| Was motivated to create another stats thread for this season by others from my previous thread. :3 Fall Anime 2013 Thread - http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=712523 So hope you cry over this one as well! (╹◡╹) Popularity Views and Biased General Public Rankings (MAL VERSION - Info copied and pasted) (Don't start hating nor bashing on any animes just because they don't have the same taste as you, and don't start pointing fingers at shows emotionally. Think of everything objectively so you don't confuse your opinions with your facts. Last but not least, these stats were created by the general public, not by nor will be for critics. Hope this list helps everyone get intrigued into other animes this season while it's ending! Enjoy!) --------------- Ranked 1-> 99 --------------- Ranked 100 -> 499 Ranked: #238 - Total: 17,646 - Gin no Saji 2nd Season Dropped: 56 Ranked: #367 - Total: 53,462 - Noragami Dropped: 492 Ranked: #406 - Total: 43,984 - Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren Dropped: 322 Ranked: #408 - Total: 20,501 - Seitokai Yakuindomo 2 Dropped: 258 Ranked: #426 - Total: 44,614 - Nisekoi Dropped: 682 --------------- Ranked 500 -> 999 Ranked: #971 - Total: 20,795 - Mikakunin de Shinkoukei Dropped: 407 --------------- Ranked 1000 -> 2999 Ranked: #1036- Total: 25,176 - D-Frag! Dropped: 793 Ranked: #1172- Total: 27,423 - Space☆Dandy Dropped: 951 Ranked: #1215- Total: 28,777 - Hamatora The Animation Dropped: 1,109 Ranked: #1216- Total: 17,744 - Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha Dropped: 310 Ranked: #1218- Total: 19,513 - Tonari no Seki-kun Dropped: 450 Ranked: #1276- Total: 25,245 - Sakura Trick Dropped: 1,122 Ranked: #1338- Total: 07,564 - Saki: Zenkoku-hen Dropped: 160 Ranked: #1704- Total: 26,936 - Witch Craft Works Dropped: 1,006 Ranked: #1759- Total: 19,633 - Toaru Hikuushi e no Koiuta Dropped: 642 Ranked: #1974- Total: 19,832 - Sekai Seifuku: Bouryaku no Zvezda Dropped: 636 Ranked: #2156- Total: 19,270 - Nourin Dropped: 807 Ranked: #2660- Total: 12,337 - Hoozuki no Reitetsu Dropped: 963 Ranked: #2698- Total: 30,213 - Mahou Sensou Dropped: 1,666 Ranked: #2728- Total: 13,697 - Buddy Complex Dropped: 773 Ranked: #2847- Total: 17,695 - Nobunagun Dropped: 1,325 Ranked: #2849- Total: 10,682 - Maken-Ki! Two Dropped: 174 --------------- Ranked 3000+ Ranked: #3057- Total: 11,348 - Wake Up, Girls! Dropped: 582 Ranked: #3158- Total: 21,798 - Nobunaga the Fool Dropped: 1,874 Ranked: #3497- Total: 16,162 - Wizard Barristers: Benmashi Cecil Dropped: 1,225 Ranked: #3973- Total: 12,972 - Onee-chan ga Kita Dropped: 415 Ranked: #4075- Total: 09,637 - Z/X: Ignition Dropped: 839 Ranked: #4478- Total: 20,828 - Saikin, Imouto no Yousu ga Chotto Okashiinda ga Dropped: 1,375 Ranked: #5583- Total: 14,818 - Super Sonico The Animation Dropped: 1,776 Ranked: #6112- Total: 08,279 - Strange+ Dropped: 783 Ranked: #6756- Total: 30,802 - Pupa Dropped: 2,304 |
MagicFlierFeb 17, 2014 11:06 PM
 |
| No surprise about GnS and Nora. They deserve their hype. I guess Nisekoi, Setokai and Chuu2 are there because one is an adaption of a super popular manga and the other two are sequel. I would have expected The Fool and Wizard to be higher...I find them fairly decent LOL |
| What are Nisekoi and that horrible Chuunibyous eason doing in the top 5? People have no taste when it comes to rom-coms. At least Pupa is dead last as it deserves. I thought Sakura Trick would do better, all I hear is people fawning over it. As for Wizard Barristers, it shouldn't be that low but I've heard a lot of people hate it because of the character designs and other visual aspects so it's no surprise to see it down there. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| If only people respected the 3 minute comedies better. Onee-chan ga kita is great. |
| I don't understand why Wake Up, Girls! has such a low rating. Same goes for Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha... I know my tastes are a bit off, but I don't believe they're that bad... |
| glad about noragami, it's a really good show!! not really surprised about pupa.. but i'm kind of sad strange+ is so low, guess the humor is not for everyone lol |
