Winter 2016 Power Ranking Committee Announcements and Check-ins  List of Shows in Winter 2016-http://anichart.net/winter Salutations fellow seasonal watchers, are you ready for the Winter 2016 Season? Want to the have a little extra fun watching? Why not join the Power Rankings Committee ^.^. The Power Rankings Committee is debuting our new system for our 4th season of this feature in the Anime Guild. We want to provide a system where more of our members can be participant in the feature and our answer to that is now having two different classes of watchers Casual Class- 5 show voting Titan Class- 10 show voting -The Power Rankings is a 4-sequence feature with voting for what you believe is the best shows after week 3,6,9, and 13(end of the season) -Missing two sumbit dates results in the discontinuing of your participation -Sequels are allowed but Shorts and Long-running shonens are not -Hand-ins of your list will be done by PM to Schizoidmouse with 1 being your first and 5 or 10 being your cut-off show -Then two separate threads will be made featuring the opinions of the collective involved. -Want an example of how the Power Rankings Posts look like, here is one of the threads http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1451110 -The number of shows that will make the cut-off on the thread will be determined based on the number of people involved at a later time. -You are also allowed to join the PRC Skype Chat once you join. Casual Class Sign-ups 1. Silyon 2. Jayling_ 3. KawaiiAnime69 4. vic10tor2 5. Hibbington 6. Vladkob(moved to Titan) 7. JJack 8. MNWmanga Titan Class Sign-ups 1. AngelShiva 2. Selinea 3. HaXXspetten 4. Jinkaku_Nijuu 5. Rayaxe 6. kyonJIE 7. Schzoidmouse 8. Splashcloud 9. SpFcArdent 10. ghostreconspart *Red means that a list submission has been missed* *Crimson means that two list submission has been missed and suspended from participation* |
HibbingtonMay 3, 2016 9:02 AM
  |
| Ooo! Interesting! I will probably watch around 5 shows during Winter so I guess you can sign me up to the casual class. |
| I'd like to sign up for titan class, but can I switch to casual if it turns out I don't watch that much ? |
 |
AngelShiva said: I'd like to sign up for titan class, but can I switch to casual if it turns out I don't watch that much ? I don't see that as being a problem. |
|
| Casual por favor |
| I'm up for titan class only if there's two rounds of voting as we've been doing. There are only like, 25 new shows, and some will probably wash out as shorts, and some already look really bad and I'm not up to blindly committing to ten all new shows. Five crappy shows, I can handle. Ten bad shows, not so much. Hibbington said: AngelShiva said: I'd like to sign up for titan class, but can I switch to casual if it turns out I don't watch that much ? I don't see that as being a problem. The only issue is, if there's separate voting, there's the chance that someone would have to catch up on five new shows upon making the switch. I mean, the likelihood of absolutely no overlap is small, but playing any sort of catch up isn't much fun, as I can currently attest. Plus, you might not even like majority of the five shows the other group is watching since you had no input in what they were. |
Selinea said: I'm up for titan class only if there's two rounds of voting as we've been doing. There are only like, 25 new shows, and some will probably wash out as shorts, and some already look really bad and I'm not up to blindly committing to ten all new shows. Five crappy shows, I can handle. Ten bad shows, not so much. Hibbington said: I don't see that as being a problem. The only issue is, if there's separate voting, there's the chance that someone would have to catch up on five new shows upon making the switch. I mean, the likelihood of absolutely no overlap is small, but playing any sort of catch up isn't much fun, as I can currently attest. Plus, you might not even like majority of the five shows the other group is watching since you had no input in what they were. Thanks both of you for your reply. I'll give a try for titan class then :) (finger cross that that season won't suck that much :D) Note : do you have a list of authorized anime ? Shorts are not but are Detective Conan, Diamond no Ace, etc. authorized ? |
AngelShivaDec 6, 2015 11:02 AM
|
AngelShiva said: Thanks both of you for your reply. I'll give a try for titan class then :) (finger cross that that season won't suck that much :D) Note : do you have a list of authorized anime ? Shorts are not but are Detective Conan, Diamond no Ace, etc. authorized ? Yeah, I'm with you, winter seasons are always rough If we go by precedent, carryovers from the previous season (so in this case, Garo, Gundam: Iron Blooded Orphans, etc.) only need a majority vote to be authorized. Given that Gate/Akagami no Shirayuki-hime were 1-cour shows from just a season ago more, I'd assume majority rules for those too. For any show that requires more than ~13 episodes of catch-up, there needs to a unanimous vote before it's authorized, since it's a big time commitment to ask of somebody who isn't caught up and thus everybody needs to agree to it. I can say with 99.9% certainty that you'll never be able to swing a unanimous Detective Conan vote, it's just too big of a juggernaut, XD. Any super long show is probably not worth even mentioning, (One Piece, Gintama, etc) fortunately or unfortunately, depending on how you feel about those shows. |
