Anime Information

Forums

gonna quote this, didn't like the ending, imho tamao+nagisa were better as etoaru, shizuma was selfish till the end first by taking nagisa as replacement for kaori, second for going back and stealing her from tamao after giving up on her.

Poor tamao :(

it started well but then turned out to be all shitty dialogues and events:S maybe just 'Nagisa, i love you' part saves the day but not enough.. also there is so many mistakes, deficients in story.. 5/10

It was sad to watch Yaya tie that on Hikari. it was like she was saying goodbye to her, and you could tell it was hard on her to. When Shizuma gave out the flowers the longing look she gave Nagisa was emotional I thought and it was obvious Tamao could see the emotions from the two of them. When Shizuma came in it was like she was busting into a wedding that she needed to break up. That was actually a really good anime series and although the ending was sad it was also romantic and very sweet.

Good ending. There's definitely not going to be a second season so I'll miss the series.

I knew Nagisa and Shizuma were going to end up together since episode 1 so this wasn't a suprise. Still would have liked Nagisa and tamao to have been together but still, this was a good ending.

but i wonder what happend afterwards? after the creds it showed nagisa back in the dorm right? i woulda thought her and shizuma woulda been together like the whole night in her mansion or something.. i guess not :(

well replying from that statement tomoa said welcome back nagisa and like i was totally lost!! i mean wtf happens and does tomoa forgive nagisa!!!???? i feel soo sorry for tomoa i wish i could go up to her and hug her but i mean after the credits does tomoa really forgive nagisa if u no what i'm saying or understand plz reply >.<

In the middle of watching this anime, I said to myself that if Shizuma and Nagisa end up together, I'll give this anime a 10 ;)

Looks like I have no choice now. I really loved the ending, I wonder how the ending in the novel looks like.

Tomao sure knows how to stay composed, and she also have a very high tolerance rate.

Poor Tamao and Yaya my 2 fav characters got a crappy ending and let go of the ones they love

Is anyone else pissed about the ending???

overall ill give it a 9/10
really funny parts and sad parts

I'm really sorry that I can't give it a 10/10, since it definitely had a few weaker moments (that whole amnesia thing was really unnecessary), still, I enjoyed the series very much. It had a lovely cast, I don't think there were any characters that I didn't like...well, maybe Sister, but that's understandable. Even the "villains" learned a thing or two. I absolutely loved the music, it added greatly to the atmosphere. 5/5 for the episode 9/10 for the series as a whole, definitely one of my favorites.

I wasn't that pleased with the ending. After Shizuma's past was revealed, I felt that everything became rushed. From the complicated relationship of ShizumaxNagisa to the amnesia of Amane and her sudden recovery due to Hikari's song. So pretty much, the Etoile selection arc was rushed.

I was expecting to see Shizuma as a graduated student and then a glimpse of how her life with Nagisa would be. But who knows, maybe the novels will be better, which I am planning to read next.

8/10.

Finished this awhile ago - but I gotta say. I absolutely loved this series and ended up giving a perfect score. The music, art, and characters were outstanding. It's genuinely depressing to know there will never be a second season.

I just finished watching it, and it is Brilliant, I think everyone feels sorry for Tamao-chan. I think Tsubomi was the cutest character and she had an interesting personality.

Overall I loved the anime, and hope there's an OVA at some point.

Tamao > Shizuma

That made me very sad indeed to see that. Even the very ending with them standing opposite of the door is kinda heart breaking. I was given the impression that although Nagisa is with Shizuma, she understands the pain Tamao is in right now.

In any case, it was a good show. Honestly, I don't think it needed to be 26 episodes as it kinda dragged on and on there in the middle. The fact that they didn't show any glimpse into the future to show the relationship status for both Shizuma and Tamao related to Nagisa was something they really should of tossed in there.

7/10 as the romantic drama never really took off for me.

This is probably the only yuri series I've ever watched and enjoyed.

Those eargasmic OP songs...

