MyAnimeList.net

Anime Information
Forums

Recent Posts | My Watched Topics | My Ignored Topics | Search

Giant Killing Episode 22 Discussion
MyAnimeList.net Forum »» Anime Discussion »» Series Discussion »» Giant Killing »» Giant Killing Episode 22 Discussion

Pages (2) [1] 2 »
View Poll Results: Giant Killing Episode 22 Discussion
5 out of 5: Loved it!
 
19 59.38%
4 out of 5: Liked it
 
7 21.88%
3 out of 5: It was OK
 
4 12.50%
2 out of 5: Disliked it
 
2 6.25%
1 out of 5: Hated it
 
0.00%
Voters: 32

#1
08-29-10, 11:29 AM

Offline
Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 219
THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE.
----------------------------------------
nice episode

i'm gettin damn annoyed by these dutch voice actors.
they suck soo fkin hard..

even the dutch VA over here are way better and they also suck...

so next episode is gonna be about the forwards
 
#2
08-29-10, 12:10 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1445
This is getting worse and worse. It seems that mangaka couldn't decide whether GK should be a realistic or 'supernatural' (Tsubasa) anime. The result is that I don't really know what's this show about.

Sports? Not really, no tactics whatsoever. Boring presentation of matches etc.
Drama? That's probably it revolves about internal conflicts and personal dramas. Too bad the level of drama is so bland and uninteresting.

And I really wanted to like this show, being football fan for like 20 years now.

2/5 for the episode

6/10 for the show so far


"There is a road in the hearts of all of us, hidden and seldom traveled,
which leads to an unknown, secret place."
 
#3
08-29-10, 1:03 PM

Offline
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 144
I don't think the Anime revolves on Drama, They're showing how the players are evolving during each games and showing how they suck before Tatsumi came. But - They're not showing much about the game though. I wanna see more soccer

I just noticed that the fans are really hardcore and angry! They'd probably kill and eat someone who'd say ETU sucks lol.
 
#4
08-29-10, 2:32 PM
Manga Moderator
Offline
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 5621
How is enjoying the match going to cause a sudden comeback? That just earned this anime a shounen tag.
 
#5
08-29-10, 5:37 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 2035
KuroDubZero said:
How is enjoying the match going to cause a sudden comeback? That just earned this anime a shounen tag.

lol. Yeah, i might of liked this if it was more realistic. I mean when you have NO scenes off the field you might need it. It feels like i am watching poorly framed games. The only reason it has a 7 instead of a 6 so far is because it actually has intense moments.
 
#6
08-29-10, 5:58 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 16
They are really starting to drag this out. They going to suddenly get superpowers and win it all in the last ep or something?

 
#7
08-29-10, 6:32 PM

Offline
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 581
Have you guys even seen any other sports Anime? -_- They are meant to inspire and motivate and show the development of the characters through the games. Sure maybe they won't achieve that for you but it is aimed at a Japanese audience, quite possible those of younger age too. This show isn't doing anything different to most other Sports Anime's though.

I think the only thing that annoys me is that Tatsumi should be making some sort of plan. I can understand his motives but the way he causes them to happen just kinda feels a bit stupid I guess.
 
#8
08-29-10, 7:51 PM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 1351
Looks like the last four eps are gonna be about this match, too. I'm not surprised since somebody mentioned that the manga for this match ended up being three volumes worth!

GINOOOO! Finally a decent pass, and lmao @ the look he gave Natsuki. And with the transformation of Sugi and a couple of the others, looks like ETU are starting to rev up and begin their fight back. :3 I'm excited.

kashim said:
This is getting worse and worse. It seems that mangaka couldn't decide whether GK should be a realistic or 'supernatural' (Tsubasa) anime. The result is that I don't really know what's this show about.

Wait, what? How is this a "supernatural" anime in any way?
 
#9
08-29-10, 8:49 PM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 3569
kashim said:
This is getting worse and worse. It seems that mangaka couldn't decide whether GK should be a realistic or 'supernatural' (Tsubasa) anime. The result is that I don't really know what's this show about.
Dunno why you say this... The only thing I know is that GK have always been a pain to animate... if you dont believe me then tell me why the soccer videogames developers have invested YEARS, ages, to make them realistic... I see no point in your statement

Sports? Not really, no tactics whatsoever. Boring presentation of matches etc.
Drama? That's probably it revolves about internal conflicts and personal dramas. Too bad the level of drama is so bland and uninteresting.

