MyAnimeList.net

Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

KHRT: Best Flame Element: Semi Finals
MyAnimeList.net Forum »» Club Discussion »» Katekyo Hitman Reborn! FC »» KHRT: Best Flame Element: Semi Finals

Must be a Club Member to Reply
Pages (7) [1] 2 3 » ... Last »
View Poll Results: 2nd Finalist?
Rokudo Mukuro, 10th Generation Vongola Mist Guardian
 
161 39.66%
Hibari Kyoya, 10th Generation Vongola Cloud Guardian
 
245 60.34%
Voters: 406
Voting has been closed

#1
08-06-11, 11:19 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 7641


Rules & Reminders said:

1) The Poll will be available for two weeks
2) Vote for the character who you think represents the Flame Element better
3) If you want, share your opinion with us
Modified by Hisagi-Chan, 09-03-11, 4:47 AM
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
 
#2
08-06-11, 1:54 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 7641
-Vid said:
MUKURO SAMA!


DAT.

Pineapple fairy is gonna own you all.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
 
#3
08-06-11, 8:36 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 953
Ganbatte Mukuro!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ε(♥3♥)3
Show them how you can own Hibari with your pineapples hehehehe x3 =D
 
#4
08-07-11, 12:58 AM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 5931
Hibari <3<3<3 Forgive me, Mukuro-sama XP
He is my favourite character <3
But I guess it's ok even if Mukuro wins xD
 
#5
08-07-11, 5:42 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 285
Its so unfair... Why... Gosh, why this dumb Hibari. == The most boring character ever... Mukuro. T.T U will be still in my heart with Yama-chan & Flan.

MUKURO-SAMAAA!!!
Signature removed.
Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines: http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=516059
 
#6
08-07-11, 7:24 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 1502
Unfortunately I've never really liked the pineapple fairy. :U Sooo my vote goes to Hibari.
 
#7
08-07-11, 8:47 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 80
MUKURO-SAMA!!!!!!!!

My Vote is for Mukuro!!!!! i like him better than Hibari xD
Modified by Ammy90, 08-11-11, 10:08 PM
 
#8
08-07-11, 12:42 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 953
* Big jaw drop at how much of a gap in votes there is between Hibari and Mukuro*

Last time I was here to check it, Mukuro was winning over Hibari by a little bit.

*Sigh* I hope this will be a close match at least...just to make this match more exciting.
 
#9
08-07-11, 1:17 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 7641
Wow, I really didn't expect it to have such a gap.

~~

@ Hisagi:
Which detestable things Mukuro did exactly? :/

Killed people which experimented on him? Swore to destroy Mafia because Mafia were the ones which killed his friends & family? How is that detestable?
Squalo, Bel & Xanxus are more detestable. Even Reborn is more detestable than Mukuro, since he picks on weaker.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
 
08-07-11, 1:44 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 7641
So, he should've done nothing and leave Ken & Chikusa to die? Is that better than saving them?

So, Varia is Italian mafia and they are forgiven.

Mukuro is Italian Illusionist from Mafia. Is he forgiven now?
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
 
08-07-11, 2:30 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 54
OMG THE TWO BEST KHR GUYS (imo at least) *O*
This is very hard, but I must go with Mukuro, he'll always be my favorite <3 <3 <3
 
08-07-11, 8:19 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 10
Hibari Kyoya
for sure
 
08-07-11, 8:29 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 953
@ Hisagi-Chan: Gotta agree with SnG there.

And also...what about Hibari's "kamikorosu-ing"? I know he is the disciplinary committee member/leader but he doesnt need to resort to uhhh...violence all the time >_> Well I guess he has to against delinquents. But he constantly makes threats to "kamikorosu" to Tsuna and Tsuna hasn't done much wrong...right? :(

Hisagi-Chan said:
AlanViBritannia said:
Killed people which experimented on him? Swore to destroy Mafia because Mafia were the ones which killed his friends & family? How is that detestable?

so its an excuse to kill others? he's putting himself on the same level as them.


