How did you feel after watching grave of the fireflies?
| I heard from many reviews that everyone would start bawling their eyes out after watching this film, so I put it on my Netflix queue. My sister watched it first and cried... alot... My mom (who never watch anime, ever, at all) watched it next and she cried a bit. I felt sad at the end when Setsuko died, but no tears. I got the "eye squinting" sad feeling. After telling that to my family members, they said that I was cold and emotionless >.> So, I just started this thread to see how you guys felt after watching the movie. I added a poll too. |
ss4gojetanksJul 1, 2012 10:10 PM
| I yawned... oh wait.. I was yawning throughout the whole movie so maybe I fell asleep at the end. |
| Voted for mildly depressed. The results of the MC's actions notwithstanding I think the consequences of war was portrayed well, I "enjoyed" that aspect, it was depressing, what I was looking for. Some shows made me bawl my eyes out, but this didn't even got me close to blurry vision. |
| We watched this in class and there were quite a few people crying afterwards. It was soooo sad!! TT^TT Such a good movie! |
 |
| I did not cry but I had a pretty awful feeling. I felt even worse after watching this than most anime I've cried during, which is odd. I think the reason for this being there was no cheap cry moment in this movie. It was all just presented, as if objectively.. It's hard to describe. |
| i see these movie only once in TV in middle-school with arabic dub thy show it in wensday "our weekend is Thursday and friday"" kids film of the week slot. that movie destory hat weeknd for all kids that week ((we have 2-3 TV chanels back thin so we all see it)) now Did i cry after you watched this movie? i stell, just go in these anime page nerly make me cry agein. it MUST SEE anime but ONCE |
 |
| If you really want to cry then watch the live action movie they made based on this. It portrays the powerful scenes better and really captures the family stress/desperation better than the animated original in my opinion. It might be difficult to track down, but I think it's worth it. It might just be that I watched the live action version first, but the animated one felt tame by comparison. |
 I am a banana. |
| I cried.. The most I'd ever in a movie frankly. It wasn't 'sad', just depressing. I was dead for about a week xD. Yes, you are very cold-hearted. |
Fuko-Brian said: It was Ok. But I Didnt Cry :P Same here, I thought it would leave an lasting sensation like Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 and Ima, Soko ni Iru Boku, but it didn´t. At much, I was slightly shocked and upset at certain scenes, but that´s all...¯\_(¯ _¯ )_/¯ |
 |
| i never shed a tear , but it was a sad anime |
 |
| The hardest war I've fought is the one against those tears while watching this anime...because my brother was in the room, I didn't want to cry with him around. I cried afterwards. Took me some time to recover from it. |
eyerokFeb 3, 2012 2:48 PM
| "...our faces marked by toil, by deceptions, by success, by love; our weary eyes looking still, looking always, looking anxiously for something out of life, that while it is expected is already gone – has passed unseen, in a sigh, in a flash – together with the youth, with the strength, with the romance of illusions.” - Joseph Conrad ('Youth') |
| When I watched this movie, I felt so bad for those kids. They lost their mother in a tragic way, had to live with a heartless aunt (I believe it was their aunt, if I remember correctly), then lived in a cave by themselves. But when it came to Setsuko's death, I wasn't crying my eyes out, but I had a tight feeling in my chest (mostly because I was trying to hold back my tears) and I shed some tears. So I think it was a really good movie. |
| I ddin't. Wasn't even sad, because all the misery was caused by his stupid pride. All I felt was anger. |
 |
| If you didn't, you're going to Hell. |
| Video rants & stuff: Top 12 Heart-Wrenching Scenes in Anime | DraconisMarch Video Club |
| I was unaffected, I was watching around The class seeing people shedding numerous years and wondering if I was supposed to cry too. We were doing depressing movies in class and I saw the documentary of the Hiroshima bombing which was the only thing that made me cry. Barefoot gen and grave of the fireflies weren't really sad to me. |
  Thanks to Iri for the awesome Signature!! ^^ |
| Mildly depressed. I never cried while watching anything in my entire life. |
 |
| honestly, Setsuko annoyed me, i actually just wanted to hit her during the entire movie. So her dying didn't effect me at all. And the other aspects of the story didn't come out well, it just seemed repetitious and predictable |
Kyuubipenguin said: honestly, Setsuko annoyed me, i actually just wanted to hit her during the entire movie. So her dying didn't effect me at all ouch... |
 |
| I manage to control my mainly tears. :) |
 |
| I cried a little on the inside, but didn't cry on the outside because I was watching this in midnight and everyone is asleep. |
 |
| Like a little bitch. I watched it a while ago, but I didn't know what I was getting into. I had done no previous research on the movie, and was handed the DVD because someone said, "if you liked Spirited Away, you'll probably like this." So... I watched it with no idea it was going to be depressing as fuck. When Seita said, "[Can't remember date]. That was the day I died." (Not a spoiler, first line in the movie) I was like, "o.o THE FUCK AM I IN FOR?" |
