MyAnimeList.net

Manga Information
Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

Sundome Chapter 76 Discussion

Pages (4) -0.2 0.8 [1.8] 2.8 3.8 » ... Last »
Poll: Sundome Chapter 76 Discussion


05-27-11, 3:05 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1482
NLeee said:
So she did die right?

isnt it obvious?
She was bleeding heavily and was hospitalized. she did die.
 
05-27-11, 4:19 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 11
isnt wasnt that obvious

i mean i was pretty sure it happen but wasnt sure
 
05-27-11, 7:50 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1482
NLeee said:
isnt wasnt that obvious

i mean i was pretty sure it happen but wasnt sure

There were alot of Tells that basically gave it away that she had a terminal condition and was constantly bleeding and was in pain. But i know what you mean, it was hard to tell if she was dead in the last chapter.
 
06-17-11, 3:57 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 20
I find it ironic that he got a girl that looks almost exactly like Sahana, with the only different being her mole and her tits.

Someone suggested that he wasn't having intercourse with her, but was just giving him a handjob in the flashback. If you look at the end of the scene, both of her hands are pinned back, so that'd be impossible. It was either a form of intercrural, or actual sex.

Of course if she actually had AIDS then he probably didn't have sex with her, but if she didn't then it's all up to interpretation. Personally, it looked like he had sex with her dead body after they both knew she wouldn't wake up. This could also explain his impotence with his new partner. After finally having a taste, but only one, of actual sex with Sahana, nothing could compare or do it for him.

Either way, it's a bittersweet story.
 
06-21-11, 4:29 PM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 1
Wow I can see I'm amonst fellow fans here by the reaction you all have! This manga and Kurumi Shahana will always have a place in my heart. The sad end we all kind new was coming is very stark in this book anyone notice the plain black chapter dividers and when Hideo meets the Doctor in his car he says that she send her limited time with him to bring or disappoint bring him. I think when she said" when I wake up lets have sex" see didn't wake hence the end chapter Sundome. It makes my sad to think about it it must have been a bloody good story if it can make you feel like that mustn't it.

One thing I didn't understand when they were on the train going Kurumi looking out of the window for three panels but who is the woman saying she's back and why(how) can she smell Kurumi? What does it mean, is a reference to Kumuri been an alien perhaps after all that? It would be funny to think that with members of the Roman standing only feet away from her doing the human radar
 
06-21-11, 7:39 PM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 570
slipinside said:
One thing I didn't understand when they were on the train going Kurumi looking out of the window for three panels but who is the woman saying she's back and why(how) can she smell Kurumi? What does it mean, is a reference to Kumuri been an alien perhaps after all that? It would be funny to think that with members of the Roman standing only feet away from her doing the human radar
The seemingly random people in that train scene supposedly denizens of the orphan home where Sahana came from. Or something of that sort. The mangaka didn't reveal much about her past after all, but it's probably better that way. It leaves a nicer memory of Sahana and ground for speculation.
 
06-24-11, 4:52 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 38
I hate this manga... really. How shoud I fall asleep now (almost 2 a.m.). It was the saddest "happy" ending I've ever read and author didn't explain almost nothing about her past and illnes. Really! How could he!? But I agree with that...
mwp said:
It leaves a nicer memory of Sahana and ground for speculation.

It's true, it's sad but it was obviously his purpose..

Isn't it scary when you know what will happen and step by step, really slowly, you are near to "it" and when "it" happen you realize it after re-read cause you hope that she somehow survived. You're just hoping that you'll find something...

Well that's all. It was really awesome but even though i hate it. You probably know why :)
 
06-24-11, 7:29 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 6
subby187 said:
outlawauron said:
THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER.
----------------------------------------
*Obvious huge spoilers*



I got the last volume in the mail today and just finished it. I wonder what did everyone else think of the ending? I was afraid of a tragic ending as it seemed that's what they were leading into, but I enjoyed the happy ending (although it took a re-read to realize the time skip). Yay for endings that actually end things!


ive seen the raw copies of it and abit confused about everything, could you send me a message explaining the last chapter please? :D


From what I read, he took her to the seaside after escaping from the hospital with her and she died. Then they show later on where he is working as a resident in a hospital with the older guy/doctor from before. We see that he's married and apparently his wife has the same interests as Kurumi. It appears that her "ghost/spirit" is with him also.


