MyAnimeList.net

Manga Information
Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

NHK ni Youkoso! Chapter 40 Discussion

Poll: NHK ni Youkoso! Chapter 40 Discussion


#1
01-26-09, 12:37 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 466
THIS IS AN MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER.
----------------------------------------
well,i am not really impress by the ending, quite disappointed really. i was expecting more from it, like a happy ending not that crap ending :S, how can they be so dense. The story and the plot was very good but both the anime and the manga disappointed me with their relationship development and the ending 6/10 or 7/10
Modified by Kineta, 11-23-12, 7:43 AM




Sumeragi Kururu - Pledge Queen of Tool Toul To
 
#2
02-02-09, 10:38 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 11
Well, I don't now if I read the last few chapters too fast, but I really didn't get the ending... Did he leave Misaki, went home and wrote ero-game scenarios and never saw her again?

If that is the case the ending sucked. If I'm wrong it might be ok :P
 
#3
02-02-09, 12:41 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 466
Lakitu said:
Well, I don't now if I read the last few chapters too fast, but I really didn't get the ending... Did he leave Misaki, went home and wrote ero-game scenarios and never saw her again?

If that is the case the ending sucked. If I'm wrong it might be ok :P

to my understanding, that is what happened, wacky isn't?




Sumeragi Kururu - Pledge Queen of Tool Toul To
 
#4
04-27-09, 3:36 PM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 244
From what I understood was, he was separating from Misaki so that he could learn how to love her for real, and not just play along with the contract or not being as serious as he could be about it. That and maybe Misaki will mature and become slightly less dramatic (although that is her funny aspect)

I think secretly inside he might have still been slightly doubtful. Doesn't mean he doesn't care about her, but he wants to be more independent so he can feel it in all his being perhaps? From what I read last, I figured they might meet again at some point. She did say she would be waiting.

Since it was realistic, and it hinted and them being together again, I thought it was an interesting ending.


 
#5
06-01-09, 7:09 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 29
Well guys, don't make me laugh.
When there is a happy ending you call it like "I knew it would end up like this, I hate it", and when there is no happy ending you say it sucks and that you were expecting something like "and so they lived long and were always happy". Just wtf? Decide, which one do you prefer.
I like the ending, cause it is not stereotypical - it is something I didn't predict, but I must say that it confused me a bit.
What's more, I believe manga is better than the anime when it comes to drama and few other things. I loved Misaki from manga, she was much better than the one from anime. Furthermore, I'd say they are two different girls! And look at Nanako! The same! Completely different than the one in anime. Hmm.. what else... There are many dramatic scenes and they really moved me deeply,for example, check chapter 19 from page 22 to 31 <-- This is just too sad.
Especially one scene stayed long in my mind (I guess I will never forget it). It is chapter 26 page from 23 to 25 <-- this scene moved me so so deeply, that I became MEGA depressed. I have never been so sad in my life.

Will it sound funny if I say that I do not recommend you reading this manga, beacuse you will be sick of sadness? I guess it's the best thing I could advice you if you are happy right now.
Modified by Bonyfreeq, 06-01-09, 7:46 AM


Forgive my melancholy.

駄目人間
 
#6
06-13-09, 11:48 AM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 244
Lo hmm, I haven't seen the anime.


 
#7
07-15-09, 4:02 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 274
genius ending, but certainly not for everyone.
 
#8
07-17-09, 4:58 AM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 76
I was told the manga is much much darker than the anime, I had no idea it was this deep. >_> A lot of things that were said by Satou and Misaki, I can totally remember me thinking those things, which makes me sad. ;_;

Bonyfreeq sums it well for me, if you don't like feeling depressed maybe you shouldn't read it. The anime is much more comical and doesn't have that terribly haunting sadness to it (well not nearly as bad as the manga). However, I liked Misaki more in the anime. :P
 
#9
08-20-09, 11:24 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 71
I think the ending worked ok, but I would've preferred more concrete closure. I was really happy when it showed Satou in bed with Misaki, I'd been waiting for them to get into a serious relationship since early on so that was super rewarding. Then like a page later they've gone their own ways lol, that bummed me out, I know that it implied they'd try to get back together after they've become more independant but I still would've more closure.
 
