MyAnimeList.net

Anime Information
Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

The ending: Guy vs Girl, Hiromi vs Noe
MyAnimeList.net Forum »» Anime Discussion »» Series Discussion »» True Tears »» The ending: Guy vs Girl, Hiromi vs Noe

Pages (9) « First ... « 7 8 [9]
View Poll Results: Which are you?
I am male and I rooted for Hiromi
 
143 32.35%
I am female and I rooted for Hiromi
 
27 6.11%
I am male and I rooted for Noe
 
197 44.57%
I am female and I rooted for Noe
 
75 16.97%
Voters: 442

09-05-10, 8:59 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 2287
Even though she a little psycho Noe no doubt. Harumi even takes a backseat to Aiko
 
09-10-10, 11:12 AM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 60
male, and i voted for noe... don't ask why, i don't know...

but i was happy about the ending... noe's "true tears" finally came out...
 
09-22-10, 2:00 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 31
Im a guy and I picked Hiromi....

Its sad to when you staying in of her 'crush' house when Shin's mom hate her. Imagine for so many years they been staying together, but Shin only enter her rooms once?
They been under the same roof since elementary school ......She put out so much suffering just want to be near with Shin.
She did her best not to hurt Shin as well as Shin's mom.
Yes she is selfish, but she also try not to go overboard.

Noe on the other hand, is a light, the light shines over the darkness in Shin's Heart.
I like how she lead Shin into a great guy. But I dont agree with you guys for saying her personality is unrealistic. I met some1 like her too. Trying her best for every1 good.

-Btw, I hate Shin ~stubborn~. Even though he been liking Hiromi since young....
I hate his mom the most ...For creating the rumor, they are siblings ....(i guess)

p/s: I post definitely biased to Hiromi lol .....I been wanting Shin choose Hiromi since the beginning of this anime, not even giving it a second thought.

But hei girls, we know you hate Hiromi characters....Try to put urself in her situation, will you do the same? I know most will say no instantly......try to put up more thought about ....Its not easy not to do as wat Hiromi did. Thought up where you are under impression that Shin's Mom did the same as Hiromi did to Noe.

sry for noe fans >.<
 
10-06-10, 9:59 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 8
Male and wanted him to pick Noe. For one thing, Hiromi wasn't a very nice person, and she didn't really like Shin till later in the show, whereas Noe loved Shin from the bottom of her heart from not long after they met, and Shin loved her back too. Shin really only had a crush on Hiromi in the first place, nothing definite, and just thought that she seemed to be sad all the time while at home. Of course, he wanted to help her because they obviously lived under the same roof, and he did care about her. Still, Noe would have been a way better choice, Hiromi just acted cold towards Noe and is a bit of a bully, which says to me that she must get what she wants.

Noe <3
 
07-10-12, 8:34 PM

Online
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 2534
If he had chosen Noe I would feel a little sad and it would be a weird situation.

Oh come on, Noe looks like a child for me.
My favorite JP songs channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/myfavtracksJP
 
07-13-12, 9:04 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 465
im rooting for hiromi from the beginning to the end.. noe just a child for me,still he deserve to be loved by shin, but shin loved hiromi since child same as hiromi. but hiromi is suppressing it because of what shin's mother said.. think of a forbidden love,..
 
07-25-12, 12:15 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 30
Male and i choose Hiromi. Not that i dislike Noe, but i know what efforts Hiromi has been do.

Because she loves Shin, she decided to stay in his house, to get closer to him. But? His mom started the rumor that they are sibling, and always give hiromi a cold face. Think of it. They are living under the same roof for so long but Shin just happen to come to her room only once, despite that Hiromi's purpose to live in Shin house is to get closer to him. And because of the rumor too, she has to bury her love for him. For more a couple of years. It must be hurt. But for her love, she can endure it.

And in the end, Noe finally get back her tears. So it was a good choice the ending finished like that. Yeah Noe is his inspiration for the picture book and other things, but the effort between them cant be compared. So i choose Hiromi. Despite that she sometimes can be bossy too. lol
 
07-27-12, 12:15 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 392
I am male and I rooted for Noe..

To be honest I was rooting for her ever sense I seen her up in the tree.
I feel like Noe was betrayed, watching the last three or so episodes really made me angry for some reason.

True Tears was my life in a nut shell. I wish I could go back and make everything right. GAHHHHH I really wish I never watched this anime. :I It makes me think of the one I betrayed, for the stuck up pretty girl, and in the end.. it did not even work out between us. I hurt more people than I would of liked. *Sigh*
 
08-16-12, 6:11 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 192
I was always for Hiromi to the extent I was kind of surprised that there was a significant chunk of the fanbase that was bothered by his choice.

