tsudecimo said: mayukachan said: It's like School Days Very few similarities. yeah |
tsudecimo said: Yeah. It has an omnibus format. My point was that it was another Eroge adaptation with sex in it. And yeah Rumbling Hearts also helps my point even if it's not a harem. Bad example then, Yosuga came after SC and so it doesn't even matter what no. of eroge with sex got adapted later on. Though school days wasn't first eroge anime with sex anyway. |
Inferno_CopFeb 5, 2015 2:36 PM
Workman94 said: It does make your point less true -.- you said that people who like it lack knowledge of other harems,I listed a few of those I watched so.....yeah,it does make your point less true since I,infact have watched other harems T'ch. I said Harem manga and Eroges. Are the ones you listed in either of the these two? |
 |
Workman94 said: tsudecimo said: T'ch. I said Harem manga and Eroges. Are the ones you listed in either of the these two? just because those are adaptations doesn't make it less true...That's like saying a green and red apple are two different fruits What... They type of manga that have sex in them don't usually get adapted. How are you not getting that? Rumbling hearts, White Album 2, and probably a lot of old anime have sex in them, so here. School days is not unique at all. |
|
| Characters act selfish in White Album 2. I also see the MC of rumbling hearts acting cowardly and selfish. Saying the characters of school days are realistic because they are selfish is quite a stretch. |
|
| I don't dislike the show. I like its premise and see some merit in it. Still, I cringe every time somebody mentions realism as a major quality. For a couple of reasons actually: 1-Being realistic in fictional media is not a quality by itself. 2-Any story that doesn't incorporate fantastic elements can be considered realistic anyway. On the other hand, I didn't perceive the whole amount of depth every character seemed to have. Yes, they have motivations but these motivations are flat and feel as if they did only exist to cover a specific role in this story. Is it overhated? I guess. And probably overpraised as well. If you ask me it's not worth that much effort from either side. |
| welll dunno actually , some people says that's its shit and eww and all of that but they keep waching it , well if you hate it drop it . anyway i've seen it , it was crazy but good to watch |
Gholy said: Just because it's a deconstruction It's not in the first place. |
|
| People hate this show (key word here is hate) because it reminds them of the envious times in highschool when they would see some guys who would get all the girls or when their highschool sweatheart cheated on them. It rubs people the wrong way to see a story that turned into non-monogamy. Remember, monogamy is sacred in society especially for people who didn't get laid much. And let's not kid ourselves, the people who tend to watch anime weren't the kids who went to lots of parties in their youths. Nothing wrong with not having those experiences, but it's obvious why people hate this anime more so than an anime where rape is portrayed to not be such a bad thing. Heck there was this popular negative review that said: "The main character in this series has sex with pretty much every girl you'll see in this series, for no apparent reason" But that's just ridiculous. Guys don't need reasons to fuck girls and vice versa. Maybe there are reasons not to but lust is not rational. |
badwolf45f said: Workman94 said: 3. As far as the characters and story goes,I have never seen a more realistic high-school anime than this as the characters act like people would in a situation like this. If you were the main character you would do the same thing,if not,you are either lying or you don't swing that way. The girls also are realistic as they show the different ways a girl could react to the events that took place. If a guy did to me what Makoto did to the girls I would kick his balls but I wouldn't murder him ._. how's that realistic? (talking only on the fem characters) Ha, do you read newspapers? Link 1 Link2 link3 actually, Here you go Plus, today teenagers are exactly like those in the show. Kolios said: Exactly this. |
 |
Kolios said: People hate this show (key word here is hate) because it reminds them of the envious times in highschool when they would see some guys who would get all the girls or when their highschool sweatheart cheated on them. It rubs people the wrong way to see a story that turned into non-monogamy. Remember, monogamy is sacred in society especially for people who didn't get laid much. And let's not kid ourselves, the people who tend to watch anime weren't the kids who went to lots of parties in their youths. Nothing wrong with not having those experiences, but it's obvious why people hate this anime more so than an anime where rape is portrayed to not be such a bad thing. Heck there was this popular negative review that said: "The main character in this series has sex with pretty much every girl you'll see in this series, for no apparent reason" But that's just ridiculous. Guys don't need reasons to fuck girls and vice versa. Maybe there are reasons not to but lust is not rational. Basically. It bothers me how many people dislike School Days just because the character were mean. That was the point the show was trying to drive, but they completely missed the somewhat obvious character motives. |
