CowboySam said:jejehartadi said:
Right, i don't even have those anime on my list :)
No, you instead like Blue Exorcist
Haha, just kidding, I have those on my manga list. Nah anyway, I thought I told you to calm down in another thread cause someone have their own favorite anime. So please stop bashing other people based on their favorite anime.
Anyway.. after this it will be pretty long. I have some spare time so I'll go with my opinions.
It's my policy to rate anime based on personal enjoyment and I would only give score '6 until 10'. Anime that has many comedy usually got on 6-8, and serious ones usually can got 9-10.
Ok, I like many genre, shounen, seinen, drama, romance, comedy, whatever, but only special ones that can I give 9 or 10. Ok, let's compare. I don't have problems with episodic episode, and I give GITS:SAC a 9. Whereas I give Bebop a 7. Bebop got praised because of animation, interesting style, and godlike OST, (if someone said storyline i think it's a bit wrong).
Well then. I never based my rating based on OST, so godlike OST won't affect me. Tension I got from watching and the story of the series is what most important. For me, Bebop appeals me in the first eps, but lost its charm on the way. Cause particularly it's just throwing some random events that feels like it doesn't important. Only a few with serious conflicts and suddenly closed with superb 2 final episodes without any signs before it. We got a rocker truck driver, mushrooms episode, 'mysterious creature(ep 11?)', and a cowboy riding a horse etc episodes which imo useless episodes. And it feels no tension coz the comedy isn't really funny imo and only a few conflicts and episodes of story which I can care of. Even when you got interesting characters, when u put them in an uninteresting story, u got nothing. What Bebop lacks is also a decent criminals. Many criminals(not all) just like rookies and uninteresting. They could've done like in Bebop movie which the criminal is worthy opponent. That's my opinion on giving Bebop 7, where the movie is 8 (almost reaching 9 actually).
Well, about GITS, they have more complex story and more serious atmosphere which I like. The laughing man was 10/10, complex story, the government conspiracy, detective stuff, etc. While I admit Bebop character is more likeable, GITS story is more appealing 'for me'.
Liking shounen doesn't mean someone is a sh*t. Ok, finished defending myself. Now it's time to defend shounen. Shounen is targeted to young audiences, but it also have values. Like one piece, even though it seems stupid, it's entertaining. And One piece have some social issues, like discrimination, dictatorship, war, etc.
Ok, hope u will not be so harsh on shounen, cause everyone have their own likings. Pls stop bashing people becuase he/she like shonen. (like u did to tsudecimo in the newest thread)
CowboySam said:tsudecimo said: Overrated.
Yes, listen to the person who loves Naruto
Whatever I said before about Bebop, if it is ur No. 1 anime then it will stay as it is. Maybe I'm the one who couldn't look at its charm.
Got tired of typing.. Anyway, every show has its flaws, even it may not appear in someone's eyes. Even if my 10s favorite anime also got critics. Pls give critic to the anime, not the person. |