| Humm whatever still gonna watch it btw, though I wish it UFO instead. |
 |
Fai said: zetsubousei_hero said: Kinda glad it was not FGO. Hoping CCC come as well if this does well. Shaft would not do FGO anyway. If that travesty ever happens, it wouldb e A1 for sure. Or Ufo. No doubt about it. |
| Is it even possible to adapt F/GO? Isn't it just a mobile game with a hundred generic servants (or copy-paste ones) to collect without a real story? F/GO anime, they would choose the 7 more popular servants like iM@S did with Cinderella Girls? hahaha |
Oiacz said: FGO has a legit story unlike most mobile games. Is it even possible to adapt F/GO? Isn't it just a mobile game with a hundred generic servants (or copy-paste ones) to collect without a real story? F/GO anime, they would choose the 7 more popular servants like iM@S did with Cinderella Girls? hahaha The issue is that the story has so many characters that they introduce and forget very quickly, based on the current "world" you are on. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Oiacz said: Is it even possible to adapt F/GO? Isn't it just a mobile game with a hundred generic servants (or copy-paste ones) to collect without a real story? F/GO anime, they would choose the 7 more popular servants like iM@S did with Cinderella Girls? hahaha FGO has one of the most simplistic narratives possible. Its the easiest fate to adapt. And it would be the most boring. It would be pretty much Mary Sue SHielder and her Gary Stu characterless player insert master going on a journey through different worlds with harem antics with characters they meet, as they try to stop mustache twirling world ending villain of doooom. |
 |
| Shaft + Fate? Am I dreaming? |
| Not booooo Mod Edit: Added spoiler tags; please hide plot details. |
ShockedMar 27, 2016 2:02 AM
Well they chose the best girl instead so :^) Mod Edit: Modified quote of edited post. |
ShockedMar 27, 2016 2:03 AM
|
Pshhhhhh~ is still best girl QAQ Annnyway~ I hope they use the Female main instead. Mod Edit: Added spoiler tags; please hide plot details. |
ShockedMar 27, 2016 2:03 AM
| Wish it was instead of but excited all the same! Mod Edit: Added spoiler tags; please hide plot details. |
ShockedMar 27, 2016 2:04 AM
 |
Ketuekigami said: Oiacz said: FGO has a legit story unlike most mobile games. Is it even possible to adapt F/GO? Isn't it just a mobile game with a hundred generic servants (or copy-paste ones) to collect without a real story? F/GO anime, they would choose the 7 more popular servants like iM@S did with Cinderella Girls? hahaha The issue is that the story has so many characters that they introduce and forget very quickly, based on the current "world" you are on. Fai said: Oiacz said: Is it even possible to adapt F/GO? Isn't it just a mobile game with a hundred generic servants (or copy-paste ones) to collect without a real story? F/GO anime, they would choose the 7 more popular servants like iM@S did with Cinderella Girls? hahaha FGO has one of the most simplistic narratives possible. Its the easiest fate to adapt. And it would be the most boring. It would be pretty much Mary Sue SHielder and her Gary Stu characterless player insert master going on a journey through different worlds with harem antics with characters they meet, as they try to stop mustache twirling world ending villain of doooom. hahaha did anybody translate this story or I can only read it in moonrunes while playing? Now seriously, the story at least makes any sense? Because I see a lot of "Arthuria Lancer", "Cu Chulainn Caster", "Medea Lily"... and of course, corrupted servants. I can't see how this game makes any sense. For me they just threw every kind of combination possible making Lily and corrupted servants, or changing classes... (Sorry if I'm wrong, I just don't know anything about F/GO) |
| awesome now i have something to look forward to |
 |
| A Fate titled not by UF, but Shaft!? Now I got to see how this turns out. |
 |
zerfblerf said: looking forward to it, but shaft? why not UFO.. Because Ufo would absolutely not fit F/E. Its extremely artsy, surreal and dialogue focused. Hell Ufo already was not a fit for FSN as shown by them removing all the words from it. ANd Shaft already did the opening for F/E CCC |
