Ranked #2402

Idol Shopping (Manhwa)

The summary above doesn't give it justice and it's a little confusing so I will add my own here.

Summary:
Song Ih's loves her twin brother, A Ul more than anything. When he suddenly returns home from school and has to hospitalized he doesn't want to go back, she wants to know why. Her parents worried that he will get kicked out of his private school don't mind Song Ih's idea to pretend to be him while he recovers. Leaving her "job" as the" bully take carer S" she goes to school for him to find out the truth and to beat up whoever did it.

The story was nice even if a little of a cliche and predictable. It was predictable but it seemed to flow well. I read a review that wrote about the dialogue not making sense and I didn't see that at all. Though it could be because this manga is from left to right and not from right to left.

The characters: They all add something to the story, though some of them I wish didn't. There are some bad characters, by this I don't mean evil even though they are. I liked the secondary characters more than the main ones.
But there are also nice/sweet though sometimes dumb as rocks characters. Who can't figure out she's a girl. I'm sorry but I find ridiculous that even after finding out she was a girl (it's not a spoiler because it's bound to happen in any manga) they still get confused?

The art was not so great. The fighting scenes were sloppy and were everywhere. In my opinion they were weak. Ga Yun was the one I noticed the most, in one shot he's wearing glasses and in the same scene he isn't. There was this one scene where they even made him blonde. Other than that it was fine.

All in all I read and I still can't figure out why it's called Idol Shopping. There's only one idol (as in show biz) and he never took her shopping. :)



read more

This story was really good i like all the drama and the twists that was put into it. But the main character pissed me off because i kindof felt that she was selfish which is a trait that I've noticed in alot of Mr Ri's main characters. But it extremely good i recommend it so.... READ IT

Ugh, Idol Shopping... i dont really know where to begin with this. The story kicks off pretty fast with a high school girl who is hired to beat up some bullies and manages to throw punches in two wrong directions. She later learns that her beloved twin-brother is coming home from his year of studying in some school which is appereantly far enough for him not to visit home for a year but in case of an emergency everyone can get there within few pages. Anyway! The brother soon realizes the plot must go on and tries to commit suicide which causes the main girl to dress up as his brother and attend the school so that he wouldnt be expelled for not attending classes.

The basic idea of this manga is that its a love triangle between two guys and girl. The guys arent exactly that interesting, blond haired guy is somekinda superstar that has to come back to school after a year of touring or something. He is by far the most interesting of the two because he has some form of a personality to him. He doupts himself, makes mistakes, panics and shows his feelings. Unlike him we have the second love interest, black haired guy who on the otherhand is the student council president and shows absolutely no feeling. It was really hard to like this ice cold guy. In short im not very fond of the characters. The main girl was fun at the beginning but she got way too into stuff later on. Antagonists of this story got way annoying way too fast.

Art can get a bit confusing in parts if you fail to pay attention. One of the characters cuts his hair and i mistook him for somebody else for a whole chapter which made things quite akward.
I think this was a nice story but i found some things lacking or annoying. Its not a very long manga tho so it can be breezed through within couple hours and i didnt feel like i wasted too many minutes of my life on this.

read more

I have no objection to the in the manga.
The characters are interesting characters, there are characters that are full of secrets.
There are also characters who are idiots, but no idiot will probably in any manga.
Why do I like that manga?
Because I like the manga where the girl disguises herself as a boy and attended the boys boarding school ...
I like gdzy bochaterka is not the girl who can not cope without help.
I like bochaterka knows when to fight and it does not look like the opinion of others does not care what any attention ....
As for the story as it also did not have any objections. read more

Over all: 8
I found this story quite entertaining, with all the drama and comedy combined it awesome!

There only somethings that kind of get me and that's the ending (not the I'm going to say what it was) I mean it was just to rushed and left to may questions unanswered, it seemed like there was supposed to have one or two more chapter to sum it all up but, no it just left it how it was. Other than that it was good with here and there thing that could of been tweaked. :D

Story: 8
I love all the drama, it's so good to the point in got me on the verge of tears. I mean with the heroine's past and all troubling discussions she had to choose.. Though It's quite sad when you are stuck between a love triangle and you the reader loves bother of the boys and wish that they could both end up with her.... but even with all the drama there plenty of comic relief to brake the tension... All in all it equals out to a fun story that you will love...

Art: 6
I thought It could of been better, though i am picky when it come to the art, but for people that aren't as picky as me you should love it..:D

Characters: 7
I love all there personalty. because there unique in there own way and ever change a little over time.. so if your a person that only read the first couple of chapter to see if you like, you better keep reading because there a hole at that you will be missing if you stop there...

Enjoyment: 9
I enjoyed it alot and i think so will you.. So give it ago and read it, you wont be disappointed except when it ends ...:D read more

This series seemed really interessting in the beggining because you were wondering, what happened, that everybody hates song's brother aul. But then when the mistery was solved it went downhill. In another half of the manhwa, the plot twist are just ridiculous as well as how they were solving the problems in the situation and you didn't really care like in the first half of the series. In the second half of the series the main focus is only romance. Also the story felt like mixed up different stories into one manhwa. Song catching bullies could actually be made into one manhwa. I wouldn't recomend this manhwa on less you only read it because of romance. read more