MyAnimeList.net

Anime Information
Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

Is Gurren Lagann Overrated (Revival?)
MyAnimeList.net Forum »» Anime Discussion »» Series Discussion »» Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann »» Is Gurren Lagann Overrated (Revival?)

Pages (3) [1] 2 3 »
View Poll Results: Is Gurren Lagann overrated?
Yes
 
63 41.45%
No
 
89 58.55%
Voters: 152

#1
12-13-10, 12:37 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 5
Okay, so I was reading this forum from, what? 2008? And I just had to leave some sort of response. My word had to get out. So here is this noobish user speaking out. So here it is... What I, personally have to say.

Gurren Lagann...

In my opinion...

Is underrated.

There, I said it. No, I'm not gonna be some retard and not say anything after that. I'm gonna explain why.
When I walk around, when I talk, when I reference, when I SING! Society is like "What are you talking about, what the fush was that?" What happens when I talk about anime? Naruto. Naruto and Bleach. It seems that I'm pulling out all these facts from my experience, I sure am! I guess I'm using the info from the eyes of a teenager (Am I gonna get haters now?). To me, this generation seems to be bloodthirsty for... whatever everyone else likes. But that doesn't stop everyone else from seeking out those anime that will be perfect for them. Everyone has their own preference. And it seemed that the preference for that one year, was Gurren Lagann. Now this is where the term overrated comes in. This is where everyone never thinks appropriately. Their anger, their hatred for Gurren Lagann... Their lust, their love for Gurren Lagann... It possesses them. The thing they overlook? What exactly makes something overrated? To me... something that is overrated, is something that a mass amount of people like, when the actual something is not as good as people say. Overrated is something that people will talk about positively, in large amounts. But this is where opinions come into place, everyone perceives things differently. Now if you were to actually look at polls and such, the only way to get the real results, would be to actually see the peoples' thoughts on it. There could be people mindlessly degrading or supporting one of the choices. So based on Gurren Lagann, it got good ratings. And, a large majority of people love it. But through the eyes of the people that did not, they perceive it as overrated. You can't fill everyone's tastes, but you can fill a large majority of it. Now why do I see it as underrated? Well, through my eyes, all those Otaku or people in anime chat rooms, don't even know what it is. Now when that original post came up, how many people actually came to give a response? How many came to actually take part in the discussion? Around 1,000 people voted, and a number of people discussed. When I think about it, 1,000 doesn't seem like a lot, considering the amount of people who COULD be Otaku in the world. Now think about, Naruto. Maybe even Bleach. How many would people would be talking about those? I keep that in my mind. Gurren Lagann maybe did have a huge hype, but it sure as hell (To me) was overrated. People always seem to try to give BS by saying, "Oh it's so childish" "It's way too over the top". But the thing is, that was the thrill of the anime. That was what made people like it. A huge amount of the population was into that stuff. They loved how over the top it was. The show was a homage, and they felt that old familiar feeling. They loved seeing all those pointless fights, all that yelling, all attack names. It was nostalgic. It was like being a child. And the young viewers? It was the heroic nature. Being able to do anything, no matter what cost. It was inspiring. It was submerging. It made you want to make a difference in life. And like all the fanboys would say, "It was manly beyond all belief." The GAR, the fanservice, the giant robots. Your typical anime, but it was done in such an extraordinary way. They had all the things that made something clichéd, but did it in such a fascinating and heartwarming way. Those fans, were the hardcore Otaku. They were the ones that were retro. All these things, just made their mind explode. It was very pleasing to them, the show, to them, was just amazing. Like I said, just seeing someone go so far to do the impossible, made you really feel for them. Seeing the development of the characters, all their wants and needs, all their dreams. Seeing it being fulfilled was heartwarming. Seeing all those fights, reminiscent of old school mecha, was nostalgic. Seeing a story, that was presented so well, was like a fresh breath of air. It was entertaining. It was an adventure. And that's why I think it's not overrated. I love this anime to death. And it would have not been right of me, to not defend it's title. So tell me, is it overrated, to you, or not?

STOP FANTASIZING
 
#2
12-13-10, 6:24 AM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 2758
You must just hang around the wrong kind of anime fan. Gurren Lagann was a great anime... that has finished airing. Naruto, Bleach and One Piece are still currently airing, hence why they are the topic of conversation amongst a good portion of fans.

