Next Straw Hat pirate member should be...
| I know we haven't really gotten any new member's of the Straw Hat Pirate's in an uber long time, but "this" (Dressrosa) arc really makes me both: think we have an unusual amount of great candidates to choose from, and feel it's time we get some new members (ideally I would like the SH's to have a big group of nakama) -not White Beard BIG- but bigger then it is now. Realistically my money's on Jinbei cos Luffy did ask him to join them... but there are so many new good characters that I feel Oda shouldn't pass up on. My personal choice would be -Bartolomeo- I wanna keep seeing his crazy personality and awkward interaction's with his Fanboy man crush Luffy =) anyway what do ya'll think? do we need a new Straw Hat at all? do they need more Girl's? or who would your ideal Straw Hat be? |
| Don't you wanna hang out and waste your life with us? -Spike Spiegel- |
| Thread Moved. |
 |
| We already have a thread. Like 6 threads down for fucks sake. |
 |
Old_Raven said: We already have a thread. Like 6 threads down for fucks sake. Yeah... I was to lazy to put this on the right section *hence this v* Luna_ said: Thread Moved. Let alone check if the same thread existed... my bad *shrugs* So feel free to go Ham and spam the shit out of this thread (maybe it'll become interesting enough to be locked) (°^°)d |
| Don't you wanna hang out and waste your life with us? -Spike Spiegel- |
| It's either Jinbei or Rebecca. Bartolomeo already has his own crew so he doesn't need to join. Instead,Bartolomeo can just form alliance with Luffy. |
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| After the latest chapter there's no chance in hell it will be Rebecca, she brings nothing to the crew. Jinbei shouldn't be an option because he is already a crew member as far as Luffy is concerned. I would love to see Baby 5 join the crew as unlikely as that may seem. I believe that the next crew member will be female, as for options in this arc it's pretty much down to Violet. If nobody from this arc joins I think Bonney is still a possibility or maybe someone from Wano Kuni or Elbaf. |
 |
| Rebecca: is so weak and don't have any special powers, we need strong people! Bartolomeo: is just annoying person (Luffy's fan boy) Law: has his own dream and Luffy's enemy as the both are pirates Momonosuke & Kinemon: they're just want to live a happy life, and why they'd help luffy to be the pirate king ? just because he helped them ? bullshit Jinbei: it has been decided a long time ago, he's the 10th member of the crew |
 |
| I personally want Bonnie the captain of the other Super Nova from 2 years ago. I want to see her out eat Luffy, either spark a rivalry or some damn shipping! |
 |
vansonbee said: I personally want Bonnie the captain of the other Super Nova from 2 years ago. I want to see her out eat Luffy, either spark a rivalry or some damn shipping! yeah, that'd be so awesome but it's impossible to happen.. i wonder what happened to Bonnie :/ |
|
creedpirates said: im still sad that bon clay didn't join the crew Well Franky and Bon Clay have the same VA so he kinda joined. |
Satan-sama said: Rebecca: is so weak and don't have any special powers, we need strong people! Bartolomeo: is just annoying person (Luffy's fan boy) Law: has his own dream and Luffy's enemy as the both are pirates Momonosuke & Kinemon: they're just want to live a happy life, and why they'd help luffy to be the pirate king ? just because he helped them ? bullshit Jinbei: it has been decided a long time ago, he's the 10th member of the crew i believe luffy said he wants to get 10 powerful nakama or crew members. he wasn't counting himself so jinbei would be number #9 not counting luffy which means we have room for 1 more. also bart is awesome and his character shows real contrast. when you first meet bart it seams like he doesn't really care what anybody thinks. for example him pissing off the side of the arena. but then you learn he is a luffy fanboy and his character seams totally different. i mean he still doesn't care what people think apart from luffy-senpai. i hope we can see more to that side of him. as far as the next crew member well its definitely gonna be female in my opinion. either violet or rebecca seam like the obvious choices but like fullmetal i would like to see baby 5 become the new SH member. she cracks me up and would definitely add more comedy to the mix. i would love to see how she reacts when brook asks if he can see her panties. bart would also add alot of comedy to the mix but he has his own crew and well i really want to see another female join the SH's. cause 2 just isnt enough. although an alliance between bart and luffy would be awesome. |