Staying in the same house for Shin's sake while having a consistent feeling of hostility and alienation from the mother wouldn't have been easy. Especially while suffering an internal conflict over the morality of them potentially being related completely justifies her inaction and ambiguousness for me. Then when you add the problem of Shin getting Noe's brother to go out with her, which would obviously be frustrating and difficult before even learning he's only doing it for Noe's sake and that he doesn't care about her, I'd feel too bad for her otherwise. She would've lost both people and while that essentially happened to Noe, Noe still knew her brother loved her which is somewhat better than meaning nothing to someone. Noe also completed her overall 'tear quest' and while I still feel bad for her, I'm comforted it looked like she had friends at the end.

Noe's weirdness also struck me as annoying towards the start of the series as well and she seemed isolated to me back then through choice, which to me anyway, implies a fair deal of strength, compared to Hiromi anyway, who's internal conflict made her seem more vulnerable.
 
08-23-12, 10:08 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 84
Male and rooted for Noe. I am actually extremely bothered by the Hiromi decision.

I feel like she had absolutely no character whatsoever. She felt extremely hollow to me. Like her entire existence in the anime is to serve as the main character's final choice. I find this ridiculously strange when the anime focuses on Noe to the point that the last scene in the series pre-epilogue is just a 2 minute still of Noe standing.

I almost feel like the author wrote Hiromi in to make the viewer feel sad over the "wrong choice." Extreme yes, but that's how much I did not like Hiromi.
 
09-23-12, 10:49 PM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 98
#1 (and ill second the "wtf no aiko?" question :P)

as some have said, and said in the show itself, when she moved in, she bottled up all her feelings, add to that the various events that happened, his mother bein the way she was to her, the bit with noe's bro an shin's deal (which she thought he was lying about talkin to "#4" at first lol) all of that woulda made anyone hesitant to do anything
 
10-28-12, 3:07 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 355
I'm a guy and I wanted Noe to win ;_;
Looks like more people wanted Noe to win.
Modified by Kirito-Dragneel, 10-28-12, 3:22 PM


 
12-19-12, 2:45 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2012
Posts: 151
Justwon said:
Male and wanted him to pick Noe. For one thing, Hiromi wasn't a very nice person, and she didn't really like Shin till later in the show, whereas Noe loved Shin from the bottom of her heart from not long after they met, and Shin loved her back too. Shin really only had a crush on Hiromi in the first place, nothing definite, and just thought that she seemed to be sad all the time while at home. Of course, he wanted to help her because they obviously lived under the same roof, and he did care about her. Still, Noe would have been a way better choice, Hiromi just acted cold towards Noe and is a bit of a bully, which says to me that she must get what she wants.

Noe <3


That's simply not true. She was in denial about her feelings for shin or withheld them for the reason that she thought they might be half siblings so she convinced herself or lied to herself that she liked someone else. When she confessed her love to shin she told him she had been in love with him this whole time finally being honest about how she felt. So the feelings they felt for one another wasn't something that just came out of nowhere, they had history that spanned since childhood. As much as there was this part of me that wanted shin end up Noe it just wouldn't of been realistic and would of been dishonest of shin to choose her.
Modified by drewzm, 12-19-12, 4:36 PM
 
12-20-12, 7:25 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 527
Quite honestly I didn't root for the main character to end up with either of them, he literally drew which one he picked out of a hat anyway.

Seriously the protagonist just sucked, maybe if he matured a bit I would've said ok but I just don't think the guy is ready for a real relationship.
 
12-21-12, 11:59 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2012
Posts: 151
hyperknees91 said:
Quite honestly I didn't root for the main character to end up with either of them, he literally drew which one he picked out of a hat anyway.

Seriously the protagonist just sucked, maybe if he matured a bit I would've said ok but I just don't think the guy is ready for a real relationship.


You are entitled to your opinion but to say his choice was something completely random is totally off base. He was in love with her even before Noe entered the picture but had essentially given up on her when he had overheard her claiming to like someone else, so he figured he couldn't have her. Noe just happened to be convenient for him at the time.
 
03-15-13, 12:23 PM

Online
Joined: Jan 2013
Posts: 357
I liked Noe from the begining i hate the ending.I hope they made some OVA alternative ending.
 
Top
Pages (9) « First ... « 7 8 [9]
FAQ     About     Contact     Terms     Privacy     AdChoices