If you read the last page, last row you will see:
Aiba: Hey
Kurumi (Ghost form - invisible): Yeah?
Aiba: On second thought
Aiba: About that golden shower...
 
07-08-11, 4:32 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 386
FUCKING BITTER SWEET ENDINGS T_T PISS ME OFF.. Why Kurumi whyyy god damnit. I fucking hate/love shit like this. Fucking mangaka had to kill her T_T....The mangaka just HAD to end it like that... GOD DAMN. I was very surprised to see Hideo without that much emotion, like breaking down and just bawling his eyes out. I mean, this was the guy who cried at the slightest hint of Kurumi leaving him, and I didn't see that many emotions out of him
 
07-10-11, 11:40 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2011
Posts: 46
d4n13lr0x He changed what were you expecting, I agree with the decision of the mangaka but speculations will always be speculations, and for the sake of all the readers he need to reveal what really happened.
 
07-10-11, 6:09 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 4108
I just feel like crying right now. Such a bittersweet ending... Throughout the entire manga it was hinted at again and again that she had some terminal disease that would end up killing her, which only made me hope for a happy conclusion more. But this manga had to have a tragic ending, there was simply no other ending for it, in my opinion.

This is how I perceived the part at the shore. When they were sitting together in the boat and he asked her if she was sleepy and then said he could masturbate, she whispered in his ear "When I wake up, let's have sex.", and then she fell asleep and woke up again (or did she pass away then, I'm not sure). He definitely had sex with her because the huge "ギ" hiragana are sounds of the boat creaking, implying movement. She died either before or during the act since her body was positioned in the same way the whole time, even as he lay next to her and grabbed her hand, her fingers didn't close around his.

We never got to know much at all about Kurumi, but she did mention once that she didn't have any parents, even if she later told Aiba it was a joke. I guess that part on the train and the orphanage confirmed it. Damn, that only makes me more depressed - no parents and an incurable disease... However, in the end she was happy. Meeting and spending her limited time with Aiba.

The one thing I liked the most about this manga was probably the main character's growth as a person. Truly great.
Modified by stAtic91, 07-10-11, 6:15 PM
 
07-10-11, 6:11 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 5985
Yeah, Kurumi herself knew she didn't have much time left in this world. So, she decided she'd raise somebody else up to live their life for her.
 
07-18-11, 10:07 AM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2010
Posts: 139
Bittersweet...


 
08-01-11, 10:49 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 5
outlawauron said:
The exact fate of Kurumi and who exactly Hideo ended up with isn't completely known. I read it the first time as him marrying Kurumi later. I suppose she may died which makes this have a super sad ending. I dunno, I may choose to live in ignorance on this one.


misaseh098 said:
dammit.... and i was sugar coating my mind, telling that the woman she's with is kurumi... this is why i sometimes hate forums... waaaaaaaaaaah~


Well, I tend to be against everyone so I agree with you both, the latter woman with aiba on the last pages REALLY LOOKS LIKE Sahana, but if you notice, there's nothing mentioning her dying or her being alive. I believe the ending was designed perfetly to one's imagination, she does move her fingers during all those 'moans' and 'moviment indicators', and why would Aiba be looking up and smiling if she would had died, he's a frigging cry-baby afterall; but at the same time, she was bloody sick, a cold (Aiba said so) night wouldn't be much revigorating, but miracles can happen as much as tragedies.. Also, that teasing look/sentence of the girl with adult Aiba kinda looked like Sahana, but again, Sahana never complained about 'piss drinking' and the woman did...
One said that when the old man told the hospital director that he would be in troulbe since she would die, why is that so? Do you think that if someone sneaked on your hospital and "kidnapped" a patient people would be happy with you?
 
08-01-11, 11:34 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2010
Posts: 5985
slycopperr said:


She's dead.

Sahana is still there in his memories. Of course he can never forget her. That's why he brought up the golden shower.

Look at the mole on the new woman's face. She's a different person.
 
09-02-11, 5:32 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 13
My two cents is as follow:

In the scene at the beach they didn't have sex, but she gave him a handjob. that's why while he was huffing, you could only see one of her hands. After he cummed her hand fell back down and she died. She whispered before "When I wake up, let's have sex." but she didn't wake up. I'm going to guess she had aids, and that's why she refused to have sex with him. He's also impotent because of this. I think his smiling there was because it flew over his head and he didn't want to believe it was true, especially with her words before.

