Is Cowboy Bebop Overrated?
Yes, it's overrated
51.8%
668
No, it's not overrated
48.2%
621
1,289 votes
| Short answer: No. Long answer: Still no. Apart from the complaints about the atmosphere, which I find awesome and unique, I can see why some people would be a little disappointed with the character development, specially in the way this anime is sold. I don't think Cowboy Bebop is really outstanding in this part, but that was not, in my opinion, the whole point of the show at all. Yes, it deals about characters; yes, there is some investigation of their past, but there is not much of a development in the sense of one displaying another attitude throughout. It's more a slice-of-life than a sci-fi action-packed series, and this kind of shows doesn't really need dynamic characters with godly awesome evolution through the storyline, but rather simple and relatable portrayals. One of the main plots of this series is, actually, talking about accepting the routine, and that includes the manners of those you share your life with. How Faye starts to be fond of the rest the way they are, how Ed seemed to fill a gap nobody cared about until she was gone, and in general the sense of a growing affection for those you see every day. Other than that, the story is amazing, with a great mix of genres, and it drives to one of the best endings I've seen in anime, so I don't know what could be wrong with that. |
| I enjoyed it, didn't see much of the hype like most of the crap nowadays, so I didn't get influenced. It's probably overrated, but it's still pretty awesome. Was looking around for a blu ray version earlier, shame there's not one around. It also made me want to rewatch my samurai champloo boxset, in eng dub this time : o I'm really annoyed that the blu ray is only in the US, though. My ps3 won't play it, I don't think. |
| No. (Maybe like 5% overrated) I am not going to explain why, cuz haters gonna hate no matter what i tell. |
| Yeah it's overrated. Not enough fan service and plot twists, not enough mindfuck and annoying main characters, not enough deep dialogue. Spike has an ugly hair cut. Not enough loli and tsundere to make it cool you know? Also there was a gay scene and a guy with woman breast, wtf is up with that? Also Champloo > Bebop |
 |
Chaotic_beauty said: Cowboy Bebop most certianly, from a critics perspective is great or among the best. It has quality and it's undeniable. The fact that it's not one of my favorites, for I prefer different type of anime is totaly unrelated. Haters need to learn to differentiate between their own idea of a fun time and general quality. Sorry this argument only works with Legend of the Galactic Heroes, everything else is a matter of opinion. And yes, Cowboy Bebop is overrated. |
| "I'm commander Shepard, and Legend of the Galactic Heroes is my favorite anime in the galaxy" |
| I think it might as well be a "classic" and rightfully so. I wouldn't call it the best, but everyone has their preferences. It's certainly likable, and has many different perspectives to see it from; whether it's the style of action, the philosophical side, the interpersonal drama, etc... I won't hesitate to say it had a pretty amazing soundtrack, though. |
 |
| "Is it overrated?" Yes, a little bit. But is it bad and deserves hatred as some other shows [cough]Code Geass[/cough] do? -Not really. It had some fucking good episodes but other ones were just meh. That's episodic anime for you! |
| It may be overrated, but there is nothing to hate. Still very solid series. |
| NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO If anything it's underrated ;) |
| *bump* (sorry) I personally don't think its overrated, but I can understand why people do. As the musician Alex Turner once said: "don't believe the hype." |
| Its very enjoyable and i can see why its viewed as one of the classic anime, but i dont particularly enjoy its episodic nature. But hey, that's just like my opinion man. |
| I would say, it some aspects it's overrated and in others it is not. You would love the show, depending on how you watch it. If you're watching it for a story that will wow you and make you think for months on end, you will not enjoy it as much. How I watch it, is that it's a relaxing show, like Aria, with a sci-fi spin, and jazzy atmosphere. I mean, it's practically an episodic series with some drama for around 6 episodes. It's well directed, the production values do not deter it, the music is amazing (And extremely memorable). The story is good. It's literally a slice of life story about Space Bounty Hunters, not a story about psychology, or a corporate conglomerate, or romance. It's kind of like a teaser for general sci-fi. I always say "If you're interested in anime, I recommend Cowboy Bebop as a first to watch." it's enjoyable. Also, some of the episodes just inspire me, like a really good Shounen anime. Does that make it the best? No, definitely not. But it certainly does require a viewing. Keep pursuing your dreams! ~ Wynn |
| My brother and I compose classical and modern music, please click the link below if you're interested. http://thesearethetwins.wordpress.com/ Please check out my profile to see what anime I recommend. Keep pursuing your dreams! ~ Wynn |
| Not overrated at all. On the surface Cowboy Bebop is great, but it tackles deep issues which makes it even greater. |
 |
| I voted no, maybe there's a few individuals who overrate it, but everything is overrated if you think of things that way. I gave it a 9 while many others gave it a 10 but it definitely deserves it's title as a classic. What makes Cowboy Bebop is not so much the story (which is good) but the storytelling it's hard for episodic shows to really have a rise climax and fall and most importantly closure, but this does. Honestly I think it may have been the first. It is still episodic, which isn't for everyone. That's one of things I always hear about the show that I disagree with that it's "for everyone" and "perfect intro series" while time has proven its a good starter series for many, nothing is ever for everyone. |