Satan-sama said: vansonbee said: I personally want Bonnie the captain of the other Super Nova from 2 years ago. I want to see her out eat Luffy, either spark a rivalry or some damn shipping! yeah, that'd be so awesome but it's impossible to happen.. i wonder what happened to Bonnie :/ I read that as eat out luffy, awkward. |
| Does anyone else need a doctor to confirm that someone without a head is dead? |
Quinius said: jimbob1141 said: Satan-sama said: vansonbee said: I personally want Bonnie the captain of the other Super Nova from 2 years ago. I want to see her out eat Luffy, either spark a rivalry or some damn shipping! yeah, that'd be so awesome but it's impossible to happen.. i wonder what happened to Bonnie :/ I read that as eat out luffy, awkward. Yeah, me too :D Haha glad I'm not the only one; didn't say anything before but yeah I thought the same thing. |
|
Fullmetal89 said: Quinius said: jimbob1141 said: Satan-sama said: vansonbee said: I personally want Bonnie the captain of the other Super Nova from 2 years ago. I want to see her out eat Luffy, either spark a rivalry or some damn shipping! yeah, that'd be so awesome but it's impossible to happen.. i wonder what happened to Bonnie :/ I read that as eat out luffy, awkward. Yeah, me too :D Haha glad I'm not the only one; didn't say anything before but yeah I thought the same thing. pervert imagination, you should go to a psychologist ..lol |
|
| I feel that Law might become the new member. For most of the crew, the Straw Hats have to rescue him/her from some villain. Law is a captive right now and in bad shape. But I can't really see him crying from every orifice of his body during the rescue attempts, which also seems to be a qualification for new members. Meh, I wish they'd add more non-Devil Fruit users to their crew. |
| Bartolomeo is awesome, but i think its unlikely. Rebecca is more likely, but there is no indication/foreshadowing that there may be a new Straw Hat. |
| Well, I'd say Bartolomeo is by far the most likely. Personality-wise he's really unique, and his ability would come in handy, not to mention he's already in love with the Straw Hats. Franky is a prime example of why it wouldn't be too far-fetched to assume that Barto could leave his "crew" to join the Straw Hats... though that's why I think Law wouldn't join so hypocrisy at it's finest! Of course, in Law's case Oda even went so far as to show Law recruiting Jean Bart... and I can't see that being for no reason. But my top 3 choices from this arc (in order) are Wicca, Baby 5, and Cavendish. I think Baby 5 would be more likely to join Law, though... but I actually think Wicca is fairly likely just because she's so different than the rest of the dwarves. Cavendish is a bit iffy since his split personality reveal, but it could still prove to be kind of interesting. Fullmetal89 said: I did the same. :/Quinius said: jimbob1141 said: Satan-sama said: vansonbee said: I personally want Bonnie the captain of the other Super Nova from 2 years ago. I want to see her out eat Luffy, either spark a rivalry or some damn shipping! yeah, that'd be so awesome but it's impossible to happen.. i wonder what happened to Bonnie :/ I read that as eat out luffy, awkward. Yeah, me too :D Haha glad I'm not the only one; didn't say anything before but yeah I thought the same thing. |
| My top choice still Kinemon ONLY dont include that brat he has to stay with kanjuro. His interaction with SH is really normal like he's already a part of the crew, and It isnt only Jinbei who was asked to join but also Kinemon (though it just half of his body and in a foolish manner). Ill only drop him if Oda reveals his background and goals that doesn't fit for SH. Leaving their son to go overseas is too common these days, so dont use Momo as the reason for not joining SH. Barto is my second choice. |
 |
| I want them to have a greenhouse for Usopp, Robin, and Nami's plants and for a couple of the dwarfs to move in and act as guards. |
     Short of the day: Monotonous Purgatory(MAL) ✰Public Domain Club | One Piece Club✰ |
PirateKingZeke said: Source link?Also, Oda has already confirmed that the next crew member will be a female. So that rules Jinbei (and all male characters) out sadly. |
|