|
| Shaft doing Fate seems incredibly weird to me but maybe it'll work out |
  |
| Extremely fitting that Fate/Extra adaptation by Shaft has a Red Saber doing a head tilt as the key visual. |
| It's going to suck |
 .. |
| I'LL SEE ANIMATED! AND IT'LL BE MADE BY SHAFT! BEST NEWS OF THE YEAR! Mod Edit: Added spoiler tags; please hide plot details. |
ShockedMar 27, 2016 2:04 AM
| Didn't expected that at all. Oh well, it's fucking Shaft, so be prepared for the headtilts :) |
 |
| That is really terrible news and as much as I like Fate series getting adaption. Shaft studio has been a weak spot and I dont think I will enjoy it as much as Ufotable |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Shaft is great, fate is great, I'm never going to play extra- this is pretty cool. Ufotable are a studio that take a lot of time to do anything and any time they spend on spin off adaptations, they aren't spending on the HF movies. Out of all the other studios that could do more fate, shaft are the best. |
 Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| But yeah everyone complaining doesn't really comprehend what fate/extra actually is... |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| Shaft animating Caster ? YES PLEASE ...still surprised SHAFT's doing it, though. |
ManjuuMar 27, 2016 2:32 AM
 |
Fai said: OH YESSSSSSSSSSSSSS BEEEN CALLING THIS FOR YEARS AND WANTING THIS FOR YEAS FUCK YESSSSSSSSS AND IT IS FUCK YESSS Please female MC please female MC please female MC This is best week ever. Now let's just hope hey eventually do CCC too. Oh who I am kidding, of course they will, this prints money :3 Zazie122 said: In before everyone complaining about Shaft. Nobody would do that. Shaft is perfect fit for F/E adaptation. In fact SHAFT would be perfect fit for Tsukihime adaptation too. FHA is impossible at this point. -Lukz said: WHERE IS MY UFO WTF FATE WITHOUT UFO ................................ Yet apart from Zero, Fate without UFO has been the only good fate. That last sentence is literally, ufoUBW wasn't good :P. Also shaft tsukihime would be fucking awesome but a ufo adaptation of the tsukihime manga would also be awesome. |
Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| I was happy until I read the studio - Shaft. Good bye with the amazing graphics and how shaft will adapt the anime. To be fair Ufotable should just license all Fate/series |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Objectively better Saber is the kinda mc here.I also heard there would be some anime original stuff. |
 |
| shaft is bleh but i'll watch this anyway because it's fate. |
 |
Renaultclio101 said: I was happy until I read the studio - Shaft. Good bye with the amazing graphics and how shaft will adapt the anime. To be fair Ufotable should just license all Fate/series Nice bait and no. Ufo would never be able to do the job with Extra's surrealist art style and setting. |
AhenshihaelMar 27, 2016 3:17 AM
|
| I don't care how good it is. All I know is best seibah is finally getting animated (aside from CP). Prepare thyselves. |
antonnMar 27, 2016 3:32 AM
Fai said: Renaultclio101 said: I was happy until I read the studio - Shaft. Good bye with the amazing graphics and how shaft will adapt the anime. To be fair Ufotable should just license all Fate/series Nice bait and no. Ufo would never be able to do the job with Extra's surrealist art style and setting. I'm happy for this news. But do you think this will be good? Because... you know.... Anime based on video games usually not good. Well Persona 4 animation and persona 3 movies are watchable at least.... |
| Shaft? Looks like this one will be interesting. |
  |
Kingof1k said: Fai said: Nice bait and no. Ufo would never be able to do the job with Extra's surrealist art style and setting. I'm happy for this news. But do you think this will be good? Because... you know.... Anime based on video games usually not good. Well Persona 4 animation and persona 3 movies are watchable at least.... Putting aside predicting whether it will be good or not, the main point of the game was it's story and characters. Hell the gameplay was just rock, paper, scissors. |