| Its overrated in my opinion, its not that good. |
ExtendedRenegade said: Voted no. I'm sorry, but this show is a prime example of episodic done right. Every single one of the stories were unbelievably fleshed out, the music was phenominal, the art was great at the time, and if you ask me, it still holds up rather well, and the English dub is very well done. i agree |
SuperSaiyen said: Yeah it's overrated. Not enough fan service and plot twists, not enough mindfuck and annoying main characters, Spike has an ugly hair cut. Not enough loli and tsundere to make it cool you know? You do realize, you just said that out loud right? |
SpikeJet2736 said: I'm pretty sure not a word was uttered, unless he talks while typing. And it was sarcasm, I imagine.SuperSaiyen said: Yeah it's overrated. Not enough fan service and plot twists, not enough mindfuck and annoying main characters, Spike has an ugly hair cut. Not enough loli and tsundere to make it cool you know? You do realize, you just said that out loud right? |
 |
Cupquake said: SpikeJet2736 said: I'm pretty sure not a word was uttered, unless he talks while typing. And it was sarcasm, I imagine.You do realize, you just said that out loud right? You know what I mean. |
SolidPayneJul 8, 2014 1:25 PM
zharnotczar said: When I asked what was so great about it, I was serious. I hear good things about this anime all the time, but I just couldn't get into it. I wanna know so that maybe I can be in on the whole thing. Because you like K-On, that's why |
Chaotic_beauty said: The fact that it's not one of my favorites, for I prefer different type of anime is totaly unrelated. Haters need to learn to differentiate between their own idea of a fun time and general quality. Well, said |
| its decent |
| I fell in love with Cowboy Bebop before I even realized what I was watching was anime. This was before I even had the internet or anything. I was captivated by the characters and the overall feel of the show, more so than I was the other shows that aired during that Adult Swim block. There's plenty more anime I find overrated (despite liking) more than Bebop. |
  |
| yes a bit |
 |
| i was gonna make a thread with this exact title but then I saw this thread, obviously. I tried watching it recently but had to drop it since every episode is exactly the kind of episode I hate. you know that one or two episodes in a series that feel disconnected from the rest of the show. the one that has the characters interact to new people and overcome new challenges and then learn nothing from it and the character they helped is never mentioned or seen again? that's almost every episode of Cowboy Bebop. sure there are episodes that help progress the "story" but most of the time they feel disconnected and I haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaate those kind of episodes. I believe its popularity had to do with the fact that for most westerners it was their first mature, animated series. the art style I can look past. it was a different time back then. the music I didn't really enjoy but I don't hate the series for it. I don't like it for its execution of trying to tell a story and getting me immersed in their universe. |
| wow that's a close poll :s OT: prob yes, but not when it was new |
  |
| Nope. It's a perfect ten always & forever; indeed it truly is one of the best anime. |
 |
| Well I think it really depends on the viewer, because Cowboy Bebop, wasn't a bad anime at all, but it wasn't a 10. I think putting 10 is overrating it, but putting 4 maybe 5 is totally wrong, because it wasn't bad, if you put a bad score, than you haven't seen some shit that is out there. Any way giving it from 6-8 maybe 9 is alright. I gave it 8, but because the ending song mood took me....I'm a sucker for moment. I think ending is really important, because that's what stays with us when the anime is ended. |
   |
| Nah, it's a really good anime which deserves its legacy. |
| "No, son, you may not have your body pillow at the dinner table!" |
| I personally believe it is. I am sure the ending itself made many people increase their score for at least 1 or 2 points. As far as the story goes, i believe they should have went "deeper" with the main plot or simply put everything in 12-13 episodes instead of 26 as it would fit in better that way. |
| Patiently waiting for the best day of my life, the day when i die. |
| Hell no, at least in my humble opinion. It ticks all the right boxes for me. It's tonally and stylistically eclectic while not feeling at all jarring, has an engaging setting, endearing and complex characters and fluid animation. Definitely worth absolutely all of the praise it has received over the years. |
Take care of yourself |
 Cowboy Bebop is amazing. Hell, I've only seen a few episodes myself staying up till 4am to catch it on Adult Swim and I hold it in high regard. It's a classic gem of the past everyone should get a chance to watch. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Cowboy Bebop Episode 26 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Metty - May 14, 2008 |
622 |
by TeeDeeHeeHee
»»
Apr 17, 11:57 AM |
|
Poll: » Cowboy Bebop Episode 21 Discussion ( 1 2 )samurai_tom - Jul 16, 2009 |
88 |
by Coletty
»»
Apr 15, 1:26 PM |
|
Poll: » Cowboy Bebop Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )ManU-Alchemist - Jun 14, 2008 |
109 |
by wallus81
»»
Apr 13, 11:26 PM |
|
Poll: » Cowboy Bebop Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )ManU-Alchemist - Jun 14, 2008 |
122 |
by wallus81
»»
Apr 13, 10:54 PM |
|
Poll: » Cowboy Bebop Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )ManU-Alchemist - Jun 13, 2008 |
206 |
by wallus81
»»
Apr 13, 10:02 PM |