DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Spider-titan55 said: ekanseht said: Spider-titan55 said: ekanseht said: Sheer_Khuwat said: never again I don't know how people who have followed this manga since it came out were able to put up with seo's shit. i hated almost every bit of drama and im amazed that you guys managed to wait a week or who knows how long for each chapter. really. so glad its over If you hated it so much, why did you continue reading? It eludes me how people can hate on something but still hang on to it like a limpet because the book is fun to rerad and fun to rage. yeah but only to an extent... quite so but the book does make you excited for what the heck is gonna happen next. true |
| In the end everyone loved the ending, right spider? ;-) |
| Having a deja vu here :D |
| Hm...Rin and Asuka weren't really important in the last arc. It's a good thing Seo brought them up at the end again. U-U |
Behemoth11 said: Hm...Rin and Asuka weren't really important in the last arc. It's a good thing Seo brought them up at the end again. U-U Basically no one was important in the last arc besides the two MCs. That doesn't mean we don't need closure for the most important supporting characters. Asuka and Rin were important during the span of the story. They were more important than Kiyomi, and I would argue on the same level of importance than Takashi and Akari, who all had their case closed correctly. I don't feel we've had enough of a conclusion for those two |
| Nah...Akari and Takashi had the childhood-friend bonus. The meaning of what Akari said to Haruto about his relationship with Yuzuki was more meaningful in my opinion, because she knew both of them for so long. Their were introduced as a Trio. and Seo brought it up again at the end. There is nothing wrong with it, I guess. |
Spider-titan55 said: ekanseht said: Behemoth11 said: Hm...Rin and Asuka weren't really important in the last arc. It's a good thing Seo brought them up at the end again. U-U Basically no one was important in the last arc besides the two MCs. That doesn't mean we don't need closure for the most important supporting characters. Asuka and Rin were important during the span of the story. They were more important than Kiyomi, and I would argue on the same level of importance than Takashi and Akari, who all had their case closed correctly. I don't feel we've had enough of a conclusion for those two well the OVAS will be focusing on yuzuki's point of view so hopefully we'll see them there. I hope so |
Spider-titan55 said: i don't see how you can give these a free pass. i know it's opinions and all but with everything that happened i'd imagine you'd be quite mad. it's also a shame how one person compared GotW with it's slow pace and repetitive bullying story to KNIM. again i know it's opinions but it just feels insulting how a good manwha ha sto be compared to a souless manga I just don't care so much about awkward side-characters as others. The main story got a conclusion. Not everyone liked it at first, but it wasn't so bad as you described it, Spider. Your main problem is you place characters like Asuka and so on in a higher position they desere and are upset about the story, because it focus on the main-characters, which you just don't like. Yes, it would be nice if we could see more of all characters, but that's maybe something for an Omake. The story of KNIM had a few good rudiments and that's something we shouldn't belittle. |
| I didn't implied that you shouldn't express your feelings, Spider. However, we also shoudn't forget the story was entertaining enough to keep us reading it. :3 |
Jet_Nice_GuyFeb 28, 2014 11:40 AM
| Satisfactory. 6/10 because there were a lot of stupid things in the manga after they started living together. |
| Even when I was in crowd, I was always alone |
| I'm giving this a 6/10, riding on mostly nostalgia. So disappointing this manga fell apart and became so obnoxious to read. |
 |
| Wow he has a kid now, Still young. 8/10 |
 |
| I was still expecting it to be til 270, guess this site caught me off guard. But I still can't believe it's over, though I really like how it ended up. 8/10 Getting married is the last step in a relationship. I mean of all moments everything will end up like that. Well that's for me I like the series anyway |
Live well - Laugh often - and Love much |
| I started reading this series when it first game out, and I was a avid reader until about chapter 170-ish. Then I went through a 1-2 year hiatus on all manga/anime due to laziness and personal life reasons. I've only just come back to anime/manga recently and I had forgotten about this gem which was my highlight of every week. Reading this series every week gave me so much joy, sadness, pain, laughter. I just couldn't get enough. So I started re-reading this from chapter one, so that I could immerse myself into it once more. Binge read the entire series in two days. I'm honestly really glad I was able to read it all in two days instead of once a week for five years. I was browsing through the forums on certain episodes and I was really confused about all the hate KNiM got from various long-time readers and people who just started. I could understand if you didn't like it from the beginning, but for those who kept on reading and raging were the ones that really confused me? It's understandable to be sad or angry that SJ is not writing it the way you would have preferred, but as I too might have felt feelings similar to you own I was able to accept it because it's the Mangaka's world. We are only the observer(s). There's no way he could write it so that everyone would enjoy it, but he told his story the way that he wanted to do it. I respect it. I love it. I'm still in that bliss feeling after finishing KNiM about five hours again. I've had thought like " I wish this would have never ended " or " If only he had added a