Forums

Still infinitely better than GC.

Both series are meh. Stop complaining about other series and actually make something worth the hype then Japan.

Wait I'm confused.... 10,000 copies? so is that considered success or failure for GC?

and also I'd prefer watching GC rather than P4 even though I'm DLing both coz P4's artwork is.....>.>"

Okay, I loved Persona 4... as a video game. But the anime is god awful. The writing, the animation, all of it. Anyone that likes it could only like it for two reasons:

1. They like the franchise too much to admit that any part of it is shit.
2. It's kind of like a bulldog. It's ugly-cute. As in, it's so bad that it's good.

Or something like that.

At least Guilty Crown is pretty to look at.

sense a hint of jealousy

As bad as GC was at times, P4 was consistently worse...

You mean like how the initials for Guilty Crown are just the initials for Code Geass backwards?

MIND=BLOWN!

LOL to the people who think Persona 4 is shitty when it has one of the best character and story developments from the fall season. What kind of development does Guilty Crown have? Nothing. Just lots of cool action scenes then BAM! Your given something totally random and unplanned.

You must have not even played the Persona 4 game, because the script has little to no changes from the actually game itself. So it isn't the script in the anime. What's the problem is the crappy animation, and really choppy pacing. But as a game adaption it excels where others have failed.

LOL are you serious? It's pretty obvious. I think they are a bit delusional if they said there are completely no similarities.

inb4 1,000 posts of shit tossing between GC fanboys and haters.

As for me I like this anime only thing it lacks is a smooth plot since it seems to jump around alot and doesn't explain much plus the episodes don't connect. Cause I really wanted to see what happened next just to see something else entirely different happen at the beginning of the next episode. Other than that its very good imo. Still 8/10 material for me haven't caught up to the latest episode yet I'm still on episode 11.

The only things are that the way they pace the show, and animation kind of messes up what the game did. Like someone else said on here, as a game it was awesome and easily one of the best on Playstation 2 (glad to see it is being remade with extra content for PSVita ^^) but as an anime it is not fluent enough too suffice how great it actually is.

I don't think these two shows are utter abominations, but neither as great works. They are decent at best. However, when it comes to script writing, there is no argument. They both lose.

I watch and enjoy both shows for what they are worth. He really is in no position to criticize though.

Meh, whatever.

Persona is more enjoyable so far.

jealous of what? Persona 4 sold 4x more than GC.

Thread should be renamed to Persona vs GC fanboys/girls...

As for me: both stuff are horrible, but GC is still slightly better.

Could care less what others think (writer of persona and other GC haters) I enjoy both anime series and won't stop watching either one. Don't know why everyone gets all butt hurt about these kind of things.

Lolwut? Really? o.o

GC is a lot better compared to Persona since the latter has some of the most horrible pacing issues you could ever see in an anime.

He's not even in the position to criticize GC anyway.

Why don't we just come to the conclusion that both are mediocre animes at best and have one giant group hug.