| Everyone isn't forced to watch the same shows anymore, were getting rid of that. |
|
| What, so everyone just picks whatever shows they feel like watching and sends in their top 5 or 10 with every edition? Is that what you mean? Sounds fair in theory, but I'm not sure how the overall ranking will be decided in that case |
  |
HaXXspetten said: What, so everyone just picks whatever shows they feel like watching and sends in their top 5 or 10 with every edition? Is that what you mean? Sounds fair in theory, but I'm not sure how the overall ranking will be decided in that case Top-Heavy Point System. |
|
| I see. Well in that case I guess I can do Titan after all. Wasn't too interested in Winter but I've already got 5 Fall leftovers and at least 7-8 new ones I was planning on trying out |
| |
HaXXspetten said: I see. Well in that case I guess I can do Titan after all. Wasn't too interested in Winter but I've already got 5 Fall leftovers and at least 7-8 new ones I was planning on trying out Okay, just remember that you need to keep at least 10 of them for the voting if you drop some. |
|
Hibbington said: >.>HaXXspetten said: I see. Well in that case I guess I can do Titan after all. Wasn't too interested in Winter but I've already got 5 Fall leftovers and at least 7-8 new ones I was planning on trying out Okay, just remember that you need to keep at least 10 of them for the voting if you drop some. Look at the size of my dropped list and that'll give you a hint |
| |
HaXXspetten said: Hibbington said: >.>Okay, just remember that you need to keep at least 10 of them for the voting if you drop some. Look at the size of my dropped list and that'll give you a hint Got it I'm reading sources for a paper I was just making a quick point XD. |
|
Hibbington said: Everyone isn't forced to watch the same shows anymore, were getting rid of that. Okay, then Angel's question stands. Are the available shows full length, 20 minutes, at least 10 episodes anime listed on anichart? Or just any show that airs 10+ episodes during the winter season? Edit: Okay, this "The number of shows that will make the cut-off on the thread will be determined based on the number of people involved at a later time." finally sorta makes sense to me, but wouldn't it be easier to just list everything? If it gets too messy at the bottom, shows with less than a certain amount of points could get thrown into an "honorable mentions" spoiler. ((You'd have to count down in the tabulating process, unless you want omissions to count as 6s for casual and 12s for titans or something)) |
SelineaDec 8, 2015 7:29 PM
| I'm new to the group but I'd like to participate - I should be able to watch 10+ shows this upcoming season so please sign me up for the Titan class. ^^ Also, how do I join the skype group? Should I add one of you? |
Jinkaku_Nijuu said: Also, how do I join the skype group? Should I add one of you? Will settle that once your locked in on participating. |
|
Hibbington said: Jinkaku_Nijuu said: Also, how do I join the skype group? Should I add one of you? Will settle that once your locked in on participating. When you'll send him the info, could you send me the info too ? |
|
AngelShiva said: Hibbington said: Will settle that once your locked in on participating. When you'll send him the info, could you send me the info too ? Don't worry. I'll message everyone when the times comes. |
|
| TITAN CLASS FOR ME! COME AT ME CASUALS!  |
Gimme a Llama on DeviantArt: https://rayaxe2.deviantart.com/ Be who you wanna be ~ Barbie girl |
| I'm back, have been slacking recently with being a weeboo. Been a little inactive from watching recently, getting through the fall season as fast as I could and the damn leftovers gosh. Concrete revolutio is AOTY btw I need something to force me to not slack, so (titan class) cause lets get beastly *cracks knuckles I'm ready but please don't make me watch any of the winter sequals, they are all crap and I haven't even tried to dive back into their prequals |
| My life is boring cause I'm boring If you're not at school what can you do, you stare at a screen of bright pixels |
kyonJIE said: I'm back, have been slacking recently with being a weeboo. Been a little inactive from watching recently, getting through the fall season as fast as I could and the damn leftovers gosh. Concrete revolutio is AOTY btw I need something to force me to not slack, so (titan class) cause lets get beastly *cracks knuckles I'm ready but please don't make me watch any of the winter sequals, they are all crap and I haven't even tried to dive back into their prequals XD are you admitting to being a weeb? Brave. But just make sure you know what weabo means https://uk.answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20080829221822AAaFBfo LET THE CHALLENGE COMMENSE! soon.... IDK... just forget I said anything. |
Gimme a Llama on DeviantArt: https://rayaxe2.deviantart.com/ Be who you wanna be ~ Barbie girl |
Rayaxe said: XD are you admitting to being a weeb? Brave. But just make sure you know what weabo means  Let me facepalm while I process that I'm not a prepubescent white simpleton. Though I have collected some chinese translated manga, is that a start? |
| My life is boring cause I'm boring If you're not at school what can you do, you stare at a screen of bright pixels |
| Another casual scrub has joined the crew 8) |
 |
| Is a Skype account needed to join? |
