elevenletters said: Xinil said: Hey MAL! .... Our current list of planned changes are:
Although I'm opposed to this change, can you try to at least change the format of the 'favorite' section so that it takes less space? Perhaps something like this:  They won't go for it because it wouldn't work on mobile. I also think it looks kind of bad, but that's irrelevant. Lirina said: - Comment box moved on top of Profile Comments, not at the end of the page. That would be terrible. I don't use the comment section that often so I don't want to have to see it at the top.. It's not being moved to the top of the profile, just to the top of the comments section. Like on YouTube. |
vegetablespiritMay 11, 2015 11:02 PM
| How about have something like "My Panel" where you can customize what you want and what you don't want to show on your profile. Like for some people they don't read manga so they don;t need the manga section. Also maybe add in something like favourite ED/OP or something similar |
| I don't wanna sound like a party crasher, but maybe we shouldn't change too much - I got heavily used to the way my profile looks now ^_^ What I'd aprecciate would be an option to block out these FB, Twitter etc. icons as I use neither. As the Malgraph subpage is about to close, what about such achievements here then? For sure it's not perpetually the best way to post the badges as screenshots as that will, as mentioned before, unneccesarily increase the amount of pictures on your profile. |
  |
vodall said: Who wont go for it? Also the mobile site doesn't have a top 10 function on the profilesThey won't go for it because it wouldn't work on mobile. I also think it looks kind of bad, but that's irrelevant. Happosama said: http://graph.anime.sc/As the Malgraph subpage is about to close, what about such achievements here then? For sure it's not perpetually the best way to post the badges as screenshots as that will, as mentioned before, unneccesarily increase the amount of pictures on your profile. |
 |
John_h said: Everyone who has watched about a hundred shows will at least share five or ten series with nearly everyone, so it's not exactly a surprise that we share some of the most well-known anime around. There are two viable options as I see it: Either add the scores so that you can instantly see whether or not your opinions are the same, or remove the thing altogether. If you want an in-depth comparison, there's a seperate page already, so I don't see much of a reason to go for what I said first, as others have already mentioned that they don't see much of a reason for the information as well. Favorites also have an impact on overall favorites in MAL. I imagine it's easy for individuals to have a top 5 of current seasons. So the other 5 slots can be reserved for all-time favorites. That will carry some weight in MAL overall favorites and lead to better accuracy. |
 |
elevenletters said: vodall said: [/spoiler] They won't go for it because it wouldn't work on mobile. I also think it looks kind of bad, but that's irrelevant. Mobile's irrelevant. There's a mobile version of this site and this change doesn't have to implemented there. Regardless, the key words in my post are "change the format of the 'favorite' section so that it takes less space" and "something like this". I don't think you know how UX design works, which may explain why your example currently looks as it is. Everything needs to be as functionable and as easy as possible, but for this to be true, the amount of space something takes barely matters. Your suggestion is not only hard on mobile users, but it also omits vital information that is currently readily available. It literally does not add anything to the site, only takes away; it's a step backwards. As Undim noted, I'm not the one saying it has to work on mobile sites, but based upon their recent changes, the devs definitely are. Even so, mobile web traffic is over half of all web traffic — that is very far from being irrelevant. |
vegetablespiritMay 12, 2015 4:46 AM
elevenletters said: Even so, mobile web traffic is over half of all web traffic — that is very far from being irrelevant. Let me rephrase that: "Mobile's irrelevant because there's a mobile version of this site" In other words: "Mobile users remain unaffected since my request doesn't concern the mobile version of the site." There. thing is, they have been changing much stuff on the desktop version just because it was causing some problems on the mobile version so you can't really say that the mobile version is "independent". We are just making suppositions here but we can't guarantee it would work properly in both |