09-04-09, 12:31 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 63
I liked the ending now to start on episode 2 of the anime...for some reason I decided to start on episode 1 of the anime mid-way through the manga
(l_/)
('o')-------------------->a bunny
 
11-18-09, 2:44 PM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 46
Absolutely stunned by this manga, I preferred the manga before the anime because of how things turned out differently. I liked the ending, and I agree with others that we
should have seen a more close relationship between Satou and Misaki in the end, overall a better ending than the anime. It would be nice if they could make a remake of the anime to be more like the manga, mostly because the anime lacks of those deep and scary moments.
 
02-03-10, 7:11 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 4
Its not for everyone, i was really depressed reading it, so the ending is like "you decide" type of ending, but since I was in a depressed mood, the ending for me is, misaki will return to school, then meet with megumi's brother again as her teacher and Misaki finally falls for him and they end up both together. While Satou forgets about her.

It really corrupted my state of mind, and sometimes wakes up in the middle of the night and never fall asleep again till the morning thinking about it in a depressed mood. I vote "Dislike" not because its a bad manga, its actually good and addictive, the reason I read it till the end, but because its not for me, it left a bad taste on my mouth. I think I would never read this kind of manga anymore.

Im a GTO fan so you know what I like, I like happy and funny stuff, the only way i would read a depressing story is if it revolves around War.

I like the Misaki anime version though.

Misaki is like one of GTO's troubled students. Onizuka and Misaki should meet each other in class, it would be interesting. Im already laughing just thinking about it, Misaki would try to cure Onizuka's bakaness and virgin stuff and make him look stupid, until Onizuka got fed with her and teach her something about life like they would die together and something like that until she reach the breaking point hahaha! A perfect match.
 
08-02-10, 1:47 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 392
Usually i would read the manga before watching the anime (and then lose interest in the anime) but i was glad that i finally get around to watch the anime and then curiosity pulled me to read the manga. I think that the manga was great, pulled me in until the end and of couse the ending to the manga is more "happy" then the anime and i really liked the ending. Though the mangaka didnt close the manga, it felt like it was a happier ending then the anime. I also liked how this series was very deep and is way darker, but the anime made everything more smooth. But wither way, the series, both manga and anime has become one of my most fav. and i plan to go through a second run when i have time.
 
08-22-10, 7:48 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 707
I was really happy when it showed Satou in bed with Misaki, I'd been waiting for them to get into a serious relationship since early on so that was super rewarding.


I couldn't tell if that was a hallucination or the real thing. I had gotten so used to her cockteasing him that I doubt anything would have come of it but if so... well he just took a big step up from most otaku.

But overall I didn't care much for the end. It seemed to come out of nowhere, and it went way too fast. The last time we saw the senpai she got caught by her husband half naked with bondage gear playing cards with Satou... I had thought that would pretty much be the end of their marriage. Yet, at the last shot they were all happy go lucky. WTF? Where did that come from? What the fuck kind of super marriage counselor did they see to fix that shit? Same thing with the chairman. It was just so random to me. Then there was Satou and Misaki, which seemed that they would finally start taking things seriously... then he moves back, and he's pretty much back to square one. At least he and Yamazaki kept up their dream of making a VN even though he's slow as dirt.... I liked the anime/novel end more.
 
09-05-10, 1:16 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 2
His senior is still married and the other hikikomori seems to be a chairman in the politics with his sister (filename is "Chairman bro and sis.jpg").

From my understanding the last page's computer background seems to show Misaki in a way that implies she is again keeping close contact with the two. She seems to be holding a diploma. I'm guessing Tatsuhiro eventually got on his feet and continued the game project(s) with Yamazaki along with the other freelance work. Misaki re-entered school. I am also guessing it was or is becoming a happy ending for Tatsuhiro and her.
Modified by Ajasta, 09-06-10, 4:52 AM
 
12-15-10, 6:19 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 67069
I like the manga. The ending seemed somewhat strange or out of place though. Overall, I really enjoyed reading this.
 