If this sort of thing happens to Hibari (if he has friends or family or anyone he cares about), I bet Hibari will probably the same thing as Mukuro would (just not with illusions though). Would you say that Hibari doesn't have any justification or excuse whatsoever to kill them?

Though I understand it's not good to kill other people, and Mukuro's decision to kill or get revenge will stoop him into their level. However, I don't think that really makes him a criminal. And I don't think he deserves to be detested for doing that kind of thing, but rather we should try to at least understand or acknowledge the pain and horror he went through (even if we detest him) ^^; I think in that situation, Mukuro could have probably either:
1. Get revenge and kill them. Who wouldn't want to kill anyone who took everything from them? And mess up his life, especially when it's not theirs to do so?
2. Simply give up and life will lose its meaning for him & the others. A very depressing and tragic life to live. If that could be truly deemed as "living" in the first place.


To summarize my long-ish explantion, I don't mind you hating on Mukuro because I don't have the power to change your mind about him. And he has done some detestable things to Tsuna and the others back then. However, I don't think his past life and horrible experiences (with those mafia people who experimented on him and others) should be used as a justification to say that he's a detestable person.

I think most people, if they were in Mukuro's shoes, would have done the same thing. And it's not like Mukuro and the other kids asked to be experimented on >_>

What would you have done if you were in Mukuro's shoes? Kill those mad mafia scientists and help you & your friends make a new life elsewhere? Or simply give up and allow those scientists to mess you up in your whole entire life?

Btw I apologize if I do sound a little harsh in some parts of my comment.
 
08-07-11, 11:10 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2010
Posts: 4991
I love both a lot, but Hibari more. ^-^
"What has two arms, two legs, and is alive? Not your favorite character thats for sure!"
 
08-08-11, 1:07 AM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 28
No, seriously I don't really like any of them THAT much, so I'll just pick one randomly... and my vote goes to the pieapple fairy. sorry hibari, but you don't have a hilarious nick-name.
 
08-08-11, 1:47 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 7641


You are contradictoring yourself.
The fact that Belphegor tried to kill [wasn's successful but he wanted to] his own brother out of jealousy, the fact that Xanxus tried to kill his adoptive father and the fact that Squalo did kill previous Sword emperor is just fine like that because "they are Italian mafia"?

If that is so, Rokudo should be even more forgiven, since he is the REAL italian mafia member, as he was born in Mafia family. Belphegor is a Prince of a distant country, he originaly had nothing to do with Mafia. Xanxus was adopted, he is just a cast-off.

So, Rokudo should have the protection of being Mafia member.

Rokudo Mukuro had the worst childhood there is in the series. And because of that childhood, he is what he is. You can't just say that the fact he and his friends [which were all very young at that point] being experimented upon is not a justification for Mukuro killing whole Estraneo family. Of course it is. What would have happened if he didn't do so? Scientists would flee from the family, lay down and in few months start operating again in black market, making even more innocent victims. Is that better than what Mukuro did?

Yes, I can't justify what Mukuro did to Lancia's family. I can somehow understand, since for his whole life Mukuro was troubled by mafia [Estraneo was trying to exploit him and other mafia families were trying to exploit Estraneo], but I can't forgive him since Lancia's family did nothing wrong. At least, I don't remember them doing anything wrong.

What he did to Tsuna? Oh, it's just violence, he didn't kill anyone, it's not big deal. I mean, if Hibari can use violence all the time and that only makes him cooler, than Rokudo shouldn't only be forgiven for his doings against Tsuna, but should also be praised.

And let us not forget that Mukuro saved many people. First being his family members Ken & Chikusa, and then M.M., Chrome, Bloody Twins. They would all be either dead or really fucked up if there wasn't Mukuro to guide them.

On note of which bad things Hibari did, we can say nothing, since Hibari is the shallowest character ever. I mean, I am not even sure if he has parents, or if he just grew from the tree, since he has no character development or character background whatsoever.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
 
08-08-11, 2:41 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 2817
Definitely Hibari^^

 
08-08-11, 8:20 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 953
AlanViBritannia said:


You are contradictoring yourself.
The fact that Belphegor tried to kill [wasn's successful but he wanted to] his own brother out of jealousy, the fact that Xanxus tried to kill his adoptive father and the fact that Squalo did kill previous Sword emperor is just fine like that because "they are Italian mafia"?

