Don't be put off by the all-male cast; you might just enjoy the story.
This series is by no means an amazing masterpiece that will blow your socks off into another dimension. At the same time I think this anime has some good qualities that make it worth the watch.
It's a singing anime so there are a ton of songs in this series. Although some songs aren't all that great, some are pretty enjoyable. Sadly, these songs actually added to my enjoyment of the series in a rather shameful way. Most of the transitions between singing and real live is so ridiculous, its comical. The transitions just fail terrible, making it pretty hilarious.
I've seen better and
I've seen worse. It really isn't special or spectacular in anyway. I do like however that the characters dancing is drawn instead of done with CGI. It adds more life to the characters. The character designs are also decently unique and it is easy to tell all of them apart.
I'm not even going to try to make this sound better than it is. The story is pretty cliche, but still stands on its own in some peculiar way. Although the events are somewhat predictable, they don't come out of nowhere. Foreshadowing is actually present in the series, which seems to be some foreign concept in anime nowadays. That being said, the series has no innovative storyline. It isn't a bad typical story, but it is quite typical.
The shining star of the anime would have to be its characters. They are a pretty fun cast and everyone grows on you. I have to commend this series for paying attention to character development. Yes their development is subtle, but it is very logical and smooth. What I am really trying to say here is that the character development does not come out of nowhere. I like how the series is built on relationships between characters, and doesn't try to be so typical in that area. Especially as the series comes to a close it is easy to see that Starmyu has taken plenty of time to make each main character pretty special. Also, shoutout to Kuga (quiet guy) for being the best mom!
This would have to be one of the guilty pleasure animes that I have seen. I acknowledge how cliche and stupid so many of the moments are, but at the same time I had a pretty fun time watching this. Sometimes the sheer stupidity of the series had my laughing out loud. If you don't want to watch a tragedy, this is the way to go.
I would recommend this series to people who generally like this kind of series: almost all male cast, a little bit dramatic, lots of ships, ridiculous events, cute characters, and lots of singing.
Generic. The story involves 5 boys who have auditioned and been put into an idol group within their school and must compete to be placed into the music department. This means they’ll be evaluated on their performance growth to see whether they could make it in the schools official elite musical.
Generally, you would assume this would mean competing against the other groups of performers for a place in the department. While this is true, it’s only to an extent. Ive counted over 20 different groups, and we only saw one group besides our main group ever perform, which they only did twice. This
means there is almost ZERO tension when they are ranked as we dont see what any of the other teams did to compare them too! We dont even get to see much of the technical side of rehearsing, as we mostly receive still shots of stretches or poses. Whatever.
Going back and listening to the tracks, they actually werent bad. I think my favorite voices belong to Kaito and Kakkeru. Voice acting was pretty solid but I cant really recall much background music.
Generic Tropes. We have the stoic, blue haired “perfect” boy with an Onii-san complex, Red-haired and arrogant uppity boy, a timid motherly type who just wants peace, The purple other-stoic but also edgy artsy one (he plays piano!), and the BORING upbeat brown-haired protagonist. Red-har was the most entertaining, as I appreciate the arrogant ones a lot plus, his cat stuff was cute.
However, the character interactions just dont feel right. After watching it, the kids barely know shit about each other and I really barely feel any substance tying each other together aside from being on team Otori. I suppose Nayuki became more outgoing from being on the team and being around MC-kun, but it want really focused on. The characters barely reflect on their past or talk about their feelings so I really dont understand why I should care.
Art: TERRIBLE. The character designs are so uncomfortable to look at. Almost every frame had me cringing just at the faces. Seriously, what were they thinking. It’s easy to see almost all the faces are identical to wear I feel like im watching the much-better Osomatsu-san. Everyone’s haor had this weird splotch of (root?) color at the top making it look like they all had bad dye jobs. Even the bodies have mostly the same shape. This designer should be fired. Some of the backgrounds during the songs looked nice I guess.