Someone else also posted about a reference to the Movie Shutter. I'm glad someone explained it because I got scared and closed the video a minute in. Basically it's like she was sitting on his shoulder and grabbed his head for balance and his head is pulled that way.

The manga does talk a lot about spirits and ghosts so who are be to judge he's happy just because he can still feel her with him. Maybe he's even content knowing that she would want him to go on. she told him he can't go with her, so he's determined to live out his life for her. Also what the doctor said to him fits in there too.

The orphanage scene confirms her parents deaths.

So in the end she died, but we must be happy, if not for our own sake then for hers... Fuck off tears. God dammit... I saw this coming from a mile away, I got mad how it pushed this and practically gave it away at every turn. I saw it coming... and yet I'm still hit by it.

I would recommend Onani Master Kurosawa here. It's not as dark or "odd" but it's defiantly one you want to read if you're into what this pulled, character development, "odd" storyline, and just generally feels in the same line, though it's happier.
 
09-03-11, 6:25 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 92
I'm still not sure if she's dead(and that's better I don't want to cry). But if that's true he should preserve her corpse and use it to jerk off, maybe use her for blowjobs or handjobs. I think she'd be happy if her dead body could make him happy(but that would be very creepy and disturbing ending). And after reading this manga I think I started liking golden showers xD
 
09-19-11, 10:03 AM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 30
Y'know, I think the saddest part about this manga is that
 
09-21-11, 2:57 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 157
I really wanted Kurumi to live. From volume 5 onwards it became more and more apparent that it wasn't gonna happen, but I kept reading in hope of a happy ending. She was such a cheerful girl who enjoyed life, and the fact that she died at such a young age after developing such deep love with Aiba and friendship with the rest of the club members makes it one of the saddest endings in manga for me.

On a lighter note, the manga some really good humor. I rarely laugh out loud when reading manga, but Sundome got a few out of me nearly every chapter. Whether it's Aiba's obsession with pee, a little brother asking innocent questions at the dinner table, or sticking your penis in your love interests mail slot; it was all good stuff. I'll definitely be re-reading this sometime, regardless of the bittersweet ending.
 
11-12-11, 7:06 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 10
I really don't know how to feel about the Ending ... Its so sad that Sahana died but I there are phew things i dont understand. For example what did Hideo mean with 'When my head starts to hang ... if its tighten like this .. it feels like this part here's being pulled' (its one of the last pages) and also did they have sex? Did she die while they did it?
 
11-20-11, 2:29 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 69
Mangaka-san said:
I really don't know how to feel about the Ending ... Its so sad that Sahana died but I there are phew things i dont understand. For example what did Hideo mean with 'When my head starts to hang ... if its tighten like this .. it feels like this part here's being pulled' (its one of the last pages) and also did they have sex? Did she die while they did it?


someone already explained it, being a reference to shutter
and about them doing it, most likely NO, im quite sure that was just a handjob


This is a really amazing manga, and it stings my heart everytime i see the ending (yeah i looked at it for about 5 times, cause its just too beautiful)
 
11-20-11, 2:37 PM

Offline
Joined: May 2011
Posts: 1482
zilentworld said:
Mangaka-san said:
I really don't know how to feel about the Ending ... Its so sad that Sahana died but I there are phew things i dont understand. For example what did Hideo mean with 'When my head starts to hang ... if its tighten like this .. it feels like this part here's being pulled' (its one of the last pages) and also did they have sex? Did she die while they did it?


someone already explained it, being a reference to shutter
and about them doing it, most likely NO, im quite sure that was just a handjob


This is a really amazing manga, and it stings my heart everytime i see the ending (yeah i looked at it for about 5 times, cause its just too beautiful)

No, he had sex with her. But she died before they started cancelling out his elimination from the College group.Sahana even said "i'm never going to have sex with you."
 
11-22-11, 1:10 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 10
And my second question what he said to the doctor his quote
 
12-09-11, 2:07 PM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 1357
aznw3ir0 said:
Yes I understand!! I re-read the manga and Hideo Aiba says "when my head starts to hang,... If I tighten it here like this, it feels like this part here's being pulled." let me explain for some who don't understand.. When his head hangs, like in the shutter reference, there is Sahana sitting on his shoulders. When he tightens his neck and tries to straighten it out, he points to his chin and says it feels it is being pulled. Imagine if your sitting on someone's shoulders and they stand up as straight as they can... You try to grab onto something to prevent from falling right? the only thing available is the chin. OooOoOoOoO that is sorta creepy! But an awesome reference.

