|
The categorization of points here on MAL is pretty strange.
10 Masterpiece
9 Great
8 Very Good
7 Good
6 Fine
5 Average
4 Bad
3 Very Bad
2 Horrible
1 Unwatchable
What kind of categories are those? Some of them are pretty much just a synonym for the preceding one. Take for example Great/Very Good, Good/Fine or Very Bad/Horrible. Yes, there are slight differences, but come on, the region of BAD starts way to early, making it almost impossible to rate any normal anime below 5 or 6.
And why is 1 Unwatchable...for me 1 point implies that there is still at least some redeeming factor, like a D- in an exam, it's terribly flawed, but it still has some qualities that keeps it above total insufficiency.
My rating categories would be
10 Very Good
9 Good
8 Nice
7 Entertaining
6 Sufficient
5 Avergae
4 Below Average
3 Flawed
2 Bad
1 Horrible
0 Unwatchable
So most of the time I'm rating according to this train of thought, because I don't want to be always giving a 6 or 7...
|
All Comments (21) Comments
Was genau ist eigentlich der Unterschied von Kuuki-kei und Nichijou-kei?
Wiki JP meint, da sei kein großer Unterschied dabei, auch wenn es getrennt genommen wird teilweise. Aber irgendwas wird sich doch wohl dabei unterscheiden, wenn das doch getrennt verwendet wird. oo"
Nebenbei, machen sich da eigentlich auch schon andere Strömungen breit? Ich habe es nicht so mit Subculture, könnte mir aber vorstellen, das Madoka oder so auch was losgetreten haben könnte.
Aber schon ein wenig abgefahren, dass daraus gleich eine ganze Pseudo-Wissenschaft draus wird.
thanks anyways ^^
I read in the Durarara ep 14 discussion that u are reading the novel. Do u mind telling me where u are reding it? :)
Also, Utena in your favourite anime and Monster in manga? That's so great :)
*in case you're wondering, I spotted you while browsing the Mouryou no Hako discussions and loved your justification on the series, I was ready to rate them with an 8 but since I have a soft spot for mystery,detective stories and japanese folklore and upon reading your opinion, I changed it to a 9*
I'd like to suggest a book, Inugamike no Ichizoku, by Yokomizo Seichi, check it out :)
I was reading up on Ookami Kakushi here, as well as on AnimeSuki, and I happened to notice that you've finished the VN. Would you be willing to share some summaries of the arcs not included in the anime (if it's not too much of a bother...)?
About Ookamikakushi, it seems like you spoiled francis even more than in 'VN Information' thread, but maybe i'm wrong. So could you send me what u said to francis?
Just a small question: how are you enjoying Ookamikakushi? You're like the only one on MAL who's read the VN. Is AIC doing a good job?