Animation: Ugh. Some of these episodes would have at least a third of the scenes shown in still frames. It’s almost like they didnt try. Theatre is a very visual and moving art, but it feels so stiff, just like most of their dance sequences. Also, please fire this animation director. Overlaying ugly still images over simple repetitive movements doesnt look nice, it makes it look like you got lazy. There was also an extreme over use of sparkles. Come on.
At least I got some good laughs at the over the top performances. Nayuki rode on a dolphin through the sky. That’s good shit.
Ludonarrative dissonance is a pretentious term from 2006 game reviewers that refers to a game's narrative clashing with its gameplay. Having watched "Starmyu", formerly referred to as "High School Star Musical", I believe that this term should be co-opted for things outside of video games, such as animation.
There's a certain point in the final episode where the titular Stardust Team claims that they will host their final performance in an avant-garde way. You see, that's sort of the overarching story of this show. The musical team of our 5 main characters likes to perform in unconventional ways - challenging the standards of their school ensnared
with tradition. So while this embracing of the new and unconventional ways totally makes sense within the show's story, it clashes with the anime as a whole.
I have not watched Prince-Sama, but I have been told by multiple trusted sources that High School Star Musical's format is a carbon-copy of it. And judging by descriptions alone that makes total sense. Both feature musical academies with teams of 5 bishonen boys color-coded by their hair, and are likely made to appeal to the exact same audience. While High School Star Musical's moral seems to be embracing quirky and new ideas, its execution is the exact opposite. It plays itself so safely that there's not a single moment of the show that stands out to me. Likewise, there's not a single moment that I really hated. High School Star Musical carefully constrains itself into as many classic tropes it can find, and by doing so, makes itself a bastion of average.
Although I didn't hate any of it, High School Star Musical definitely has some quirks. The character designs look like they were stolen from the vaults of the producers of Free!, and the character models seem are very samey. Episode 6 introduces two twin girl characters (the only girls in the whole show, literally), and they kind of look like the animators just took their standard boy designs and added some long pink hair. Also they reminded me of those twin girls from Johnny Test. God bless all of our souls.
High School Star Musical, like almost every bishonen show, suffers badly from queerbaiting. The target audience of this show was surely preteen and teenage girls, and to capitalize on that, the producers made sure to add plenty of romantic tension between the main characters. But never enough. You see, the producers want those teenage girls to take the cast of High School Star Musical as their husbandos. However, they also know that boy's love sells. In an attempt to appease both, the producers add all sorts of blushes, stuttering, and even misinterpreted declarations of love and dates, but never actually announce that their male characters are in gay relationships. This queerbaiting is present in western shows too (think Supernatural and Sherlock), and once you notice it, it's really hard to ignore that the producers are using marginalized sexual orientations as a footstool to make their show more popular, without even giving those orientations proper representation.
I've been giving High School Star Musical a lot of flak, but if its goal was to create an utterly average show like I outlined earlier, then it did it well. If you don't put a lot of critical thinking into it, the show isn't a slog to get through - under one condition. If you watch the show at 1.5 times speed, it becomes easy to get through and all the music goes nightcore mode. The lines are simplistic enough that you can keep up with reading too. Shortening episode duration to 15 minutes makes this show incredibly manageable, and if I hadn't discovered this I would probably have given it a lower rating.
In the end, High School Star Musical seems as average as can be, but there may be a lot of value in the discourse that results from it. Its ludonarrative dissonance is strongly resonating and each viewer may interpret said dissonance very differently.
Back in 2006, when the term "ludonarrative dissonance" was coined, game reviewers were so caught up in talking about how a game's mechanics worked alongside its story that they forgot to actually talk about things readers cared about, like whether the game was fun and worth buying. Sort of like how you can read a Pitchfork album review and have no idea what the music is supposed to sound like. So for the Starmyu Review, I tried to recreate that feeling of being so far up your own ass that you can't even write good reviews.
I am a quite big fan of music anime and handsome anime guys so it's a given that I would like this anime.But I don't think you would regret watching this even if only to laugh at the boys' weird dances(and songs) that pop out of nowhere.
At first I didn't know what I was getting myself into,I just knew there would be music so that was enough for me.The story isn't all that new and was fairly predictable but it still was entertaining.
