New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Jul 28, 2008 10:03 AM
#101
oh well, no more CC piloting KMFs, but she's so darn moe >_< and complications, shmomplications, and why oh why did you say you are Zero, Lelou? Just like what Brian333 said, CG's turning into a cliche fest. Cue Gundam SEED ending battle <_< though, well, with growing distrust in the Order itself, it seems...well, the HSQ will go up a few points in the coming eps, hopefully. |
Jul 28, 2008 10:06 AM
#102
Xannieh said: 2. OO I remember when I saw shrimp and something else on the pizza.. I love shrimp..just not..yeah.. LOL that's the truth - looked like there was broccoli on there this week - bleccch xXBlackjacKXx said: IncognitoOtaku said: People who haven't tried Pizza Japanese style really need to try it. It's an epic experience in its own right. It looks epic alright - it looks like what you'd find in the toilet bowl the morning after an epic frat party /shudder. I worked for a pizza place when I was in college - that dish needs a new name for it that isn't pizza. Pizza Hut Barf Platter maybe. |
TrojunJul 28, 2008 10:54 AM
Jul 28, 2008 10:16 AM
#103
It DOES look like something you would eat after a heavy night of drinking...that thing is probably crawling with calories and fat. |
Jul 28, 2008 10:56 AM
#104
shin_otaku said: Brian333 said: The writer and project heads really need to stop caring so much about what the public wants. dude when you typed this, do you actually hear yourself thinking this??? I don't get what you're saying. Did I realize what I was typing when I typed it? Yea, I did. Does something sound wrong about it? |
Jul 28, 2008 11:18 AM
#105
Jul 28, 2008 11:57 AM
#106
From my thoughts, it was a good episode. It is cool to see Kallen knock some sense into Suzaku. XD The new C.C. is fairly cute and moeish but I still hope they bring the old C.C. back though. Very interesting scene on the Emperor's sudden return. Also, Suzaku now knows that Lelouch got his memories back. I really look forward towards the moment they meet again next episode. |
Jul 28, 2008 12:34 PM
#107
Excellent episode. It also is probably leading the way to a lot of mecha combat, which is what i am really craving for now in the show, since Suzaku already got his ass beat by Karen... |
Jul 28, 2008 1:29 PM
#108
Jul 28, 2008 1:31 PM
#109
Jul 28, 2008 1:37 PM
#110
kie_ said: dumbasatri said: kie_ said: amazing episode i cant wait for the next episode anyone thinks that ninja maid pretending to be ohgi. Seems pretty obvious the way ohgi reacted when dietard greets him . couldnt be, She was in Japan with Rolo wasnt she? no.she was after ohgi and i think she killed him yeah, but in the new episode, at 14:18 (at least on eclipses sub), it shows what appears to be Japan, and Rolo walking with Sayoko and some other people. Something definitely seems weird about Ohgi, but at least it couldnt be Sayoko dressing up as him, since she cant be in two places at once. |
Jul 28, 2008 2:18 PM
#111
but at least it couldnt be Sayoko dressing up as him, since she cant be in two places at once she's a ninja maid ... so i doubt that :))) |
Jul 28, 2008 2:25 PM
#112
Jul 28, 2008 2:33 PM
#113
Jul 28, 2008 3:06 PM
#115
Well, it was rather nice, however I agree with Brian333, but this is Sunrise... and that wasn't a pizza <___< |
Jul 28, 2008 3:36 PM
#116
@Brian333: You are wrong about what CG was and is. It was and still is a series that lies somewhere in middleground with cliche themes on one side and darkstory on other side. Remember when in season 1 L.L. & Suzaku fought together against a enemy who seeks independence for Japan by using Chinesse help? That was light years worse then this one is. Also, friendship was shown as an important element many, many times during R1. The first scene we see is the friendship of Suzaku and L.L. Through the R1 and R2, their friendship is put on test. And Kallen beating Suzaku wasn't really fanservice. Suzaku has imagined himself that he is a great, white knight like Lancelot is. Like the one from fairy tails. And a guy with such personality can be expected to do this. I was more suprised of how angry Kallen was then the fact she punched him. If this didn't happen, she would need to get her vengeance later and that is obviously something the authors don't want. And pushing L.L. from the antihero status? Two episodes before he gave orders to slaughter unarmed people and children! There was no need to kill them. He is greater anti-hero then he ever was in R1. And yes, it is obvious that CG shall end this season. If they were going on slower pace (like R1 did), we would get R3 and a story of R1 quality. Now, we have a story in chaos and we shall get an R3 which shall be an unintended add-on to the first two seasons. The series is popular and a popular series make money. At least one more season shall be made. But no matter what happens, R2 alredy suffered because of the pace. The story didn't change. The way it is presented has. |
Jul 28, 2008 3:55 PM
#117
Islaya said: rofl, best gif ever http://randomc.maximum7.net/image/CODE%20GEASS/CODE%20GEASS%20R2%20-%2016%20-%20Kallen%20beating%20up%20Suzaku.gif haha great gif. *saves* aww poor CC got a boo boo |
Jul 28, 2008 4:43 PM
#118
Well, that pathetic face of Lulu when begging Suzaku highly amuses me , I think I like that scene more than when that Kallen bitch did stupid fanservice. |
Jul 28, 2008 4:45 PM
#119
dumbasatri said: kie_ said: dumbasatri said: kie_ said: amazing episode i cant wait for the next episode anyone thinks that ninja maid pretending to be ohgi. Seems pretty obvious the way ohgi reacted when dietard greets him . couldnt be, She was in Japan with Rolo wasnt she? no.she was after ohgi and i think she killed him yeah, but in the new episode, at 14:18 (at least on eclipses sub), it shows what appears to be Japan, and Rolo walking with Sayoko and some other people. Something definitely seems weird about Ohgi, but at least it couldnt be Sayoko dressing up as him, since she cant be in two places at once. yeah i saw that. maybe you are right but DarknessAngel said: but at least it couldnt be Sayoko dressing up as him, since she cant be in two places at once she's a ninja maid ... so i doubt that :))) |
Jul 28, 2008 4:45 PM
#120
Well, you all are arguing that this story is getting more cliche yet why do we all still see the episodes every week then. honestly, we still watch it because the overall story and plot along with the weekly cliffhangers has us hooked so i say lets just sit tight and watch everything unravel. and then we can contemplate if it was good or not... |