Awesome reference?! I won't be able to fall asleep tonight! *shivers*
Really guys, I was crying before I read this. Now I'm just freaked out.
*cough* Here's how I interpreted the "when my head starts to hang,... If I tighten it here like this, it feels like this part here's being pulled" part - he's talking about the imaginary collar he already mentioned earlier in the manga. So no creepy sitting on shoulders ;____;

Anyway, that was so sad. I saw it coming, like everyone else, but I was still hoping for a happy ending somehow (and not happy in this way)..
 
12-13-11, 5:24 AM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 31
This manga really is making me go crazy, giving such a tragic end to the story when I really want a happy ending. I love it and hate it at the same time. I could see the end coming from even very early in the series, but I couldn't help but wish otherwise. I wanted to close my eyes and say that woman at the end was Sahana, but I just couldn't do it because it was just too obviously not her. Even though Aiba can still feel Sahana with him at the end, it doesn't make me feel happy at all.

As for the ending, I believe that Sahana says "'When I wake up, let's have sex" that is her in the afterlife talking already. I think that what Sahana whispers to Aiba after suggesting to jerk off is to actually rub his crotch against her body, so nobody's hands need to be used. While in the middle of this, Sahana dies, and Aiba finishes the job even though he knows she died because that whisper must have been a request, and Aiba always tried to fulfill Sahana's requests and promises.
 
02-26-12, 9:51 AM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 95
Really enjoyed the whole manga and liked the ending.
Maybe someone could put a link to the "Shutter" scene everyone's talking about, and what is that "ashes metaphor" someone mentioned?
Also, I would like to think that the protagonist only imaged the sex between her and that man, as he was only a doctor coming to see her.
Modified by decay, 02-26-12, 9:57 AM


 
03-14-12, 6:17 AM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2011
Posts: 1217
At first I was sugarcoating my mind into thinking that the woman at the end was Kurumi,but then I read this thread and my gut started to sink. Sad. Just,really,really,sad. Saddest manga I've read so far. The emotions that were portrayed in the manga is like none other :(

 
04-02-12, 10:49 PM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 1
I finished this manga yesterday and have been mulling over the ending in my head trying to get some answers.

I don't think the point of it is whether or not she had a real disease and trying to classify it as something that we are familiar with doesn't seem to be the author's point.
Instead, consider the facts.
1) He became a doctor (implies help from the OB which implies he was still a virgin)
2)It seems pretty obvious that the phrase that begins "起きたら(When I wake up)" was what she whispered to him earlier, to which he responds ok.
3) The boat was moving and both of his hands were on the floor the entire time.
4) Her hand didn't move except to shake with the boat.

If we take these as givens, it's extremely likely that she died sometime after she whispered the final words to him and before he started doing whatever he was doing. The question that I have is what was he doing? I find it REALLY unlikely that he'd end up having sex with her corpse because that doesn't fit with the progression at all since in the beginning she did say that she'd never have sex with him.

Basically what I'm trying to say is that literally every hint the author gives throughout the entire story points to them not having sex EXCEPT the MC's actions at the end. What the hell was he doing? I honestly have no idea. Just rubbing or something probably.

If someone has counterpoints I'd love to hear them because I'm not even sure about what I just wrote.
 
04-11-12, 12:17 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 1
Lots of spoilers here!