12-15-10, 6:19 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 67069
I like the manga. The ending seemed somewhat strange or out of place though. Overall, I really enjoyed reading this.
 
12-15-10, 6:19 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 67069
I like the manga. The ending seemed somewhat strange or out of place though. Overall, I really enjoyed reading this.
 
06-02-11, 9:11 PM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 468
I can safely say I prefer the Anime.

I'll probably read the Light Novel soon and from looking at one or two pages I can see that the Anime was probably the more faithful adaptation which I'm thankful for.

The Manga seemed to be trying its best to make the characters less likable.

Why did they make it so that the abuse Misaki suffered as a child was just a lie as well as her parent's deaths?

Why did they bring Nanako back in after Yamazaki broke it off with her so dramatically, only to make her turn out to be a lesbian who was just fucking with him for shits and giggles?
Modified by TopgunUK, 06-02-11, 9:25 PM
 
09-07-11, 9:30 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 7561
Now that I've read the manga, I'm not really sure if I prefer the anime or not. They're both so different that I just can't make up my mind. Well one thing's for sure, if I ever get the chance I'm reading the light novel in a heartbeat.
 
09-21-11, 10:17 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 281
I liked this ending. It seemded to hint a lot more to the possibility of Satou and Misaki to get into a serious relationship at some point. I also liked the fact that the manga didn't rush things as much as the anime and some events are just more logical in the manga.
Misaki is really different in the manga compared to the anime though. I don't know which version I like best, but I can say that I truly enjoyed both ^^.

What I didn't get though, was that Satou totally ditched Misaki in the
housedemolish scene. Even though he had decided 1 min ago that he would die for Misaki's happiness.

And them saying that they hate each other, that wasn't true was it? Because, that was sort of random all of a sudden.

Also this -->
''Even if you don't love me, I want to be near you.'' --> Misaki
And then Satou decides to go back home? THE F*CK.


But as I said I still enjoyed this ending a lot.
 
12-29-11, 11:35 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2011
Posts: 3963
Wow, sucha an amazing manga. I will be checking out the anime for sure.
"Justice Never Dies!" - Kenji Endou, 20th century Boys
 
01-07-12, 3:54 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 1182
two years ago i finished watching the anime
and yesterday i thought of reading it
cause i was somewhat curious LOL
all i can say is
i'm definitely glad i read it~
----
yeah! mizaki finally graduated~!

satou got a new hair cut! LOL
i think satou still works with yamazaki with creating a game cause of the message
"please get me the scenario quick, satou-san!

yamazaki still left for the farm though
it was more dramatic and more lonelier in anime

still i think nanako said those things so that yamazaki can move on without
any doubts
i felt bad for her in the anime LOL

then
jougasaki and kashiwa's wedding worked atlast?

somehow i don't really know which ending was better
cause both were not stereotypical
though i like them both even though
they were different from each other

the manga explained most of the scenario
the manga is heavier and darker than the anime
more emotions than the anime i think?

the anime was more shounen like
and the suicide part was better in the anime
and the ending was that satou has a work and now
the two of them still meets at the park and somehow tutoring misaki? :D

It's definitely one of best~
 
08-16-12, 9:53 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2011
Posts: 421
Hitomi > Misaki (Tho she was never inline to be with Satou).... Rather interesting manga at first then, ya.. Took me a wile to finish.
 
09-26-12, 11:37 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 123
I'm somewhat unsatisfied with the ending, they should've kissed or something, I mean the ending wasn't completely bad, but wasn't very good either. However, I do wish that the anime did incorporate more of the elements from the manga into there, wouldn't been more fun to watch.
 
10-23-12, 6:30 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 1
Meh, ending made not much sense to me, it sucked as if author had no idea how to end it. 2/3 of manga was very nice and i liked it more than anime but ending was bad and disappointing to me...
 
03-30-13, 9:37 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 482
Horrible pacing towards the end. Often would jump around without any proper transition or warning.

