Timofmars said: I wasn't very impressed. I'm surprised at how small a minority I see to be in because of that. But then again, not too many people have seen this, so it doesn't seem to have very broad appeal to get people who might not like it to watch in the first place.
It's a decent show, imo, but it's got a lot of shortcomings.
First of all, I didn't care for Watashi's grandiose, obsessive, naive ramblings. I certainly can't relate to him. Maybe it made for an interesting setup at the start, but it just got old quickly. The fact that the dialogue comes so fast doesn't help things. It just makes it a bit more unpleasant to watch.
I also never cared for this type of constant wild weirdness that is so prevalent here (the psychological element). It's like the show has ADD, as it tosses weird things at you almost as fast as it tosses dialogue at you. I don't mind it, but much of it really seems pointless to me, as if it exists just to be wild and different. The show relies on it too much.
People here are forced to come up with their own interpretations of the seemingly pointless artistic choices, looking for subtle symbolism and meanings. I never really cared for symbolism even when it's rather obvious, so I certainly don't get anything out of symbolism that is totally dependent on personal interpretations to make any sense. I feel like I'm at an art gallery looking at a multi-million dollar piece of art that looks to me like somebody just splashed a bunch of paint at the canvas. And everyone around me is fawning over it and describing different ways that they see a masterpiece in it. I think even if I agreed with some of these interpretations, it still wouldn't make my viewing experience any more enjoyable.
Some of the first episodes were good just in their own right. I mean, the way Watashi got fed up and publicly humiliated Jougasaki by exposing his embarrassing secrets... That was funny and interesting. But what brought down this show for me was the heavy way in which they purposely made so many things repeat. You get a very wildly different set of events, but the core things holding it together are simply repetitive. How many times do we need to see the fortune teller. Yeah, we know from the start that he just needs to give that white doll to Akashi and he'll end up happy, so stop already. All you gain from episode to episode is a little bit more info on the characters. Really, the episodes aren't even very memorable.
I mean, I did sort of like the idea of seeing how things change with his choices of different paths, but I'd rather that these changes reveal something a bit more subtle about what he was doing wrong each time. Maybe for each episode, they could have given us better detail about how exactly this new attempt at a rose-colored campus life could possibly be superior and lead to happiness, and then develop a revelation throughout each episode about how this was a flawed goal to focus on. Then I'd have my own expectations about how it would work, and I'd be more interested in watching how it succeeded or failed.
But instead, I was left to just observe something wild without any expectations about what crazy stuff was going to happen. I had nothing to look for or to hope for. I just knew Watashi would be naive and obsessive and would gain nothing. There were no revelations. Just wild stories that usually weren't funny, and were too off-the-wall to be really engaging.
And why couldn't there be more Akashi? She was actually interesting and fun to watch. In the end, she didn't even seem like such a wonderful "goal" to catch. She started out very intriguing, but actually became less interesting as the series went on.
I give it a 6.5/10.
you missed the point. he was never really doing much wrong in the first place. he was having fun and living life (albeit imperfectly) with his friends in all but the last universe (the one where he chose to stay in his room and isolate himself). he had happiness all along, just not perfection, because perfection doesn't exist. |