Just because people don't talk about it often, that doesn't mean that they neglect it in favor of the aforementioned series.
 
#3
12-13-10, 6:44 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 973
You should add tl;dr you'd get a lot more responses/discussion that way...
 
#4
12-13-10, 6:54 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 2668
Hmm, I don't know if I agree with the "otaku (I hate it when people use this term -_-) don't really know about it" think. I mean, I've gone to Otafest for 2 years now. If you plop down a picture of Yoko, I'm sure most people would know exactly who she was and what series she was from. The other portion would ask. So I don't think it is as underrated as you make it seem, but it is by no means truly overrated either.

I have a much harder time finding fans of Clannad, Wolf's Rain and Durarara!! then I do Gurren Lagann and supposedly, those series are "extremely overrated" as well. Just the way this site is, basing "overrated" on the rating themselves.


 
#5
12-13-10, 9:56 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 5
IDex said:
You should add tl;dr you'd get a lot more responses/discussion that way...
What's that? I'm a noob here anyways.
Kipcha said:
Hmm, I don't know if I agree with the "otaku (I hate it when people use this term -_-) don't really know about it" think. I mean, I've gone to Otafest for 2 years now. If you plop down a picture of Yoko, I'm sure most people would know exactly who she was and what series she was from. The other portion would ask. So I don't think it is as underrated as you make it seem, but it is by no means truly overrated either.

I have a much harder time finding fans of Clannad, Wolf's Rain and Durarara!! then I do Gurren Lagann and supposedly, those series are "extremely overrated" as well. Just the way this site is, basing "overrated" on the rating themselves.
Clannad has scarred me emotionally...(Too damn depressing...) I love it anyways. And about the word "Otaku"... I don't know, I use it in the way western people use it, although in Japan it pretty much means, "Shut in". Also, I guess it IS just the people I hang out with, but at those kind of places, a large amount of people go, right, so of course you're bound to find a good group of people who know about it. Too tired to even type right now...

STOP FANTASIZING
 
#6
12-13-10, 10:01 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 5
DirtyRoxanne said:
You must just hang around the wrong kind of anime fan. Gurren Lagann was a great anime... that has finished airing. Naruto, Bleach and One Piece are still currently airing, hence why they are the topic of conversation amongst a good portion of fans.

Just because people don't talk about it often, that doesn't mean that they neglect it in favor of the aforementioned series.
I'm sorry I was actually referring to you when talking about the people I hang out with... Anyways, the fact that they hold on to it so preciously after it still goes on bothers me, it was great at first but then it just got WAY too long, I understand that they want to finish it, but it seems that they shun any other anime and such because they have been blinded by it. I didn't literally really mean it when I said, that they were blinded by Naruto, but in some way, I am.

STOP FANTASIZING
 
#7
12-16-10, 4:38 PM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 51
Evangelion is better.
 
#8
01-02-11, 8:54 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 5
Sodomyy said:
Evangelion is better.

I'm Replying so late... That's opinionated.

STOP FANTASIZING
 
#9
01-02-11, 11:35 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 66
I think it was pretty cool, but nog OMGFTHATSOFRIGGINAMAZING-like.

I gave it an 8, because;



It was sometimes just a litte too badass for me. e____e
I don't mind that at all in anime, but sometimes it was just a little over the top and
you could just predict what would happen. ;o

The ecchi overload sometimes. I love Yoko, and I can understand guys think she's hot, but there's no need to make her undress every second. :l
That was one of the minor points though. xD

What I did find awesome was the Spiral arc and stuff. I've never seen an anime so focused on drills. x'DDDD

I guess that's it, mostly? XD
Modified by EllaMila1, 01-02-11, 1:12 PM
 
01-02-11, 11:45 AM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 145
DirtyRoxanne said:
You must just hang around the wrong kind of anime fan. Gurren Lagann was a great anime... that has finished airing. Naruto, Bleach and One Piece are still currently airing, hence why they are the topic of conversation amongst a good portion of fans.

Just because people don't talk about it often, that doesn't mean that they neglect it in favor of the aforementioned series.