This is my first manga, I came across Sundome completely by accident while searching for another book. When I took a look, I was completely hooked, got all the books, and it's fair to say that I have been haunted by this series with the description of a strange love affair in which one person walking in the shadow of death ensures that she will leave her mark on the world, and we will always know that Kurumi Sahana did exist, through the legacy of her love for Hideo Aiba, and his love for her.
I would like to share my thoughts about this last chapter. When I first read it, for me it was profoundly sad, but at the same time a powerful statement of the power of love. Aiba is operating on two levels, he knows that Kurumi is dying and he has so little time to fulfill his promise to share the wave-flowers with her, but at the same time he wanted to ensure that Kurumi would leave this world knowing that she was loved, that she was the centre of Aiba's world, that as far as Aiba is concerned, he loves her out of passion, not pity.
In the last scenes by the shore with the failure of their attempts to have penetrative sex, Kurumi whispers to Aiba, "Tomorrow when I wake up", both knowing that because how close to death Kurumi is this will not be happening, fulfilling her promise from the beginning of the series that they will never have sex. Yet sex and passion is still important for both of them, and so Kurumi offers to use her hand to bring Aiba-we only see one of her hands in those frames- which both fulfills his final wish to show how much passion he is filled for Kurumi, and at the same time giving Kurumi the comfort to take her final journey-in one of the earlier volumes it is suggested that she teased Aiba by grabbing his penis when she was frightened, maybe at this point it is no longer a tease, as she faces her passing, she needs all the comfort she can receive from know ing how much she is still loved and an object of desire for Aiba. After he climaxes, they rest in each other's arms, they still have time for whispered conversations as well as silence, and sharing in a gentle love of presence to one another, at this point they have talk of the importance of the wave-flowers for Kurumi as a symbol that because of their love, she herself is a wave-flower giving beauty to the world through her passing, rather than simply sinking to the bottom. Then knowing what she has accomplished by being in the presence of someone who has healed her from her own wounds of loneliness from her troubled past, knowing that she has been, is and always will be loved by Aiba, at some point she fades away. I like to think that she leaves her body to become a spirit in Aiba's life, a constant reminder of what they shared with one another, how what they shared should continue to bring joy and happiness to Aiba's life-even in his relationship with his wife, and that now and again, she will give that a collar a gentle tug to get Aiba back on track!
As I said, this series will haunt me for a long while, it has been a blessing to share in this story of the mystery of love.
 
05-04-12, 2:07 AM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2011
Posts: 18
FortSandy said:
In the last scenes by the shore with the failure of their attempts to have penetrative sex, Kurumi whispers to Aiba, "Tomorrow when I wake up", both knowing that because how close to death Kurumi is this will not be happening, fulfilling her promise from the beginning of the series that they will never have sex. Yet sex and passion is still important for both of them, and so Kurumi offers to use her hand to bring Aiba-we only see one of her hands in those frames


Sorry, but I believe that your are misinterpreting the scene and the order of events. It has been pointed out repeatedly in this thread that the art is used very deliberately to strongly indicate that Kurumi is already dead during the intercourse. The lifeless, limp hand, the hidden eyes, Aiba's pained expression and Kurumi's body shown against the background which explains that the white foam are lifeless shells of plankton.

Yet something has been bothering me about the composition of the scene since I've finished the manga (well, something besides the necrophilia aspect) and I think I have a clearer picture of what it is now: The position of her right arm seems rather unnatural if you start with the assumption that she was already dead when Aiba started having intercourse with her. I'd rather expect that the arm would be closer to the body and not be bend behind the head unless Aiba positioned the arm himself and there's little reason why he should do it in the first place. So let's change the assumption to Kurumi being alive at the beginning of the intercourse and that she died in the process. That would offer a better explanation for the position of the arm. Maybe she caressed Aiba's face and it came to rest there when her life faded away or she used it to stabilize her head. Another advantage of this explanation is that it is not so damaging to Aiba's character as he wouldn't have disregarded Kurumi's wishes in the end by raping her undead body while still keeping the sundome aspect intact (he didn't come while she was alive after all). I don't think it's a problem that she said she wouldn't have ever sex with him as she made the proclamation at the very beginning of their relationship long before they developed their deep bond so it's only natural that your opinion changes, especially at the end of your life (if it ever was serious in the first place and not only used to tease him).
Modified by ErunnoToo, 05-04-12, 2:15 AM
 
06-12-12, 5:04 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 22
This manga was AMAZING! The ecchi scenes really stayed by the humor and balanced it out; so it wasn't just ecchi, it had me on the ground Laughing with joy and happiness. ^^ "Le perfect manga".

