What do you think about 10's on above user list and how much would you rate it?

iSheep said:
Haven't seen any of your shows yet, but I'm really looking into watching Cowboy Bebop. I hear a lot of good things about it.

tsudecimo said:
Madoka. Really bored the hell out of me, it took me 3 months to watch 6 episodes of it. The second half was interesting but with a pretty terrible ending. The main problem the series has imo is the characters especially Madoka, who I think off only as a plot device and nothing more. I hated the reason for Sayka's development and the basis for her conflict. 7/10.

Nichijou. Brilliant. The best Kyoani work I've ever watched. Who knew they can actually make a creative, original and funny anime, that doesn't rely on stuff like melodrama and ''moe''. I might re-watch it on the future. For a 26 series that only has comedy, it was pretty damn entertaining. 8.5/10.

TTGL. Meh, I disliked Kamina but liked the second half. Disliked the ending, and didn't really like the over the top style and the cliche on purpose stuff. The plot and characters weren't really that good. 7/10. But I would have probably give it lower if I didn't watch it early on my anime ''carrier''.

Emnay said:
i'd rate them all 0

vigorousjammer said:
@Dark_Chaos: Holy crap! so many 10s! (o_o;)

Let's just go with the ones I've seen...

InuYasha - It was dumb, generic shounen stuff. I never cared much for it, or it's characters. I gave it a 4/10

Death Note - The story continued to be interesting throughout, just seeing how Light would fool everybody next. However, the characters, while decent, still ended up being a bit disappointing to me, overall. It also isn't very re-watchable at all. I gave it a 7/10.

Yu Yu Hakusho - This was a fun shounen anime, and the characters were all really nicely done. I didn't give it a score yet, because I can't remember it too clearly. I plan on re-watching it, but in my memory it felt like an 8/10.

Ranma 1/2 - I've only seen one random episode, and it was funny, but I didn't get a good sense for how the quality of the show actually was. It didn't seem incredible, but gave me a good first-impression, So, I guess currently it's sitting at a 6/10.

Crap, posted too late, lol.

Alright, let's see...

@FGAU1912 - Taking a look hang on.

HOLY CRAP! 449 different shows rated 10?!?!?!

Well, lemme just go with the 18 of those that I share with you...

Neon Genesis Evanegelion - I never watched very much of it, only a handful of episodes. I didn't officially give it a score yet, but I'd say it's currently sitting around an 8/10 for me.

Akira - I thought the animation was really nice, and the characters were decent, but the overall plot got a bit disappointing, especially by the end, where it kind of just became too big. I gave it an 8/10

Mobile Suit Gundam 08th MS Team - I've only seen two episodes of this randomly, and really enjoyed it. I rated it a 7, but something tells me I should go back and watch it in full to really appreciate it fully. 7/10.

Princess Mononoke - This was an incredible film, totally deserving of a high amount of praise. I'm not exactly sure why I gave it a 9 instead of a 10, but I did. 9/10

FLCL - Another anime that is definitely deserving of a high amount of praise. I gave it a 9 because I felt like even though it's one of my favorite anime, there are still a few minor things that it could have done better in terms of the plot that are made almost completely meaningless by it's many other positive points. 9/10

Outlaw Star - I really liked this show, but felt like the style of it kind of held it back. It fell into many cliche shounen-style tropes, but still managed to stay enjoyable, creating a memorable cast of characters that held it up and made it feel really special. 7/10.

Perfect Blue - Satoshi Kon is a genius, and this is one of his best works, for sure. I gave it a 9/10.

Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence - While I thought the animation was beautiful, and it had a good presentation, it just seemed to be lacking something in terms of substance. I just felt like it dragged on and on and nothing really happened. Batou is a great character, and it was nice to see him take center stage, this film just seemed a little dry and boring, though, despite looking incredible. 7/10

Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind - The film was memorable, and had quite a great story to it, as well as really well done characters. However, I felt some of the dialogue was a bit explanitory, explaining to the audience what was currently going on, and that was the biggest disappointment. The soundtrack was also a little weak. I gave it a 9/10.

Vampire Hunter D - A cool tale about a vampire, great animation for the time. It was memorable for it's action scenes and it's animation, even if the characters or story aren't. 7/10.

Detective Conan Movie 03: Last Wizard of the Century - I liked this, but thought the pacing was a little weird like in all of the other Detective Conan films I've seen. It also focused more on action scenes instead of the mystery aspects. It was good, but didn't overly impress me. 7/10.

Ronin Warriors - I've only seen one episode of this, of the English Dub, and it was TERRIBLE. Maybe the original dub is a little bit better, but I was so disappointed at this that I gave it a 1/10.

Bio Hunter - A cool action/horror OVA. It's fun to watch, and the animation is good, but it didn't overly impress me. 7/10.

Cyber City OEDO 808 - This is another cool little sci fi action OVA. However, this one sticks in my mind so greatly. It's got some really memorable scenes, and osme really great characters. Still, it's not like it's incredible or anything, it's just a fun little action thing. I gave it an 8/10.

Voltron - I only saw one episode of the English dub and thought it was pretty sub-standard. 4/10

Barefoot Gen - I couldn't finish this film because it was so sad. I think that really says something positive about the story. The animation was nice, too. however, I thought the characters seemed very forgettable, and I can't recall the soundtrack whatsoever. I gave it an 8/10.

Gigantor - Saw a few episodes of this. It seemed like your pretty standard classic robot anime. I didn't like the art or audio mix very much. I also didn't really like the silly storylines they had in the episodes. 4/10

Moyashimon - It was decent, but I thought many parts of it seemed very standard. I have a full review for this one up if you want to know more. 6/10.

FGAU1912 said:
rread how i rate f=befire you qquestion me

Lime_ said:


Started to read how you rate out of curiosity, but then quit becuase what I can only assume was a poor attempt at humor (The gross mistypings that would make a pre-schoolers mom proud) came off as ignorant, so I can only assume your rating system is of the same caliber