If that is so, Rokudo should be even more forgiven, since he is the REAL italian mafia member, as he was born in Mafia family. Belphegor is a Prince of a distant country, he originaly had nothing to do with Mafia. Xanxus was adopted, he is just a cast-off.

So, Rokudo should have the protection of being Mafia member.

Rokudo Mukuro had the worst childhood there is in the series. And because of that childhood, he is what he is. You can't just say that the fact he and his friends [which were all very young at that point] being experimented upon is not a justification for Mukuro killing whole Estraneo family. Of course it is. What would have happened if he didn't do so? Scientists would flee from the family, lay down and in few months start operating again in black market, making even more innocent victims. Is that better than what Mukuro did?

Yes, I can't justify what Mukuro did to Lancia's family. I can somehow understand, since for his whole life Mukuro was troubled by mafia [Estraneo was trying to exploit him and other mafia families were trying to exploit Estraneo], but I can't forgive him since Lancia's family did nothing wrong. At least, I don't remember them doing anything wrong.

What he did to Tsuna? Oh, it's just violence, he didn't kill anyone, it's not big deal. I mean, if Hibari can use violence all the time and that only makes him cooler, than Rokudo shouldn't only be forgiven for his doings against Tsuna, but should also be praised.

And let us not forget that Mukuro saved many people. First being his family members Ken & Chikusa, and then M.M., Chrome, Bloody Twins. They would all be either dead or really fucked up if there wasn't Mukuro to guide them.

On note of which bad things Hibari did, we can say nothing, since Hibari is the shallowest character ever. I mean, I am not even sure if he has parents, or if he just grew from the tree, since he has no character development or character background whatsoever.


SnG did a much better job at defending Mukuro than I did.

Like SnG, I don't believe Mukuro is justified in hurting and killing Lancia's family. But he has gone through a lot and I think his mentality or attitude (towards others) got pretty messed up (thanks to the horrible life he endured under those scientists). Well basically, he became more cynical and bitter as a result. And maybe mentally unstable as a child. If Mukuro didn't have to go through those conditions, I think he would have been a much better person.

And Hisagi-chan, I'm probably being a bit harsh on Hibari. And maybe he's not as violent or "horrible" as I perceived him to be. However, just because he doesn't kill doesn't necessarily make him any more likeable. Like SnG, Hibari really lacks character depth, so there's barely anything that makes me want to hate or love about him oO. The fact that Hibari barely has any complexity to him kind of annoys me a little. I used to like Hibari a lot, but without much needed character development, this could only last for a very short amt. of time.

Therefore, I don't think either character necessarily has something that makes them more likeable than the other. However, I think Mukuro's past, personality and his actions all together make him more memorable as a character for me personally.

I'm not saying that Mukuro has the best character development or whether he's actually a good guy right now or not. He's not there yet, but I think he's getting there. And I believe he has the potential (if he chooses to) to change into a better person. I don't think we should ignore his past crimes or anything, but I think we should also acknowledge all of the things that he has done to help Tsuna and the others.
Modified by sallym613, 08-08-11, 8:24 AM
 
08-08-11, 10:48 AM

Offline
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 671
My vote goes to Rokudo Mukuro, 10th Generation Vongola Mist Guardian

I see Mukuro more powerfull than Hibari,without doubt.
In a fight,Hibari would loose easely!

Mukuro will win...because he will use his illusions.

Kufufu...


Cine sunt eu?!...un geniu plictisit...intr-o lume putredă!
 
08-08-11, 1:15 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 6
LOL I knew it would be between hibari and mukuro~!!!xD Its a tough choice but i still pick hibari! cuz he hot! xD

 
Top
Pages (7) [1] 2 3 » ... Last »
Help     FAQ     About     Contact     Terms     Privacy     AdChoices