MyAnimeList.net

ishitagupta's Anime List | ishitagupta's Manga List
ishitagupta's Profile

Aug 28, 2012
Inoribana (Manga) add
6 of 18 people found this review helpful
 
Sniffle. This one is going to tug at the most cynical of heartstrings and leave you bawling. It’s a short and simple tale of a relationship (not necessarily “shoujo romantic” in nature) blossoming out of chance meetings and encounters between two nobles. The setting and circumstances prove challenging for the couple but how they handle themselves throughout and maintain a connection is brought out in beautiful and touching manner.

The story is original, if bittersweet. It’s almost completely devoid of any clichés and a couple of twists and turns leave you with a catch in your throat. The character development was gradual and believable. Irreverent dialogues read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Jul 23, 2010
Love -Motto Aishite- (Manga) add
5 of 11 people found this review helpful
 
There are plenty of one shot compilations on fluffy shoujo love and romance, many of which explore relationships and diverse circumstances very interestingly without resorting to stereotypes and almost all of them will leave you with a much better taste in your mouth than Love Motto Aishite.

This compilation includes both old and newer mature (read unhappy) romance stories. While all are lengthy enough to develop a premise, it's the horrid execution of the story itself that made me cringe with every panel. Your reflex after 5 or 6 pages in the first two stories will be to abandon them or it will force you to read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Jul 20, 2010
Kare wa Tomodachi (Manga) add
36 of 43 people found this review helpful
 
Kare wa tomodachi is one of my top ten go to drama-romances and with good reason. No manga reader picks up a shoujo romance title and thinks to himself "Sheesh, there sure seem to be a lot of misunderstandings between these people and a lot of unnecessary conflict and pain is resulting from it. If only they grew up and stopped making such a big deal out of small things!" Hahah, OK while reading, maybe we do let slip such harsh thoughts, but honestly, being a teen is hard, and it is precisely this anguish and delight of being a teen, finding and losing and read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
21 of 25 people found this review helpful
 
Aikawa Saki is one of my favourite mangakas and even though I may not always enjoy (or even stomach) her story lines, her art keeps me coming back for more.

Which is why I was shocked once I finished Houkago Sensei... because the story proves beyond a doubt how she has finally matured as a storyteller as well as at developing characters. Generally I found weak shoujo leads and naively besotted bishounen in her stories, where any tiny dialogue or event would cause a SHOCKED or a teary eyed response from the heroine at the drop of a hat (Yeah I'm talking about you Hotaru from read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Jul 15, 2010
Hyakujuu Kingdom (Manga) add
10 of 17 people found this review helpful
 
Hyakujuu Kingdom created that rare and hitherto unknown conflict in me. Do I rate it based on how I was revolted with the underlying theme creating some unnaturally misogynist personalities or am I obligated to rate it according to the story and the characters and the development of the premise? I'll let you know when I figure that one out!

The premise is interesting enough. A delinquent type Kaichou (student council president) is basically making life miserable for most of the student body but is grudgingly tolerated for practical reasons by the staff and school. Enter female foil who pulls his ego trip down a notch read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Jul 10, 2010
Muteki Kareshi (Manga) add
9 of 18 people found this review helpful
 
Seeing as the main story hasn't been scanlated, this one's only for the oneshot included in this volume: Amairo Omoi

I have a somewhat subtle obsessive slash stalker instinct in me at all times, so this story really appealed to that side of me! But even if you don't suffer from disturbing personality disorders, you can still find so much idealism and heartfelt adulation in this manga, that you should definitely put it on your reading list already!

Aiko is a shy girl who doesn't have much experience with boys or love, but on the first day of high school, when she's not made any friends and read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Jul 10, 2009
S+M (Manga) add
35 of 47 people found this review helpful
 
Are you tired of love triangles where one hero obviously has the edge and even before the underdog has confessed, you know who’s gonna get the girl?
Are you equally frustrated with seeing the heroes unequally matched with one being sweet and gentle but unable to move the maiden’s heart while the other is brash and unkind but the word soulmate oozes from his very being?
Do you finally want a shoujo romance where the triangle in love triangle is somewhat equilateral rather than horribly bent in one direction?

Well then this story is IT for you!

Our heroine Ryou has the hugest rack you can physically imagine, read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Jul 10, 2009
Gokujou Twins (Manga) add
19 of 26 people found this review helpful
 
This compilation comes with five one shots, only one of which has been scanlated so far, as the others come, I hope to add their reviews as well.

Story 3: Itazura Ouji

Whoa! His eyes were twinkling when Sai The Bishie made his first appearance~! Although his hair look a little thorny in some panels, him thumping a credit card onto Mayuri's forehead to unburden his unintentional first kiss guilt kind of puts him in my good graces, hehe.

This is a very very very short story about a girl(Mayuri) meets boy(Sai) because her father works for the boy's father. They end up seeing each other a read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Mar 26, 2009
Kiss/Hug (Manga) add
87 of 113 people found this review helpful
 
You know some of those stories which make you want to cut out the heroine and paste your own face on her body just to be able to live out the story even more vicariously than is already possible? This is that times 20! Kiss/Hug is exactly as the title suggests, all about x's and o's and the squeal inducing in between moments of two of the most unexpected yet refreshing shoujo characters you'll come to love...

Yukino lives a comfortable existence in a community where she has friends, the caring and handsome senpai, her mother and younger brother and her late father's flower shop where read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful
Mar 16, 2009
Get Chu (Manga) add
28 of 37 people found this review helpful
 
Initially, I’d ignored this title, even though I liked Ayane’s Desire Climax. But that’s just because the summary doesn’t do this beautiful and colourful story justice and belies its true frivolous nature, instead making it seem pedestrian and predictable. However nothing in this one follows any standard manga stereotypes! There are no teary eyed shoujos who run the other way from their bishies, there is no dashing hero who’s waiting in the shadows to jump to the rescue every time she trips over her own clumsy feet, and there are no scheming best friends! Yay!

The starting scenes are perhaps the funniest. Our heroine Chitose read more
I found this review Helpful  Not Helpful


Help     FAQ     About     Contact     Terms     Privacy     AdChoices