| Book is big crap, dunno why would any1 wanted to see this on big screen? |
| Your story was bad. It was terrible, in fact. It was like that lame twilight bullshit. I have no patience for that crap. It’s not writing, it’s like bound toilet paper. |
| I've read the books and they don't seem to me that bad..what I don't like is that the sexual content is way too much and it takes up pages that could be used for further plot/character development. Also, Ana (the female protagonist) is really getting on my nerves. I will watch the movie out of curiosity, in order to see if it is well adapted or not. But I would prefer it if Ian Somerhalder was Christian Grey, he is so beautiful. The lead actress doesn't resemble Ana either. |
A lot of the criticism for this book has a misogynistic tone. It's only considered a shitty book because it's written for women by a woman -- and I doubt it's been read in whole by most of the sheeples commenting against it.  OT: Looks like my Valentine's Day is booked. Will buy ropes soon. |
RevelryJul 25, 2014 2:38 PM
| Yeah...just gonna add that to my "never watch" list. |
| "Let Justice Be Done!" My Theme Fight again, fight again for justice! |
| Ugh terrible, just nobody go see it. Ive never read the book but isn't the male character meant to be an older man? because honestly seems to me to be pretty much a clone of that 'the Secretary' movie. But yeah if you are going to have a plot of a young women been seduced into sin by a rich swarve guy make him older than a guy in his 20's seriously. Do I have to spell it out? have fucking Michael Fassbender |
SpooksJul 26, 2014 9:32 AM
 |
Kibura_Iburasa said: But yeah if you are going to have a plot of a young women been seduced into sin by a rich swarve guy make him older than a guy in his 20's seriously. Do I have to spell it out? have fucking Michael Fassbender You have to take into consideration the audience to which it is aimed. This and I don't think Fassbender would accept such a role. He already did great with Shame, so why ruin his image?! And nope, the guy in the book is like 6 years older than the girl, so the flaw is in the original source, not in the movie. |
| If I wanted to watch hentai or porn without character development I would just watch Boku no Pico. |
Wecc said: All hail HaXXspetten king of the loli traps!  |
 |
 |
Red_Keys said: So was the book actually bad, or does everybody consider it shit because they are so enraged that erotic fiction aimed toward women, and not heterosexual men, got to be mainstream and they don't know what to do with themselves except throw a temper tantrum, just like when Free! was announced? Cause this didn't look all that bad for smut I only ask that, because one, I haven't read it (or Twilight for that matter), and two, whenever people complain about the book, it's never about the actual writing, plot, characters, etc; it's always about the content (porn for girls) and who reads it (middle aged housewives). Never anything else. well you spotted the main problem , all the fuss that was made from this book developped discussion , tv interview and so on , making the book a center of attention , like if it was a society phenomenon...but it's just a bad book , nothing more . the problem is that this book is neither feminist , nor misogyn...this book is absolutly zero subversive even if it is sold like if it was . To think this book could be considered a tools for women emencipation and such make me really sad . This is all marketting , well done despisable marketting crafting The way it is written is just bad ( maybe the translation make it even more horrible , I don't know ) , and the so called perverted loving...let just say that it's postal card SM , unharmful and cliché . There is no imagination in it...nothing . the movie just look the same way , it try hard to be something it isn't...just like all heavy production , the only goal is to sell . nothing to see , just void wispering in a commercial world |
 |
Manganese said: Um no, I do not. I read the book in the middle of the library on a slow day, was mildly disturbed and almost lost my stomach when I heard they were adapting it into a movie. I'm just resigned to the fact that THIS pile of crap is getting a movie when there are things so much more deserving.... Don't worry, most hollywood adaptations mak fans of the book rage anyways. It might be better your favoritevbooks aren't getting adaptted/ |
"Fuck this shit, fun things are fun!" |