The main character,Hoshitani once saw a boy dancing when he was in middle school and it captivated the protagonist so much that he
even enrolled at Aoyanagi academy to become an amazing entertainer.He didn't really know much else besides the fact that he could achieve his dream there so when Nayuki tells him about the competition for the star frame class,he enters without realising that it isn't all that easy.But then his performance catches Ootori's eye so he takes Hoshitani under his wing along with 4 other students who were supposed to fail.From then on they proceed to follow their senpai's lead and actually having fun with what they do unlike the other members who follow the rules to maintain the school's tradition and reputation.There are a few obstacles and thorns along the way of our heroes but there isn't anything our heroes can't overcome with the power of music.
The story is simple enough,the pacing felt a bit slow at times(but they actually rehearse!) and halfway through is just getting to know the characters but it's a nice change to sit back and relax,enjoy the music and laugh.
Most animes of this genre us a more mature look for the characters that would give a more appealing look but this one used a more cartoonish style.Three of the main guys have unbelievably big eyes(Nayuki looks like a bunny with that pout of his) but the rest look alright.Their rivals seemed better looking in my eyes to be honest.And most of them were ''assigned'' a color to make the differences visible.For example Hoshitani green,Tengenji red,Nayuki yellow ,Tsukigami blue,Kuga purple,etc.It's a given with the number of characters I guess.I am at least glad that this anime doesn't use CGI for the dances,that would've been horrible.
The songs aren't all that wow but they are acceptable.Not too memorable either but I enjoyed the opening and ending,Kuga and Tsukigami's character songs and their first performance.It's also a plus that Ootori has the voice of Grimmjow(Bleach),Aomine(Knb),Ren(Utapri) and Atobe(Pot).Every time he says ''boys'' is a blessing to my ears.
The characters follow quite a bit on single trait basis at first:Hoshitani is the one who can get along with everyone,Nayuki shy,Tengenji tsundere,Kuga quiet,Tsukigami the brocon and Ootori the model.Even if there wasn't that critical of a development in the boys,it still was pleasing to see beyond their stereotypical appeareances,relate to the characters and cheer them on.I'm a bit surprised at the relationship between the student president and Ootori but I feel it was a nice addition.The president's fanboy annoyed me like hell though.Did he really have to butt in every time.At least in the end he gives the boys a break...
This has been a nice experience for me because I managed to forget my worries when I was watching those students achieve their dreams.It isn't the most memorable of animes and you won't have a change of life perspectives because of it but it's entertaining.I would rewatch it again just because.
It's an average musical anime with all the clichest of premises but I felt it was something more than that and I would recommend it to anyone who likes to unwind and enjoy its liveliness.
Starmyu - An enjoyable and funny, yet slightly cringey and weird show.
After watching the TV series imagine-nation, you can learn a few things about the show and art.
It's a weird show, but it's quite funny. It's a bit predictable, but still entertaining enough to keep you engaged till the end. You'd like to see what happens to the characters as they story continues, and the complication comes along. There isn't much to describe here, but even so, I think the storyyline is good.
Please don't get me started on the art. I'm sorry, but seriously. The main characters' appearances look alright, but honestly, most
of the characters look really..really...REALLY....I dunno...weird? Sorry if you think they look handsome or anything, I just find them weird. I mean, have you seen Kaito's older brother Haruto? I'm sorry to his fans out there but..CRINGE.
I don't have much to say here as well but the songs were really great and nice to listen to and the voice actors played their part not amazingly well. I especially loved the song they performed in Episode 12 . The voice actors of Team Otori are quite famous actually.
The characters were okay I guess. They're a bit cliche. The leader, the upbeat Yuta Hoshitani, his best friend(well, at least, I'm pretty sure he is) the gentleToru Nayuki, the strict blue-haired Kaito Tsukigami, the arrogant Kakeru Tengenji, and the quiet Shuu Kuga. Is it just be or are they similar to the Love Live! characters?