| Nah, I liked the anime, it gets too much shit, I gave it a 7, because it was good and addicting to watch for me personally, some just hate the MC for being a prick, I say he doesn't deserve the heat. 7/10 |
| Signature removed. |
| No, it deserves all the hate it gets and more And seriously? Workman94 said: Is it just me or is this show overhated? To me this show is probably the most realistic and cleverly executed deconstruction of the harem genre. Realistic? Are you fucking kidding me? So to you "Realistic" means a group of girls willingly having sex with a guy who is denser than a fucking black hole, and a complete dickhead. Yeah okay. And when you say that this deconstructs the Harem genre, no. It doesn't. All it is, is softcore porn. You insult men when you say that we want to be like Makoto. He's a disgusting example of human life, who doesn't even realize he's doing something wrong when he has sex with 7 or 8 girls, AT THE SAME TIME. The only props this show gets from me is that it made me completely despise the main character, more than any other anime MC in existence, and then proceeded to give me a satisfying conclusion, by killing him. |
"You either die an Ashita no Joe, or you live long enough to see yourself become a Naruto."  |
| Well, you cant bang every girl and get happy ending. He failed the routes and got bad ending. like quite a few people stated, this show is overrhated just because most of people are jealous :P Btw, there is a lot of people like Makoto, you just or dont know any or you just dont want to accept, plus, anime is faaaar from softcore porn. TBH, i dont even remember did i see any boobs in this anime. You should give a To Love-ru and Kiss x Sis a try, and if that is not enough i bet we could find some more (softcore ofc) But hey, everyone rate based on their enjoyment and their own criteria. |
| |
| I agree OP. A score of 6.40 doesn't really give the show justice. LPGeneratorx said: No, it deserves all the hate it gets and more And seriously? Workman94 said: Is it just me or is this show overhated? To me this show is probably the most realistic and cleverly executed deconstruction of the harem genre. Realistic? Are you fucking kidding me? So to you "Realistic" means a group of girls willingly having sex with a guy who is denser than a fucking black hole, and a complete dickhead. Yeah okay. And when you say that this deconstructs the Harem genre, no. It doesn't. All it is, is softcore porn. You insult men when you say that we want to be like Makoto. He's a disgusting example of human life, who doesn't even realize he's doing something wrong when he has sex with 7 or 8 girls, AT THE SAME TIME. The only props this show gets from me is that it made me completely despise the main character, more than any other anime MC in existence, and then proceeded to give me a satisfying conclusion, by killing him. The OP didn't say we should be like Makoto. For people who think that he was supposed to be cool for having lots of sex, I would have to disagree with them. His disgusting behavior is supposed to induce feelings of dislike, because we see a character who's primal urges for sex override his sense of morality. He ends up harming other people in the process of satisfying his lust. Essentially, I believe we're supposed to hate him and learn a lesson about sex and relationships. |
| Its just a shitty hentai visual novel adaptation with the "bad ending" as its conclusion,big freaking deal. For all the "hate" its receiving troughout the years it also inadvertently received a ton attention from word of mouth and such (the no such thing as bad publicity deal) ,when there are so many other series that could have genuinely deserved said attention... |
| Let's just call it a ''shitty masterpiece'' |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
More topics from this board
Poll: » School Days Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ranivus - Sep 20, 2007 |
1285 |
by Atsunome
»»
Apr 22, 4:37 AM |
|
Poll: » School Days Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )OriginalName - Sep 12, 2007 |
206 |
by Atsunome
»»
Apr 22, 1:37 AM |
|
Poll: » School Days Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )cyruz - Sep 5, 2007 |
203 |
by Atsunome
»»
Apr 22, 1:21 AM |
|
Poll: » School Days Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )DeleteMe3409 - Aug 29, 2007 |
176 |
by Atsunome
»»
Apr 22, 1:03 AM |
|
Poll: » School Days Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Phrosh - Aug 22, 2007 |
123 |
by Atsunome
»»
Apr 22, 12:45 AM |