And I really wanted to like this show, being football fan for like 20 years now.
It is about soccer ne? It is about a sport... so... They might be abusing with all those build ups and the presentation, but common it is the most realistic soccer Manga/Anime series Ive ever seen in my entire life so it is needed, all this drama and personal conflicts, and it is just as velcom said, theyre meant to motivate people, especially those who play soccer, and obviously maybe us that we are so used to soccer and its problems are not that surprised with we are watching ne? Personally I found it refreshing since its an Anime we are talkign about here... maybe it doesnt have the punch, but it is an amazing thing. Football fan huh? I am one too... and I-m fully enjoying the show

Besides that I found the whole thing interesting since looks like ETU is finally catching up to the tune they should work with... Wha I mean? well looks like they are finally doing what they should be doing.... messing with the other teams enemies and enjoying the game... I do agree with Tatsumi... those who enjoy play better and if they are really having fun those will be the best playes... They are finally understanding that...

And so looks like next chappie will be about Forwards, especifically Natsuki... and looks like ETU will score a goal next episode... WOnder who will score... Natsuki in one of his weird plays, or Tsubaki in his permanent wild run... Or Gino with one of his surgical shots... or surprising us Sera... Well one thing is certain, a goal will fall... Oh Gino... LOOOOL at Ginos face when Natsuki failed to do something good with the ball XD..

Signs,
Green



 
08-29-10, 11:22 PM

Offline
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 67069
Tatsumi never actually comes up with specific/proper plans. It's more like he's relying on the team to work things out on their own or by thinking positive. Kinda unrealistic to me.
 
08-29-10, 11:23 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1445
Two clarifications

@yamakasi
By supernatural, I mean soccer anime like Captain Tsubasa or more general one, like Dash Kappei!


@rebwaters
GK - Giant Killing ; I know about goalkeepers, played various versions of Winning Eleven ;)



Overall, I know that it is a sports and a shounen, but compared to other titles it's clearly inferior. One Outs has helluva lots of tension (albeit it's not 100% sports shounen) and Hajime no Ippo has lots more explanation and signs that author knows what he's writing about. So no, GK isn't a good sports anime (imho)


"There is a road in the hearts of all of us, hidden and seldom traveled,
which leads to an unknown, secret place."
 
08-29-10, 11:39 PM

Offline
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 3026
Well that is the first time I've seen Gino pissed. Most of the time, it looks like he doesn't care.

I don't know about you people but I'm enjoying this than other Football anime that I've watched before because it's all about teamwork and good coaching, and not because of some super special moves or a super human player though given benefit of the fact that it suffers from the typical shounen genre. Still pretty good show.
 
08-29-10, 11:49 PM

Offline
Joined: Dec 2007
Posts: 899
AlexSadist-sama said:
Tatsumi never actually comes up with specific/proper plans. It's more like he's relying on the team to work things out on their own or by thinking positive. Kinda unrealistic to me.
His plan for this game was for them to defend with all they got in the first half and have Gino make terrible passes to make Osaka think that Gino was having an off-game and that he wouldn't be a threat. Not to mention he wanted discord amongst the Osaka forwards (such as Hauer being really ticked off by the end of this episode). So it's not like Tatsumi doesn't come up with plans. That's actually pretty much all he does. He's just not a big believer in half-time speeches.

Anyway, I was pretty disappointed with this episode. Despite all that fire and enthusiasm in the locker room the only player who seemed to has changed his style is Sugie. He finally figured out that he needed to put pressure on Kubota and not just let him dance around the field.

I mean, if Natsuki has troubles making decisions on who to pass to, then why put him in the center? Why not have him on the side with Sera at the center? Only thing I can think of is that Tatsumi sees potential in Natsuki and wants him to overcome this issue, but this really is not the time or place for that imo.
Currently blogging at Chocolate Syrupy Waffles
 
08-30-10, 12:51 AM

Offline
Joined: Nov 2007
Posts: 1351
kashim said:
@yamakasi
By supernatural, I mean soccer anime like Captain Tsubasa or more general one, like Dash Kappei!