 "It's just...a bad dream! Wake up, wake up...!" |
| I have to admit, it was rather depressing. I did cry some at the credits, I think that was mainly because I was reflecting back on how these kind of situations actually happen during wars- and what I just watched was, what I believe to be a very good interpretation of how wars can tear apart the fabric of families. On that basis alone, it is enough to make somebody feel a little helpless inside. It makes you wonder about all of those people during the first and second world wars that had to experience things like this, it is very touching, to say the least, even if you do leave the two kids out of it. |
| no )) maybe - Mildly depressed )) |
 |
OminousFlare said: Well, I didn't exactly 'cry,' but there was definitely a sense of utter depression. I couldn't call it out as 'morbid' for presenting such a tragic ending, as it was very realistically done, and the actions of Seita were not ridiculous or nonsensical enough to be exaggerating, which is often what 'morbid' and 'emo' are. Depressing is realistic. Totally agree. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the General Forum Guidelines. |
| It felt heavy. |
 |
| While I didn't cry on the outside, I felt definatly drained emotionally. An incredible film though, very realistic, and morbid. One of the best war films I've ever seen, and is basically required viewing for any fan of animation. |
| I hate to mourn, and less watching animes ... throughout the film I had a knot in my stomach and it was becoming larger TT ... I was almost praying that Setsuko not die but was so ... and the mother dies in a horrible and father, and I that I have a little sister I felt very identified seeing the movie and at the end when he dies, burning and pulling when the ****** guard the box with the bones ... I started out with tears, and that I am not to mourn. But somewhat restrained BD (? ( Excellent movie, but I hope it was exaggerated and that these situations never really pass ... Thank for the post!! =) |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
DmonHiro said: I ddin't. Wasn't even sad, because all the misery was caused by his stupid pride. All I felt was anger. Exactly. It was all his fault. He could have at least swallowed his pride when she was on the verge of dying. But noooo, he can feed her perfectly with nothing :D Nevertheless, it was depressing. Even though she died because of her idiot brother, it's sad because he ruined his and her life. He could have lived like a wealthy man if he stayed with his Aunt (note: wealthy as in, have food). |
 "Your sight, my delight. Will you marry me?" |
| I did...quite a lot. ;( |
| I went into the movie wanting to but even though I tried to build up how bad everything was I couldn't. Kind of disappointed. |
 |
ZetaZaku said: DmonHiro said: I ddin't. Wasn't even sad, because all the misery was caused by his stupid pride. All I felt was anger. Exactly. It was all his fault. He could have at least swallowed his pride when she was on the verge of dying. But noooo, he can feed her perfectly with nothing :D Nevertheless, it was depressing. Even though she died because of her idiot brother, it's sad because he ruined his and her life. He could have lived like a wealthy man if he stayed with his Aunt (note: wealthy as in, have food). I was wondering why nobody thinks like this. Okay, it's sad indeed. I feel sorry for Setsuko, but not really much on Seita. I just don't understand that if he really cares about his little sister, why not just swallow his pride? ALSO, if he HAS PRIDE, why does he still going around stealing things? I mean, when there's an air raid, he went around houses knowing it's deserted to steal things, and there's a part showing he's very very happy about being able to steal things DURING the air raid itself. It looks like he's happy to steal it successfully, which doesn't look like he have any pride in him. It's very low of him in my aspect(I know when it comes to life and death, doing this may be because there's no other waya, BUT there IS a better option... which is apologise). All in all, the reason why this movie doesn't made me feel very depress was because it's very conflicting for me. Isn't it worst to be doing something against your pride everyday, with a chance of being caught and punished, than just go against your pride once and secure his little sister's life/stomach? Also stealing isn't against his pride but apologising does? I believe if one love or care about another person a lot, wouldn't he do anything to help that person? But.. okay I shall stop here, or else I'm getting more and more confuse and blur. |
 |
| No. The ending left me more confused, if anything. I suppose if had been on the same level as Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 I think I would have bawwed my eyes out... |
| We're the same. Nuisances with nowhere to go. |