Jul 28, 2008 6:03 PM
#121
Jul 28, 2008 6:10 PM
#122
Jul 28, 2008 6:40 PM
#123
YES!!! An ending within sight. (I hope anyways). And who knows...maybe after all of the shit they've been through, maybe...just maybe, there will be some kind of mutual understanding between Suzaku and Lelouch. *hears crickets in the background* Okay, okay, so it may sound a little far'fetched. Who knows though. |
Jul 28, 2008 6:53 PM
#124
I love the old C.C. And I'm glad I knew the old her before this new one. If she was like this from the beginning, there are very high chances for me to dislike her ^^; But I actually love seeing my favorite characters being . .. out of character xD So this new C.C. is so fanservice to me. I like it. It's just so damn cute =3 And with this vulnerable and honest side of hers, Lelouch is acting more caring and protective . . . thus, more Lelouch x C.C. moments. I like that xD Oh I want more *_* |
We Heal As One. |
Jul 28, 2008 7:53 PM
#125
I love this ep. specially when Kallen beats Suzaku up! Lelouch's father is not yet gone.. its getting more and more exciting.. cant w8 for ep.17 x.x |
Jul 28, 2008 8:07 PM
#126
Nayrael said: @Brian333: You are wrong about what CG was and is. It was and still is a series that lies somewhere in middleground with cliche themes on one side and darkstory on other side. Remember when in season 1 L.L. & Suzaku fought together against a enemy who seeks independence for Japan by using Chinesse help? That was light years worse then this one is. Also, friendship was shown as an important element many, many times during R1. The first scene we see is the friendship of Suzaku and L.L. Through the R1 and R2, their friendship is put on test. And Kallen beating Suzaku wasn't really fanservice. Suzaku has imagined himself that he is a great, white knight like Lancelot is. Like the one from fairy tails. And a guy with such personality can be expected to do this. I was more suprised of how angry Kallen was then the fact she punched him. If this didn't happen, she would need to get her vengeance later and that is obviously something the authors don't want. And pushing L.L. from the antihero status? Two episodes before he gave orders to slaughter unarmed people and children! There was no need to kill them. He is greater anti-hero then he ever was in R1. And yes, it is obvious that CG shall end this season. If they were going on slower pace (like R1 did), we would get R3 and a story of R1 quality. Now, we have a story in chaos and we shall get an R3 which shall be an unintended add-on to the first two seasons. The series is popular and a popular series make money. At least one more season shall be made. But no matter what happens, R2 alredy suffered because of the pace. The story didn't change. The way it is presented has. bleh, I'm quite hesitant to respond to an account that has 1 post (this one), has no anime entries, and was made this month but it seems like a serious post so whatever. Lelouch and Suzaku never truly fought together against the Japanese Liberation Front (I assume this is what you're referring to). In the one case that they were on the same side of justice, it was against an act of terrorism. In the end, it proved to be for different motives and both sides were acting independently. So no, I don't consider that collaborative. Especially not when Lelouch effectively took the hostages hostage to guarantee his own escape. And CG has changed. You can't deny that. What has changed? We'll start with what you brought up: Lelouch and Suzaku. Before, Lelouch was an ends justify the means type of person. Suzaku was a type of person that valued the means to an end. Both were very resolute in their pursuit of a goal and valued friendship but were inevitably torn apart by the conflict in their paths. Until the start of R2, both characters really played into those roles and neither were cliche. Both had their history and both had their justification. Beginning with R2, Lelouch started to care more about the means that he previously compromised in his pursuit of his goals. Suzaku compromised his previous dedication to "doing things the right way" in favor of his goals. Suzaku, who wasn't a traditional villain at all in the first season became the model for a despicable villain in R2. Lelouch, who wasn't a traditional hero at all in the first season became the model for a soft, caring and loving protagonist. Lelouch's dual existence and identities were much more pronounced before and the character and plot dynamics that resulted from that were what defined the first season. Lelouch's life and his character was split between a normal student and the leader of a rebellion that used methods that were far from righteous. He was an anti-hero in every sense of the word. He pursued the truth behind a personal vendetta and a world that he thought Nunnally wanted and needed. Nothing else mattered. Friends, lovers, blood and innocence didn't matter. Now, Lelouch and Zero are pretty much a singular entity painted with a very traditional (and cliche) hero role. He doesn't go to school anymore at all. He doesn't care. The battle isn't a selfish rebellion against leaders and governors that weren't necessarily bad people (Euphemia, Cornellia) anymore. Now, it's a united resistance against Charles and the image of evil that has been given to a character that was previously a rather unknown entity. Now, it isn't about a single man's vengeance, hatred, or delusional views on life. It's about a global urge for freedom from oppression and a leader that's fighting for lost friends, love, and the world. He's very much a traditional hero now... at least more so than before. And really, more of an anti-hero now than before? How so? Because he commanded an attack on a research facility filled with children bred to be murderers and assassins with god-like weapons given to them in a fashion that defies basic human rights? These people weren't innocent by any measure. Rolo was a member of the cult and look at how he turned out. Look how many people he has killed in cold blood because of his geass. Children or not, it was a research facility made to produce weapons, assassins, and murderers. Innocent? Lets go back to innocent... people like Shirley's father and the entire town that Lelouch effectively massacred by creating that landslide. How about Euphemia? How about murdering a ship full of demoralized Japanese liberation soldiers that had already surrendered? I could go on about how things have changed to abide by much more conventional standards but I think you get the picture. R2's pace has actually been okay for the most part. A span of 2 episodes that had break-neck pacing does not make a whole series poorly paced. R2 has suffered because of inconsistencies within the writing, poor justification behind major changes, and just general confusion and lack of focus and vision. |