PirateKingZeke said: Also, Oda has already confirmed that the next crew member will be a female. So that rules Jinbei (and all male characters) out sadly. yes...sauce plz? Anyways, going by how the current line up is(in current arc), I don't see any of them being part of the Straw Hats. If you look up the current SH's, they have 3 things that make them part of the crew(which gets shown): - Tragic Past - Goal in their life(eg. Zoro being the best swordsman, Sanji seeing All Blue etc) - Must prove to be of use in the Sunny(even a musician is useful in a pirate ship, one thing Sunny don't need is a fanboy or an ex-shichibukai, even if Luffy had already accepted Jinbei in his head) As for Sabo, well definitely a 'no' as I see him more as a replacement for Ace. He's there to help, but is too powerful to be part of the crew. |
PirateKingZeke said: Dark_Messiah said: PirateKingZeke said: Source link?Also, Oda has already confirmed that the next crew member will be a female. So that rules Jinbei (and all male characters) out sadly. TensaiShonen said: PirateKingZeke said: Also, Oda has already confirmed that the next crew member will be a female. So that rules Jinbei (and all male characters) out sadly. yes...sauce plz? Anyways, going by how the current line up is(in current arc), I don't see any of them being part of the Straw Hats. If you look up the current SH's, they have 3 things that make them part of the crew(which gets shown): - Tragic Past - Goal in their life(eg. Zoro being the best swordsman, Sanji seeing All Blue etc) - Must prove to be of use in the Sunny(even a musician is useful in a pirate ship, one thing Sunny don't need is a fanboy or an ex-shichibukai, even if Luffy had already accepted Jinbei in his head) As for Sabo, well definitely a 'no' as I see him more as a replacement for Ace. He's there to help, but is too powerful to be part of the crew. Hmm, I can't seem to find it again = I remember it was from a translated interview with Oda. It would make sense though, since if they get another guy, the male:female ratio will be largely one sided. Also, the interview had said that the new crew member was a straw hat enemy at one point. Anyway, none of the characters match the recruitment process (http://onepiece.wikia.com/wiki/Straw_Hat_Pirates/Recruitment#Recruiting_Process) Unconfirmed rumours that have been circulating the internet for years now without a verifiable source. That one rumour about the new Straw Hat being a former enemy has been around since 2006. Point about the recruitment process is invalid. Immediately below the listed process it says that Nami and Robin didn't follow the process since their backstories weren't revealed till later. Also Alabasta arc wasn't about helping Robin and the crew wasn't in need of a particular position that Robin ended up filling. |
jpem said: Bart is great but his joke would get old if he was around constantly. Better to have him as an ally who shows up way later so he can fan boy about their new world exploits. Law won't for obvious reasons. ^THIS. not that Barto is bad, but his fanboyism will get boring if he join the SH. he's still funny right now because his fanboyism is still a new thing for One Piece. I would get bored if he literally crying everytime he met Luffy if he join SH. |
 |
| Anyone for sugar joining the strawhats? :3 Would be interesting |
  |
jpem said: Bart is great but his joke would get old if he was around constantly. Better to have him as an ally who shows up way later so he can fan boy about their new world exploits. Law won't for obvious reasons. This Bart is a one dimensional character. Except for throwing jokes he is absolutely uninteresting. My bet would be Bellamy, Boney or some new female character we have never seen before or maybe nobody, but I think the New World should bring one last crewmate. Instead of having Luffy asking Bellamy to join I can somehow see Bellamy with his bag on the shoulder going to see Luffy when he departs from Dressrosa and tell him "It seems all these years I boarded on the wrong ship. Now I want to see what it is to live on a ship where men still have dreams, Strawhat would you take me in your crew?" |