| It's poorly written fanfiction. The only difference here is the author was smart enough to realize if she replaced the name "Bella" with "Anastasia" and the name "Edward" with "Christian", then she technically would have her own original story. Much like its source material, Twilight, a lot of the hatred comes from the amateur writing (the lead female describes her vagina as "down there" like she's a child), it's direct relation to the hateable book franchise, and how it mistakes abuse for romance. It doesn't do men or women any favors and only serves to be highly popular trash. This itself wouldn't be a problem, but the media treats it like its legitimate literature and gives it credibility when its nothing more than (even more than Twilight) a middle-aged woman's sex fantasy made public. |
| My first novel, Kardia has been published! Click here to read! |
| It portrays BDSM poorly and there's better smuts online than the book. |
 |
| Is 50 shades a better love story than twilight? |
| [size=200]MAL AVATAR SYSTEM BLOWS |
Red_Keys said: So was the book actually bad, or does everybody consider it shit because they are so enraged that erotic fiction aimed toward women, and not heterosexual men, got to be mainstream and they don't know what to do with themselves except throw a temper tantrum, just like when Free! was announced? Your prejudice is showing. Have some decency. |
 |
Exdeu said: cuz it got global popularity, same reason why people went to go see twilightBook is big crap, dunno why would any1 wanted to see this on big screen? |
Exdeu said: fap materialBook is big crap, dunno why would any1 wanted to see this on big screen? |
 |
Revelry said: A lot of the criticism for this book has a misogynistic tone. It's only considered a shitty book because it's written for women by a woman -- and I doubt it's been read in whole by most of the sheeples commenting against it. OT: Looks like my Valentine's Day is booked. Will buy ropes soon. While I agree that misognystic criticisms are the book are both horrible and unnecessary I think that the fact that 50 SOG was written by a woman doesn't make it exempt from criticism - after all it is largely a portrayal of a completely unsafe and unhealthy sexual relationship and the fact that it's portrayed as something healthy and desirable in the book is completely awful and really worth criticizing having actually read the book myself and seen reviews of it i can say that nah the fact that it's considered shitty isnt about the author or intended audience - it's about the unsafe sexual practices and abuse it condones in addition to just plain shitty writing etc. |
Revelry said: A lot of the criticism for this book has a misogynistic tone. It's only considered a shitty book because it's written for women by a woman -- and I doubt it's been read in whole by most of the sheeples commenting against it. Ever think that maybe, just maybe the criticisms of the book have nothing to do with the gender of the author or the target audience and are instead directed at the fact that it's just pretentiously long-winded erotic fanfiction? No women are impressed with your faux feminism, pal. |
 |
Nihilfist said: This.Revelry said: A lot of the criticism for this book has a misogynistic tone. It's only considered a shitty book because it's written for women by a woman -- and I doubt it's been read in whole by most of the sheeples commenting against it. Ever think that maybe, just maybe the criticisms of the book have nothing to do with the gender of the author or the target audience and are instead directed at the fact that it's just pretentiously long-winded erotic fanfiction? No women are impressed with your faux feminism, pal. On topic, I'm surprised sex filled stuff like this gets green lit to show in theatres, then again, I guess that's what the Rated R section is for . . . |
| "Fuck this shit, fun things are fun!" |
Aggra-Dearheart said: Can you blame me when the most common criticisms and slandering of the book are comparable to retarded, vapid, shallow, ignorant, nonsensical shit like this?Red_Keys said: So was the book actually bad, or does everybody consider it shit because they are so enraged that erotic fiction aimed toward women, and not heterosexual men, got to be mainstream and they don't know what to do with themselves except throw a temper tantrum, just like when Free! was announced? Your prejudice is showing. Have some decency. Broeksnoek said: |
 |
| Oi. That's the huntsman of once upon a time, I liked his accent. The female lead is not hot, so I'm not gonna watch it. |
 |