Overall, it was alright and I think it was quite funny. The songs were great, the story was nice, characters were fine and so was the art. I recommend you watch this anime if you like anime boys trying to become musical stars. The 2nd Season is actually quite good so far, so I hope you watch that too^^
It is the japanese version of High School Star Musical
This anime is so enjoyable with simplistic story and conflict. There's episodes that focuses on each characters with their solo performance. Every episode fleshes out the development for each character but they never truly change.
The art is very common and sometimes it gives out a cool scene but I can't help but look at some deformed character parts.
Every episode is full of numbers by each of the characters ala High School Musical and even though there's no unique beat and catchiness in it, I love how it gives the characters a personality.
The characters are common, you
have the optimistic center, shy guy, boastful guy, overshadowed-by-his-famous-brother guy, and the side guy. Nevertheless, they all became enjoyable to watch. I laugh at how fast they got friendly with each other but hey, it is a 12 episode anime.
The rivals though are lackluster, they're just a group of bishounen who just dance and I can't see how they're better, aura wise and all.
I enjoyed the anime and not one minute did it made me bored. It is so funny and the cast are just so simple, no complicated backstory that can make head fuzzy. Just simple anime to watch and enjoy.
Overall, I had fun with watching it but I don't know for you guys.
Enter the next coming of UtaPri! Or what it was suppose to be, I think. This one is just another in the singing anime trend that's been going on. Well, with the rise in popularity of the voice actors, I'm not very surprised.
StarMyu is a bit different from UtaPri since there is zero romance (and lots and lots of bromance). Kind of to the point where I think it borders the shounen ai genre, but I like to think of it as guys who are extremely close friends. Yes.
The story itself is pretty cliche. It follows that group of failures/ oddballs that are
picked up by oddball yet talented senpai and turned into sparkling talents themselves through hardwork and conflict. Pretty standard for animes regarding the entertainment industry. Standard set.
The anime is really pretty to look at as well. The character designs aren't too flashy, but give off the "I am the main character" vibe and it's great. The dance sequences are also animated really well, although I wish they could change the dance choreography a bit, but that's just personal taste. It's a really pretty and beautifully done anime in terms of the animation department! 9/10.
The cast of the anime sing really well. I can't give it a lower score. They've got some sweet songs in the anime, but not nearly as good as UtaPri. They used singing voice actors, including Ono Kensho, who's actually a singer. This was one of the first singing animes I've heard with Hanae Natsuki in the cast, but from the character songs I've heard, he's a pretty decent singer as well. Nice songs to listen to and the lyrics aren't strange to listen to outside of context! Although listening to some duets between the guys was difficult to take seriously because the lyrics were clearly love lyrics, but it was because of some bromance conflict thing.
The cast is also pretty standard set. You've got the optimistic try-hard who starts off as the hole of the team and can't do anything from lack of experience. Then you have the shy boi who's good at cooking and cleaning, the mama of the group of boyz. Then you have the arrogant one that calls everyone a boor because he's got a ton of kabuki talent and comes from a renown family. Then the aniue complex boi who has his stuff together but always feels overshadowed by his bro-bro. And you can't forget the aloof one who's strange and didn't really have much character development because he just sort of got along with everyone without an episode dedicated to him. I mean, they show why he's so mature and stuff, but in the end he just kind of joins with no conflict. Pretty standard boy bandy stuff.
The dance scenes were pretty enjoyable to watch, although they just kind of broke out into song in the most random places and I couldn't help but make to fun of it. Like I said, it was really pretty to look at and the characters may be standard but their pretty balanced so their interactions are pretty entertaining to follow as well. Story's not really memorable though.
If they had come up with a better scriptwriter, I think the anime would've been a lot better than it was. The overall plot was just cliche and bad. The animation and sound made me watch the anime through the end and definitely made me enjoy it. If you want singing, pretty boys, and great animation, StarMyu is where it's at.
After watching all twelve episodes, I find Starmyu highly overrated at its current average score of 7.09. The story and the setting being clichés I wouldn't mind, after all what can one expect from high school slice of life? Even if it is flavoured and we have a music academy instead of a regular school this time - that's really where its specialty starts and ends.