 |
Splashcloud said: Is a Skype account needed to join? Not necessarily, being in the skype group makes it easier to communicate with you about what is currently going on and an easy way to hand in your list to Sean. We'd advise you join the skype group though. |
|
Hibbington said: Splashcloud said: <br />Is a Skype account needed to join? <br /> Not necessarily, being in the skype group makes it easier to communicate with you about what is currently going on and an easy way to hand in your list to Sean.<br /> <br /> We'd advise you join the skype group though. I'll join as Titan class. I think I made a Skype account a while ago, but I'll have to find the information for it. |
|
| i think i can join casual list :) |
| Drop me in the filthy casual pile please hubbs |
 |
| Well, I'm going to watch around 25 anime this season so I choose Titan class if it's available. |
ArdentDec 27, 2015 6:05 AM
 |
| Think I'm going to try this out. Doesn't seem to bad. I plan to watch 12-13 anime next season. Sign me up for titan I guess. |
| So we are officially changing this over from a sign-up thread to a tracking thread to help our admins know who has sent in their lists and how haven't when the time comes. |
|
| I have 2 questions : 1) do I need to give only 10 animes, or can I give more ? 2) If I started to watch an anime but decide to drop it at week 5, is it okay even though I gave my thought on it for the week 3 batch ? (and even if I still watched 10+ animes) or should the 10 animes I gave on week 3 be the same for all the season ? |
|
| Yes, you can only hand in a list of your Top 10 for Titan. Yes, you can drop something on week 5 even though it was on your list in part 1 of the PRC rankings. No, the 10 anime don't have to be the same throughout the season but you do need to be watching and caught up on 10 or more. |
|
| Another question n_n What's the the deadline fort week 3 ? |
|
| I think Ajin was the last anime to start this season and that has its third episode released on the 29th of January so I guess that ought to be the deadline |
| |
HaXXspetten said: I think Ajin was the last anime to start this season and that has its third episode released on the 29th of January so I guess that ought to be the deadline Still waiting for Sean to give the official announcement but that seems like the way it will probably go. |
|
Hibbington said: HaXXspetten said: I think Ajin was the last anime to start this season and that has its third episode released on the 29th of January so I guess that ought to be the deadline Still waiting for Sean to give the official announcement but that seems like the way it will probably go. Oh, okay, thanks for the answers ! I thought that it was this week end and wanted an early notice to plan my schedule :) So I guess I have even more time to be even more late on my "need to watch" animes XD |
|
AngelShiva said: Hibbington said: Still waiting for Sean to give the official announcement but that seems like the way it will probably go. Oh, okay, thanks for the answers ! I thought that it was this week end and wanted an early notice to plan my schedule :) So I guess I have even more time to be even more late on my "need to watch" animes XD The main goal is to be completed with week 3 but not everything airs in 7 days. So it is determining if the shows in question are too far into week 4. |
|
| So here is the plan. Lists will be due by 29th. You'll send them to me through PM. You can either send it to me through skype or MAL PM On the 30th I will make the PRC Part 1 Thread. |
|
| Once you believe you have your list ready your free to send it to me, I honest would suggest sending it before the 29th so that you don't forget -.^. I'm honestly curious how many will actually remember. |
|
| I guess I just keep doing this as a daily reminder to hand in your lists. I have 3 out of the 19 so far. So there is a good amount of you that still need to send it in. |
|
| So i'll probably do the posts right when I get up on Saturday my time, so I'd say you all have 30 hours to get your lists in. If your not caught up, you'll have to make the decision or not to send in your lists still. |
|
| So I got some good news for some stragglers. Some things came up and I'm going to have to push back posting the threads until Saturday night so that means the 30 hours left has been reset to now. |
|
| So just to keep you guys and gals up to speed. The next submit date is on February 19th. Sean should be resuming his duties as well. |
|
| Nice soliloquy you've got going there |
| |
HaXXspetten said: Nice soliloquy you've got going there It's sexy right -.^? Not everyone is in the skype chat. So every update I have to make a post. |
|
More topics from this board
Sticky: » Spring 2024 Power Ranking Committee Sign-upsHibbington - Mar 13 |
44 |
by Tsuxken
»»
Yesterday, 5:35 AM |
|
Sticky: » 【Anime Guild】Discord Invitation Thread ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Hibbington - Aug 7, 2016 |
1280 |
by Hibbington
»»
Apr 17, 10:19 AM |
|
Sticky: » ❤~Staff Thread~❤ ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Mikochondria - Sep 19, 2014 |
1164 |
by RisaK
»»
Apr 15, 1:31 PM |
|
» [CLOSED] Winter 2024 AOTS Card Edition: BokuYaba Season 2coziitsu - Apr 9 |
28 |
by coziitsu
»»
Apr 14, 6:15 AM |
|
Sticky: » [Toriyama Class] Power Ranking Committee Winter 2024: Part 4/4 FINALEKANLen09 - Apr 9 |
1 |
by KANLen09
»»
Apr 9, 9:02 PM |