short_review said: jpem said: Bart is great but his joke would get old if he was around constantly. Better to have him as an ally who shows up way later so he can fan boy about their new world exploits. Law won't for obvious reasons. This Bart is a one dimensional character. Except for throwing jokes he is absolutely uninteresting. My bet would be Bellamy, Boney or some new female character we have never seen before or maybe nobody, but I think the New World should bring one last crewmate. Instead of having Luffy asking Bellamy to join I can somehow see Bellamy with his bag on the shoulder going to see Luffy when he departs from Dressrosa and tell him "It seems all these years I boarded on the wrong ship. Now I want to see what it is to live on a ship where men still have dreams, Strawhat would you take me in your crew?" Ah yeah, I never really considered Bellamy before, but that would actually be very interesting. I pretty much agree with everything else you said. In this particular arc, no one truly stands out as someone Luffy would try to recruit. Well, Imma sit back and just let it play out like always. |
 |
| I think it will be a logia member i believe jinbei will not become a nakama because he is already in crew as rebecca doesnt seem she want to sail to the sea for trafalgar especially 'NO' because of his crew momonosuke & Kinemon its kinda fail for being their nakama.....The craziest scenario i want to believe is sabo because he is a logia user and if you think there arent logia members on mugiwara crew and i think the last nakama will be a logia user if not sabo just someone else in the next arc im sure it will appear on the next arc |
| Its pretty clear Rebecca is not going to join. She is Vivi 2.0, that's her whole purpose as Dressora is supposed to be structured off the same as the Alabasta Arc. I know Law seems unlikely but I haven't seen a non-nakama character get as much fleshing out as he is getting, maybe he'll be a temporarily member till he can find his crew. Or hey maybe his crew was destroyed by Big Mom. Most likely though it'll be Bartelomo. |
| Previously: BlueXRam |
| I also already considered Jinbe as the 9th member. As for this arc, I think no one will join. Bart and Bellamy will be united to a one crew then will become allies of SH. Rebecca doesn't really have a dream and she doesn't want to fight. Sad to say but she will just be a burden to the crew. Violet, like Rebecca, doesn't have a goal. I think she will be the heiress of the kingdom. Safest bet will be Kinemon. He will be with Strawhats for quite some time. He might leave Momo in Wano and join in. Who knows? But there is ample time to delve in his story so there's a possibility. Also, comedy-wise, he fits well in the crew. Oda is reserving Bonney for something. To becoming a Strawhat, perhaps? :))) As for Law and Sabo, Law has his own crew and Sabo is a Revolutionary. They will not join but they're allies. |
mythical020Sep 20, 2014 10:15 PM
| Somehow I would love Caesar to join the SHC lol =)) and still I want Jewelry Boner join the crew!!! |
tr1ckst3rSep 21, 2014 3:53 AM
|
| I still a bit upset that Perona didn't join Straw Hat Crew. This new straw hat crew that join in,what is his/her role? Luffy=captain Zoro=swordsman Sanji=cook Nami=navigator Usopp=sniper Chopper=doctor Robin=archaeologist Franky=shppwright Brook=musician Is there any occupation in a ship crew being left out? What else does a ship crew usually need? |
But it's important to remember that a movie review is subjective;it only gives you one person's opinion. http://www.classzone.com/books/lnetwork_gr08/page_build.cfm?content=analyz_media&ch=30 It doesn't matter if you like LoGH,Monster etc.If you are a jobless or college/school dropout living in your mom basement, you are still an unintelligent loser. Taste in anime does not make you a better person.If elitist don't exist, casual pleb and shit taste also don't exist. |
| I think we are seeing jimbei on the cover stories atm for a reason, i'm expecting him to make an appearance at some point in this arc or in the post arc. I think he's next. I think oda said there is still more crew members to come, the way it was translated made it sound like numerous members, but i dont know japanese, so idk about the translation :P |
| Does anyone else need a doctor to confirm that someone without a head is dead? |
Zapredon said: I still a bit upset that Perona didn't join Straw Hat Crew. This new straw hat crew that join in,what is his/her role? Luffy=captain Zoro=swordsman Sanji=cook Nami=navigator Usopp=sniper Chopper=doctor Robin=archaeologist Franky=shppwright Brook=musician Is there any occupation in a ship crew being left out? What else does a ship crew usually need? How about a scout/interrogator? this is why i think Violet will join i mean do you realize how incredibly useful her powers would be to a pirate crew. Also we need another girl cause the straw hat crew is a total sausage fest right now. Even if you don't count brook, cause he don't have sausage...cause he is dead yohohohoho thats still 5 vs 2, thats not a good ratio. So if anyone from this arc joins, imo it has to be violet. Rebecca is useless, and doesn't have any talents. i like baby 5, and all that but we already have usopp, and franky so she doesn't bring anything new to the table. |