couple more chapters or at least held out until chapter xxx ". I'm actually really happy about all the people who flamed and raged because it just shows how much SJ's work had of an effect on you. That's probably one of the artists greatest feelings. To be able to unite people across the world in discussion about it every week. If I was the artist I would be overwhelmed even if it was negative remarks because I would have known that you took my work into your heart and were able to express it freely. I admittedly cried for about an hour after I finished reading because I had so many emotions running through me heart and soul. I guess it was because I could connect because I am in a long distance relationship as well because I am finishing my masters in another state from my fiance. I thought the ending was quite fair, slightly rushed in my opinion. I think he would have been able to put a couple filler chapters in between ch 260-261 about those 1.5 years that was skipped. Sure we get small amounts of information such as Takashi and Kiyomi's second child, but I would have preferred to know more information in that time period. Oh well, I'm still very impressed and very happy about the overall end chapter. 10/10. Yes. 10/10. Through everything. Hiroshima. Tokyo. Kazama. Kochi. All of it. |
| I know the theme of this story is separation and shit, but the last few chapters were so fucking unessecary, especially when the mangaka suddenly pulls a 'everything is suddenly perfect' ending. At least I marathoned this series in three days, so I can still remember the manga before non random girl filler stuff came. 7/10 cause the beginning was so good |
 |
| Talk about a rushed ending. Thoroughly enjoyed the series. It fell a little stale during the Job arc, but that was fine. I'm a sucker for happy endings. Pointless breakup tbh. I wanted him to leave his job and let Yuzuki follow her dream as a teacher since he had no real emotinoal connection to his job. Shoulda became a chef from the beginning. |
 |
| I thoroughly enjoyed it up until the job arc, but since I'm a sucker for happy endings I was pleased. He had a pointless breakup and should have just left his job in the beginning and let Yuzuki pursue her dreams as a teacher even if it meant giving up his job. He knew he wasn't passionate about his own job, and since Yuzuki loved hers he should have dropped his in order to follow her. Pointless drama. Rushed ending as well. Akari had a more meaningful wedding (it had feels to it). Gonna drop this here, but seeing the side bitches move on and find their own loves is a bit ... empty? While I understand that they need to move on, it always seems that their love with the MC is always stronger than the love they've found currently. Btw Asuka ftw. I was yelling "side bitch ftw" when he started dating her. Haven't seen a couple more perfect and laid-back. Sure, Yuzuki is his true love, but Asuka's relationship with MC was very compatible. |
|
| 8/10 But if series can carry atmosphere and intensive like first 140 chapters I'll give it 9/10 I really like a countryside atmosphere of early series too. |
| That ending caught me by surprise. I thought it was going to end on chapter 270. 7/10 overall the first few chapters were 10/10. Probably up until Kazama died maybe a bit further. |
| It was mainly filler from 170-240 but this manga was really enjoyable! I really enjoyed the happy ending. The breakup when they moved away was understandable since they were important to each other so much but their jobs were also important. I'm glad Yuzuki waited for Haruto in the end, that makes it the perfect end :D |
| Well,that ends that.Can't decide between a 5/10 or 6/10 for this. First 141 chapters were a solid 7/10,that's around when Haruto got back together with Eba after he dumped Asuka iirc. Honestly wish this hadn't been prolonged by so long,Haruto and Eba living together,having sex,getting married,having a kid,etc shouldn't have been prolonged by over 100 chapters (of which most were filler),this might have turned out better if it hadn't been for that. Didn't completely hate this though (like I was expecting) and this wasn't as bad as I was expecting either.Gotta say the chapters I enjoyed the most were the one Seo trolled honestly (they were the most amusing parts of this entire manga). |
| Finished. Feel free to PM if you want to discuss. :) |
| Finally finished. The author should have ended this after Yuzuki's father let them live together. then a timeskip would be nice Unfortunately the author kept milking this and so many unnecessary drama that happened. What a shame this should be a solid 8. Kazama's helmet always gives me a bad after taste. That NTR guy was the real hero of the story. 6/10 ironically I rated the anime higher |
blessofcurseApr 30, 2015 3:17 PM
| The story and characters was crap. There were just too many misunderstandings and coincidences and it feels like the mc haven't rly developed. Only reason i won't give this a 1/10 is becauce of the art. Final score 3/10 |
| This manga is horrible. Seo is horrible. If you like this manga, you're horrible. Stop being horrible. Stop. Just. Stop. |
Theorder14 said: The story and characters was crap. There were just too many misunderstandings and coincidences and it feels like the mc haven't rly developed. Only reason i won't give this a 1/10 is becauce of the art. Final score 3/10 Ducat_Revel said: This manga is horrible. Seo is horrible. If you like this manga, you're horrible. Stop being horrible. Stop. Just. Stop. firs time in my life i felt like i want to kill 2 main chars lol first Eba was idiot dumping MC for bitty she felt for Kaza, then MC for making career (& dumping Eba for that) mane priority, u need to find balance not prioritize one thing to another, that's not all, but this are things that pissed me off the most not much of a manga reader (watching animes more) & i commented here long time ago |