From the very start I've had the feeling that the anime suffers from a bit of an identity crisis: the main cast is supposed to be a bunch of musical students, but pretty much all we ever see them do
is practice dance moves and sing. Last I checked, musicals are not operas, they include acting as well, something there's about one and a half attempts at bringing into the show. It's more of idols in training, and that in itself wouldn't be bad if it wasn't for the constant verbal reminders that they in fact want to be "musical stars". The singing itself, however, is a problem, as I don't think I can recall one single song that was entirely cringe-free in 12 episodes. Which is saying a lot as there is at least one "performance" in every episode: again, in the genre, one can't really expect much from the lyrics, but here the prompts (if there is one) and the "performances" themselves are both just cringe-worthy. And somehow out of place, weird, random: from all we see it's like it's in their heads, as opposed to within the scene with the other character(s) there with them; just diving into memories or musings, magically changed into some costume, in an imaginary world (much like an opening or ending) - but then the song ends and the interactions with whoever's there in the scene seem to prove that yes, that singing really did happen. On that note let's not forget that one song does not make a musical, either: practical limitations obviously prevent anything more full-fledged, but it's unfortunate that I can't recall even a single remark or hint or anything else about this "tiny" detail (save for the words "musical" and "actor" being constantly thrown around, which rather annoys than helps, all things considered).
But who even are "they", the main cast? As far as I'm concerned, it's five rather common boys, with the protagonist being the most unremarkable one of them all. They each have about one trope characteristic, and one "fatal" flaw that immediately nullifies their chance to get on a Star Team and that is all - the four of them also magically form a bond with the "leader" after just one personal incident. I don't think I could even call them bishounen: on one hand there really isn't a "control group" they could stand out from; on the other, I don't find them particularly pretty either. Not entirely unlikeable, but there's very little to like them for. And their superiors, the esteemed Kaou-kai? Two of them get quite the focus, while the other three barely get enough screen time for us to even remember their names.
Once more, all these wouldn't make such a bad overall impression, if only...
If only there was something to the story at least. One little twist, one moment of actual clarity and realisation, one instance of real comedy. Anything.
If only at least some of the characters were actually pretty or had a hint of depth to them. An actual overdone trait, a bit of actual drama that's not obvious at first glance, some confusion, some real issue. Anything. As it is, I found it hard to connect to them, and I'm not sure they really connected with each other.
If only at least the animation was farther away from average and a little closer to great, at least in the crucial performance scenes. Sadly, even those are quite often downright shoddy, with annoyingly choppy dance moves that really shouldn't exist here.
If only at least the songs were memorable: catchy tunes, great melody, nice rhythm, creative lyrics. Instead they're just forgettable.
If only the story did something, anything at all, but here it feels like the dots are either too random, too far from each other, or just simply don't get connected for whatever reason.
If only the fanservice, heck even the queerbaiting was done on a level that goes above the safety threshold. It's not that that one can only see and feel it being used as a tool - for the most part, it's even below that. A boys-only private school begs for certain obligatory elements, most of which are outright missing and the ones that are present, are mostly just present as hints, rather than anything full-blown.
I'm not sure what the creators wanted to achieve with this series, to be honest. Series like this, they usually either have great art/animation, or ample amount of fanservice, or some kind and amount of substance - none of those is present in Starmyu. Sure, there is such a thing as playing it safe, but what we get here is too safe. It's so safe it's just not enjoyable at all, as it fails to take full advantage of even the most overused tropes - tropes that are overused because they can still work if the dosage is right; here it isn't. And at the same time it also fails to deliver where it really should: music and songs. Some of the instrumental score in certain scenes was actually nice, but that's hardly gonna save an anime focused on musical students. You can watch it if you're absolutely deprived of BOYS in anime, I suppose, just don't expect anything of it. Then again, not being able to find an abundance of boys in anime is a pretty difficult spot to get to, isn't it?
I absolutely love Starmyu despite not getting into it easily at first, but I'm glad I finished it. I enjoy it more now that I went back and re-watched the series.