“Fear beyond rational limits forces people to cling to normality”
― Hiroya Oku
 
06-12-12, 7:52 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2012
Posts: 1
the way i took the ending with the "whenever my head gets heavy hangs" whatever comment was in reference to the pet ownership thing Kurumi had with him.

the idea that he was her loyal loved pet who guided him when wrong and made him into a man, and no longer that exile as she was.

also the "collar" number to each chapter. this all kinda made me thing that scene with the doctor at the end refers to Kurumi "pulling his chain and guiding him in the right direction"



either way. fucking so deperessing. just spent all night and got through it in one sit. that was an emotional rollercoaster and bomb lol.
the scene where kyouko seems to be laughing and says whilst actually crying shes so glad to have met her and the zoom out.

the "hideo go", "WOOF" scene was biggest tearjerker i think...

the two things i found attributed to the really depressing and different atmosphere compared to the rest of the chapters n volumes was the little himari even said or expressed
and probably in line with the "woof" thing as wel, the fact that hideo doesnt show any pain or saddness. THE LACK OF SAD IS SAD DAMMIT!!!! X( i mean i dont know whether to take it as the holding back of sorrow and despair to prevent needless words and not waste time or to save Kurumi the grief or whatever. but its just absolutely devastating TT_TT

im just kinda depressed and lost atm and dont really know how to vent it so *create account, comment*

seems that more and more frequently i keep finding these bitter sweet amazing stories that i value by far the most yet regret reading so much.
cant weigh the beauty of the stories to the resulting emotional impact of them...


THATS MY 2 CENTS
anyone actually fucked to read far or comment on ur view n validate some of this
CHEERS ^_^
p.s any error in names, fixed, or coherency i put to major lack of sleep. sorry in advance
Modified by GeeT02, 06-12-12, 7:57 PM
 
07-08-12, 4:40 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 67069
I expected a more powerful ending.
 
07-10-12, 3:08 PM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2010
Posts: 1152
AlexSadist-sama said:
I expected a more powerful ending.


Are you serious?
The ending wasn't powerful enough for you?
Nevermind the fact that he risked his hide and neck to break her out of the hospital, carry her on his back all the way to the station then to the beach and how she spent her final moments in his arms as he came on her by the one place he promised to take her.

I feel like the lack of closure is both a pro and a con but with all honesty it would have been nice for even a minute amount of detail. We never really get to glance at Kurumi's past and whilst that is a good thing in itself, the lack of any real development in her character other than her relationship with Aiba makes it extremely difficult to sympathise beyond the "love that never can be".


 
08-03-12, 8:54 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 4
I dont think he ever would have gotten in trouble at that hospital because the sahana's doctor and the director of the hospital were OB's. Also aids can be transmitted through any bodily fluid.

If you reread the end of the first chapter he says "but I still thought the day when she and I became one was yet to come". This seems like foreshadowing to let you know that they dont have sex in that boat or that its not considered sex. Also it seems like in the beginning she's just messing around with him when she says that they will never have sex like how she said she use to be a boy. Later on it seems like she wants to have sex with him but wont because of the roman clubs rules, she's dying, because he wont ask for it, or a combination of the three. Remember the doctor said that she was waiting for him to make a move also she invites him to do things like rub her but hideo only thinks about rubbing himself.
 
08-03-12, 9:23 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 4
Besides the chin thing mentioned earlier I think there is more evidence Sahana is a ghost watching over Hideo, like wen his wife goes to take a shower and has a sudden change of heart about the whole golden shower thing. Its not to strange to think that Sahana caused her to change her mind because the exchange is after Hideo says that Sahana still exist and this manga has a strong occult undertone.
 
08-06-12, 6:03 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2009
Posts: 2177
I'm a bit conflicted with this manga. The drama is really good, but I still feel the ecchi is a bit too much. I think it actually has more to do with the extreme fetishes. I think this aspect could have been toned down a lot and still maintain the excitement of the drama. This would also help the manga to reach a larger audience.
 
09-03-12, 9:43 AM

Offline
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 821
This was surprisingly good, I was mostly indifferent to the extreme fetishes displayed or the ghost hunting hijikings but I really enjoyed most of it the story, I actually read this in its entirety in one afternoon. The only thing I didn't like is how vague it was about Kurumi's life and illness or the fact that it didn't give us any glimpse of what was going on in her head.

As for the ending, I was expecting her to die but since a lot of foreshadowing was done leading up to it but that doesn't mean I wasn't sad when it actually happened and in the back of my mind I was hoping for some deus ex machina to somehow make it into a happy ending.
Modified by MagEarwhig, 09-03-12, 6:10 PM
 
09-22-12, 8:12 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 12857
Just finished the manga from start in one go.