Revelry said: Nihilfist said: Ever think that maybe, just maybe the criticisms of the book have nothing to do with the gender of the author or the target audience and are instead directed at the fact that it's just pretentiously long-winded erotic fanfiction? No women are impressed with your faux feminism, pal. Neither am I impressed at you bringing up genders here, young lady. So what if it's pretentiously long-winded? It's an erotic fiction; let women watch what they want. The movie perfectly accomplishes its goal of fulfilling their fantasies; its goal wasn't to compete with the Harvard Classics. When did I say that women shouldn't be allowed to watch what they want? Just because some women like something doesn't mean that the thing they like is immune to criticism. Especially not when it's something like FSoG which is clearly trying to be something "more" than a madlibbed Twilight erotic fanfic and failing miserably at it. |
|
| I hope they don't leave out my favourite scenes. |
 |
| What's your opinion about this movie for this upcoming Valentine 2015? To be honest, I never knew there's a book about this movie. For me, even though I don't mind BDSM thingy, the story line is boring for me and there's nothing to intrigued me enough for me to watch it. Why would people overly excited about this movie? And if you didn't watch the trailer yet, here's the video: I find it's really weird when lots of my female friends excited about this movie. |
 |
| Did you actually read the book? Or are you just assuming it's boring based on the trailer? |
 |
| Well I tried. I really tried. But after a few pages I just couldn't anymore. It is like it what written by an 8th grader. |
|
| They also have the lego version: |
 |
| Merged. |
Here are my thoughts on this movie: I actually did try reading the book and got about a quarter of the way through before I gave up because the writing style gave me a headache. |
| I am actually contemplating the idea of wasting money on a theater ticket just to see how hilariously bad this pile of tripe is. |
| Since this poorly written piece of Twilight fanfiction has been adapted into a movie I suppose we should be expecting the announcement of a Boku no Pico live action anytime soon? |
 Nico- said: Conversations with people pinging/quoting me to argue about some old post I wrote years ago will not be entertained@Comic_Sans oh no y arnt ppl dieing i need more ppl dieing rly gud plot avansement jus liek tokyo ghoul if erbudy dies amirite |
| Can't wait to see this. I saw the books in my University book store and had to force myself to refrain from buying them over the book I needed for my Lit course. |
| This movie is a shame >.< |
ReaperCreeper said: Red_Keys said: I only ask that, because one, I haven't read it (or Twilight for that matter), and two, whenever people complain about the book, it's never about the actual writing, plot, characters, etc; it's always about the content (porn for girls) and who reads it (middle aged housewives). Never anything else. I've heard the writing and characters are really poor, BDSM isn't portrayed remotely realistic and it uses the "not if they enjoyed it" rationalisation so rape gets portrayed as love. Btw I heard the sex scenes are gonna be way more tame in the movie. It isn't although I probably wouldn't know, but there are much better ones out there. Even most manga is better as they're not just saying exactly what's happening only trying to make it sound erotic. And I hope the movie is better. (Not that I'll be allowed to see it.) |
     |
| Whenever i Hear FSOG something opens in my pocket... |
| its essentially just porn i dont know why the fuck everyones so angry about it. let these older women have their shitty bondage porn! |
| Trash "movie" for the ones with shit taste. Nothing out of the ordinary here. |
More topics from this board
» Currently listening to ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )tsukareru - Mar 29, 2021 |
7598 |
by JustOscar
»»
10 minutes ago |
|
» What was the last TV show episode (non anime) have you watched?Vargnatt - Mar 23 |
33 |
by juanlqr
»»
1 hour ago |
|
» Who is your favourite rapper?ChrisBlitz - Jan 19 |
39 |
by French-Japanese
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» Is it ok to enjoy stories with little Lbtg representation?Zack312 - Feb 25 |
19 |
by DreamWindow
»»
2 hours ago |
|
» What was the last song you listened to? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Death - Oct 1, 2020 |
3377 |
by French-Japanese
»»
4 hours ago |