removed-userJul 28, 2008 9:40 PM
Jul 28, 2008 8:17 PM
#127
hahaha, i loved this episode, major points for kallen to 7 combo'd shitzaku anyways, the episode was pretty good. C.C being overly moe was just infinitely cute. i would love to have her with me, omochi kaeri!!!!!!!!! cornellia finally seeing zero. and lulu still treats her as a sister. it seems like lulu only has hatred against his brothers, like a real man! treason is foreseen kallen 7 combo-ing suzaku was the greatest thing in R2 so far. her acting all tsuntsun was great, she even did the "hump" look C.C and pizza, the inseparable duo... i love how the artist decided to give her more cute eyes rather than those awesome eye looks that she had when she was more badass. anya is still cute. and now that she has revealed that she seems to think about two pasts, it seems like the emperor does have some sort of connection with anya. from the flashbacks in her fight against c.c, it seems like she was really close to marianne and lelouch, and maybe even nunally (suspicion of nunally being a fake sister rises). then again, why wouldn't lelouch remember after he got degeassed from c.c in his memories? knight of 10 is a complete asshole... kallen needs to kick his orange ass for good. she needs to pilot the new guren that not even suzaku can pilot, and destroy the shit out of him.... i even like suzaku better than that. freya in lancelot does seem to be bad... and by spoilers on future episodes, it does seem like suzaku, or at least freya, will blow the shit out of millions of japanese people in tokyo... ougi's look seems like either its true that villeta has been captured by diethard, and he is being threatened, or that he is sayoko.... who knows wouldn't rivalz suspect rollo and lelouch already? geez Guilford seems to be going to change sides after his talk with orange. with lulu having cornellia at his side, it seems like guilford's fate is with cornellia due to him being her knight, kaguya wa kawaii yo emperor charuru seems to be toying with zero... so... gayneizel is also against charles? awesome, we might have zero and his brother against charles. i felt sorry for C.C when lulu snapped... lulu no baka... he even wasted a slice of pizza that c.c cutely saved for him.... also, chess symbolism ftw. c.c not healing fast enough might mean she is mortal again... but that also means that there are more chances that she will end up with lulu.. but meh, this is not a romance, so whatever. suzaku turning into suzaku was completely out of the blue.... i never expected for him to ask suzaku for help... and now it seems like the spoilers are more than true,.... awww... so, with schniezel finding out zero's true identity, he will reveal it. the black knights will find out about it, and betray zero, not only for him being that of a prince of the enemy, but also for hiding so many secrets such as the geass, and the cult they just slaughtered. but... i still want kallen to escape with the guren, and join lelouch, but if the spoilers are true, there will be too much shit between all that. like her questioning lelouch's true intentions and all that. anyways, i want to see at least anya and suzaku switching sides to lulu's, and cornellia, guildford, and who knows, even schneizel to join lelouch... as for nina, i want her to blow up with her freya. well, i can only wait and see now... also, lulu ordering c.c. to wear her clothes inside out and dance in one foot was lulz, but her actually doing it was even more lulz.... i miss the old c.c., but the new one cannot be cuter... i still want to hear her real name though... geez.... but she crawling was win... long wall of text that i wrote due to boredom also, does c.c not being a geass giver anymore mean she can get geassed? |
TsundereRicJul 28, 2008 8:21 PM
Jul 28, 2008 8:57 PM
#128
dumbasatri said: co_flame said: LOL Tamaki is the internal cleaning supporter yeah, i saw that and laughed. Might as make that three. Tamaki always seems to make me laugh sometimes. XD |
Jul 28, 2008 9:02 PM
#129
Brian333 said: Nayrael said: @Brian333: You are wrong about what CG was and is. It was and still is a series that lies somewhere in middleground with cliche themes on one side and darkstory on other side. Remember when in season 1 L.L. & Suzaku fought together against a enemy who seeks independence for Japan by using Chinesse help? That was light years worse then this one is. Also, friendship was shown as an important element many, many times during R1. The first scene we see is the friendship of Suzaku and L.L. Through the R1 and R2, their friendship is put on test. And Kallen beating Suzaku wasn't really fanservice. Suzaku has imagined himself that he is a great, white knight like Lancelot is. Like the one from fairy tails. And a guy with such personality can be expected to do this. I was more suprised of how angry Kallen was then the fact she punched him. If this didn't happen, she would need to get her vengeance later and that is obviously something the authors don't want. And pushing L.L. from the antihero status? Two episodes before he gave orders to slaughter unarmed people and children! There was no need to kill them. He is greater anti-hero then he ever was in R1. And yes, it is obvious that CG shall end this season. If they were going on slower pace (like R1 did), we would get R3 and a story of R1 quality. Now, we have a story in chaos and we shall get an R3 which shall be an unintended add-on to the first two seasons. The series is popular and a popular series make money. At least one more season shall be made. But no matter what happens, R2 alredy suffered because of the pace. The story didn't change. The way it is presented has. bleh, I'm quite hesitant to respond to an account that has 1 post (this one), has no anime entries, and was made this month but it seems like a serious post so whatever. Lelouch and Suzaku never truly fought together against the Japanese Liberation Front (I assume this is what you're referring to). In the one case that they were on the same side of justice, it was against an act of terrorism. In the end, it proved to be for different motives and both sides were acting independently. So no, I don't consider that collaborative. Especially not when Lelouch effectively took the hostages hostage to guarantee his own escape. And CG has changed. You