xahjun said: ZetaZaku said: DmonHiro said: I ddin't. Wasn't even sad, because all the misery was caused by his stupid pride. All I felt was anger. Exactly. It was all his fault. He could have at least swallowed his pride when she was on the verge of dying. But noooo, he can feed her perfectly with nothing :D Nevertheless, it was depressing. Even though she died because of her idiot brother, it's sad because he ruined his and her life. He could have lived like a wealthy man if he stayed with his Aunt (note: wealthy as in, have food). I was wondering why nobody thinks like this. Okay, it's sad indeed. I feel sorry for Setsuko, but not really much on Seita. I just don't understand that if he really cares about his little sister, why not just swallow his pride? ALSO, if he HAS PRIDE, why does he still going around stealing things? I mean, when there's an air raid, he went around houses knowing it's deserted to steal things, and there's a part showing he's very very happy about being able to steal things DURING the air raid itself. It looks like he's happy to steal it successfully, which doesn't look like he have any pride in him. It's very low of him in my aspect(I know when it comes to life and death, doing this may be because there's no other waya, BUT there IS a better option... which is apologise). All in all, the reason why this movie doesn't made me feel very depress was because it's very conflicting for me. Isn't it worst to be doing something against your pride everyday, with a chance of being caught and punished, than just go against your pride once and secure his little sister's life/stomach? Also stealing isn't against his pride but apologising does? I believe if one love or care about another person a lot, wouldn't he do anything to help that person? But.. okay I shall stop here, or else I'm getting more and more confuse and blur. lol, none of what you guys said makes any sense whatsoever. What he did make perfect sense because he was just a boy, and he did not understand the effects of his decisions clearly being a minor child, and going through a traumatic experience like watching his own mother die after being burnt horribly, and not knowing where his own father was at that time made things harder. And he certainly did not expect his sister to die like that so easily. His actions make sense for a boy of his age who has had to depend on his parents for everything up until that time. For the record, this anime is based on an actual semi-autobiographical account which the writer wrote as an apology to his own sister who died in the War. Technominator's review for this was the best, and it clearly explained this aspect, because this was already criticized by some people in the forum, and especially in the review by YoungVagabond. She summed up the whole thing perfectly, but unfortunately she deleted all her reviews in what some people call 'a fit of emoness'. |
eyerokNov 18, 2012 1:40 PM
| "...our faces marked by toil, by deceptions, by success, by love; our weary eyes looking still, looking always, looking anxiously for something out of life, that while it is expected is already gone – has passed unseen, in a sigh, in a flash – together with the youth, with the strength, with the romance of illusions.” - Joseph Conrad ('Youth') |
| Depressed. I felt really bad though. |
| I saw it yesterday with my boyfriend... I cried and cried like for hours and he was very very sad. This movie is based in real life (it is based in a novel, and the writer based the story in his life during the war) so it is so realistic it makes me depressed |
| I shed a tear or two, it was pretty sad. |
| can't stop the tears from falling... =_=!! |
     |
| Unaffected. I thought there would be a more serious conflict, and also thought the end would tie in with how it started. I guess I was expecting more. Well, I don't cry from shows or stuff anyway, although I may often get depressed after a good series or movie (such as 5 cm per second). |
 |
| A lot man, a lot. That second half almost killed. |
 |
| didn't cry outside but inside i did...especially at the end. Makes me totally feel sympathy for anyone who was left famished and left with nothing in the war. |
| Well, i'm about to find out |
| Part that hit me the hardest was when Seita looked at the picture of his dad later in the movie and started crying. I'd almost forgotten that he was a kid himself because of all of how mature he'd been acting. The last 20 minutes or so were especially devastating. |
| Yes i shed tears durring some of the scenes in the movie. The real cry came durring the ending credits for me. I was crying durring the ending credits because i was thinking about myself and about the reality of our species. I think i have gone through hard times. I think i have suffered. I think i know what being alone is like. Well i was wrong. I dont know what pain is. It isnt just durring war times that things like these happen. Literaly while i type this people are going through this exact thing, many MANY people. Is it necessary? The anser is simply no, and thats why i was crying. |
 |
| I felt nothing. That was odd. |
| It was somewhat depressing but I got over it after like 5 mins |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Hotaru No Haka Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )yakyuu-addict - Nov 28, 2008 |
313 |
by WeebAngo
»»
Mar 8, 5:18 AM |
|
» Useful for learning the Kansai dialect (J-subs)RudeRedis - Jul 8, 2023 |
18 |
by theSporz
»»
Jan 17, 5:58 AM |
|
» Grave of the fireflies is not that much sadIshow_suii - Nov 16, 2023 |
24 |
by ToufiqHassan
»»
Nov 17, 2023 4:26 AM |
|
» I don't think I'll ever re-watch this movie. ( 1 2 )Abyque - Sep 13, 2022 |
51 |
by Lungitar90
»»
Sep 11, 2023 4:09 AM |
|
Poll: » SeitaNeo2425 - Jan 1, 2023 |
19 |
by Saytr
»»
Jan 13, 2023 3:58 AM |