Smurphinator said:LucianRoy said:
Someone should remind the elf not to kill anyone tonight unless we discover definite mafia.
You'd think that if Grave was a what she hints she is, she also would have been paying attention to these nods to her role and commented on them a bit earlier on.
grave_robber said:
Lynch: Smurphinator
I wanna see you squirm a little :p
I don't buy this being a placeholder vote. I already had one vote against me, so if she had been trying just to put a vote out there, she would have done it to someone who didn't have one already to even things out. Skewing the votes as a placeholder makes no sense.
xanic said:
unvote: smurphinator
vote:grave_robber
Xanic changes his vote pretty randomly. Originally, he and Grave both had the same random lynch choice, but then he votes Grave upon very slight provocation. This could either be a sign of him being a sheep, but since he put in one of the first lynches, this seems unlikely, and leads me more to think he was trying to overshadow the fact that his and Grave's lynches previously aligned.
grave_robber said:
I invite all cops to investigate me tonight.
vote lynch: DatNeonPanda
^ that's your 1st scummy mafia right there!
Grave starts it after she gets online. Seems pretty reasonable she would vote for him, given that she was accused on the first day. May have been a bit defensive, but, eh... I'm sure some of the "cops" followed that request, part of the reason for my ambivalence.
DatNeonPanda said:
Lynch: xanic
Let's give more options then.
Since Xanic had the aforementioned weird voting going on earlier, it was likely that this vote was to pressure Xanic, especially since it didn't actually change the fact that it still left x_at_home and Grave tied.
Zurel said:
Wait, now you're putting xanic into the list for God knows what reason. If I vote you with Grave, you will just change your vote to her again and it's a tie.
Zurel fails to realize Panda's previously mentioned motives since they weren't super obvious. I don't think he was doing it to be scummy.
Karrote said:
Vote: DatNeonPanda
Why don't we do this?
And then Karrote comes on last minute and puts in the extra vote to lynch Panda. Which seems pretty sketchy.
Verdict: I'm ambivalent on Grave. On the one hand, her hints seem pretty well placed, and her original motives for getting Panda not too out of place either, but it was exact opposite of what I thought of her coming in this phase. Karrote seems fishy for jumping in like that, and Xanic's weird vote change makes me uneasy, since he never gave a reason or foreshadowed he was going to do either vote. Don't quote me on anything, though, since I'm terrible at analysis. I just figured I should put in my two cents since the thread has been awfully quiet aside from the saturation of Lucian's posts.