can't deny that. What has changed? We'll start with what you brought up: Lelouch and Suzaku. Before, Lelouch was an ends justify the means type of person. Suzaku was a type of person that valued the means to an end. Both were very resolute in their pursuit of a goal and valued friendship but were inevitably torn apart by the conflict in their paths. Until the start of R2, both characters really played into those roles and neither were cliche. Both had their history and both had their justification. Beginning with R2, Lelouch started to care more about the means that he previously compromised in his pursuit of his goals. Suzaku compromised his previous dedication to "doing things the right way" in favor of his goals. Suzaku, who wasn't a traditional villain at all in the first season became the model for a despicable villain in R2. Lelouch, who wasn't a traditional hero at all in the first season became the model for a soft, caring and loving protagonist. Lelouch's dual existence and identities were much more pronounced before and the character and plot dynamics that resulted from that were what defined the first season. Lelouch's life and his character was split between a normal student and the leader of a rebellion that used methods that were far from righteous. He was an anti-hero in every sense of the word. He pursued the truth behind a personal vendetta and a world that he thought Nunnally wanted and needed. Nothing else mattered. Friends, lovers, blood and innocence didn't matter. Now, Lelouch and Zero are pretty much a singular entity painted with a very traditional (and cliche) hero role. He doesn't go to school anymore at all. He doesn't care. The battle isn't a selfish rebellion against leaders and governors that weren't necessarily bad people (Euphemia, Cornellia) anymore. Now, it's a united resistance against Charles and the image of evil that has been given to a character that was previously a rather unknown entity. Now, it isn't about a single man's vengeance, hatred, or delusional views on life. It's about a global urge for freedom from oppression and a leader that's fighting for lost friends, love, and the world. He's very much a traditional hero now... at least more so than before. And really, more of an anti-hero now than before? How so? Because he commanded an attack on a research facility filled with children bread to be murderers and assassins with god-like weapons given to them in a fashion that defies basic human rights? These people weren't innocent by any measure. Rolo was a member of the cult and look at how he turned out. Look how many people he has killed in cold blood because of his geass. Children or not, it was a research facility made to produce weapons, assassins, and murderers. Innocent? Lets go back to innocent... people like Shirley's father and the entire town that Lelouch effectively massacred by creating that landslide. How about Euphemia? How about murdering a ship full of demoralized Japanese liberation soldiers that had already surrendered? I could go on about how things have changed to abide by much more conventional standards but I think you get the picture. R2's pace has actually been okay for the most part. A span of 2 episodes that had break-neck pacing does not make a whole series poorly paced. R2 has suffered because of inconsistencies within the writing, poor justification behind major changes, and just general confusion and lack of focus and vision. Keep in mind, that ideas and mindsets do change over time. I still see what you mean though, good point. |
Jul 28, 2008 9:12 PM
#130
so i just watched the last 3 episodes in a row... i dont really know what to say, like, how many times is lelouch gonna have to kill his pops?? C.C. is making it harder for the Karen ending to unlock. Karen is still awesome, especially in her prisoner outfit. "I'll never be mean to you" ... later that day ... "SHUT UP" *smashes plate* ... ???? Lelouch still looks pathetic when he begs. Orange's phone call should be interesting. Suzaka thinks Lelouch killed Shirley, hopefully Karen thought he was full of shit when he said that to her. A waffle is like a pancake with a syrup trap. Karen come back to us pleeeeeeeeeeeease :( :( D': i miss you oh, and the quote above me says "children bread", is that a new flavour? |
holy_mosesJul 28, 2008 9:16 PM
Jul 28, 2008 9:40 PM
#131
yea, that was an obvious misspelling of the word bred. I should go back and fix that. |
Jul 28, 2008 9:46 PM
#132
Jul 28, 2008 10:01 PM
#133
Jul 28, 2008 11:26 PM
#134
Scud said: C.C should stay like this. Moe C.C. is the best thing ever since... Hot Dog STUFFED CRUST pizza!! The toppings look like: God i was trying to find the mini game that had some Pizza Hut guy do a taste test on th e different dipping sauces for the hot dog crusts. He tried everything from stone mustard to mayo to ketchup even fresh ground wasabi ground right of the plant it was pretty comical. |
Jul 28, 2008 11:40 PM
#135
vindemon64 said: Well I do think that episode 17 will be a major step toward reconciliation between them. They won't leave there with things being completely alright, but long as Suzaku doesn't try to kill Lelouch it will be a building block. The important thing will be Suzaku getting the truth about Euphy and I'm sure Shirley will come up as well. They should go into the fight on opposite sides, but do think there is a chance for things to change after that.YES!!! An ending within sight. (I hope anyways). And who knows...maybe after all of the shit they've been through, maybe...just maybe, there will be some kind of mutual understanding between Suzaku and Lelouch. *hears crickets in the background* Okay, okay, so it may sound a little far'fetched. Who knows though. Have to say that is a sad assault against the name of pizza. Just creepy stuff. |
Jul 28, 2008 11:41 PM
#136
Jul 28, 2008 11:49 PM
#138
I would say kallen and lelouch meet up in the next 2 or 3 episodes....leaning towards 3 or more. |
Jul 29, 2008 1:04 AM
#139
Jul 29, 2008 2:48 AM
#140
I kinda expect C.C's memories coming back to her at some point too. But let's watch at a poor village girl for a change...she still likes pizza! =3 I never expected Lulu would ask Suzaku for help and revealing himself to him. And I never expected Suzaku would agree either...damn,that's some twisted plot Kallen beating Suzaku to a pancake = most epic thing ever. I even expected '10 points!' signs to appear every time she hits him. Those are the scenes I live for XD |
Jul 29, 2008 5:40 AM
#141