| I still think the whole "Lets break up" thing was so sudden and bad. Seo should have just continued the long distance relationships without trying to do anything funny which he sadly did. Well happy ending they got married. 7/10, aside the bullshits I really love this series |
Klad said: I still think the whole "Lets break up" thing was so sudden and bad. Seo should have just continued the long distance relationships without trying to do anything funny which he sadly did. Totally agreed. I feel the same way about the break up with Mishima; it seemed very sudden and forced, for the sake of drama and moving the plot along at all costs. |
 |
| I stopped reading this way back and took a long break from it, then I saw I wasn't far from the ending and completed it. I dunno where to rank this manga, I was always switching from a 6 to 7. Never went as low as an 5, but it probably deserves it after all the trolling from the author Asuka was 1000x better for him, I would ranked this much higher if they stayed together. He let that Yuzuki ass get the better of him, yeah definitely a nice perk but the manga was sooooo much better to me with HarutoxAsuka. Once they broke up I was pretty much over this crap, just a downward spiral of the same gestures, repetitive scenes, blah-blah. 6/10. Mostly filled with bad arcs and angles, but the ones that are good I did enjoy. |
| The ending was so-so. There is way too much being left unexplained. I still like the conclusion, though... it is very much cliché. However, the manga was definetly too long. Especially after around chapter 150 when it started to go downhill (as many have already pointed out). What I really disliked was how many new chicks pop up into MC-Kuns life. Instead of focusing on just the very important ones (Akari, Nanami, Asuka, Kiyomi, Rin and Eba), Seo throws in so many girls that it is hard to keep track of them all, and for what? Just to be bait for a cliffhanger. I mean the 2nd half has barely any Drama and reduced itself to an average RomCom. There was so much wasted potential for drama that it got actually pretty annoying whenever a new character popped up. Like... why the fuck was there never any progress between Rin and Haruto? Rin was obviously interested in the 2nd half and having sisters duke it out would've been refreshing instead of filler material. Same goes for Akari. God, let him find his love for Asuka again (after she dragged him back to her place when he was drunk) to get some conflict going for all I care, anything would've been better than the dreadful fillers where nothing happens. /rant Anyways, I still gave it a 6/10 because of the first half and because it (the first half) reminds me in a way of my own love live I went through when I was in my early 20s. Was quite nostalgic while reading and actually got 150 chapters done in 2 days. |
| 10 out fuckin 10. If there wouldn't end this way... This is one of those stories which NEEDS a happy ending. I'm so glad that it ended in this way. I really respect Seo, even if he is doing something like last arc. He can write interesting stories, and well, he can perfectly transfer the feelings of characters by his drawings. It was awesome, so many years passed in this manga, the whole universe. And well, the ART, this is one of the most beautiful manga which I read, I LOVE his artstyle. Ok, now I need to buy Fuuka. |
rsc-plNov 23, 2016 11:35 AM
| Dub = fake crap. Always. |
| Incase anybody already hasn't figured it out yuzuki's fantasy chapter is basically the prequel to this chapter (or 260.5) so you probably want to read that (or read it again) after this chapter since things didn't make sense back when i read it after ch 200. Now as for this manga as a whole , I enjoyed it. There were definitely some parts that either made me rage (the last break up) or just straight up didn't make sense (quitting the job he left yuzuki for) but all in all I really did enjoy this manga. I will definitely look for more of Seo's work....I just hope it isn't as frustrating as this manga could be at times (even though we all know it will be). |
niaxato said: [quote=niaxato]THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER.THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- Pretty much as expected. They get married and Haruto becomes a chef. Also get a cameo of a teenage Fuuka. Personally would have much preferred that it was a dream sequence of Haruto's and they wouldn't have gotten back together but oh well. At least this crap is over. ---------------------------------------- i prefer it this way tho when he said lets breakup my eye balls got out of the sockets but i was little relieved when they got back together but it just keeps bugging me that they were apart for 1.5 year again man i hate the long distance stuff everything was so much fun when they were in tokyo living together but oh well this is cliche for every other manga or tv show to just burn the hell out of the viewer's mind at the end or near the end but ending could have been little more better but it still was good and it was emotionally strong |
 |
More topics from this board
» Is there a better english translation of this manga?Reshiram_IX - Apr 17 |
2 |
by Cristobal2325
»»
Apr 17, 5:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Kimi no Iru Machi Chapter 132 Discussionbelarion - Apr 21, 2011 |
22 |
by Mohan_Raj3
»»
Mar 19, 11:12 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimi no Iru Machi Chapter 140 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )TechDragon - Jun 21, 2011 |
113 |
by uruna117
»»
Jan 20, 9:09 PM |
|
Poll: » Kimi no Iru Machi Chapter 259 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )outkastfox - Jan 26, 2014 |
1089 |
by DarkHumor04
»»
May 28, 2023 4:09 AM |
|
Poll: » Kimi no Iru Machi Chapter 253 Discussion ( 1 2 )viesiu - Nov 23, 2013 |
61 |
by psyche-K
»»
Sep 28, 2022 11:08 PM |