fri said: Number-of-titles achievements are on their way, along with I Like Them Long. The real problem is that there are three times more manga entries than anime, so I'm not sure if listing all insert_any_genre_here titles makes sense, since there will be a shitload of them. We could limit it to the most "representative" titles, ignoring unpopular ones. Suggestions based on this thread: - mahou shoujo (list) - mystery/detective (code or list? I guess a list would be better) - romance (code?) - shounen ai/yaoi (code?) - games excluding sports (list) - sports? (code?) I don't really like the idea of letting the code "decide" on that, since I don't trust genres on MAL, and we would end up with very many titles that aren't related to given genres. I'm with you, the genres on MAl are not that accurate :| |
 |
| Games has only seven pages for the manga genre tag, so a list shouldn't be too horrendous to put together. Sports should also be easily doable. Shounen-ai/yaoi is probably better off being done using the code; I think I trust that genre code enough to not mislabel something with those. Romance is such a huge genre that I don't see any good way of quickly drawing up a list without it being ridiculously long. Just make the threshold higher, maybe? Mystery/detective should probably be a list just in case. In either case, I will try to have badges done for the X anime/manga completed and I Like Them Long sometime this weekend. I was gathering screencaps and stuff. :)b |
| Code for Shounen ai/yaoi should work assuming you group both in one achievement since all seem tagged appropriately. |
| <img src="http://30.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lx1a8gz3tu1qbxqfpo1_500.png" /> |
| I still want hentai achi for manga..... NOT, but well how about achi for reading manhwas/mahuas and such ? well title might be Manga addict NOT or something xD Also I want my chinnese cartoons fanboy badge back >:0 |
| I had no time to follow the club recently, but there's one thing that's been on my mind. I think that the length chart for manga should use volumes, not chapters (with zero volumes reserved for one-shots). After all, one average volume can contain from four (typical for monthly or quarterly manga) to twenty and more in case of 4-panels. |
 |
| Something simple, on the Ratings per decade section, could the pop up possibly show the count of the titles as well. eg 7.27 - 36 Or something similar. |
 |
fri said: There's a reason we only have a few of those lists and limit them to first 20 entries 2bad, would like 2see the full "Favorite genres" list.. :x |
 |
| It would be cool if you made a little section for your mean scores of demographics. |
| Video rants & stuff: Top 12 Heart-Wrenching Scenes in Anime | DraconisMarch Video Club |
Phantaminum said: It's Over 9000! - Watch 9001+ anime episodes, Picture of Vegeta breaking the scouter (Vegeta what does the scouter say about his episode count?) It can be achieved "easily", so I would suggest to make a level 2 up to 4 for it. 36001+ anime episodes on list means an art of life... The picture could be the same with the level number on one of it's corner. |
| I second the above request. It really would be very interesting. |
 |
| disregard request. |
 |
IonicSquid said: Okay. I can't really tell when we'll have it done though.Would we be able to get a graph for mean score per year? It would be interesting to have a visual representation of mean score on a year-by-year basis. roflmaonubcake said: The API doesn't return such data, so MALgraph has no way of knowing how many times you've rewatched/reread any title. You could contact the MAL's team, but I believe it has been mentioned multiple times already, and no one is bothering with updating the API."Score to time distribution" ought to take into account rewatches. |
| There should definitely be an achievement for reading a lot of manga by Osamu Tezuka, since he is the Godfather of Manga. |
autistic_catgirl said: There should definitely be an achievement for reading a lot of manga by Osamu Tezuka, since he is the Godfather of Manga. I think I suggested that once, so I'll second your suggestion of it. It's a great idea. |
| I don't think Malgraph should go AniDB way. One site is enough. |
| |
| Is it possible to show the difference between your mean score and the average mean score like they used to? Also, is it possible to show the mean score for different series lengths? For example, do I score series in the 14-26 range higher than 7-13 range? Thanks. |
InfiniteRyvius said: Like in the first MALgraph? Nope, Mg2 doesn't have any global stats.Is it possible to show the difference between your mean score and the average mean score like they used to? InfiniteRyvius said: Nice idea! I'll write it down for future updates (don't expect anything for the next few months though - I have a thesis to write, and rr- is quite busy).Also, is it possible to show the mean score for different series lengths? For example, do I score series in the 14-26 range higher than 7-13 range? |