astrozombie84 said: How about a scout/interrogator? this is why i think Violet will join i mean do you realize how incredibly useful her powers would be to a pirate crew. Also we need another girl cause the straw hat crew is a total sausage fest right now. Even if you don't count brook, cause he don't have sausage...cause he is dead yohohohoho thats still 5 vs 2, thats not a good ratio. So if anyone from this arc joins, imo it has to be violet. Rebecca is useless, and doesn't have any talents. i like baby 5, and all that but we already have usopp, and franky so she doesn't bring anything new to the table. ^ Thank you, I'm thinking the same as you. Also: Ussop+Viola was freaking amazing, I need to see more of that! (plus, Sanji's already totally into Viola, Viora-chwaaaaaaaaaan) Also, I think you have to read this: http://onepiecepodcast.com/2014/07/04/eiichiro-oda-interview-with-china-times/ |
| Boa Hancock --Don't think she will leave her Island or is allowed too + all this lovydovy with luffy already gets on my nerves and that every ep no please don't Camie (and Pappag) + Hachi / Hatchan -- They completed their role in the series already doubt they show up again Jinbei -- wouldn't mind him too be a member of the crew but luffy haven't shown enough intresst in him till now I guess Momonosuke/Kinemon: the wanna have a peaceful life soo I go back home not on a adventure Rebecca: Fights for her country + shes the granddaughter of the King soo surely she stays in dressrose for the same or alike reasons like Vivi did Perona -- she said she wanna return to thriller park and I doubt she will join her enemies even so she helpt zoro out -- I doubt it will gets more than that Mr. 2 Bon Clay --finished the job he had already -- plus he already had a boss doubt he will continues as he did in the past Bartolomeo/Cavendish -- Join Forces in Dressrose but Bartolomeo is more the Fanboy and wont get more then that maybe making a alliance with the strawheads causew both already have a crew Law-- Many said Trafalgar should join but don't forget he already has his crew and wont quiet with the heart Pirates I would love too see him more often but the Alliance is more then fine with me |
| I haven't fully caught up on the Dressrosa arc yet (waiting for it to finish), so take my guess with a grain of salt. Bartolomeu doesn't strike me as the kind of guy who would join. He's a rabid fanboy, but he doesn't really have a distinguished role in this arc. Rebecca may join, but I would picture that she would want to settle down after Dressrosa is liberated. Jinbei will join, but probably not until later. I want Law to join, but fat chance of that happening :( As for the other two, I don't know. They are probably just here for the ride for now, and will stop following them later (sort of like the Alabasta princess). So I voted 'Other.' Maybe next arc. |
 |
| i hope Bartolomeo he is strong |
 |
| Isn't it obvious that Caesar will be the next nakama? I'm surprised lot of people doesn't realize this yet. |
[i][b]I'am the Mayor of under development residential called MAL Backstreet Residential. [/i][/b]Now what are you waiting for?! Come join us at MAL Backstreet Residential!! |
forevenge said: Isn't it obvious that Caesar will be the next nakama? I'm surprised lot of people doesn't realize this yet. It's absolutely not obvious ! |
More topics from this board
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1069 Discussion ( 1 2 )FMmatron - Dec 6, 2022 |
86 |
by Kakuneon
»»
Yesterday, 11:48 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1112 DiscussionAhriTheS3xyFox - Apr 16 |
3 |
by thebrentinator24
»»
Yesterday, 8:34 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 5 DiscussionJoquishaJoestar - Jan 19, 2010 |
32 |
by vsuc
»»
Yesterday, 1:43 PM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1111 DiscussionFMmatron - Mar 19 |
47 |
by Zorowork
»»
Apr 16, 2:27 AM |
|
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 768 DiscussionYerinArelius - Nov 19, 2014 |
47 |
by KoniginElle
»»
Apr 14, 2:50 AM |