Yes.
This is what hurts me.
Why can't people talk about Clannad or Gurren Lagann or Black Lagoon or Eureka Seven or Yu Yu Hakusho or Darker than BLACK or Highschool of the Dead... And many more. Makes me feel alone.
:(
 
01-02-11, 11:52 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 281
clannadrezz said:
DirtyRoxanne said:
You must just hang around the wrong kind of anime fan. Gurren Lagann was a great anime... that has finished airing. Naruto, Bleach and One Piece are still currently airing, hence why they are the topic of conversation amongst a good portion of fans.

Just because people don't talk about it often, that doesn't mean that they neglect it in favor of the aforementioned series.

Yes.
This is what hurts me.
Why can't people talk about Clannad or Gurren Lagann or Black Lagoon or Eureka Seven or Yu Yu Hakusho or Darker than BLACK or Highschool of the Dead... And many more. Makes me feel alone.
:(


Agreed I'm sick of hearing about naruto or bleach or even dbz sometimes
 
01-28-11, 10:31 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 7279
I am on episode four and this is about as good as the first four episodes of the original Pokemon
Plato is my friend — Aristotle is my friend — but my greatest friend is truth
 
01-28-11, 10:48 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2010
Posts: 625
When things become too popular Rich douchebag companies start to use the name in order to make some extra cash, because once it gets a big enough following, everyone will buy whatever they make... sadly Death Note has fallen into this realm. I'm not sure about TTGL but I'm quite happy with its current status.
 
01-29-11, 10:02 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 297
For me, Gurren Lagann is just an alternative Gunbuster (Which I like more).

Gurren Lagann is good? Yes. Original? No.
 
06-04-12, 10:13 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 63
MentalTeen said:
IDex said:
You should add tl;dr you'd get a lot more responses/discussion that way...
What's that? I'm a noob here anyways.
Kipcha said:
Hmm, I don't know if I agree with the "otaku (I hate it when people use this term -_-) don't really know about it" think. I mean, I've gone to Otafest for 2 years now. If you plop down a picture of Yoko, I'm sure most people would know exactly who she was and what series she was from. The other portion would ask. So I don't think it is as underrated as you make it seem, but it is by no means truly overrated either.

I have a much harder time finding fans of Clannad, Wolf's Rain and Durarara!! then I do Gurren Lagann and supposedly, those series are "extremely overrated" as well. Just the way this site is, basing "overrated" on the rating themselves.
Clannad has scarred me emotionally...(Too damn depressing...) I love it anyways. And about the word "Otaku"... I don't know, I use it in the way western people use it, although in Japan it pretty much means, "Shut in". Also, I guess it IS just the people I hang out with, but at those kind of places, a large amount of people go, right, so of course you're bound to find a good group of people who know about it. Too tired to even type right now...


Have you watched Angel Beats? Now that is definitely going to scar your emotional life.
 
06-04-12, 10:26 PM

Offline
Joined: Feb 2012
Posts: 562
Does it actually get better after episode 10? That's around the time I dropped it. Episode 8 was the only episode I enjoyed really...
 
06-09-12, 12:02 PM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 51
GodotCoffee said:
Does it actually get better after episode 10? That's around the time I dropped it. Episode 8 was the only episode I enjoyed really...
Well, it should have ended at episode 15 in my opinion it was okay that far.

After episode 15 (episode 16 was a recap) it was just too much exaggeration bullshit that I couldn't enjoy it at all.
 
06-16-12, 10:57 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 15
I don't think it's overated, although i do think some people get a bit to "vocal" about it sometimes. One of my all time favorite anime though.
 
06-16-12, 11:07 PM
Forum Moderator
Offline
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 6271
Personally I couldn't get into it. It is was boring and it seemed kind of childish. Do I think it is overrated perhaps however I am certain it is not underrated. Perhaps it is rated just right...
 
06-17-12, 11:39 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 118
probably the most inspiring anime in this fucking vast universe. the score speaks for itself.

had a somewhat meh start but damn was it worth watching it.

i mean... TESTOSTERONEEEEEEEEEEE
 
Top
Pages (3) [1] 2 3 »
Help     FAQ     About     Contact     Terms     Privacy     AdChoices