fri said: InfiniteRyvius said: Like in the first MALgraph? Nope, Mg2 doesn't have any global stats.Is it possible to show the difference between your mean score and the average mean score like they used to? Really? It used to say that your average was so much above or below the global average.... I swear it did... Maybe I was using something else... fri said: InfiniteRyvius said: Nice idea! I'll write it down for future updates (don't expect anything for the next few months though - I have a thesis to write, and rr- is quite busy).Also, is it possible to show the mean score for different series lengths? For example, do I score series in the 14-26 range higher than 7-13 range? Thanks! Though, what I really want to get behind is the average score for each year, or even maybe! for each season, so I may look back and see that the winter season for 2011 was shit, but the spring season for that year was fantastic! What with two cour shows that might be difficult, but I really do like that thought. |
InfiniteRyvius said: Yes, it did! I meant it was possible in the first MALgraph (the tiny one that looked like this), but isn't possible in the current version.fri said: Really? It used to say that your average was so much above or below the global average.... I swear it did... Maybe I was using something else...InfiniteRyvius said: Like in the first MALgraph? Nope, Mg2 doesn't have any global stats.Is it possible to show the difference between your mean score and the average mean score like they used to? InfiniteRyvius said: The average score will be shown for years and decades, as opposed to decades-only as it is now. I guess we'll add the "mean score" text to activity timeline, which shows number anime completed in a given month (no seasons, sorry!)Though, what I really want to get behind is the average score for each year, or even maybe! for each season, so I may look back and see that the winter season for 2011 was shit, but the spring season for that year was fantastic! What with two cour shows that might be difficult, but I really do like that thought. |
| Or at least an achievemnt to the real classic titles, like Umi no Shinpei, Chagama Ondo, Suteneko Tora-chan, Nakamura Katana, Kumo no Tulip and so on. Those, what were created before 1959, the end of the black and white era. For start, there are directors like Kenzou Masaoka, Mitsuyo Seo. |
| Little suggestion - show when stats were last updated somewhere at the bottom. Like "Last updated: 5 hours ago" or at least date&time. |
| I love MALgraph, but one thing is bothering me. Let me explain it in an example: January: I think "Hm... this XXX anime looks intersting. Let's give it a try!" and watch 1-2/26 episodes. After that, I think "Uh, boring" and I put it on my dropped list. April: I think "I have nothing to watch. Maybe that XXX anime wasn't that bad?" and I complete XXX. And then, guess what? I view my MALgraph... and I see that I've completed XXX in January. It's untrue. Any hope for improving it? |
| You can fix it yourself by simply editing your watching date. Open your list and click on "Edit" next to that entry, and change the start or finish date. |
| But, for example for Kuuchu Buranko I have dates: 02.03.2012-12.12.2012 - and MALgraph says that I've completed it in March. Of course I can set start date to December, but I don't see a point in lying that way. I think it's not so difficult to change this. |
IdanJan 19, 2013 4:58 AM
| Just a quick feature request - can the badges be kept when gotten? I have to admit I quite liked the images on some of them and when they get replaced it tends to irk me a bit ^^; |
| You can link to the images on the server, e.g. http://mal.oko.im/media/img/ach/anime-mecha-1.png |
| What about weighted average (for favs)? |
| It used to be weighted, and most users said they weren't spot-on. It was a real pain to choose the right formula, and we ended up with powers like 0.889. That was in Mg2. In Mg3, we use straightforward sorting - either by count or mean score - so we don't "guess" user's favorites anymore. |
| It would be nice if graphs in comparison mode used the same scale. |
| Will the archivements workshop be opened soon again? There may seem to be missing some more titles. (like http://myanimelist.net/anime/14957/Shakugan_no_Shana:_Naze_Nani_Shana_2 http://myanimelist.net/anime/17551/Shakugan_no_Shana:_Shana_to_Yuuji_no_Naze_Nani_Shana while it's prequel and anything else from the franchise is in the magical Girl Archievement list, [and which may be pretty much the last ones until I get rid of the Sailor Moon button, haha]) Aside that, Monthly activity in descending order is, in my opinion, perhaps more handy, it saves one to scroll to the complete right side of the graph. (Since whatever may change is usually among the recent months). Through that is mathematically also pretty counter-intuitive I guess. |
shina_lunaFeb 22, 2013 5:26 AM
Luna needs some space~ Luna's Sales List~ (German Version) Luna's Search & Sale pile (English Version) |
shina_luna said: Mg3 is open source, so the list is visible to anyone (here). I added the title you just posted to the server (not on GitHub).Will the archivements workshop be opened soon again? Monthly activity should follow basic plot guidelines, which means further to the right = later time. |