Well, you all are arguing that this story is getting more cliche yet why do we all still see the episodes every week then. honestly, we still watch it because the overall story and plot along with the weekly cliffhangers has us hooked so i say lets just sit tight and watch everything unravel. and then we can contemplate if it was good or not... Some watch it with hopes that it will become like the R1. Some watch it because they are bored or don't have anything better to do. Some watch it because they like it. Lelouch and Suzaku never truly fought together against the Japanese Liberation Front (I assume this is what you're referring to). In the one case that they were on the same side of justice, it was against an act of terrorism. In the end, it proved to be for different motives and both sides were acting independently. So no, I don't consider that collaborative. Especially not when Lelouch effectively took the hostages hostage to guarantee his own escape. I am talking about episode 20 where Zero and Suzaku fought against Sawasaki in Kyushu. You can say that Zero had reasons to do that, but reason for making this episode is clear: they wanted to make an episode where Suzaku and L.L. fight together against a common enemy. There are more episodes that are centered on friendship and rivality of L.L. and Suzaku. Since ep. 5 it was obvious what this series is about: two paths to change the world and how their friendship is wounded by thiese conflicting paths. Suzaku, who wasn't a traditional villain at all in the first season became the model for a despicable villain in R2. There were hints of that happening in ep 23 and at the end of ep 25 it was obvious that he wasn't Suzaku he was before Euphemia's death. In other words, he turned like that during R1. During most part of R2 he stayed like that. But it seems that Zero's appearance made him think about his methods as he remembered that he does not want to become what L.L. has become. In last two episodes, he started caring about Nunnaly again and he even let Karen beat some sense into him. The next episode will show if he is still villanous Suzaku or if he became heroic Suzaku again. To make a long story short, in last few episodes Suzaku started thinking like his oldest self and it shows that he might become a good guy in evil faction again. Lelouch, who wasn't a traditional hero at all in the first season became the model for a soft, caring and loving protagonist. R2 episode 4: "I will use you until you dry up and throw you away like a ragged cloth" *villanous smile* [This can't be called soft and caring] Kidnapping Tianzi was also an act of betrayal. Making China rebel and turning Xinge to his side was a plan he came up at last moment. He wanted to use the poor child for his own gains. He also felt no remorse or hestitation when he gave orders to slaughter the Order. Innocents were killed, children were slaughtered and he didn't care at all. And his warm conversation with Cornellia which was filled with "I am sorry for what happened to Euphemia.", sad faces, inner tears... no, wait. He doesn't go to school anymore at all. No, he just ran all way from China to Japan to return to school. He was just hunted by every girl in his school. He was a school botanist for few moments. Like in R1, there are few episodes centered on him as a school boy. The battle isn't a selfish rebellion against leaders and governors that weren't necessarily bad people (Euphemia, Cornellia) anymore. He betrayed Xingke and Eunuchs by kidnapping Tienzi. He changed the plan when he saw that the newer is more profitable, but the fact remains: his plan was to destroy both the eunuchs and Xingke, both of whom helped him (tough one betrayed him later, but the other trusted him). Now, it's a united resistance against Charles and the image of evil that has been given to a character that was previously a rather unknown entity. Charles was a villain since the very beginning. He even laughed when his own daughter was killed. And don't tell me you tought that L.L. would beat Britannia with Japanesse forces? To beat a nation that controls half of the world, you need manpower. And his Japanesse manpower would fall after he liberated Japan and the Black Knights woudn't survive the next invasion which would probably be lead by Schneizel or Charles, both smarter then L.L. You need the support and manpower of the rest of the world if you want a small chance to beat Britannia. He realised that during R1 when he sent C.C. to negotiate with Chinesse Federation and when he broadcasted events in Japan in order to gain prestige which shall show the world that he is capable of fighting Britannia and that the rest of the World can put themeselves into his hands. After liberating China, he gained enough prestige to become the military leader of UN... and now he has all the manpower of those nations at his disposal. And really, more of an anti-hero now than before? How so? Because he commanded an attack on a research facility filled with children bred to be murderers and assassins with god-like weapons given to them in a fashion that defies basic human rights? These people weren't innocent by any measure. Rolo was a member of the cult and look at how he turned out. Look how many people he has killed in cold blood because of his geass. Children or not, it was a research facility made to produce weapons, assassins, and murderers. Innocent? Thats a machiavelistic way of thinking (goal justifies the means). A good hero would never order such a thing or he would at least feel saddened by that. Taking it over is also a nicer option. It also ain't just a research facility that created murderers. It is a nation in its own right (researchers don't need a city). Those people were born to be geass users or reaserchers and most of their children will not get a geass. And all those people had their lovers, friends and sisters like nunnaly. Dreams as well. But he did not take it over. He slaughtered it without any kind of mercy As you mentioned in a former topic, it was all for Shirley. He murdrered them all for Shirley. He murdered them all for vengeance. Lets go back to innocent... people like Shirley's father and the entire town that Lelouch effectively massacred by creating that landslide. The fact that Brittish civilians were either uninterested or found Zero's actions cool shows that most civilians didn't die. The fact that Britannia didn't use that to fight their "Allies of Justice" title shows thatmot civilians didn't die. Civilians were evacuated before the battle and most of those who were there during the landslide where those who are in military. And killing Euphemia was an unplaned accident. Shooting her was a sign of mercy as she would go insane for what she has done. emperor charuru seems to be toying with zero... so... gayneizel is also against charles? awesome, we might have zero and his brother against charles. Or we might have Charles Vs. L.L. Vs. Schneizel. Schneizel might use the situation to take over the Brittish throne from his father (he does not know that Charles is immortal). I think that was mentioned in CG: the strongest one gets the throne. At this point, i'm wondering if C.C. will still have a big role to play We still don't know what is her connection with Empress Marianne. |