 "In the past few months since we met, I've shared many memories with Nagato. Though I've also shared memories with Haruhi, Asahina-san and Koizumi, I found that I've experienced more events with Nagato in particular. In fact, every situation seems to involve her. I might as well mention this, she's probably the only person to cause the bell within me to shake the most vigorously..." ~ Kyon, TMOSH |
| Maybe on your profile page when you switch between Home, Reviews, Recommendations, Clubs, Friends it doesn't reload the page? It gets a bit annoying. In the Clubs tab clubs could have thumbnails? Oh and please don't remove Random Anime and Manga. I kinda like it. |
 |
| YES INCREASED FAVOURITES!! CAN'T WAIT TO ADD ROSE OF VERSAILLES |
 |
Looking back at the previous pages, some of the suggestions are along the lines of:
|
Ry-sama said: You already have the about me for pictures, pretty pointless to add a cover photo option.Input like a cover photo type thing to your profile, makes it more personalized. And Possibility of Favourite Anime opening and closing songs to profile? |
|
Radiene said: Ry-sama said: You already have the about me for pictures, pretty pointless to add a cover photo option.Input like a cover photo type thing to your profile, makes it more personalized. And Possibility of Favourite Anime opening and closing songs to profile? exactly what I said before v -Panda_Hero- said: Lirina said: Can we make the profile page like the "my panel" view where you can move stuff around? Can we get different background colours for different sections of the profile pages? (Probably not, but I ask anyway.) Also, I'm for a cover picture similar to the one that facebook has. oh, please, no >.< we already have the "about me" section to put images and layouts and such Give people too many customization options and everyone goes crazy with it xD Ry-sama said: And Possibility of Favourite Anime opening and closing songs to profile? and what do you mean with the anime opening and closing songs thing for profile? o.o |
| "In the past few months since we met, I've shared many memories with Nagato. Though I've also shared memories with Haruhi, Asahina-san and Koizumi, I found that I've experienced more events with Nagato in particular. In fact, every situation seems to involve her. I might as well mention this, she's probably the only person to cause the bell within me to shake the most vigorously..." ~ Kyon, TMOSH |
I think for the outdated sites such as Aim, Skype, MSN, etc instead of removing them maybe put the new social media sites like Tumblr and Instagram? |
lifehurts said: Oh yeah I mentioned this a couple posts above :b But yeah Something like the panel would suffice for a upgrade, since Our profile is a bit stiff.How about have something like "My Panel" where you can customize what you want and what you don't want to show on your profile. Like for some people they don't read manga so they don;t need the manga section. Also maybe add in something like favourite ED/OP or something similar http://myanimelist.net/editprofile.php?go=panelsettings As for your other suggestion.. Its up for debate and I wouldn't mind it since most things are optional anyways. |
 Behold of my awesomeness~ controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted. But my feels. |
Ry-sama said: Sounds like a pain. You'd have to create separate pages for OP & EDs, and I think they're fine where it is rn, at the bottom of each entry.And Possibility of Favourite Anime opening and closing songs to profile? |
 |
Aridus said: Maybe on your profile page when you switch between Home, Reviews, Recommendations, Clubs, Friends it doesn't reload the page? It gets a bit annoying. In the Clubs tab clubs could have thumbnails? Oh and please don't remove Random Anime and Manga. I kinda like it. Everything loads really fast for me, so Its barely noticeable. Perhaps its your internet connection? :O Thumbnails? And Yes I agree I like Random things!! Its too bad users see It as a nuisance or something >< IDK why. |
RascoMay 13, 2015 6:11 PM
Behold of my awesomeness~ controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted. But my feels. |
| Notifications for Disabled Comments Basically you get a notification when you're going to reply to someone who's recently disabled their comments. I know a lot of people who regret writing a huge paragraph only to reply to a disabled comment section. You do get a notification, but it's after you write a reply. Why am I getting this afterwards? Make it show up when I'm ready to reply. The comment box shouldn't even appear. |