I still don't really understand what you mean (or the references), but I'm guessing something like "the players suddenly have amazing powers and are really strong/fast/can score every goal they try" or something like that? If you do mean that, then I would have to say that Giant Killing is not trying to be that kind of sports anime. It's more about how the players make mistakes and learn from each other as well as Tatsumi. So, to me, it would be more "realistic" than "supernatural" (if I'm right with what I think you mean by "supernatural").

kashim said:
Overall, I know that it is a sports and a shounen, but compared to other titles it's clearly inferior. One Outs has helluva lots of tension (albeit it's not 100% sports shounen) and Hajime no Ippo has lots more explanation and signs that author knows what he's writing about. So no, GK isn't a good sports anime (imho)

Well, I agree with this, mostly. Admittedly I haven't watched a lot of sports anime, but Giant Killing hasn't been the best that I have seen. (So far, that would be Over Drive). Then again, it definitely isn't the worst sports anime out there. I would say that it's average, and depending on the remaining eps, bordering on better-than-average. The important thing is that it be entertaining, which it is.
Modified by yamakasi, 08-30-10, 12:56 AM
 
08-30-10, 4:36 AM

Offline
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 5181
They are finaly fighting back now if only Natsuki would pass the ball faster , he is making Gino mad XD

Awesome Sig by Lailide
 
08-30-10, 8:00 AM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 1445
@yamakasi
yup, powers etc. And for realistic aspects of the show, they're too far fetched but we will be able to assess it in full only after the show has finished airing.


"There is a road in the hearts of all of us, hidden and seldom traveled,
which leads to an unknown, secret place."
 
08-30-10, 8:34 AM

Online
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 10985
cool episode and lol at the people wanting realism on anime even in sports movies like the movie Coach Carter you actually believe its for real? eventhough Coach Carter is base on true story i doubt their is more realism to it
 
08-31-10, 1:00 AM

Offline
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 152
@ Kashim :wait a minute,have you ever seen a football game involving a major club,like Inter Milan, Barcellona or Manchester United,and a minor team,like Bari,Getafe or Birmnigham? It's ALWAYS a one-side match. EtU is just a little team who is playing against a top(Osaka in this case). That's why this anime is well-done and realistic. In real life is difficult ETU could have won a match like this,but not impossible
 
08-31-10, 6:49 PM

Offline
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 78
KuroDubZero said:
How is enjoying the match going to cause a sudden comeback? That just earned this anime a shounen tag.


And the idiot of the day award goes to you. I guess you have never played a sport in your life, and probably just watch sports anime because you look for realism. It's funny you are even looking for realism in an anime where the most popular anime's are about killing people with a Notebook, A Highschool Kid with superpowers, and a Teacher who can jump off the top of buildings and still survive.

First off let me teach you a little lesson about playing sports since you must be an ammature. When you are not enjoying the sport you are playing as you are playing it, are you bound to play better or worse? Rhetorical question don't answer.

I have played Soccer, I have bowled in Leagues, I have ran track, and I have wrestled, and when I am having fun and not frustrated is easily when I have done my best. All Tatsumi is implying is not necessarily that they will be the winners, albeit it's what he wants badly, but that the players will not be winners if they don't know how to change their attitude and enjoy the game.
 
09-01-10, 12:30 AM
Manga Moderator
Offline
Joined: Jul 2009
Posts: 5621
ZweiTheBadAss said:
KuroDubZero said:
How is enjoying the match going to cause a sudden comeback? That just earned this anime a shounen tag.


And the idiot of the day award goes to you. I guess you have never played a sport in your life, and probably just watch sports anime because you look for realism. It's funny you are even looking for realism in an anime where the most popular anime's are about killing people with a Notebook, A Highschool Kid with superpowers, and a Teacher who can jump off the top of buildings and still survive.

First off let me teach you a little lesson about playing sports since you must be an ammature. When you are not enjoying the sport you are playing as you are playing it, are you bound to play better or worse? Rhetorical question don't answer.

I have played Soccer, I have bowled in Leagues, I have ran track, and I have wrestled, and when I am having fun and not frustrated is easily when I have done my best. All Tatsumi is implying is not necessarily that they will be the winners, albeit it's what he wants badly, but that the players will not be winners if they don't know how to change their attitude and enjoy the game.


First of all I'm curious of how you came to this sudden conclusion of me never playing sports? In all my twenty three years on this earth, I'm completely illiterate to sports? Seriously...and on top of that you assume telling me your athletic history solidifies your opinion? Well it doesn't and you playing sports doesn't make your words anymore meaningful. Your hypothesis about winning is completely biased.

back to the main topic Tatsumi didn't give a sermon before the match or even words that of encouragement. He simply said enjoy the match? Really? So now because we're suddenly enjoying the game were going to crush a team that has never been defeated? If that doesn't scream SHOUNEN then you obviously haven't seen enough shounen anime to understand my statement.

Normally I would just ignore this, but being called a idiot by some random noob/half-wit for simply expressing my opinion, doesn't leave me feeling the least bit happy. In the future you should learn to chill and type more steadily you ammature, No I mean you Amateur.
 
Top
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
Help     FAQ     About     Contact     Terms     Privacy     AdChoices