What I hated most is how the characters would have some huge epiphany and a giant monologue sermon to go with it, and then they'd immediately revert back to their previous state of mind or even worse. I suppose it's realistic for people to fall back into old habits, especially with someone as weak-willed as the protagonist, but it just felt like I was being duped after the 4th time.
 
04-19-13, 2:17 PM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 1176
I don't know why, but i want to cry now.
 
06-01-13, 10:15 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 1121
8/10

Misaki is so cute XD The ending was kinda surprising to me, in a good way though. But i still wanna see Satou and Misaki kissing >_>


and still waiting patiently for a 3rd season of Spice & Wolf :'|
 
06-09-13, 6:17 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 3
I watched the anime and felt the need to read the manga. I definitely don't regret it. I may be sad now, little depressed even, signified by the fact that my situation isn't that far from a main hero, but I'm glad that I decided to follow anime up with manga.

I definitely need to read novel next, although I'm not sure if it can be called "light" novel if it's similar to manga. ;)

It will definitely stay with me. It's time to go sleep, I wonder what kind of dreams I'll have today with last episodes of anime and whole manga fresh in my mind. :)

I feel I should say a few words about last chapter too, so I'd like to commend it for delivering non-trivial ending that I find increasingly difficult to find nowadays. And I'm glad it wasn't anything depressing, I think it was even happy for me and thanks to that my sad state from reading rest of manga didn't get worse. :)

It definitely was an experience I won't forget in a long time.

And is it just me, or did manga have happier ending than anime despite being overally sadder? :)

Modified by Ilxuss, 06-09-13, 10:25 PM
 
11-21-13, 9:35 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2012
Posts: 138
I loved this manga. Read it in two nights. I wished it had a different ending, but it was still great. 10/10 Masterpiece. Time to check out the anime.
Modified by -Dragonreborn-, 11-21-13, 9:44 PM
 
11-27-13, 12:24 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 9557
The pacing and execution of the manga far exceeded the anime. I like how they made the pyramid scheme arc mesh with other arcs instead of the anime. Not also that, there was much better development on Yamazaki and Hitomi. The ending was fucking terrible though. I prefer the anime. I'll read the light novel and get on with my life. This manga gets a

9/10
 
12-18-13, 10:59 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2013
Posts: 789
Derpyderp said:

What I didn't get though, was that Satou totally ditched Misaki in the
housedemolish scene. Even though he had decided 1 min ago that he would die for Misaki's happiness.


At this point its not surprising considering how indecisive and directionless Satou is.



 
02-01-14, 1:46 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 80
This was better-sweet...playing with my emotions and all...I hated it all...yet...I liked it...the manga was way better in my opinion...
 
02-04-14, 11:11 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2014
Posts: 1
I did not like this ending. It left me empty, and not in that emotional, "the world is cruel" way. There was no resolution. The story didn't end, it simply stated that some situations are better and some are going to go pretty much in the same way. I'm not even bothered that the love interest never resolved to anything concrete, hell, I expected it. I felt no attachment to Satou's desire to love Misaki through his own independence. It became clear before this final chapter that Satou was now capable so the ending was little more than an affirmation a hurdle we already went through.

It didn't feel like an ending. The revelations resulting from character dialogue were no more impactful than others in the manga. It only felt like an ending because of a time skip and some pictures reminding me of the good parts of the story. "Hey, remember these characters and what they did! Awesome, huh? OK, it's all over now." Bottom line, no impact at all.

I loved the manga though, although I rated it a 6/10. But that's simply because I do not see myself recommending this to anyone. Personally, it hits close to home for me. I sympathize with the main character so much that a rating feels stupid. It's not even what I'd think of as a favorite manga, it's just emotionally sticky. A story like this will stay near my heart, where I can reflect on it for eternity.
 
02-05-14, 4:59 PM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 151
Like when I finished this chapter I continued clicking over because I didn't realize that this was the end of the manga. When the page came up saying that there wasn't a chapter 41, I just sat there dumbfounded for a moment.

I felt like it ended 3-5 pages too soon. When looking back on the final chapter though, the ending fits in with how the rest of the manga worked.