fri said: Well, those who were happy were silent, those who were unhappy were complaining...most users said they weren't spot-on. As for me - they were quite ok, but now they're completely off. fri said: It's just the same quessing, but less smart.so we don't "guess" user's favorites anymore. |
fri said: shina_luna said: Mg3 is open source, so the list is visible to anyone (here). I added the title you just posted to the server (not on GitHub).Will the archivements workshop be opened soon again? So, if there are changes and additions to be done, one just have to add them into the json file of the github link? Thanks for the quick update through. =D Monthly activity should follow basic plot guidelines, which means further to the right = later time. Guess, mathematically it really makes sense. Through may there be some way to have the default display on the furtherst right part? That would do just about the same of saving to scroll. |
Luna needs some space~ Luna's Sales List~ (German Version) Luna's Search & Sale pile (English Version) |
| Am I correct in assuming that the franchise feature shows every anime that is connected to the "main" anime in any way? While I do think this is a great feature, I believe some changes have to be made since it also lists "Inukami!" to the Shakugan no Shana franchise list because they are connected by the Dengeki Bunko 2007 Festival Special. This should also be the case with various other anime like Gintama and SKET Dance, Lucky Star and Anime Tenchou or One Piece and Toriko. Due to this, I think the franchise feature shouldn't count anime that are connected by the character tag on MAL. |
fri said: shina_luna said: Mg3 is open source, so the list is visible to anyone (here). I added the title you just posted to the server (not on GitHub).Will the archivements workshop be opened soon again? Is there a more complete version of the list? When I look at that page, it looks like the lists for Mecha and Slice of Life (just to name a couple examples) are missing a lot of titles. (Mecha has only 22 titles on the list that I see?) |
| The list is automatically generated from MAL's data for given title's genres. Some of them don't have set the genre properly (e.g. a lot of sequels to Historical series don't have a Historical genre), so we fill out the missing pieces. I'll take a break now, that was a pretty busy day. We'll continue looking into things that don't want to work properly (I can't load any comparison now...). Thank you for all suggestions so far! |
| luv the Achievements, also comparing achiv and favorites with others, bit laggy tho :p anyway got some suggestions kinda: -seperate Recommendations & Missing titles, more Recommendations wouldn't hurt either -Favorites rearange - 1. Favorite genres, 2. Favorite studios, 3. Favorite years -Achievements: moar ach wouldn't hurt ^^ -also forum shortcut to MALgraph 3 could be placed at the top, or did i miss it o_O |
| |
| I had a talk with a friend about our favorite titles and such who aren't that favorite how often we have rewatched them. Just made me think it would be nice to have some rewatched most list according to one's rewatch count entry. =D |
Luna needs some space~ Luna's Sales List~ (German Version) Luna's Search & Sale pile (English Version) |
| As the very first post in this thread says, we are unable to get rewatch data. Sorry. |
| Oh. Sorry, I didn't pay attention. >.<" Does the API return "Total Episodes Downloaded"? (If yes, could be used as a workaround to fill in instead, perhaps?) |
Luna needs some space~ Luna's Sales List~ (German Version) Luna's Search & Sale pile (English Version) |
| WarcowUshi: 1. There are over 7300 anime titles and over 14500 manga titles in DB. 2. As for users, API does not provide one way to retrieve all the data we need. We have to scavenge through many different documents in order to get user data. It's a long shot but one user = 4 documents minimum AFAIR. 3. Let's assume we have 1000 users in DB (which is actually underestimate). 4. That's over 25000 documents to fetch. Most of unique visitors are just checking things out and never come back. And for some reason CURL has problems connecting to MAL, each transfer takes 4-5 seconds. (We use parallel requests, don't worry.) So the idea to put everything into cron is not going to work. Sorry. |
  |
| The only thing I miss is the episode count chart. Is there any chance to make one again? |
More topics from this board
» Current IssueSofiaBulga - Feb 21, 2020 |
1 |
by hacker09
»»
Jun 17, 2020 12:11 PM |
|
» Achievement list? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )bluedragon777 - Apr 9, 2013 |
391 |
by Rhiannon-Senpai
»»
Apr 13, 2017 1:39 PM |
|
» Important announcement, please read! ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )fri - Apr 14, 2015 |
402 |
by Tulicloure
»»
Aug 7, 2016 7:15 PM |
|
» Bug reports ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )fri - Mar 7, 2012 |
928 |
by Dragonflyk
»»
May 12, 2015 7:37 AM |
|
» Some charts_North - Apr 14, 2015 |
0 |
by _North
»»
Apr 14, 2015 6:36 PM |