Jul 29, 2008 6:48 AM
#142
i hated that episode how dare lulu smack my C.C. >=( |
Jul 29, 2008 10:45 AM
#143
Nayrael said: Well, you all are arguing that this story is getting more cliche yet why do we all still see the episodes every week then. honestly, we still watch it because the overall story and plot along with the weekly cliffhangers has us hooked so i say lets just sit tight and watch everything unravel. and then we can contemplate if it was good or not... Some watch it with hopes that it will become like the R1. Some watch it because they are bored or don't have anything better to do. Some watch it because they like it. Still we watch it for various reasons proving my point further. that is why we should just hang back and not have pointless arguments amongst ourselves, instead we should argue wit sunrise or the channel which airs it to release episodes faster. OR discuss whats goin on instead of debating opinionated topics and stuff... such as Lelouch being a Hero or Villain or Suzaku being a Hero or Villain. |
Izzy2008Jul 29, 2008 10:50 AM
Jul 29, 2008 11:26 AM
#144
Jul 29, 2008 12:49 PM
#145
Ulquiorra_4th said: i hated that episode how dare lulu smack my C.C. >=( Lmao. Don't worry, he still ended up wrapping a bandage over her cute finger. |
Jul 29, 2008 1:47 PM
#146
Jul 30, 2008 12:30 AM
#147
Very long post in response to Nayrael. Nayrael said: I am talking about episode 20 where Zero and Suzaku fought against Sawasaki in Kyushu. You can say that Zero had reasons to do that, but reason for making this episode is clear: they wanted to make an episode where Suzaku and L.L. fight together against a common enemy. There are more episodes that are centered on friendship and rivality of L.L. and Suzaku. Since ep. 5 it was obvious what this series is about: two paths to change the world and how their friendship is wounded by thiese conflicting paths. Okay, that's fine. My original point dealt with the changing Lelouch and the fact that friendship and love took a backseat to his goals. He was willing to throw away his friends, his soldiers, and even himself so long as he could protect his goals. Before, it was all about his personal vendetta, the truth behind his mother's death and his distorted perception of what Nunnally wanted and needed. Those are some very self-centered goals. This wasn't about a selfless battle against a world power in pursuit of freedom, peace, and equality. It was all about Lelouch using and riding the lives and sacrifices of countless people in an effort to get what HE wanted. You're right that friendship was a more central theme in the first season. I'm not saying that it wasn't. I'm saying that unlike this season, friendship and other human relations were treated in a very different way -- a much less idealized and less cliche way. The key difference lies in the fact that ultimately, Lelouch chose to pursue his goals over protecting his friends, commanding his soldiers, and over the life of his best friend, Suzaku. What does that say about the importance of friendship to you? Now, this season, friendship has become a motivating factor behind everything that Lelouch is doing. His "friends" were the reason behind why he chose to reclaim his mask and his role as Zero when he had lost sight of his path. Avenging the death of a friend effectively compromised Lelouch's ability to obtain critical information regarding the truth of geass, possibly the truth behind Marianne's death, and potential explanations for what Brittannia has been doing with geass. Now, in times of desperation, he turns not to the death threat he used on Suzaku in season 1 but rather a plea to hear out and understand a friend. So really, in comparison to the "lone-wolf" Lelouch that relied on his own genius and power in pursuit of his own goals, what we're seeing now is a Lelouch that is beginning to draw on the ever-so-cliche power of love and friendship. So, Lelouch has become a very different character built on different morals and different priorities. That's why I said he has become much more of a true hero. There were hints of that happening in ep 23 and at the end of ep 25 it was obvious that he wasn't Suzaku he was before Euphemia's death. In other words, he turned like that during R1. During most part of R2 he stayed like that. But it seems that Zero's appearance made him think about his methods as he remembered that he does not want to become what L.L. has become. In last two episodes, he started caring about Nunnaly again and he even let Karen beat some sense into him. The next episode will show if he is still villanous Suzaku or if he became heroic Suzaku again. To make a long story short, in last few episodes Suzaku started thinking like his oldest self and it shows that he might become a good guy in evil faction again. He acted on hatred in the final battle and set out into the war with the intent to kill Zero. That doesn't make you into a villain, that just merely makes you human. In his final conversation with Lelouch, it was very apparent that what was powering his actions was a combination of his sense of justice and an internal conflict with his need for revenge. His sense of justice was still very much intact. Now it could've stopped with that. Suzaku could've approached things very differently from that point on. He didn't and that's what we've been given with R2. Now, I agree with you in that it was more an issue with Suzaku being out of character and that it looks like he's finally realizing the faults in his decisions. That doesn't change the fact that in R2, he has been made into more of a traditional villain. For the mass majority 15 episodes, he was without a doubt quite the conniving bastard. R2 episode 4: "I will use you until you dry up and throw you away like a ragged cloth" *villanous smile* [This can't be called soft and caring] Kidnapping Tianzi was also an act of betrayal. Making China rebel and turning Xinge to his side was a plan he came up at last moment. He wanted to use the poor child for