Looking at this manga in an overview, it is completely different from the anime. The stories only share the most basic of thread between them, and the characters except for the MC and Yamazaki aren't really the same at all. As an example, I almost dislike Misaki in the manga. I much prefered the damaged girl with a past to the insane girl with some issues.

After viewing both the manga and the anime, I think I'm going to have to say that I like the anime more. Thats not to say that they both aren't rock solid, but the anime is superior in my opinion.
 
02-11-14, 7:21 PM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 2456
what I learned from this manga:

1) all the characters have mental issues

2) the world is cruel ==> YOU DON'T SAY ?

I also think the "It was a joke!" after an overdramatic situation was overused in this manga. It was funny the first time, but Jesus find something else...
 
05-19-14, 12:01 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 128
Blfrvfrv said:

What I hated most is how the characters would have some huge epiphany and a giant monologue sermon to go with it, and then they'd immediately revert back to their previous state of mind or even worse. I suppose it's realistic for people to fall back into old habits, especially with someone as weak-willed as the protagonist, but it just felt like I was being duped after the 4th time.


Yeah, this really bothered me too. I prefer the anime to the manga because in the manga I just felt too overwhelmed by the characters problems to feel any sort of sadness or sympathy for them.
 
07-18-14, 12:16 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2013
Posts: 78
I decided to stay up til 2 am and get 5 hours of sleep to finish this and it was worth it. I saw the series a while ago and decided to go back and read the manga and rewatch it (cause I love it that much). The ending is definitely different but in a good way. From what I can understand I really like how sato decides to go home and get his life together and learn to really love Mizaki. It's definitely unexpected and kind of bizzar for an author to do but I feel like Sato doing that fit his character and it was realistic.

The manga didn't get me as down as the anime did but that's probably because of the lack of background music. Still it did get me down but in a good way. The manga gave me the same urge the series did: made me want to lye in a field while it's raining and just stare at a night sky while laughing at all the stupid things I've done and my regrets.

In the end I loved it and probably will reread it if I feel down. 10/10.
Examining one series under the magnifying glass at a time.
 
10-08-14, 9:00 AM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 45
Beautiful ending.

While the ending is somewhat open, we do see see that everyone is happy and has made some progress in their lives. Satou has a part-time job and is still working on games with Yamakaze, Misaki seems to have graduated, and the photo shows that the three of them got to see eachother recently and look happy.

Neither Sataou or Mikasi are emotionally prepared for a real relationship yet and the REAL happy ending here is that they both have gained some self awareness and maturity to realize that. However, the possibility is still there for a relationship in the future after they've matured some more and found their selves.

Beautiful. 10/10
 
12-20-14, 4:28 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2014
Posts: 2
Honestly, I didn't understand anything about the manga about halfway. I don't even understand the ending at all. 1/5
 
01-02-15, 12:58 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2014
Posts: 1200
I believe they ended up together... the author just did not show that... so each of us can have their own conclusion to their ending...
Got something to live for, I know that I won't surrender,
A warrior of youth,
I'm taking over, a shot to the new world order
I Am Bulletproof. . .

 
02-16-15, 6:53 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 730
What a shitty ending. The last few chapters felt rushed.
 
02-19-15, 3:54 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 4022
I'm maybe in minority but I like the anime better. More funnier less drama, less annoying Satou and real angel Misaki.
The romance was more satisfying in manga though, it was implied that they have sex but we never saw them kiss.

The ending was very clear so I'm not sure why some of you can't understand what happened.


6/10
 
02-22-15, 6:44 AM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2014
Posts: 23
I find this magna really interesting but the ending was rather disappointing. The fact that Satou still hasn't found a job but was writing another scenario for Yamazaki and that Misaki was using Satou to the very end. That's how i feel about it.


"Do you believe in magic?" - Lee "The Magician" Eul

 
02-25-15, 11:06 PM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 5
It's a lovely ending. Who knows what'll happen to them...but they learned so much already from their experiences and interactions in the story, and their lives continue...hence that graduation pic with Misaki and the 2 others when they presumably got together again. They've made progress!
"Life goes on" for them, as should for all of us :)
 
Top