Jan 13, 2023
So 4/10 as a whole.
To be honest i have loved reading yuri but i prefer play with happy ending, and this oneshot collection is just terrible 1st and 2nd oneshot were nice,
Talk about 1st one it was decent with a lovely story I'd rat this 8/10 but i think there should have been a sequel to this one with an after story telling, so that there are no had feelings over the reader that the couple were together forever or not.
Now talk about 2nd one it's a demi-human related romance which is not much of a romance at all it's just master-servent relationship, I'd say
...
it was cute in its own way, but still I'd say the story seems to be rushed, despite being oneshot it could have more potential if written properly.
Now the 3rd one the one i really hated the most the one with a terrible ending, this one was going really good and warm until the last moment showed up and ruined everything, if you don't want to cry please skip reading this one, it's not sad it's just terrible i hate the author idk what in the actual hell he was thinking when he drew that scene, this story had so much potential to be a good yuri but damn talk about disappointment, to be honest this story is the sole reason for my bad rating, the ending just ruins the whole character development, it's annoying to think about it.
Talk about the 4th one it was good short sweet and simple I'd say it's the so good so far with only 11 pages max.
5th one I'd say i have mixed feelings the ending is decent, but feels like something is missing idk how to describe it in words.
Alright the 6th one is a nightmare it's not that i disliked but I'd rather not read this ones it felt like the author tried very hard to make the reader cry it's sad but not in a way you'd she'd tears over the end is also unsatisfactory.
Now for the last one I'd say 1/10 well the reason is the ending is cliffhanger and it leaves the reader in question, the ending is sad if you look at the words carefully maybe her answer was a 'no romance between girls is not possible' but it was not dipicted properly so I'd say i hated
The reason why i gave 4/10 is because no matter how good 1 and 2 were it was not that great cuz i have read even better oneshots so i am a bit picky but that doesn't change the fact that i hate sad stories we have seen so many sad stories atleast make us happy when we are reading manga and in yuri genre i want all happy ends when i select yuri i don't wanna hear nonsense like "romance btwn two girls is not possible" give us a happy ending or don't categorize that in yuri if you gonna make nonsense like that.
That's all
In the end if u read this far then lemme tell ya I don't recommend this collection for reading
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