RothMay 14, 2015 10:53 AM
|
| Use Lazarus: Form Recovery add-on, it's a life-saver |
   |
| I like how you can see the ratings of your friends in the stat page of an anime. Actually, imo, it would be even more useful if you could see the ratings of determined users who you think are trustworthy or have similar tastes, rather than your friends. I say this because not always that kind of users are prone to accept your friendship, so you can't take full advantage from that function. Edit: Ok, I just realized this isn't really fitting for this topic. I'm going to open a topic in the suggestion section. |
Aria-da-CapoMay 14, 2015 8:53 AM
| Add profile view count in place of one of those things you're removing in the details list. |
chaosflame5 said: *A favourite genre section would be nice too on a profile page. *A lot of people tend to re-watch anime or re-read mangas. "Re-watching" and "Re-reading" is displayed, but I would also like to have the number of re-watches and re-reads to be displayed as well, or even "Re-watched/Re-read x times" (x for any number). If people see a "Completed" label for a re-watched anime or re-read manga, they wouldn't know if this person has re-watched this entry or did that person finished an entry for the first time. So this should clear it up. I would second these two. Also, how about a "Favourite Studios" part on your profile? |
| Just don't fuck it up please (the profile feature is easily the best feature after the anime/manga list), and make new additions optional. |
 |
Serhiyko said: Thanks! :)Use Lazarus: Form Recovery add-on, it's a life-saver |
|
vodall said: Also, what about adding a + option in the recent updates? If I'm watching a single series, I really don't like having to go to my list every time to update my progress. Like this:  Here you are: MAL Plus in the Recent Updates |
|
Serhiyko said: Does this also work for when you're in the Panel? That's where I think it would be the most useful.vodall said: Also, what about adding a + option in the recent updates? If I'm watching a single series, I really don't like having to go to my list every time to update my progress. Like this: Here you are: MAL Plus in the Recent Updates |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| It's not working for me :/ |
|
Okashi_sama said: Doesn't make much sense, program =/= userscript. Some people would rather just do everything on the site using an add on they already have rather than use a different program.Why not just download Taiga if you're as far as using a user-script?! Roth said: Great that that was finally fixed.Appreciating the new spoiler change. |
Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
| add the ability to add 10 favorites done. |
| :3 |
IntroverTurtle said: Does this also work for when you're in the Panel? That's where I think it would be the most useful. Good point, it does now in the updated version Roth said: It's not working for me :/ It only works for anime, I was going to mention it and totally forgot. Manga uses one additional parameter and I have no idea how to get it without additional requests |
SerhiykoMay 15, 2015 4:13 AM
|
IntroverTurtle said: wait what is this change? Did alignment not work or something?Roth said: Great that that was finally fixed.Appreciating the new spoiler change. I'd check the changelog but it doesn't seem be be updated anymore |
|
| Is there any news as to when this is planned to be changed? Just gonna say threads tab again. Am I the only one, really? Awww. Friends tab could use work. I made a separate suggestion about that already. Seems people don't really care, though. |
 |
| I was thinking, instead of the current PM system (which is honestly pretty bad since managing your inbox and stuff is incredibly awkward), can't you just make it so that you can post profile comments incognito? As in let's say a checkmark box when you post a comment on someone's profile so that only the sender and the recipent can see the message when they're logged in, but nobody else can. It'd have the same effect as PMs in practicality, but it'd be way more convenient as quite frankly it's waaaayyy smoother to talk to people via com-to-com than PMs as it is atm You could possibly even maintain the notification feature if you want but link it to private comments only, and have a "message read" checkmark box to fill in to make the notification disappear, same way you do when you open an unread mail |
  |
Undim said: Syrup- said: wait what is this change? Did alignment not work or something? I'd check the changelog but it doesn't seem be be updated anymore Re-hiding the spoiler would put the button to the left margin, regardless of how it was aligned before it was shown. It's always been broke until now. I don't see any problems with the fix. Using Firefox btw. |