Very basic setting. The main character admires a highschooler watching him dance at an outdoor stage and decides to enroll in the same school and department as him, despite forgetting his face. It follows a linear storyline, nothing too complicated which is a good thing.
I like the character designs and most of the art was okay. The animation isn't great though, especially during the musical scenes which simply made it
cringy and almost made me drop the series.
Despite being a musical anime, their songs aren't anything special either. The only one I could get into was the opening. On the other hand, voice acting did good job.
The characters can all be determined by a single trait, but were all extremely likeable and fun. It doesn't make all the characters shallow though because they're all presented with strong emotions and their reactions to different situations are quite entertaining. The best part of the series was definitely the interactions between all the characters, their different viewpoints and changing relationship.
Although there isn't anything particularly special about this series in my opinion, the potential was there. It never fails to be more interesting as every episode adds on and by the end of it, I was touched. Then again I'm weak to cliche stories.
When I first saw STARMYU introduced in 2015 I actually thought, "oh? another boys idol anime, name is kind of lame and these characters look a bit generic." Because I usually don't enjoy idol animes as much, although I think they are great to watch just for fun. 2 years later, I found my initial thoughts completely wrong and enjoyed the series so much I watched it twice for the first time.
A lot of people seem to compare this to UtaPri, which can be true at times but I think the overall tone of the anime is drastically different from how UtaPri presents itself.
Such as UtaPri capitalizes on nuanced romance and STARMYU is more about pure romantic love for music and performance, also not "idols".
Throughout the anime, the storyline is pretty straightforward, standard run of the mill: dreams, hard work, friendship, rivals, conflicts, etc. However, it presents itself in an interesting format of interjecting character songs/songs in general to serve as inner dialogue and characters motivations. This might be jarring (and I was also completely like wtf in the first episode), but it became entertaining once I understood its use (*gasp* like in a musical *says the stupid me*). And how could you go wrong with comedic song inserts? The dialogues actually spoken also are a refreshing, and well written take on many overdone concepts and themes: like really developing the characters and their conflicts.
Sometimes the dialogue also gets extremely cliche cringe worthy, but the show accepts that and I give props to it for not presenting it through rose colored lenses. (Which I will point out in UtaPri because you know those are hella cringe worthy lines only made not cringe worthy by beautiful voices and glamour shots).
At times the art quality isn't that great, and character designs may seem very bland for its genre. Nonetheless, I think facial expressions are drawn very well when crucial and portray all the characters emotions no matter how subtle (ex: the character Kuga). Backgrounds are drawn in a way suited to the setting, but the character song bg's are fantastic and artistic!
Also fantastic is the use of no CG and hand drawn performances! I'm quite impressed with the routines in their shown fluidity and the actual choreography. I don't think any other series I've seen holds up to par, because you can feel the weight of pull of every movement. If you also look you can even see that "wrong" parts are choreographed.
Being a musical anime, the music's going to make or break the anime for me. I think I enjoyed this series as well as it did because of the music. To start with the voice actors all are well suited to their roles. What's even more impressive is how well suited their voices are to each individual's song and how great they are able to adapt their singing to different musical impressions and genres. This anime presents a lot of musical genres and approaches that are all wonderfully done, the song writers did a beautiful job and took chances that played out well. I'm surprised I loved every single song to the point of going to buy them for sure.
The OST/background music is so effing beautiful. Its extremely notable at the points of conflict/tension and each piece is well suited for the type of conflict (ex: sad, frustration, resolve). These range from beautiful piano pieces that haunt throughout to even heart pumping techno ones.
The main cast fits into the archetypal boys: the cheerful one, the shy one, the silent guy, the oresama guy, and the I've got reasons why I'm like this arrogant guy - also enforced by their hair colors! But I think each one develops in a refreshing manner that's not over the top unrealistic or cheesy. Background/secondary characters are also entertaining to meet, perhaps more so than the main guys. The only thing really lacking is that the "villainous" characters motivations weren't portrayed well enough to convince me that they really needed to do some of the stuff they do.
