| If it was a good anime sure. Depending on what the anime is about it could fit. |
| That's not moe. |
 |
kenjigreato said: a magical fat girls anime would honestly be amazing.Narmy said: That's not moe. Fat cannot be Moe? BubbleGum_ said: If it was a good anime sure. Depending on what the anime is about it could fit. What kind of anime do you think it would fit? Magic Girls? Harem? Serious Drama? Shonen Fighting? |
| How fat? Obesity is nothing to be proud of, it's ugly. Idk why but in anime dudes can be represented as slim, slightly chubby or absolutely obese but when it comes to chicks it's either slim or absolutely morbidly obese.. But on topic: probably not.. |
fairygood said: kenjigreato said: a magical fat girls anime would honestly be amazing.Fat cannot be Moe? What kind of anime do you think it would fit? Magic Girls? Harem? Serious Drama? Shonen Fighting? the new series puella magi madoka hamburger |
| I CELEBRATE myself, And what I assume you shall assume, For every atom belonging to me as good belongs to you. |
| Accel World will watch it while eating pork ribs. |
   I envy your delusion; I wish I could live in it  |
| If they didn't make the character's personality something that is heavily influenced by their weight in an extremely unbelievable manner then I might watch it. Most fat male protagonists I've seen in manga were depicted as failures in life and generally disgusting otakus. I'd like it if the authors of such work didn't implement such ridiculous stereotypes into their stories, but I guess that's what anime and manga are usually all about. |
I'm also filled with pure-hearted ulterior motives. |
kenjigreato said: I was thinking a serious drama with a bit of comedy maybe the main protagonist could have anorexia and wouldnt actually be fat, but would often be shown like that because that's how she sees herself and it could be about what its like having a body image disorder. I'm just saying what comes to mind lmaoBubbleGum_ said: If it was a good anime sure. Depending on what the anime is about it could fit. What kind of anime do you think it would fit? Magic Girls? Harem? Serious Drama? Shonen Fighting? but I mean, I could see an anime like that being interesting. |
kenjigreato said: 4blaze2it0 said: How fat? Obesity is nothing to be proud of, it's ugly. Idk why but in anime dudes can be represented as slim, slightly chubby or absolutely obese but when it comes to chicks it's either slim or absolutely morbidly obese.. But on topic: probably not.. I guess we can start with 25 BMI? Which is just classified as barely overweight. Most anime girls are around 155-165cm and around 50Kg. The lowest is probably 40Kg You can check VNDB . Honestly I am not saying I am supporting anything , I personally like anime the way it is. I am more curious if there are people that don't enjoy anime because of the way it is. 25 BMI isn't even fat. I'd watch if upto 30 BMI but it starts looking ugly beyond probably 31-33.. |
kenjigreato said: Bro, Anime are set in Japan. They are Asian. It's more common for them to be underweight than overweight. Don't work out? Their metabolism still makes them skinny.I find it interesting we need a plot because there are plenty of people in real life that are fat . Don't workout and eat a lot would be the most simple explaination for most . But in the anime world where about 2% of the population is fat , we need to come up with plot reasons. The main dude in Accel World is around 31. He's drawn almost like a ball. Fuck the Accel World kid. He's not drawn realistically, both height and weight. |
kenjigreato said: But that's not fat though...............4blaze2it0 said: 25 BMI isn't even fat. I'd watch if upto 30 BMI but it starts looking ugly beyond probably 31-33.. Considering everyone's 'waifu' ranges from about 18-22 at MAX. 25 would be enough to look different. |
 NasalShark said: I'd love to squeeze your nipples until they look like a purple slushie, Senpai. |
kenjigreato said: 4blaze2it0 said: 25 BMI isn't even fat. I'd watch if upto 30 BMI but it starts looking ugly beyond probably 31-33.. Considering everyone's 'waifu' ranges from about 18-22 at MAX. 25 would be enough to look different. The main dude in Accel World is around 31. He's drawn almost like a ball. Hes 31? My dad says he used to be 28 (now he's 25) and I don't remember him being all that fat or anything.. I guess I've got it wrong then. In that case I change my answer to 26-28. |
| If it's an ecchi or harem nope. Please don't hurt me feminzis. If it's not and it works well with the story then maybe. |
 |
| If they're chubby like Kanako or the girls of Chubbiness or other Marshmallow Girl groups, sure, but SSBBW is a no. Chubby is hot, morbidly obese is not. |
 |
| Well I don't watch anime solely because the girls are skinny or average. |
 |