That was a beautiful story. However, I still like the Nagisa x Tamao pairing more. They looked very cute and beautiful together in this episode. It's not that I didn't like Shizuma with Nagisa, but their relationship often felt empty. One episode they were crying and dying for each other, next episode they acted like nothing happened. It was overly dramatized. I also hated Shizuma in the beginning, trying to hit on every random girl.
Another problem with the series was that the two main relationships were both identical love-triangles, just like Murbella said. Both times the friend had to give up on their love, which was really said. I liked how Tamao let Nagisa go with pushing her while taking her ribbon off, that was really well portrayed.
I also didn't like that the series was often very predictable and some thing were unnecessary, like the amnesia thing and the b1tches from Spica.
Last thing is that I think Chikaru should have been the Etoile. She was way better for the job.

Except for the b1tches all of the characters were lovable so I think they did a great job on that part. I also liked that didn't always had to tell their feeling, but they could show them with symbolic things. The main concept of the 3 all-girl schools was also good, I was a little surprised though that being a lesbian here seems to be a very normal and everyday thing, not that it was bad or anything :)
My favorite character was Nagisa of course, she kind of reminded me of Sora from Kaleido Star, with her being a very kind, cute, determined and admirable girl :) Second was Chikaru. She was an all-around kind, loving, caring and awesome girl :) She should have gotten more screen-time.

Considering everything I gave this anime a 7/10. It was very beautiful and wonderful, but for the problems I mentioned above I had to take away some points. Might rewatch sometime or read the novel/manga.

This was a very satisfying, long anime. I'd like to emphasize the long because halfway through the anime, I began to be very bored and had trouble watching it. If it weren't for some of my favorite characters (*cough* Chikaru *cough*), I probably would've dropped it. I was honestly planning on rating it 4 or 5 out of 10.

But the last episode did a great job of tidying up the plot. All the pairings were decided and it was very satisfying.

7/10

Aside from it being over with I loved the ending. I love when shizuma comes to get Nagisa. I do feel really bad for Tamao and would be interested in seeing more beyond where they left it.

Off topic a little. If you like show I would highly recommend the books!

I really liked how much nagisa resembled kaori chan. They were both really wide eyed, optimistic warm kind loving people and i think thats why shizuma loved nagisa. I feel that was implied but i sort of wanted shizuma to explain to nagisa why she loved her and what about her made her so lovable ~!

I finished watching it today!:3
I totally agree with him! (so I had to quote this XD) :3 except I rate this anime an 8/10, because they were crying about events that have happened, which they forgot all about the next day, as if nothing had happened, which made me a bit confused. Furthermore I really got annoyed of the part that Shizuma was hitting on every girl :(. Anyway the NagisaxTamao..... I was starting to like that couple more towards the end, but in the beginning and end I was for ShizumaxNagisa, because the anime worked to that couple.

Last thing about Tamao is that she didn't really get all lovey-dovey with Nagisa.... So I already guessed that Nagisa would get back to Shizuma.

The thing is, I think it's strange, that Shizuma barely showed any emotion if you compare her to the other characters. I saw her 1 time laughing and 1 time blushing (blushing was only in the last episode) and most of the time she doesn't show any emotion in my opinion. Don't forget, that I compare the emotions of the other characters, about blushing etc.

Ah well, the part that was really weird is the part that every girl on that school seems to be lesbian... not that I complain though, but I just think it's weird.
I started to like Shizuma when she barged in while they were announcing the results and confessed to Nagisa, but that was too late for me. So basically I like Shizuma if she is cheery and naughty.:)

Oh and I forget to add, that I think Tsubomi and Yaya-chan will end up together in a relationship, well, that is something I assume.:)
The other thing I found to be weird, is that you don't see Shizuma had sex with Nagisa, but you saw Shizuma had sex with Kaori.... So why not showing they had sex (if they had sex of course)?

I think I'm gonna read the manga or only the end of it, to see if it's much different from the anime^^.

I really liked the ending, the only sad things are tamao and yaya but how shizuma confessed in front of everyone there was really beautiful, doesn't matter if things are predictable as long as they are nice..

and the shizuma x nagusa kiss scene in the end was very romantic and beautiful as well :)