Is this gonna be the next SAO/AOT?

Dragon_Slayer_X said:
It isn't fair because because Mahouka has only started. Whether the source material is mediocore or not, it's a different story altogether.

Besides why compare different animes in the first place?

mayukachan said:

They're different but all of them share one trait - they're unbelievably popular instantly.

jakkubus said:
I think the main differences between series like SAO or SnK and Mahouka are questions and mysteries. In Sword Art viewers question themselves: "Who nad why locked people in game?", "Do they really die when are unplugged?". In Attack on Titan they wonder about: "What are Titans?", "How it was possible to build so high walls?" or "Why neck is Titan's weakpoint?". On the other hand we have Mahouka and its mysteries like "Why is MC so bland?" or "How can antagonists be so retarded?".

millie10468 said:
I've never met anyone who is so determined to force himself to watch something they hate so much. It's like, wherever there's a place to say something negative about Mahouka, you're there. Did someone perhaps force you to watch and you want to get back at them or something?

jakkubus said:

It's a bit funny, because among the critics I never mentioned hating it. I just pointed its flaws. So everyone who doesn't acknowledge Mahouka greatness is a hater?

millie10468 said:


Of course they're not but if all a person ever talks about is the perceived flaws of something, wouldn't it come across like they hated it and were forcing themselves to watch it for some reason? No fan here is saying Mahouka is a masterpiece. At the very most, it's entertaining. So if all you're doing is always pointing outand criticising the flaws, making it a point to make sure anyone who even gets an iota of entertainment from the show is reminded over and over again about what you perceive as the flaws (which is subjective anyway), and generally acting as though it has no redeeming qualities whatsoever, then of course it comes across like the complaining is actually what you find entertaining. And I personally don't understand how that can be so. Of course, you wouldn't be the first and only person to do it. It's just that you're the one who seems to have read the novels just so you can ridicule any enjoyment people get from it.

If that's not what you're doing, I sincerely apologize. Otherwise it really does come across like that in all your posts.