| >animated Nero Fuck yessssss. Male MC pls. Wonder if they'll do something with Tamamo bc I want her too. |
AirConditionerMar 27, 2016 4:08 AM
antonn said: Kingof1k said: I'm happy for this news. But do you think this will be good? Because... you know.... Anime based on video games usually not good. Well Persona 4 animation and persona 3 movies are watchable at least.... Putting aside predicting whether it will be good or not, the main point of the game was it's story and characters. Hell the gameplay was just rock, paper, scissors. Also in this cases, Nasu is literally the writer for the anime. AS in not just some ideas and scenes. All of it. And the first F/E game could use a little tweaking there and here in terms of story to flow better. If it is messed up then it will be messed up because of him and his decisions specifically. Which, I doubt he would up and sabotage his own work. AS long as Hakuno's character growth, conflict and personality remains intact it will be okay at worst. Hopefully he is smart enough to go with female mc. |
|
| Very interesting news and pretty cool visuals, but still don't believe in Shaft until i watch it. |
 |
| Just turn her head a little more and it would've been a typical Shaft head tilt I kid, I kid. I've yet to even finish all 3 routes due to constantly putting it off, so I'm nowhere close to any other if the spin-offs in the nasuverse, but still, a bit excited at this. |
    |
| I wasn't expecting this,but I'm pretty hyped. |
| Shaft is actually a better fit than Ufo for Extra. Though I'd say the plot of a single route of Extra doesn't even have enough material for one cour, so I wonder what they'll do about that. Don't really like Saber, but then same for Caster too so ah well, w/e. Fai said: Also in this cases, Nasu is literally the writer for the anime. AS in not just some ideas and scenes. All of it. And the first F/E game could use a little tweaking there and here in terms of story to flow better. Well he was the writer for a significant amount of material in GO and UBW that you complain about too, but don't let that stop you. |
| Another Fate anime? Count me in! |
 |
| No. and supervised the rest and for UBW he writes a script and send it to Ufo and they re-write again to fit a tv series True, but he did still want and/or approve some of the changes to the anime vs the porn game. |
Dab1za9 said: eh as far as i know for main story he only wrote the beginning and Higishade and Sakurai are writing the rest unless you mean the events. This is veering off topic, but he oversees and edits the rest as he wants. and yeah i realize that but he does have more freedom now on Extra than UBW. Yes, that is true. |
| Shaft and Fate is a good combo. Will be looking forward to this now I don't have to play the game. |
 |
| While I am super hyped because I like this game very much and SHAFT is my favorite studio there is some things that bugs me. 1. Objectively I would say that this is a rather mediocre game but I like it, but will it be a good adaptation and will it make a profit? 2. Will Tamamo be in this? (Played through the game 3 times with her) 3. Will this anime be interesting to the ones who have never played the game? But overall I think that SHAFT will be the best studio for this kind of anime and I think that they will do a good job. I also hope they will go with female protag but if they go with Saber they probably will go with the male one. |
SayaVikingMar 27, 2016 5:17 AM
| Shaft? Okay. This ia already dropped. |
More topics from this board
» 'Black★★Rock Shooter: Dawn Fall' Reveals Additional Cast, First PromoDatRandomDude - Feb 11, 2022 |
11 |
by nisafitri
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» Original Anime Movie 'A New Dawn' Announced for 2025DatRandomDude - Apr 23 |
5 |
by dimidrum
»»
Yesterday, 3:41 PM |
|
» 'Mahoutsukai no Yakusoku' Announces Production Staff, CastDatRandomDude - Yesterday |
4 |
by Memore
»»
Yesterday, 1:40 PM |
|
» 'Maougun Saikyou no Majutsushi wa Ningen datta' Announces Supporting CastHyperion_PS - Yesterday |
0 |
by Hyperion_PS
»»
Yesterday, 12:19 PM |
|
» 'Suki demo Kirai na Amanojaku' Reveals Additional Cast, TrailerHyperion_PS - Yesterday |
1 |
by RobertBobert
»»
Yesterday, 11:45 AM |