Think this is the first time I've ever teared up reading a manga let alone a book honestly. I don't read much manga though.

I could tell what was going to happen a lot earlier with all the foreshadowing but I just wanted to believe it wouldn't happen.

Now I'm very depressed.

Using a GIF in your sig? Make sure to read the site & forum guidelines, section II.
 
09-23-12, 10:27 AM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2010
Posts: 3
Couldn't sleep last night. Finally got up at 5 and finished volume 8 this morning. The sense of loss is a bit overwhelming.

I wish more had been explained about Kurumi's background and illness. What was the deal with the scene on the train where they passed a children's home? I guess I'll never know.

Looks like I'm going to have to watch some comedy for a while....
 
09-23-12, 7:48 PM

Offline
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 570
daedalous said:
What was the deal with the scene on the train where they passed a children's home? I guess I'll never know.
The vague amount of information disclosed regarding Kurumi's past implies (perhaps it's even mentioned, I can't quite recall) that she was raised at an orphanage. So that was that, supposedly.
 
09-24-12, 6:38 PM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 97
Wow. This manga... I'm actually at a loss right now. I thought she had some kind of a disease, but I really wanted to know what it was.
Actually, I'm more mad at the mangaka for not explaining a lot of things, but yeah..
I knew it was going to be some kind of bittersweet ending. No way a manga like this was going to end with a happy feeling.
Let me clear some things up.

You can clearly see here that she IS dead already and how the fuck did you come up with a fucking HANDJOB?! You must be really fucking blind.

This is a flashback. I don't really get what the author is trying to say here with "You were the same as me", but anyway.

Still flash from the scene before they started doing it. You can clearly see that she's whispering in his ear and she is saying "When I was up, let's have sex" knowing that she'll never wake up.

He's cuming here, but that's not the point. Look at her lifeless hand.. Handjob?! Saying like she was doing it with her left hand is fucking hilarious.

He was talking to himself here after he came on her dead body.

Probably when she talks back about the golden shower, he remembers her and shit. Probably.
I'm guessing he FUCKED her, because there's not even an explanation, but you must be blind or retarded if you think she was giving him a handjob.. Why?

It was quite the HARDCORE manga if you ask me. My dick feels strange and I feel strange too. Too bad the mangaka didn't want to write the details..
 
09-26-12, 7:10 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2011
Posts: 503
That ending, Saw it coming but was still hard to take in.
 
09-27-12, 8:17 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 1
If this woman is not Kurumi then why does she use 'Fu' 'Fu' all the time like Kurumi did and why is she using very familiar language when talking about Kattsun and Kyouko chan like Kurumi did and not using their family names?
She is alive and still exists.
 
10-02-12, 9:32 PM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2012
Posts: 3
In the end...although i knew it was gonna happen....the tears still came.

Good for Hideo, becoming a doctor like he said he would.
I think it's Kurumi at the very end, and that opinion(a fact to me) won't change.
 
10-22-12, 9:51 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 2641
marduk666777666 said:
If this woman is not Kurumi then why does she use 'Fu' 'Fu' all the time like Kurumi did and why is she using very familiar language when talking about Kattsun and Kyouko chan like Kurumi did and not using their family names?
She is alive and still exists.


Wasn't it Hideo that said that?


 
10-24-12, 12:54 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2012
Posts: 4
I liked the manga but the mangaka didn't go very detailed in the end. It's still very vage.
 
10-26-12, 8:01 PM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 52
mmm well the Manga was Excelent..Couldnt stop myself from reading it...and when i got the last Volume i stayed up reading it so when i got to the end i was tired and thats probly why i was confused xD...Well..at first i thought it was Kurumi who was with him at the end but the way she was talking to him revealed the Truth then reading other peoples comments i came to see what the truth was.....still saddened by the fact that they ended it with out telling us much(Like the reason she died and why she didnt want to have sex with him...Ah well do hope to find something like this soon..
 
11-08-12, 10:16 AM

Offline
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 1124
Ended kinda unexplained, kinda disappointed. :O
But i liked the manga, it was good, i love ecchi, although this was pretty much hentai.
 
11-19-12, 12:10 AM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2012
Posts: 10
The ending was a bit anticipated, but I still cried on chapter 75, then chapter 76 made everything all better.
 
Top
Pages (4) -0.2 0.8 [1.8] 2.8 3.8 » ... Last »