 |
Robin6128 said: I don't understand why Wake Up, Girls! has such a low rating. Same goes for Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha... I know my tastes are a bit off, but I don't believe they're that bad... I think idol anime just isn't that popular. I was gonna get to it once I watch the movie. |
| Besides silver spoon, I don't think any of those series in the same tier should honestly be ranked where they currently are. SYD* has been a disappointing sequel and the rest are all equally bad. Kind of surprised Dandy and WCW aren't ranked at least under 1000 since I thought they were somewhat popular this season. |
| Gin no Saji at #1 is unsurprising and well-deserved. I have my doubts about how Noragami is going to end, but I think that #2 spot is about right for it. As for the other three in the top five... ugh, Chu2koi is terrible compared to the first season and Nisekoi is just boring (and I haven't watched the first season of Seitokai; not interested). I'm surprised Space Dandy didn't crack the top five; while it isn't perfect it's certainly better than most of the stuff in this shitfest of a season. |
 |
Nerolunar said: I'm surprised Inari Konkon is so low. It is good so far. I agree. Well, it's just like Gingitsune. Solid show, but will never be as popular as the others. |
Robin6128 said: I don't understand why Wake Up, Girls! has such a low rating. Same goes for Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha... I know my tastes are a bit off, but I don't believe they're that bad... Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha doesn't strike me as having a low rating or being 'that bad', when it is actually in the top 10 of the season. It also has one of the smallest dropped numbers so I really don't get how you interpret the stats of the Opening post as it being received badly. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| Hoozuki no Reitetsu should be ranked much higher. That show is great. I guess a lot of people don't 'get it' due the heavy use of Japanese folklore and mythology. I'd personally put Mikakunin above Chu2Koi 2. The former has been quite consistent and good, while the latter took a while to get the romance subplot going again. And from what I've seen of NouRin/No-Rin, I'm not really impressed, so I think its ranking is too high. The rest (from what I've seen) seems to be placed right, relative to each other. Joshua1207 said: If only people respected the 3 minute comedies better. Onee-chan ga kita is great. Tonari no Seki-kun is much, much better, though. Heck, even Strange+ is better than that show. Joshua1207 said: Robin6128 said: I don't understand why Wake Up, Girls! has such a low rating. Same goes for Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha... I know my tastes are a bit off, but I don't believe they're that bad... I think idol anime just isn't that popular. I was gonna get to it once I watch the movie. Not every idol anime is the same. I haven't seen it, but it apparently lacks something the other shows of its kind have if it does this bad. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Robin6128 said: I don't understand why Wake Up, Girls! has such a low rating. Same goes for Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha... I know my tastes are a bit off, but I don't believe they're that bad... wake up girls isn't that bad, but the story isn't really memorable yet and the characters aren't really interesting imo (i can't even tell them apart tbh), but yeah i still think it has potential. |
|
Higashi_no_Kaze said: What are Nisekoi and that horrible Chuunibyous eason doing in the top 5? People have no taste when it comes to rom-coms. there's a reason they are top sellers in japan |
 |
| Nisekoi pulls out a lot of cliche stunts, but its still an enjoyable watch. Overrated? Sure. But its not bad. |
| I'm surprised Mahou Sensou is even that high. It is quite bad imo. The Fool and Buddy Complex are getting better, hopefully they will have better rankings at the end of the season. D-Frag is actually one of my highest ratings this season. Surprised it doesnt break 1k. |