his own gains. He also felt no remorse or hestitation when he gave orders to slaughter the Order. Innocents were killed, children were slaughtered and he didn't care at all. And his warm conversation with Cornellia which was filled with "I am sorry for what happened to Euphemia.", sad faces, inner tears... no, wait. First, Lelouch became the model for a soft, caring and loving protagonist. The key word here is became. His conflict and decision on Rolo was still when he was quite the anti-hero. In episode 6, he left his comrades for dead on the exterior of the ship while he went to talk to Nunnally in private. He didn't really start shaping into the change until he re-evaluated his ways during episode 7. Shortly after, he expressed genuine and somewhat biased concern for the safety of Kallen on the battlefield. Shortly after, he took the advice of Shirley on how to deal with Tianzi. Recently, he commanded an attack on the Cult as a result of Shirley's death, the need to right a wrong, and avenge a friend. And like I said in my original post, it's not like he was attacking innocent people without any justification. He was attacking the origin of mass-produced geass assassins and murderers. And, did you just totally ignore the other aspects of kidnapping Tianzi? First off, he saved her from being sold to Brittannia. He also didn't geass her into accepting their alliance. I was quite upset at the time that he didn't. He let her have her own free will and a right to choose. He didn't even use her to try and get Kallen back when it was clear as day that he had the trump card in that situation. No, he just ran all way from China to Japan to return to school. He was just hunted by every girl in his school. He was a school botanist for few moments. Like in R1, there are few episodes centered on him as a school boy. Again, my point was that as of now, he's not even trying to maintain his school life anymore. Since the death of Shirley, he's focused more purely on his other obligations. The alternative persona he tried to maintain and the dynamic that existed there is gone. Rivalz said that Lelouch and Rolo were not attending school. He betrayed Xingke and Eunuchs by kidnapping Tienzi. He changed the plan when he saw that the newer is more profitable, but the fact remains: his plan was to destroy both the eunuchs and Xingke, both of whom helped him (tough one betrayed him later, but the other trusted him). So how does this not make conflict my statement that his battle isn't a selfish rebellion against leaders and governors that weren't necessarily bad people (Euphemia, Cornellia) anymore? The Eunuchs were clearly not good leaders. They didn't give a damn about the people of their country. Schneizel withdrew his support because he knew that they had lost the people of the country. Xing-ke was never in the position of a leader. The Eunuchs were the ones that controlled that country and Xing-ke while he was an enemy of Lelouch. Charles was a villain since the very beginning. He even laughed when his own daughter was killed. And don't tell me you tought that L.L. would beat Britannia with Japanesse forces? To beat a nation that controls half of the world, you need manpower. And his Japanesse manpower would fall after he liberated Japan and the Black Knights woudn't survive the next invasion which would probably be lead by Schneizel or Charles, both smarter then L.L. You need the support and manpower of the rest of the world if you want a small chance to beat Britannia. He realised that during R1 when he sent C.C. to negotiate with Chinesse Federation and when he broadcasted events in Japan in order to gain prestige which shall show the world that he is capable of fighting Britannia and that the rest of the World can put themeselves into his hands. After liberating China, he gained enough prestige to become the military leader of UN... and now he has all the manpower of those nations at his disposal. I never said anything about the accumulation of man power. I was talking about motives and intent as well as how the story has established sides in this current war. Before, the rebellion wasn't an issue that was black and white. It wasn't justice versus evil. It was a battle built on lies and deception. Lelouch was using the Japanese people and the movement of the rebellion to try and fulfill his own motives. When his goals were jeopardized, he jumped ship and turned his attention towards preserving his goals. My point was that at a very fundamental level, the war now is actually about peace, equality, and freeing the world from oppression as a first priority. It's actually a fight for friends, for lost comrades, for lost lovers, for the future, and for a collective goal rather individualistic goals. Now, this is a cliche war between two defined sides that clearly parallel a struggle between good and bad. Thats a machiavelistic way of thinking (goal justifies the means). A good hero would never order such a thing or he would at least feel saddened by that. Taking it over is also a nicer option. It also ain't just a research facility that created murderers. It is a nation in its own right (researchers don't need a city). Those people were born to be geass users or reaserchers and most of their children will not get a geass. And all those people had their lovers, friends and sisters like nunnaly. Dreams as well. But he did not take it over. He slaughtered it without any kind of mercy As you mentioned in a former topic, it was all for Shirley. He murdrered them all for Shirley. He murdered them all for vengeance. No, this is not a Machiavellian way of approaching the Cult. by Machiavellian standards, Lelouch would've taken control of the Cult and geassed them all into giving him the information he wanted. Then, he would've geassed them again and turned them against Brittannia. He would've had an army of geass soldiers sent against Brittannia. So what if geass effectively damned Euphy and Shirley? Brittannia is going down and that is what matters. Nothing about that entire situation was about deceiving and manipulating others for personal gain. Destroying the Cult wasn't about personal gain it was about avenging a friend and righting a wrong. Nothing about that was calculated. It was a rash and rushed decision. And I'll admit that I've said some things in the past that I wouldn't agree with now. Especially in episode response threads where I can get caught up in the heat of the moment and make rushed, harsh and somewhat rash judgements about the episode shortly after watching it (and before it really sets in). I said they were