I watched this twice the first run through.. I'm also going to buy all the songs I can. I absolutely love music anime because I've dabbled in music myself. But I'm often disappointed with the lack of well done music in many of these "music" animes. Usually because 1) nothing new is done 2) minimal effort in song production leading to very bland, not very complex arrangements. STARMYU is above a lot of music animes and makes me fall in love with music again.
Personally I would rate at a 9 but I held back. I wrote this review because I'm saddened by how many people pass this over because they clearly expected something else. I would recommend you watch this if you love/appreciate music, keep in mind this will take on a musical format, a little comedic ridiculousness, light hearted development, and cute boys as a plus.
Let me start by saying I watched this all in one sitting and if that isnt some indication that I even remotely enjoyed myself than you're thick-minded ways aren't welcome to this review.
In saying that - my enjoyment was only to some aspects of this anime. Straight to the point - the character bonds, some of the songs and the anti-climatic disasters (lol) and thats really it.
Take away the singing and all thats left is a bunch of males training to be actors. Or was it musicians? Or Dancers? Either way, I won't pretend theres much of a story here. 5 boys - the protagonist,
the uke/sensitive kid, the silent undercover-cool dude, that guy with a family complex and the stuck-up rich guy - who were supposed to be cut from auditions to the musical program in a prestigious school but they all get placed in a musical group together to perform and what not. We get clashing personalities that turn into overboard friendships, students that look more like grown men and a whole bunch of random singing scenes. Unlike some musicals though, these songs are pretty catchy. A few circumstances that came across as plot twists or 'wow-factors' sort of fell flat as well. Disappointing in a way but I didnt expect a rollercoaster of twists and turns.
The characters, as mentioned, are cliche and theres not much to elaborate on that. You see them alot in boy-based/harem animes and its not necessarily a bad thing but it gives predictability and if you're not into that then dont hold your breath. Development was fair for a short series but I also think having said stereotypical characters is what you need for a short anime - otherwise you wouldn't get enough development on the complicated characters. So im indifferent about that aspect.
I did enjoy the journey the boys take together in finding their friendships, sharing their dreams and pushing through difficulties as a team. As boring as that may sound - I think that's what I looked forward to the most. That and the unforeseen singing of course.......... * cough* SO the art and sound doesnt need to be touched on - its a musical and it was made in 2015 - what more needs to be said?
Overall, Im a musical person myself so I probably have more of a biased view - and I enjoyed Starmyu for what it was. It was fun and lol-worthy. It's nothing Id seek out if I'm after something serious or that draws a heavy stroyline of course but when you have the time - watch it.
I don't know how to feel about this series. On the one hand, it's got a pretty good story and lovely art; I also love music based anime, and I looove musicals. So I was really looking forward to this, despite seeing the not so decent score it had during its airing, and then only spiking up to a score of 7ish after its final episode.
However....idk if it's just this series or if all musical type anime series are like this, but..like 90% of the songs came out of nowhere and just didn't belong. Not to mention it doesn't
have the same flare as real life musicals do, in regards to the music segments. Any time a character started singing, it seemed more like it was happening in their own head and the visuals made me feel like I was watching an anime opening video. Then the song would finish and they'd just be looking at the character(s) they were trying to intimidate/encourage with said song with a kind of "soo..what'd you think? ;D" kinda look on their face. They felt really weird and out of place..
Musicals typically aren't supposed to be self aware (except for in High School Musical where Corbin Bleu (I forgot his name in the movie) says how everyone broke into a musical number and it was weird). But other than that, the music segments are just supposed to be there as part of the story, where the character(s) singing aren't magically transformed into some random costume with some colourful backdrops behind them. They should be singing IN the scene with the characters watching them so you know that they're the ones being sung to.
Expressions made by the character singing and the characters while being sung to are such a critical part of a musical. I mean, that's just my own opinion obviously, but without seeing character reactions during music segments, it just ends up being super weird and feeling like I'm watching an AMV or an anime opening/ending video. Idk if all anime that are legit musicals are like this. If they are, then maybe the Japanese just don't know how to make a proper musical? An animated one, anyway. I'm sure Broadway musicals done in Japan are the same as ones in North America and Europe and such. Anyway, got off topic a bit there..