Joshua1207 said: It's actually the only one I'm watching this season besides Space Dandy. Nisekoi is pretty good so far, I haven't read the manga yet though. Hopefully they'll keep the series going for a while and adapt the entire manga if they can.Nisekoi pulls out a lot of cliche stunts, but its still an enjoyable watch. Overrated? Sure. But its not bad. |
 |
| Pupa deserves the place it was given. Sakura Trick is kinda low, but that's to be expected since it's all fanservice |
 |
| Pupa... lol. I am still following it... |
| My Reviews and Rants: http://bunny1ov3r.wordpress.com/ 痛就是爱 |
| Witch Craft Works should be higher. |
 |
| It is a travesty that Sakura Trick is so low. You peeps need to tap into your inner yuri!!! Noragami and Nisekoi are way too high. Chuunibyou started off terrible too, but really has picked it up the last two episodes, so no complaints there. Everything else seems decent enough. |
 |
Forgetfulness said: Just watch the movie first. I'm really enjoying the show.Hm, I was planning to watch Wake Up, Girls! :/ Doesn't seem like it's doing too well, but I guess I'll check it out |
Makomonogatari said: lupadim said: The best part is that you somehow actually exist.And the best part is that no one can prove it wrong |
| This season was pretty regular IMO. Only shows with some hope are Buddy Complex, Nobunagun and Nobunaga the Fool. Pupa and Mahou Sensou are, by far, first and second worse anime this season. Let's hope spring gets better. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Thanks for making this thread again, it's nice to be able to keep track of how everything is doing this season. I see Gin no Saji S2 is doing really well, is it something people here would recommend watching? Admittedly I wasn't able to get really into it the first time around except for the subplot with the piglet. |
shadedclan said: I personally don't like how it's just 4 minutes per episode. Should have juast made it into a short movie. I agree. It would have been somewhat decent as a short movie or OVA. daedroth4 said: I see Gin no Saji S2 is doing really well, is it something people here would recommend watching? Admittedly I wasn't able to get really into it the first time around except for the subplot with the piglet. Second season is pretty awesome so far! |
daedroth4 said: I see Gin no Saji S2 is doing really well, is it something people here would recommend watching? Admittedly I wasn't able to get really into it the first time around except for the subplot with the piglet. I think this second season is superior, but if you didn't like the first, I don't think you'd like it either cause it doesn't change that much. |
| What I find remarkable is the dropped/watching ratio of Gin no Saji 2. It seems there's little discussion about (the anime) GnS in general on MAL, though. Noragami is relatively close. That is sad. Gets the high praise probably because of the manga. The anime itself is such a lackluster. Enjoyable, yes, but not enough for position 2 (in my eyes). However, I'm just gonna leave this here and be on my way now~ |
 |
murazrai said: Again, this list is incomplete so I add a few missed items: Ranked #4788 - Total: 694 - Future Card Buddyfight Dropped: 51 Comment: The English dub is awesome and I don't see why people dismissed it as another "children's card game anime". Apparently, this is not as well received as Cardfight!! Vanguard. Ranked #5516 - Total: 959 - Youkai Watch Dropped: 113 Comment: Hmm...it got massive following in Japan out of nowhere, so something must gone right. I didn't add those shows because the total was under 5000. Thank you for mentioning them though! |
|
More topics from this board
» Do you drop shows?EverRealm - Today |
45 |
by T3NLTD
»»
3 minutes ago |
|
» Anime Misandry ( 1 2 )ColourWheel - Apr 21 |
86 |
by APolygons2
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Credit cards companies are forcing the Hentai industryDije - 9 hours ago |
39 |
by traed
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
» Things you are jealous of in animeIpreferEcchi - Apr 20 |
38 |
by Zalis
»»
9 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Interest and hobbies change with timenishant0 - 7 hours ago |
25 |
by Otakupervert890
»»
13 minutes ago |