innocent people at the time but other people ended up arguiing amongst themselves regarding their innocence and it changed the way I viewed them. And an independent nation or not, they were being lead by the brother of the Emperor of Brittannia and had a number of their "products" used by Brittannian forces. So, are the scientists who develop weapons of mass destruction free from the guilt and responsibility that comes with the atrocities their children are used for? You said it yourself. They're all humans so why are they making weapons to kill and manipulate other humans? Why are they conducting research on other human beings? We've seen how geass can decimate the human soul. Why are you forcing children to inherit such a power? Why are you teaching them to treat the importance of life so lightly? Geass is clearly a weapon that should not exist in their world. It's clear that its lineage has seen nothing but tragedy and abuse. Wanting to rid the world of it is not a bad intent by any measure. The fact that Brittish civilians were either uninterested or found Zero's actions cool shows that most civilians didn't die. The fact that Britannia didn't use that to fight their "Allies of Justice" title shows thatmot civilians didn't die. Civilians were evacuated before the battle and most of those who were there during the landslide where those who are in military. And killing Euphemia was an unplaned accident. Shooting her was a sign of mercy as she would go insane for what she has done. And if you're going to play the card of "oh but they're humans, too!" then why the double standard here? Because it doesn't support your argument? For Lelouch, the battle at Narita was another step in establishing his army and his ability to pursue his goals. What happened at the Cult was a much less selfish concern that stemmed from the spark created by Shirley's death and the resulting realization about how wrong geass is and how the world would be better without it. This in itself is the difference between Lelouch in the first season and the second. And as for Euphy, I disagree that it was an act of mercy. Why you're trying to paint that act in a positive light is beyond me. He was pressed to make a decision regarding her life and it came down to turning the massacre into momentum for his rebellion and seeing her as a sacrifice. If his heart was genuinely with Euphemia's welfare, he would've just detained her and pursued a means of controlling or atleast suppressing his geass rather than use her death as a stepping stone to unite the different rebellions around japan. Had he actually approached the situation with a sense of empathy and thought about what Nunnally would want, no doubt he would've done something different. The truth is that his pursuit of his goals was an obsession that controlled him. He could've cleared her name by revealing the truth behind why she did what she did and pursuing a different objective like Cornellia has been doing. Doing so wasn't an option because if he had done so, his cover would've been totally and completely blown. He could've tried to convince her that it wasn't her fault (either forcefully through the use of a geass or just through reason). |
Jul 30, 2008 4:47 AM
#148
Ok, so that was incredible. That was something that was (for me) full of information. IMO current Nanali is not Lulu's sister. See... Anya, this is my type. Why? She's got a diary with pictures, and her memories was changed. Why? Think of that queen Marianne was geass user. She made pact with C.C. She's got some kind of power, that Charles was scared so much, that he killed her, or V.V. was the one that killed her (just like he tried to kill Lulu - reason why Charles took his immortality). 2nd version is most probably, but Charles want to protect his daughter and Lulu from others events like that. So, he took current Nanali, and made her a princess. His geass is good enough to do that. There is other option - Anya is reaincarnation of Marianne, but this is to freak to be right. If my supposition is right, then I am a genius and thou shall bow to me! |
Jul 30, 2008 12:32 PM
#149
Kallen should be a boxer...she'd win a world title in no time! |
Your search on "Oran Solus" returned the following quotes: "Oran Solus? I know him. What a wanker. He still owes me a tenner." Oscar Wilde "Oran, you're so intelligent and awesome <3" Bakayaro "Oran's sexy." LolitaDecay "Oran is a sophisticated penguin." Drybananna "Oran is a Hand-Eye you faggots." EddieSpaghetti "Oran for Prime Minister." the_prime_one "Oran is all that is stated in his sig and more." orbitzz |
Jul 30, 2008 2:32 PM
#150
Froscik said: Ok, so that was incredible. That was something that was (for me) full of information. IMO current Nanali is not Lulu's sister. See... Anya, this is my type. Why? She's got a diary with pictures, and her memories was changed. Why? Think of that queen Marianne was geass user. She made pact with C.C. She's got some kind of power, that Charles was scared so much, that he killed her, or V.V. was the one that killed her (just like he tried to kill Lulu - reason why Charles took his immortality). 2nd version is most probably, but Charles want to protect his daughter and Lulu from others events like that. So, he took current Nanali, and made her a princess. His geass is good enough to do that. There is other option - Anya is reaincarnation of Marianne, but this is to freak to be right. If my supposition is right, then I am a genius and thou shall bow to me! I think thats deep. But i just hope Anya is not the reincarnation of Marianne, that would be just too f*cked up. But like you, im sure that Anya has a deep connection with Marianne. She probably knows who killed Marianne maybe. And i like the hypothesis that Anya is Lulu lil sister. I can totally imagine it! |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )yuzuko - Apr 20, 2008 |
239 |
by Delritos
»»
Mar 29, 9:00 PM |
|
Poll: » Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 Episode 25 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ahenshihael - Sep 28, 2008 |
1901 |
by DarkVoyagerx
»»
Mar 25, 4:10 PM |
|
Poll: » Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 Episode 19 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )removed-user - Aug 17, 2008 |
435 |
by Dante9231
»»
Feb 21, 2:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )dtshyk - Jun 29, 2008 |
291 |
by Dante9231
»»
Feb 20, 2:21 AM |
|
Poll: » Code Geass - Hangyaku no Lelouch R2 Episode 23 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ahenshihael - Sep 14, 2008 |
305 |
by Beatnik
»»
Feb 17, 11:58 AM |