Shokugeki no Souma
Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Soma

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

I see that the other reviews aren't that positive but don't mind if I do:

Art is perfect. However, the part where the manga REALLY shines, are characters. Some people aren't happy with the recent development but after almost 300 chapters of couse someone will drop it. Personally this manga is the absolute #1 one best thing I've ever read and invested myself into, so if you are wondering whether to read this - of course you should it's a god damn masterpiece.

I have one problem: The ending is a bit rushed. I don't like that they skipped some battles so I've been wondering whethet ... to give it a 10 or a 9. Personally, it's a 10, but you need to read the Le Dessert special chapter.

As I said the best thing about this manga are the interesting side characters. There are a LOT of them mind you, so not everyone gets a lot of screen time, but I never felt that a character was wasted, they always achieved something important. Even the villains are great, Tsukasa Eishi is imo one of the best written characters (or antagonists?) in manga as a medium. I'm not that fond of the boss of the Central arc since he doesn't really cook, but I can't say that I don't respect him as a character. And then the charming Asahi - perfect villain imo.

I've been reading this manga for like 5 years and it really gave me a lot, so I recommend it and I hope

What was once a shining star in the overall mediocrity of Shonen Jump’s catalog finished its run worse than the likes of Death Note and Fairy Tail’s endings. Yes, I invoked the conclusion to Fairy Tail, and no, I don’t think I’m being facetious. I have no words — I mean how could I? Any effort would be a waste, and yet this intellectually fickle mind is doing it regardless. Take that how you will.

The ending is a slight on all that is good, kind, or right. It is dissonant in the workings of satisfying character/plot progression and conclusions in ways ... one could not feasibly picture in their bulky weeb brain. There are no ideas to be portrayed, no textures to be defined, and contentions that are unimaginably vast. Such a monstrosity is so egregious to the point where criticism is in of itself a completely benign endeavor. Imagine stabbing Godzilla with a toothpick. Yes, this ending does exist, and no, it is not some trite fan fiction. If no one else is to sympathize with the reader's plight, I will. All those page turns and bubbling oddities were nothing more than a cover-up for the nothingness that remains hidden under platitudes, and that in and of itself is a travesty.

Emotional it is not. Just ask the Azami’s flaccid plot twist to instantly become a likable character to fit the plot. Visceral it is not. Tosh is truly gifted as a manga artist, but the flat storyboarding leaves much to be desired. What began as endearingly bombastic became much more of an irritant at anything once the curtains fell. Food Wars is a bastardization of all the effort that has led up to this point, from both the creators and the reader.

That said, I’m a sentimental fool who will give it a 6/10 regardless. Sue me.

Shokugeki no Soma is one of the most popular ongoing shonens in Weekly Shonen Jump. Its anime is rated pretty highly on myanimelist, IMDb, and other media forums. The manga here is rated an 8.36 on MAL. Does this mean you should read it? Absolutely not.

It's unfortunately common for long running series to end unsatisfactorily, whether that's because it's dragged out for too long, author doesn't care anymore, it's cancelled, or other unforeseeable circumstances. Look at Bleach and Fairy Tail. Those two series are infamously regarded as the worst shonen manga to have ever existed, due to how they've fallen in terms of the quality ... of their storyline and conclusions. Shokugeki no Soma? It tops those in terms of how mediocre it is.

I have little to say about the first 264 chapters of this series. Why? Because the final arc of this series DECONSTRUCTS all of which the fans loved about this series.

From the beginning to the end of chapter 264, we had seen the cooking journey of a young diner chef surviving in one of the world's strictest yet most prestigious cooking institution, trying to chase after his father's footsteps in order to inherit his family's diner. Along the way he met a variety of other chefs around his age and experienced their unique lifestyles, cultures, techniques, quirks, and personalities. Training with a master French Chef and losing several competitions, he adapts and strives toward each challenge and grows out his little "Diner world" and realizes he wants to come up with his own brand of cooking and follow his own footsteps. To do that, he must create a dish that his eternal rival, the possessor of the God's Tongue, the talented and beautiful daughter of the Cooking Yakuza (the noble Nakiri Family), Erina, will acknowledge. But said prodigious heroine has her own cooking journey to explore with our male protagonist.

Sounds like a really great story. A little diner chef rose to the top of the cooking world and the rich and talented heroine goes to the bottom to see the little things in cooking to discover her own sense of identity, her own cooking. Well, now lets rinse and repeat all of that, let's ignore the rest of the talented cast that the MC met and have Soma start at level 1 once again. Let's have him be the underdog and prove that diner cooking is the best! How do we do that? Well let's have the heroine be kidnapped by his long lost mafia brother who has superpowers and has defeated who was built up to be the final boss of the series, Soma's father: Joichiro Saiba. What does he want? To marry Erina to make his cooking taste better. How will he do that? By appealing to Erina's horrible mother that abandoned her as a child and has shit taste that can't let her consume anything in this world.

Erina Nakiri becomes an abused doll who can't make a single decision for herself in her life and has no hope of pleasing her mother's shit palette with her prodigious cooking. She has to tell the MC to lose and let her marry the mafia brother so her mother can be happy. SHe went from developing for 264 chapters into a confident young chef who fights for her newfound friends and views cooking as fun to this.

Soma Yukihira had risen to the top of Totsuki academy as the First Seat of the Elite Ten. By the end of the Central arc, he had already created what he referred to as his own specialty. Now? "His cooking style is just addition and substraction. He can't multiply, and he certainly has no super powers! What can he do? No way he can make me strip!" Everything he has learned about cooking has went to 0 and he has to use his DAD's cooking yet again to fend off against the dastardly "Dark Chef's" Wolverine Claws, TNT, and chainsaws.

Repeating Nakiri abusive family drama, replacing the final boss of the series (when the series was all about Soma coming up with his own cooking style to beat his father and inherit his restaurant), NO LONGER EVEN REVIEWING DISHES OR SHOWING THEM BEING MADE (possibly due to the author's fixation on Chunnibyou super powers or because the series's cooking consultant has left), having a battle between light and darkness, showing guns and kidnapping, and worst of all deconstructing the main characters and shafting most of the cast. This series takes it all! Everything that was hyped and built up and somehow made it turn into a worst trash than it was the week before.

The series betrayed its own themes and basically its premise by dragging on way past what it needed to be. It became a battle shonen criminal NTR INCEST soap opera family drama than a cooking manga. The author needed to increase his foodgasms of fanservice to BUILDING-breaking levels (lewding all sorts of girls wasn’t enough, the food has to give buildings orgasms now!) in an attempt to critique the kind of cooking this series has produced now.

Might as well change the name of the series from Shokugeki no Soma to “Keeping up with the Nakiris”.

Overall, I give it a 4/10. 264 chapters of a respectable quality being its crutch, it's an utterly garbage series that destroys all expectations.

Read with caution if you want to stop up to chapter 264 or wish to see a masterpiece of a trainwreck. Otherwise, do not bother with this series.