Anime Information

Forums

I know its way bit too early but i just wanted to know and would like to see more opinions as we get further into the series. Who do you like more and who do you think would be the smartest? Alice from Kamisama or Victorique from Gosick?

Vic has a lot of knowledge already in her head and can peice together anything as long as she collects evidence
Alice has a lot of knowledge on current subjects and can peice together anything as long as she can research

Well shit

aha yeah you summed that up pretty well xD.

Victorique is a fucking idiot.

she just read lot of shit, but she is a stupid tsundere with ilogical reactions.



alice seems a bit better , but that last scene... was also stupid.

That's because Kujo is her only friend and the only person she talks to without being discriminated and hated.

The only other people she's spoken with were Grevil who treated her like a monster, about one sentence from her mother, and MAYBE her father, who would've treated her like shit too.

She's pretty much had no human contact, it's not farfetched to assume she doesn't have people skills.

That dont justify the fact that she blames other people for things that are her fault.

The only thing that was different about them is that Alice has freedom and Victorique has none... Other than that, they are both very similar to me just different era and place.

Victorique only need Kujo tell what happen, instantly case solve...

Alice is looks cuter and she is taller.

That's enough reason for me to choose Alice.

Both. At the same time.

Victorque has that oldschool charm while Alice is just like every other japense anime girl.

Victorique is more smarter.Alice's deduction is good but not really brilliant...I will say she is good as an information broker only.

Alice is generic looking, I can get the same thing from a good harem anime, Alice also is more like a really good Operator and information genius, Victorique is classy, she has very high intelligence and victorian dress is a plus even though she can get mean and unladylike at times but being locked in a tower most of your life will do that to anyone.

Victorique

I'd rather have both.

Also, boo at pitting these two lovely girls against each other.

Alice makes real deductions based on the information given (deductions that the reader/watcher can also make if they pay attention). Victorique pulls information out of thin air to solve her mysteries.

I think Alice is more resourceful.

And the cases in Gosick were never THAT complex, so I can't really say if Victorique is more intelligent.



Well yeah, Victorique is European and Alice is Japanese.



Really?

Not him but yes, as you said Alice is more resourceful but Victorique also had her fair share of complex cases in the later episodes of Gosick. Not all of them are easy and even though it's easy to guess the culprit, how he/she did it is the hardest part to solve and that's Victorique's Wellspring of Wisdom put her in an advantage.

Couple that with her life just reading books for most of her life because of her confinement. Plus, Victorique was used by her father on how to make decision to win a war. This is not even a debate really.

Victorique has a gooder fashion sense.
Smarter? I don't care.

Alice has more subordinate that give her the info and skill that required in each case
teamwork is better choice

But teamwork is...