|
Phraze said: I don't see any problems with the fix. Using Firefox btw. There aren't any problems with the fix, that's the point |
|
| Just a random one. Display Picture Gallery. Like, when someone wants to switch Display Pictures, it turns into a hassle... but if you add in a DP Gallery, you can switch in between the DP's that are pre-loaded into the Gallery. For instance, I love my Lapis Lazuli DP... but I also want to use a Patchouli Knowledge DP... So I just load both in, and I can choose when I want to switch in between the two! One day I want the Lapis, Just switch to it... Another day I want Patchouli... No Problem! Just switch to it~ Of course, a Limit to how many DP's are in the Gallery would be nice... Around a Limit of 3 or 4 would be nice. |
Roth said: Eh, which button are you referring to? Both the one on your Panel, the one in the dropdown tab as well as the one on your About Me section all lead to the Personal tab for profile editing at least..This is getting annoying, you guys should fix the default link for Editing your Profile. It links to the Panel Settings and not Personal. |
| |
| No nevermind, lol. Forget about that, that was the script. Just fixed it :> Deleted my post. |
|
| A notification for profile comments that appears in the right with the username, would be nice. |
|
| Favourites increased to 10 is all I need :D |
 |
Azurea said: Yes Keep the randomness ALIVE (see what I mean by possibilities?).. Anyways good feature idea sounds fancy and maybe it could be set to randomize your profile Picture when its refreshed like certain signatures. Just a random one. Display Picture Gallery. Like, when someone wants to switch Display Pictures, it turns into a hassle... but if you add in a DP Gallery, you can switch in between the DP's that are pre-loaded into the Gallery. For instance, I love my Lapis Lazuli DP... but I also want to use a Patchouli Knowledge DP... So I just load both in, and I can choose when I want to switch in between the two! One day I want the Lapis, Just switch to it... Another day I want Patchouli... No Problem! Just switch to it~ Of course, a Limit to how many DP's are in the Gallery would be nice... Around a Limit of 3 or 4 would be nice. And about the limits.. I think it should higher but yeah 4 is a nice even number. Of course I'm not sure how stable this site is but I'm not adding that into account for now(since there is not any major lag present). tsudecimo said: The consensus for this is outstanding and so I hope that our voice's have been heard to get some type of notification for comments. And perhaps maybe even for the forums too..A notification for profile comments that appears in the right with the username, would be nice. Ciarson said: Really? Well I guess some users see it satisfactory enough. (Just like with 5) But I think having a "show all" for more favorites would hit the nail on the head for Complete satisfactory. Favourites increased to 10 is all I need :D |
RascoMay 17, 2015 4:03 PM
Behold of my awesomeness~ controversial and/or sensitive topics likely devolve into the same repetitive, derogatory, abusive, and harassing comments can no longer be posted. But my feels. |
Roth said: Ry-sama said: Sounds like a pain. You'd have to create separate pages for OP & EDs, and I think they're fine where it is rn, at the bottom of each entry.And Possibility of Favourite Anime opening and closing songs to profile? I don't think there is a need to have a page for ED or OP. I mean just link it to the anime that those op and ed belong too should be just fine |
| To all that participated by providing suggestions or constructive criticisms. THANK YOU! I saw a bunch of great ideas that we're excited to implement! For now though, I'm closing down this suggestion thread and will provide an announcement in the future when our profile changes are ready to release. |
More topics from this board
» Add number of episodes and number of members in the advanced search.Yacine2104 - Jan 10 |
8 |
by Alexioos95
»»
3 hours ago |
|
» Local Language districtskuroneko99 - Apr 22 |
5 |
by Luchipher-Zen
»»
Yesterday, 1:02 PM |
|
Poll: » Change picture of favorite character ( 1 2 )gehoti2822 - Nov 12, 2022 |
60 |
by AgravityBoy
»»
Yesterday, 9:09 AM |
|
» Corporate imagesNoctisnox - May 15, 2023 |
19 |
by himanshi122
»»
Apr 19, 5:51 AM |
|
» Reply button should show text that will be quoted.Euthymia_Gerv - Apr 15 |
8 |
by Alexioos95
»»
Apr 18, 10:22 AM |