Aside from the 2 only really good songs in the entire series *****minor spoilers***** when Otori and Hiragi sing that song about their past and such, and when Otori and Hoshitani sing that one song on that small outdoor stage. They were necessary and made sense. The rest just didn't fit (not including obvious musical performances by the different Star Teams and such)*****end of spoilers*****, the rest, while a bit catchy, weren't anything special. I was praying for them to end as soon as they started.
Aside from weird music stuffs, the characters were mediocre at best. A couple were decent but the main character is dreadful. He's so expressionless and dull. I really felt no attachment to him at all.
It definitely picks up in the 2nd half once you've gotten used to how weird certain elements of it are. Tl;dr it's kinda cute. Decent music and a good story, so if you're into watching something pretty laid back and relaxing, go for it. Otherwise, it's not really worth your time.
Alright, this is my first review and I am only doing it because I felt like this anime hasn't gotten enough attention and I will do anything for that to change.
First off let's make it clear that this series is not AMAZING, not by itself neither for the genres it falls into. But it's not bad either, and I'm seeing it get tons of low ratings in other sites. People aren't even giving it a chance.
The story's without a doubt the weakest point of the anime. It's generic, nothing special. A group of 5 failures trying to prove the world that they can actually
do things right and thus surprising everyone. That's the main plot, anyway. In the end of the series, tons of things happened that I would never have even imagined. Not like it was a big turn of events anyway.
I honestly didn't like the art that much. It's not bad, but it's nothing outstanding either. The character designs are simple, I could even say plain. And it feels like they were running out of hairstyles when they designed Kaito Tsukigami's brother, and simply decided to make him a blue-haired Kuga. But that's fine.
I also never pay attention to the animation whoops. Sorry. But if it didn't get my attention, it's not terrible neither good.
I loved all of the songs, specifically the ending song and Ayanagi Showtime. Most of them sing well, but props to Team Hiragi for being 10 times better than the actual main five. KENN voicing Toraishi got me screaming every time he appeared onscreen.
Then again Team Otori also has great voices, like Hoshitani's and Tsukigami's. I never pay attention to background music so I can't talk about it, but overall I think it was lacking.
The main characters had plain personalities and fall into the generic archetypes. The main character is that generic "let's give it our all & let's all be friends" leader. Honestly I love that kind of character, because let's be honest, if the leader was someone who did everything their own way or was too scared/shy to even talk to the members of their team no one would like them. Original? Yeah, that's the least you'd be able to say about a leader like that.
And the other characters, we have blue-haired Kaneki (or Kaito Tsukigami, whatever you prefer to call him) who feels overshadowed by his successful brother, purple-haired Kuga, better known as Haruto Tsukigami. There's the effeminate and motherly-type shy guy, Nayuki, that one guy that thinks he's better than everyone else, and the silent guy.
Then why did I give the Characters such a high score? I'm not going to lie, I love all of the secondary characters. Otori's amazing, and all of the five Team Hiragi guys are amazing as well, though I wish they'd have gotten more screentime - they really didn't, but you can sort of distinguish their personalities with the little time they get.
I love music anime, but only when it's interesting enough to get me going. I really couldn't go past the first episode of Uta no Prince-sama, which has been compared to Starmyu by other people many times. I hate reverse harems, even if they're with singing boys. Just no.
Starmyu had no romance, and I like it much better that way.
Perhaps I scored everything a little higher than it would have actually been, but I really did like this show and despite being a little biased, it's not bad at all. If anything watch up to episode 3-5, give it a chance instead of dropping after reading the synopsis or after episode 1.
The songs were amazing! It's very enjoyable, good story line and overall i recommend it to people who like Utapri or Music. The singing was very good, The voice actors for Tsukigami and Kuga had good voiced when singing the Ootori Countdown!~ Overall i rate it a 10/10. The main points of this anime was probably friendship or working hard to achieve your dreams and goals. It focuses on alot of the Starmyu characters and talks about their past and why they decided to tryout for the star team. There's a lot of competition between team Ootori and team Hiragi, well, that makes it hilarious!