kenjigreato said: What are you asking for? First you say you want it to be realistic because there are more fat people in the real world but Anime is set in Japan, targeted towards Japanese people. Therefore, most characters will be skinny.Mayuka said: Bro, Anime are set in Japan. They are Asian. It's more common for them to be underweight than overweight. Don't work out? Their metabolism still makes them skinny. Fuck the Accel World kid. He's not drawn realistically, both height and weight. Anime set in Fantasy land , Anime set in Fake Germany , Anime set in Future. All have the same no. of fat people. I like it that way , but I am just saying , its not limited to 'Anime set in Japan.' |
| I wouldn't watch a show if either was portrayed as fat, like Accel World. I hate that MC, half decent show, but he ruins it. Obesity is not something that should be accepted as ok, it's not. |
 |
kenjigreato said: Necromia said: If it's an ecchi or harem nope. Please don't hurt me feminzis. If it's not and it works well with the story then maybe. Would you watch Spice and Wolf with a fatter Holo? Yes, holo is still a great character. |
|
kenjigreato said: Jayden said: I wouldn't watch a show if either was portrayed as fat, like Accel World. I hate that MC, half decent show, but he ruins it. Obesity is not something that should be accepted as ok, it's not. Don't worry I couldn't watch the show because of the MC too. But also because hes really very meh as an MC , I can never feel like I will ever believe in him as the MC. Yeah exactly, if he was a short fat badass, I would probably finish it. It's currently on hold atm since the story is still interesting. |
|
| Sure, as long as they have a certain charm. |
| I generally avoid all-female cast shows in the first place. |
 |
| If the story's good, sure. If the story's shit, then no. This isn't rocket science people. |
| I think gin no saji have plus size girl (rich cow girl). Another one probably the chubby girl from maken ki. Most girl is not your typical slender type i think. Cant remember any other plus size beside the breast area. |
| Nah, i dont think sharing anime ratings in signature is cool thing. Here, stare at this pointless signature instead. |
iwansquall said: but they made her fat as a joke to make her skinny later on.. like araki from area no kishiI think gin no saji have plus size girl (rich cow girl). |
Calling the kettle black, are we? Anyway, some insn't bad and can still be moe.  Ironically, the unrealistically enormous boobs often drawn in anime are what I find unattractive.  |
 |
| if it is to show they getting trolled because of their appearance and then murdered, sure! |
| yeah I love big bitches I don't get tired |
| Eat Me |
If we're using the Asian definition of "overweight" set at a BMI of 23 I think it could work. Although 25 is considered simply "overweight" in the US it's considered "obese" in Japan. Only around 3% of Japanese people have a BMI over 30 while around 30% of Americans have a BMI that high. These girls are considered overweight in Japan but white people of that size would be completely healthy. I would watch it. I doubt it would have the same effect here, but it would still be fun to watch. |
  |
| Sure, I can count on anime to make big girls look cute. See I mean look, Kanako is hella cute and then some. |
  |
| If it has a great story, then yes i would. |
 |
| Yeah, I would. Just to see something different. |
 |
| If the anime is good then what is the problem? |
| "i never met a chick that was too thick for me" -viktor vaughn |
| I would still watch it regardless, it would be different too see |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Why not? If they're well-developed, the writing is good, the art is good, the story is good, why not? |
| WEAPONS - My blog, for reviews of music, anime, books, and other things |
| I don't typically like series that are "all-female" in the first place since they are usually moe shows that are just "meh" to me. However I doubt I would watch a show with all fat girls. The problem is more in the fact that the author felt the need to make them all fat, it is almost undoubtedly very strained and poorly written. Like that comic book writer that decided to make a series with a fat female lead, I wouldn't be caught dead reading it. It is just a gimmick marketed to a certain crowd that wants to pride themselves on being "tolerant", meanwhile the material is shitty. Having said that, if it turned out to be an amazing series, then sure I would give it a shot. |
 |
| Depends on the plot really. It'd have to be really good. |
╮ (. ❛ ᴗ ❛.) ╭ |
More topics from this board
» Are you e-famous? Are you an Internet celebrity?DesuMaiden - 8 hours ago |
18 |
by Kenrin
»»
15 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Do you live with regrets?Lightskynight - 6 hours ago |
11 |
by Lost_Viking
»»
18 minutes ago |
|
» Is English your native language? ( 1 2 )DesuMaiden - Apr 16 |
52 |
by Oshieteoshiete4
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» What do you think about law enforcement (police) in your country?Sad - Apr 16 |
24 |
by bevarnow
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» I'm currently on a keto diet.scarydragon - 7 hours ago |
8 |
by Zettaiken
»»
2 hours ago |